Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout04-12-10 PacketPage 1 of 4 Milton City Hall City Council Chambers 13000 Deerfield Parkway, Suite E Milton, GA 30004 Persons needing special accommodations in order to participate in any City meeting should call 678-242-2500. CITY OF MILTON, GEORGIA Joe Lockwood, Mayor CITY COUNCIL Karen Thurman Julie Zahner Bailey Bill Lusk Burt Hewitt Joe Longoria Alan Tart Monday, April 12 , 2010 Regular Council Meeting Agenda 6:00 PM INVOCATION – Chaplin Remco Brommet, Chaplain for Milton Police and Fire 1) CALL TO ORDER 2) ROLL CALL 3) PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE (Led by the Mayor ) 4) APPROVAL OF MEETING AGENDA (Add or remove items from the agenda) (Agenda Item No. 10-1083) 5) PUBLIC COMMENT 6) CONSENT AGENDA 1. Approval of the March 1, 2010 Regular Meeting Minutes. (Agenda Item No. 10-1084) (Sudie Gordon , Interim City Clerk) 2. Approval of the March 8, 2010 Special Called Meeting Minutes. (Agenda Item No. 10-1085) (Sudie Go rdon, Interim City Clerk) 3. Approval of the March 8, 2010 Work Session Minutes. (Agenda Item No. 10-1086) (Sudie Gordon, Interim City Clerk ) MILTON CITY COUNCIL REGULAR MEETING AGENDA APRIL 12, 2010 – 6:00 PM Page 2 of 4 Milton City Hall City Council Chambers 13000 Deerfield Parkway, Suite E Milton, GA 30004 Persons needing special accommodations in order to participate in any City meeting should call 678-242-2500. 4. Approval of a Contract between J.J.E. Contractors, Inc. for Emergency Repairs to the Providence Road Bridge Over Copper Sandy Creek. (Agenda Item No. 10-1087) (Carter Lucas, Public Works Director) 5. Approval of a n Intergovernmental Agreement By And Among The Cities of Alpharetta, Johns Creek, Milton, Roswell And Sandy Springs For Participation In The U.S. Geological Survey Assistance Award Program. (Agenda Item No. 10-1088) (Ken Jarrard, City Attorney) 6. Approval of an Agreement between the City of Milton and Avenet Web Solutions, LLC (a/k/a GovOffice.com) for the design and maintenance of new city web site. (Agenda Item No. 10-1089) (Jason Wright, Communications Manager ) 7. Approval of a Services Agreement between the City of Milton and Cook Construction Services, Inc. for the Removal of an Existing Dump Site at Birmingham Park. (Agenda Item No. 10-1090) (Carter Lucas, Public Works Director) 8. Approval of a Software License Agreement between Guardian Tracking and the City of Milton. (Agenda Item No. 10-1091) (Deborah Harrell, Chief of Police ) 9. Approval of a Contract between the City of Milton and PropertyRoom.com for the Disposition o f Evidence and Property. (Agenda Item No. 10-1092) (Deborah Harrell, Chief of Police ) 10. Approval of a n Agreement between the City of Milton and Georgia Technology Authority to Obtain Motor Vehicle Reports for N on Public Safety Employees. (Agenda Item No. 10-1093) (Deborah Harrell, Chief of Police ) 7) REPORTS AND PRESENTATIONS 1. A Georgia Cities Week Proclamation. (Presented by Mayor Joe Lockwood) 2. A Proclamation Recognizing Milton High School 2010 Georgia AAAAA Boys Basketball Champions. (Presented by Mayor Joe Lockwood) MILTON CITY COUNCIL REGULAR MEETING AGENDA APRIL 12, 2010 – 6:00 PM Page 3 of 4 Milton City Hall City Council Chambers 13000 Deerfield Parkway, Suite E Milton, GA 30004 Persons needing special accommodations in order to participate in any City meeting should call 678-242-2500. 8) FIRST PRESENTATION 1. Approval Of An Ordinance Of The Mayor And Council Of The City Of Milton, Georgia, To Amend The City’s Purchasing Policies To Allow For The Option Of Procurin g Professional Services Without Competitive Bidding, And For Other Purposes. (Discussed at March 8, 2010 Council Work Session) (Agenda Item No. 10-1094) (Presented by Chris Lagerbloom, City Manager & Ken Jarrard, City Attorney) 2. Presentation of An Ordinance To Amend Chapter 48, Article IV, Traffic Calming And Control Of The City Of Milton’s Code Of Ordinances. (Agenda Item No. 10-1095) (Presented by Carter Lucas, Public Works Director ) 3. U09-03 – 2880 Mountain Road by T-Mobile South, LLC to obtain a use permit on AG-1 (Agricultural) zoned property for a 145 foot tall monopole cell tower with an additional 4 foot lightning rod for a total of 149 feet (Article 19.4.7). (Agenda Item No. 10-1096) (Presented by Lynn Tully, Community Developmen t Director) 4. U09-04 – 14495 Hopewell Road by T-Mobile South, LLC to obtain a use permit on AG- 1 (Agricultural) zoned property for a 150 foot tall monopole cell tower with an additional 4 foot lightning rod for a total of 154 feet (Article 19.4.7). (Agenda Item No. 10-1097) (Presented by Lynn Tully, Community Development Director ) 5. U09-05 – 13302 New Providence Road by T-Mobile South, LLC to obtain a use permit on AG-1 (Agricultural) zoned property for a 150 foot tall monopole cell tower with an additional 4 foot lightning rod for a total of 154 feet (Article 19.4.7). (Agenda Item No. 10-1098) (Presented by Lynn Tully, Community Development Director ) 9) PUBLIC HEARING ALCOHOL BEVERAGE LICENSE APPLICATION 1. Approval of the Issuance of an Alcohol Beverage License to I Love N.Y. Pizza & Attila’s Grill located at 980 Birmingham Road, Suite 200, Milton, GA 30004. The applicant is Anar Gafarzada for consumption on premises – wine and malt beverage. (Agenda Item No. 10-1099) (Presented by Stacey Inglis, Finance Director) 10) ZONING AGENDA (None) MILTON CITY COUNCIL REGULAR MEETING AGENDA APRIL 12, 2010 – 6:00 PM Page 4 of 4 Milton City Hall City Council Chambers 13000 Deerfield Parkway, Suite E Milton, GA 30004 Persons needing special accommodations in order to participate in any City meeting should call 678-242-2500. 11) UNFINISHED BUSINESS (None) 12) NEW BUSINESS (None) 13) MAYOR AND COUNCIL REPORTS 14) STAFF REPORTS 15) EXECUTIVE SESSION (If needed) (Agenda Item No. 10-1100 ) 16) AD JOURNMENT (Agenda Item No. 10-1101 ) The minutes for March 1st Regular Council Meeting, March 8th Special Called Meeting and March 8th Work Session were provided electronically on March 29, 2010 to Mayor and Council. City of Milton 13000 Deerfield Parkway, Milton, Georgia 30004 1 To: Honorable Mayor and City Council Members From: Christopher J. Lagerbloom, City Manager Date: Submitted on March 29, 2010 for the April 12, 2010 Council Meeting Agenda Item: Approval of a contract with JJE Constructors, Inc. City Manager’s Office Recommendation Ratify the contract with JJE Constructors, Inc. for emergency repairs to the Providence Road bridge over Copper Sandy Creek. Background In January 2010 it was brought to our attention that the wooden wingwalls on the Providence Road bridge over Copper Sandy Creek had failed. The failure created a void adjacent to the travel lane on Providence Road. Failure to act could have resulted in undermining of Providence Road and ultimately the failure of the road itself. Discussion Presented before you is a contract with JJE Constructors, Inc for the emergency repair work that was completed on the bridge structure. In accordance with our purchasing policy we are notifying council of an emergency services contract that was executed by staff. It comes before the Council at this meeting for ratification. Funding and Fiscal Impact The contract is lump sum contract of $7,500. Funds are available to cover the cost of this repair. Alternatives: There are no other alternatives. Concurrent Review: City Manager. Project was completed as an emergency services contract. J.J.E. CONSTRUCTORS, INC. Earthwork — Civil Structures General Construction James C.L. Embro Contractor (770) 417-1531 (770) 417-1130 Fax Proposal Submitted to: City of Milton 13000 Deerfield Parkway, Ste 107G Milton, GA 30004 ATTN: Carter Lucas TEL: 678-242-2626 PROPOSAL FAX: 678-242-2499 E-MAIL: carter.lucas�].cityofmiltonga.us P.O. Box 76953 Atlanta, Georgia 30358-1953 333 Mitchell St. Norcross, Georgia 30071 Date: January 26, 2010 Project Name & Location Bridge Repair over Copper Sandy Creek We propose to provide all labor, equipment and material to perform the following specified work: Provide Traffic Control Remove existing pile lagging; install new piling and lagging -5' h x 12' long oak lagging with coating Backfill wing wall with material provided by City of Milton Provide and place (1) load of Type III Rip Rap to armor creek bank and end of new wing wall Mulch all disturbed areas LUMP SUM COST: $ 7,500.00 Special Conditions: * *Note* * Terms: 30 days from date of invoice Invoices will be submitted on a monthly basis. _,--P)kICE5,yALID FOR 60 DAYS 13ke(resentative of .17E CONSTRUCTORS, INC Acceptance of Proposal: The above prices, specifications and conditions are satisfactory and are hereby accepted. You are authorized to do the work as specified. Payment will be made as outlined above. Date of acceptance: Acceptor's Signature Title WE MUST RECEIVE THIS PROPOSAL SIGNED IN ORDER FOR US TO PROCEED WITH THE INDICATED WORK. INTERGOVERNMENTAL AGREEMENT BY AND AMONG THE CITIES OF ALPHARETTA, JOHNS CREEK, MILTON, ROSWELL AND SANDY SPRINGS FOR PARTICIPATION IN THE U.S. GEOLOGICAL SURVEY ASSISTANCE AWARD PROGRAM THIS INTERGOVERNMENTAL AGREEMENT (“Agreement”) is entered into this ___________ day of ___________________, 20__, by and among the Cities of Alpharetta, Johns Creek, Milton, Roswell, and Sandy Springs, Georgia (collectively referred to herein as the “Participating Cities”). WITNESSETH: WHEREAS, pursuant to the terms of an Intergovernmental Agreement by and among the Participating Cities and the City of Dunwoody, dated January 1, 2010 (“Aerial Imagery IGA”), the Participating Cities are collaborating with the City of Dunwoody to acquire a new color aerial photography and light detection and ranging (“LiDAR”) data system, and a remote sensing system used to collect topographic data (referred to herein collectively as the “Aerial Imagery”); and WHEREAS, the Participating Cities have become aware that certain funds may be available from the U.S. Geological Survey (“USGS”) to defray a portion of the costs of the Aerial Imagery; and WHEREAS, as one of the cornerstones of the National Geospatial Program of the USGS, The National Map (“TNM”) is a collaborative effort among the USGS and other federal, state and local partners to improve and deliver topographic information for the United States; and WHEREAS, in support of national security initiatives, the USGS will make funds available to municipalities and others in the form of an assistance award to pursue eligible activities in furtherance of the goals of the USGS; and WHEREAS, the Participating Cities believe that the Aerial Imagery qualifies as an eligible activity for which request for an assistance award from the USGS is appropriate; and 2 WHEREAS, an award by the USGS to the Participating Cities for the Aerial Imagery could represent up to twenty to thirty percent (20%-30%) of costs for the Aerial Imagery, resulting in significant savings to the Participating Cities; and WHEREAS, O.C.G.A. § 36-34-2(5) gives municipalities the power to contract with any political subdivision of the State of Georgia to execute any project for the political subdivision in which the municipality has an interest; and WHEREAS, each of the Participating Cities desires to maintain a mutually beneficial, efficient and cooperative relationship that will promote the interests of the citizens of all Participating Cities; and WHEREAS, the Participating Cities desire to collaborate to apply for available funds from the USGS for the Aerial Imagery and has authorized the execution of this Agreement through appropriate action of their governing bodies; WHEREAS, the City of Dunwoody has determined not to participate in the application for assistance award; and NOW, THEREFORE, in consideration of the following mutual obligations, the Participating Cities hereby agree as follows: ARTICLE 1 PURPOSE AND INTENT The purpose of this Agreement is to establish the intent of the Participating Cit ies jointly to cooperate in submitting an application (“Application”) for an assistance award (“Funds”) from the USGS to defray the costs of the Aerial Imagery. The use of the Funds shall be subject to all terms and conditions of the USGS in the award of the Funds. ARTICLE 2 SPONSOR It is in the mutual interest of the Participating Cities to designate one of the Participating Cities as a sponsor (“Sponsor”) for submitting the Application. The Sponsor shall coordinate the 3 Application process and serve as a liaison to the USGS in the effort to obtain an assistance award for the Aerial Imagery. The Sponsor, however, makes no representation as to the success of the Application and shall not be responsible to the Participating Cities for an unsuccessful Application. For purposes of this Agreement, the City of Alpharetta is hereby designated as the Sponsor to coordinate the Application. ARTICLE 3 APPLICATION AND RESPONSIBILITIES OF PARTIES Each of the Participating Cities agrees to cooperate fully with the Sponsor and to assist the Sponsor in undertaking the Application at the Sponsor’s request, including providing the Sponsor with information and resources necessary to accomplish the Application. Each of the Participating Cities agrees to act in good faith and with due diligence in the performance of its obligations and responsibilities under this Agreement. Each of the Participating Cities further agrees that it shall fully cooperate in all things required and appropriate to comply with the terms and conditions of any Funds received for the Aerial Imagery as a result of the Application. ARTICLE 4 USE OF FUNDS All Funds received by the Participating Cities pursuant to the Application shall be used for the Aerial Imagery in accordance with the terms and conditions of the award of the Funds. The Funds shall be applied, on a pro rata basis, to the financial obligations of the Participating Cities entering into this Agreement, as such obligations are described in Article 4 of the Aerial Imagery IGA. ARTICLE 5 TERM OF AGREEMENT This Agreement shall commence upon execution by all parties to this Agreement and shall continue in effect for a period of twelve (12) months. 4 ARTICLE 6 NON-ASSIGNABILITY None of the Participating Cities shall assign any of the obligations or benefits of this Agreement without the mutual written consent by resolutions of the councils of all Participating Cities. ARTICLE 7 ENTIRE AGREEMENT The Participating Cities acknowledge, each one to each of the others, that the terms of this Agreement constitute the entire understanding and agreement of the Participating Cities regarding the subject matter of the Agreement. ARTICLE 8 AMENDMENT This Agreement may be modified at any time upon mutual written consent by resolutions of the councils of all Participating Cities. ARTICLE 9 SEVERABILITY If a court of competent jurisdiction renders any provision of this Agreement (or any portion of a provision) to be invalid or otherwise unenforceable, that provision or portion of the provision will be severed and the remainder of this Agreement will continue in full force and effect as if the invalid provision or portion were not part of this Agreement. ARTICLE 10 BINDING EFFECT This Agreement shall inure to the benefit of, and be binding upon, the respective Participating Cities’ successors, heirs and assigns. 5 ARTICLE 11 COUNTERPARTS This Agreement may be executed in several counterparts, each of which shall be an original, and all of which shall constitute but one and the same instrument. ARTICLE 12 GOVERNING LAW AND VENUE This Agreement shall be governed by the laws of the State of Georgia and proper venue for any actions arising out of this Agreement shall be in the Superior Court of Fulton County. ARTICLE 13 NOTICE Any notice required by this Agreement may be given by a Pa rticipating City or its attorney, or its Agent herein named, and shall be given at the following addresses: If to the City of Alpharetta: Robert J. Regus, City Manager 2 South Main Street Alpharetta, Georgia 30009 With a Copy to: Sam Thomas, City Attorney Bovis, Kyle & Burch, LLC 200 Ashford Center North Suite 500 Atlanta, Georgia 30338 If to the City of Johns Creek: John Kachmar, City Manager 12000 Findley Road Suite 400 Johns Creek, Georgia 30097 With a Copy to: William F. Riley, City Attorney 12000 Findley Road Suite 400 Johns Creek, Georgia 30097 6 If to the City of Milton: Christopher J. Lagerbloom, City Manager 13000 Deerfield Parkway Suite 107 Milton, Georgia 30004 With a Copy to: Ken Jarrard, City Attorney Jarrard & Davis, LLP 105 Pilgrim Village Drive, Suite 200 Cumming, Georgia 30040 If to the City of Roswell: Kay G. Love, City Manager Roswell City Hall 38 Hill Street Suite 115 Roswell, Georgia 30075 With a Copy to: David Davidson, City Attorney Roswell City Hall 38 Hill Street Suite 110 Roswell, Georgia 30075 If to the City of Sandy Springs: John McDonough, City Manager 7840 Roswell Road Building 500 Sandy Springs, Georgia 30350 With a Copy to: Wendell K. Willard, City Attorney Two Ravinia Drive Suite 1630 Atlanta, Georgia 30346 All notices are effective upon receipt. Any Participating City may change an address by giving written notice of said change of address to the other Participating Cities. 7 IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the Participating Cities have executed this Agreement through their duly authorized officers on the day and year first above written. CITY OF ALPHARETTA, GEORGIA ATTEST: __________________________________ _________________________________ Arthur Letchas, Mayor City Clerk (SEAL) Approved as to form: __________________________________ _________________________________ Sam Thomas, City Attorney Robert J. Regus, City Manager CITY OF JOHNS CREEK, GEORGIA ATTEST: __________________________________ _________________________________ Michael E. Bodker, Mayor City Clerk (SEAL) Approved as to form: __________________________________ _________________________________ William F. Riley, Jr., City Attorney John Kachmar, City Manager 8 CITY OF MILTON, GEORGIA ATTEST: __________________________________ _________________________________ Joe Lockwood, Mayor Interim City Clerk (SEAL) Approved as to form: __________________________________ _________________________________ Ken Jarrard, City Attorney Christopher J. Lagerbloom, City Manager CITY OF ROSWELL, GEORGIA ATTEST: __________________________________ _________________________________ Jere Wood, Mayor City Clerk (SEAL) Approved as to form: __________________________________ _________________________________ David Davidson, City Attorney Kay G. Love, City Manager CITY OF SANDY SPRINGS, GEORGIA ATTEST: __________________________________ _________________________________ Eva Galambos, Mayor City Clerk (SEAL) Approved as to form: __________________________________ _________________________________ Wendell K. Willard, City Attorney John McDonough, City Manager City of Milton 13000 Deerfield Parkway, Milton, Georgia 30004 1 To: Honorable Mayor and City Council Members From: Christopher J. Lagerbloom, City Manager Date: Submitted on March 29, 2010 for the April 12, 2010 Council Meeting Agenda Item: Approval of a contract with Avenet Web Solutions, LLC (GovOffice) City Manager’s Office Recommendation Ratify the contract with Avenet Web Solutions, LLC (GovOffice) for the design and maintenance of new city Web site. Background It has been identified through interaction with citizens and staff that the City of Milton Web site needed major revisions and content upgrades. This contract allows for advancements in a number of areas, including more robust web applications, ease of use and overall look and feel. Discussion Presented before you is a contract with Avenet Web Solutions, LLC (GovOffice) for the redesign and maintenance of the city’s website. Information about the scope of work included and features to be built are in the contract. The City Attorney has reviewed and approved the contract and based on Mayor and Council direction in previous public meetings has authorized Mayor Lockwood to execute the document. It comes before the Council at this meeting for ratification. Funding and Fiscal Impact The contract is based on a one-time cost of $10,780. Yearly costs are based on site size and slated to be $1,155. Alternatives: Other contracts ranged in price but did not offer the full range of tools available from GovOffice. Concurrent Review: Paul Higbee, City Attorney – Approved to content and form & added Addendum to Contract on March 16, 2010 Chris Lagerbloom, City Manager Addendum to Quotation for Service And Govoffice Terms and Conditions This Addendum is attached to and made part of that Quotation for Service dated Iq lak r l- /A 9 201 Q (the "Agreement") between the City of Milton, Georgia ("Client") and Avenet, LL ("Avenel," also referred to from time to time as "GovOffice.com" and "GovOffice"). In the event of a conflict among the provisions of the Agreement, the Terms, as defined herein, and this Addendum, this Addendum will govern. The Client and Avenel agree that the Agreement and the Govoffice Terms and Conditions attached hereto as Exhibit "A" (the "Terms") are hereby modified as follows: THE AGREEMENT 1. Page 3, Signature Block: The following sentence is deleted: "Also, by paying for or utilizing the GovOffice.com Web service, you agree to the `Terms and Conditions' as they appear on our Web site at www.GovOffice.com/terms." THE TERMS 1. Paragraph 9, Confidential Information: This Paragraph is modified by adding the following new sentence to the end of said Paragraph: "Client's compliance with the Georgia Open Records Act shall not constitute a breach of this Agreement." 2. Paragraph 10, Limited Warranty: The third sentence of this Paragraph is modified to read as follows: "In the event of a breach of this warranty, GovOffice.com shall remedy such material deviation within a reasonable time." 3. Paragraph 15, Indemnity: The first paragraph, first sentence of this Paragraph is modified to read as follows: "Except as provided above for personal injuries and destruction of property, you agree that you shall, to the extent if any allowed by law, indemnify and hold GovOffice.com harmless against any claims, liabilities, causes of actions, losses, damages, judgments, costs and fees (including attorneys fees and disbursements) to you or any third party which GovOffice.com may hereafter incur, suffer, or be required to pay, defend, settle, or satisfy as a result of your use of the Service in violation of this Agreement, including the content of your Web Site or any information contained therein." 9 Paragraph 16, Governing Law and Venue: This Paragraph is modified to read as follows: "This Agreement and Terms of Use Policy shall in all respects be governed by the laws of the State of Georgia, without reference to the rules of any jurisdiction concerning conflicts of laws. The parties agree that all disputes arising out of this Agreement shall be subject to the exclusive jurisdiction of and venue in the federal and state courts located in Fulton County, Georgia, and the parties hereby consent to the personal jurisdiction and venue of these courts." All other terms of the Agreement and Terms shall remain unchanged and of full force and effect. Those individuals executing this Addendum on behalf of Client and GovOffice.com, respectively, hereby certify that they are fully authorized to bind the entity on whose behalf they are executing this Addendum. for "Client" Namefritle: 06,4) 0 0 4 Date for Avenet, Name/Title: GOVOFFICE.COM SUBSCRIPTION SERVICES AGREEMENT and TERMS OF USE POLICY THANK YOU FOR USING GOVOFFICE.COM WEB SERVICES. This document provides important information regarding your use of the GovOffice.com service. You are urged to read and understand it thoroughly. We encourage you to print a copy of this entire document for reference and understanding before and as you use the service. We also encourage you to periodically return to this page and access this information to review any changes or modifications that may have been made since your East review. IMPORTANT: GOVOFFICE.COM IS AN ONLINE INFORMATION AND COMMUNICATIONS SERVICE TO BE USED FOR THE PURPOSE OF AIDING GOVERNMENT OFFICES AND ELECTED OFFICIALS IN THE OPERATING AND MANAGING OF OFFICIAL GOVERNMENT OFFICES. PLEASE READ THIS AGREEMENT AND POLICY CAREFULLY BEFORE ACCESSING OR USING ANY OF THE SERVICES DESCRIBED BELOW. BY PAYING FOR OR UTILIZING THE GOVOFFICE.COM SERVICE, YOU ACKNOWLEDGE THAT YOU HAVE READ AND UNDERSTAND THIS AGREEMENT AND TERMS OF USE AND AGREE TO BE BOUND BY THEIR TERMS. IF YOU DO NOT AGREE TO THESE TERMS AND CONDITIONS, PLEASE CANCEL THE SERVICES IMMEDIATELY BY CALLING GOVOFFICE.COM AT 1 (877) 564-4979. GOVOFFICE.COM SUBSCRIPTION SERVICES AND LICENSE AGREEMENT 1. Services: The GovOffice.corn service (the "Service") provides access to software, server space, technology and other tools for you to develop and deploy one or more Web Sites for use by governmental entities. The specific features of the Service depend on the level of Service selected by the customer for its use. You are responsible for providing and maintaining all necessary computer equipment, software and telecommunications services to access the Service. GovOffice.com shall supply, subject to the provisions of this Agreement, such subscription access to and use of certain software, server space. technology and documentation related thereto as may be agreed with you and specified in connection with your use of the Services. 2. Fees and Payment: For access to and use of the Service, you agree to pay the amounts indicated for the level of Service you select as specified on a Quote for Services document or Invoice provided by GovOffice.com and incorporated herein by reference. To the extent any tax applies to your use of the Service, the collection, withholding, reporting and payment are your responsibility. The fees payable to GovOffice.com are net of any such taxes or impositions. In the event that there are past due amounts, those amounts will be charged interest at the rate of one percent (1 %) per month or the maximum amount permissible by law until paid in full, whichever is greater. You agree to pay all collection fees (including attorney fees) in connection with collection of any past due amounts from you. 3. Customer's Obligations: You agree to pay the fees and prices agreed to and applicable to your subscription. You agree to comply with the Terms of Use Policy that is part of this Agreement and all applicable laws and regulations, including, but not limited to, those related to privacy, copyright, trademark, other intellectual property rights, data privacy, pornography, obscenity, communications, defamation, trade regulations and all tax laws and regulations. You are fully responsible for all content appearing in and contained on your Web Site. You agree to notify GovOffice.com promptly in the event you suspect any unauthorized use of your GovOffice.com Web Site. Until you notify GovOffice.com, you remain solely responsible for any such unauthorized use and any damages that may result therefrom. You further agree to notify GovOffice.com immediately in the event you become subject to any lawful order or process that would prohibit or limit your use of the Service. You may not resell, re -market, or otherwise redistribute the Service or any portion thereof or offer services to others for the creation of Web Sites using the Service without written permission of GovOffice.com. 4. License: Upon your subscription, GovOffice.com grants to you, and you accept, a non- exclusive, non-transferable license (the "License") to use the Services and any related documentation ("Documentation"), together referred to as the "Licensed Materials," subject to and only as permitted in this Agreement. The Licensed Materials (including but not limited to any images, photographs, animations, video, audio, music, and text incorporated into the Software) are and remain the property of GcvOffice.com or its licensors. Any data which you provide and which is manipulated or stored by the Licensed Materials remains your property and does not become the property of GovOffice.com. From time to time, whether or not obligated to do so, during the term of the Agreement, GovOffice.com may provide changes or additions (the "Updates") to the Software and Documentation, such as, but not limited to bug- fixes, upgrades, and new releases. You are not permitted to reverse engineer, de-compile, disassemble, or otherwise examine the Software, except and only to the extent that such activity is expressly permitted by applicable law. You are not permitted to adopt all or any part of the Software or its algorithms as your own. You are not licensed to use any trademarks or service marks of GovOffice.com. GovOffice.com shall have the right to place its trademarks, service marks, logos and copyright information on the Web Site. Software and documentation are internationally protected by the laws of one or more of the following: copyright, patent, and trade secrets. Marking the software or documentation to indicate ownership by GovOffice.com is for notice only and is not evidence of publication. 5. Term: This Agreement shall take effect immediately upon your payment of the licensing fee and shall continue in effect so long as you comply with all terms of use and pay all applicable hosting, customer service, design, custom upgrade and/or other fees incurred in accordance with the payment terms. The License granted hereunder ends with the termination of this Agreement for any reason. GovOffice.com may upon 15 days notice modify or restrict your use of the Service if GovOffice.com determines in its reasonable discretion that your use of the Service violates the Agreement, the Terms of Use Policy, any laws or regulations, or the intellectual property rights of GovOffice.com or a third party. In the event GovOffice.com modifies or restricts your use of the Service, GovOffice.com will notify you of the reasons for the modification or restriction and you will have fifteen (15) days thereafter to correct the violation. GovOffice.com may terminate this Agreement if you do not make corrections by the end of that period. 6. Termination of License: Either party may terminate this Agreement for cause in the event of (a) any material breach of the terms and conditions hereof, which breach is not cured by the party in breach within fifteen (15) calendar days following notice, by the other party, of the breach; (b) the commencement of a voluntary case or other proceeding seeking liquidation, reorganization, or other relief with respect to either party of its debts under any bankruptcy, insolvency, or other similar law in effect at the time of or after creation of this Agreement; or (c) either party's making a general assignment for the benefit of creditors or becoming insolvent or taking any corporate action to authorize any of the provisions for parts (b) or (c) of this provision. Either party may terminate this Agreement for convenience at any time upon sixty (60) days' notice to the other party. In the event GovOffice.com terminates the Agreement for convenience, following the sixty (60) day notice period, GovOffice.com shall cease to charge ongoing fees to you. Notwithstanding anything to the contrary, GovOffice.com may terminate this Agreement at any time in its sole discretion if GovOffice.com deems any content on your Web Site to be inappropriate, obscene, inflammatory, illegal, or if your use of the Service disrupts or causes a malfunction of the Service. 7. Rights and Duties Upon Termination: Upon termination of this Agreement, all rights to the Service terminate immediately. All fees and charges due under the Agreement for the remainder of the term of the Agreement shall become immediately due and payable in full as a cancellation fee. You remain liable for all charges during any period for which your Service is suspended or terminated. If this Agreement is terminated by GovOffice.cam, you may not re-register for or otherwise access the Service without GovOffice.com's written permission. The term of the License ends with the termination of this Agreement for any reason. Upon termination of the License, all customer data on GovOffice.com servers will be deleted. It is your responsibility to print out all data prior to termination. S. Web Site Availability: The Web Site(s) provided under this Agreement will be accessible to third parties via the World Wide Web portion of the Internet twenty-four (24) hours a day, seven (7) days a week, except for scheduled maintenance and required repairs, and except for any loss or interruption of services due to causes beyond the control of GovOffice.com. GovOffice. corn cannot represent or warrant that the Service wi11 never be interrupted. You understand that there may be occasions, due to circumstances not within our control, that may result in interruption of the Service. GovOffice.com will use its best efforts to provide continual availability of the Services. Examples of causes beyond aur control include, but are not limited to, the interruption or failure of telecommunication links, interruption or failure of transmission links, and slowdowns or failures of the Internet itself. GovOffice.com reserves the right to interrupt services for purposes of upgrading, debugging, maintaining and improving the system, among other reasons. To the extent feasible, GovOffice.com schedules these activities for performance at the least inconvenient time so as to minimize interruption. 9. Confidential Information: Unpublished information within the software and documentation provided by GovOffice.com, as well as GovOffice.com information to which you may gain access, that deals with GovOffice.com's product plans, product details and operations, business strategies, and the like, including, but not limited to, all information that you would wish to maintain in confidence if the information belonged to and applied to you rather than GovOffice.com, is "Confidential Information." You agree to treat the Confidential Information with at least the degree of care and protection with which you treat your own essential and most highly proprietary and confidential information, but in any event with no less than reasonable care and protection, and to use the Confidential Information only in a manner and for purposes consistent with the provisions and objectives of this Agreement. You agree not to disclose Confidential Information or otherwise to make it available to third parties without GovOffice.com's prior written consent, except to the extent that the Confidential Information (i) was in the public domain at the time it was disclosed or has entered the public domain through no fault of you; (ii) was known to you, without restriction, at the time of disclosure by GovOffice.corn as demonstrated by files in existence at the time of disclosure; (iii) is disclosed with the prior written approval of GovOffice.com; (iv) became known to you, without restriction, from a source other than GovOffice.com, without breach of this Agreement by you and otherwise not in violation of GovOffice.com's rights; or (v) is disclosed pursuant to the order or requirement of a court, administrative agency, or other governmental body; provided, however, that you shall use all reasonable efforts to provide prompt written, and sufficient advance notice thereof to GovOffice.com to enable GovOffice.com to seek a protective order or otherwise prevent or restrict such disclosure. You shall take appropriate action by instruction, agreement, or otherwise with Licensee's employees, agents, and other representatives to satisfy your obligations under this Agreement with respect to the use, copying, modification, protection and security of Confidential information. 10. Limited Warranty: GovOffice.com warrants that the performance of the Service will not deviate materially from that represented in the GovOffice,com web site (www.GovOffice.com). This is a limited warranty. Your remedies in connection with this warranty are described below. Also described below are warranties that GovOffice.com expressly declines to make. 11. Disclaimer of Other Warranties: GOVOFFICE.COM PROVIDES SERVICES ON AN "AS- IS" BASIS, WITH ALL FAULTS, AND WITHOUT WARRANTY BEYOND THAT DESCRIBED IN THIS AGREEMENT, GOVOFFICE.COM EXPRESSLY DISCLAIMS ALL OTHER WARRANTIES, EXPRESS AND IMPLIED, INCLUDING, BUT NOT LIMITED TO, THE IMPLIED WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY, FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE, AND TITLEJNON-INFIR INGEMENT. GOVOFFICE.COM DOES NOT WARRANT THAT THE SERVICES WILL MEET YOUR REQUIREMENTS OR THAT THE OPERATION OF THE SERVICES WILL BE UNINTERRUPTED OR ERROR -FREE OR THAT DEFECTS IN THE SERVICES WILL BE CORRECTED. GOVOFFICE.COM DOES NOT WARRANT, GUARANTEE OR MAKE ANY REPRESENTATION REGARDING THE USE OR RESULTS OF THE USE OF THE SERVICES, SOFTWARE, ACCESS TO THE SERVERS, OR THE INFORMATION PROVIDED BY THE GOVOFFICE.COM DIRECTORIES, LISTINGS AND DATABASES IN TERMS OF ACCURACY, RELIABILITY, QUALITY, STABILITY, COMPLETENESS. CURRENTNESS OR OTHERWISE. NO INFORMATION OR ADVICE GIVEN BY GOVOFFICE.COM OR ITS AUTHORIZED REPRESENTATIVES SHALL IN ANY WAY CREATE A WARRANTY OR INCREASE THE SCOPE OF THIS WARRANTY. YOU ARE ENTIRELY RESPONSIBLE FOR AND ASSUME ALL RISK FOR USE OF THE SERVICE. GOVOFFICE.COM DOES NOT WARRANT OR REPRESENT THAT ITS SECURITY PROCEDURES WILL PREVENT THE LOSS OF OR IMPROPER ACCESS TO YOUR DATA. GOVOFFICE.COM IS NOT RESPONSIBLE FOR TRANSMISSION ERRORS OR CORRUPTION OR SECURITY OF INFORMATION CARRIED OVER TELECOMMUNICATION LINES. GOVOFFICE.COM OFFERS NO NONINFRINGEMENT WARRANTY WHATSOEVER AND DISCLAIMS ALL RESPONSIBILITY WITH RESPECT TO INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RELATED TO ITEMS PROVIDED UNDER THIS AGREEMENT BUT NOT PRODUCED BY GOVOFFICE.COM 12. File Corruption: GOVOFFICE.COM DOES NOT GUARANTEE OR WARRANT THAT FILES AVAILABLE FOR DOWNLOADING IN CONNECTION WITH THE SERVICES WILL BE FREE OF INFECTION OR VIRUSES, WORMS, TROJAN HORSES OR OTHER CODE THAT MANIFEST CONTAMINATING OR DESTRUCTIVE PROPERTIES. YOU ARE RESPONSIBLE FOR IMPLEMENTING SUFFICIENT PROCEDURES AND CHECKPOINTS TO SATISFY YOUR PARTICULAR REQUIREMENTS FOR ACCURACY OF DATA INPUT AND OUTPUT, AND FOR MAINTAINING A MEANS EXTERNAL TO GOVOFFICE. COM. S SERVERS FOR THE RECONSTRUCTION OF LOST DATA. 13. Limitation of Liability: IN NO EVENT SHALL GOVOFFICE.COM, ITS AGENTS, EMPLOYEES, OR OTHER REPRESENTATIVES BE LIABLE TO YOU OR ANY THIRD PARTY FOR ANY INCIDENTAL OR CONSEQUENTIAL DAMAGES (INCLUDING, WITHOUT LIMITATION, INDIRECT, SPECIAL, PUNITIVE, OR EXEMPLARY DAMAGES FOR LOSS OF SUPPORT, LOSS OF PROFITS, LOSS OF GOODWILL OR REPUTATION, GOV INTERRUPTION, LOSS OF DATA, OR LOSS OF INFORMATION) ARISING OUT OF OR CONNECTED IN ANYWAY WITH THIS AGREEMENT OR THE SERVICES, OR FOR ANY CLAIM BY ANY THIRD PARTY (INCLUDING FOR INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY INFRINGEMENT), EVEN IF GOVOFFICE.COM HAS BEEN ADVISED OF THE POSSIBILITY OF SUCH DAMAGES. THE TOTAL LIABILITY OF GOVOFFICE.COM TO YOU FOR ALL DAMAGES, LOSSES, AND CAUSES OF ACTION (WHETHER IN CONTRACT, TORT OR OTHERWISE) SHALL NOT EXCEED AN AMOUNT EQUAL TO THE TOTAL FEES PAID BY YOU TO GOVOFFICE.COM IN THE TWELVE (12) MONTHS PRIOR TO THE EVENT CAUSING LIABILITY, provided, however, that this limitation shall not apply to damages for personal injuries to your employees, contractors, or other representatives or for destruction of your tangible personal property proximately caused by negligence or malfeasance of GovOffice.com. 14. Exclusive Remedy: Your sole right and exclusive remedy for breach of this Agreement by GovOffice.com if you are dissatisfied for any reason with the Service is to terminate this Agreement as provided herein. 15. Indemnity: Except as provided above for personal injuries and destruction of property, you agree that you shall indemnify and hold GovOffice.com harmless against any claims, liabilities, causes of actions, losses, damages, judgments, costs and fees (including attorneys fees and disbursements) to you or any third party which GovOffice.com may hereafter incur, suffer, or be required to pay, defend, settle, or satisfy as a result of your use of the Service, including the content of your Web Site or any information contained therein. GovOffice.com will indemnify you and hold you harmless with respect to any claim or demand by any third party that the Licensed Materials infringe any United States copyright, patent, or trade secret. You shall cooperate fully with GovOffice.com in defending against any such claim or demand and shall take no action, without prior written consent of GovOffice.com, which may compromise or settle such claim or demand. In the event that you are prevented by injunction or similar order from using the Licensed Materials as contemplated by this Agreement, GovOffice.com may: procure the necessary license for the affected items) of the Licensed Materials; modify the affected item(s) to avoid infringement; provide a replacement for the affected item (s); or, if none of the foregoing is commercially reasonable, terminate this Agreement, ceasing to charge ongoing fees to you and refunding a pro rata portion of any initial or paid-up fees that you have paid to GovOffice.com. 16. Governing Law and Venue: This Agreement and Terms of Use Policy shall in all respects be governed by the laws of the State of Minnesota, without reference to the rules of any jurisdiction concerning conflicts of laws. You agree that all disputes arising out of this Agreement shall be subject to the exclusive jurisdiction of and venue in the federal and state courts located in Minneapolis, Minnesota or within Hennepin County, Minnesota, and you hereby consent to the personal jurisdiction and venue of these courts. No claim arising out of or in connection with this Agreement may be brought by you more than one (1) year after the cause of action on which it is based has accrued. 17. Force Majeure: Neither party will be responsible for any failure to perform its obligations (other than payment obligations) under this Agreement due to causes beyond the reasonable control of the party failing to perform, including without limitation acts of God, war, riot, embargoes, acts of civil or military authorities, fire, floods or accidents. To receive the benefits of this provision, however, the party so failing to perform must (a) notify the other party promptly of the fact, cause, and expected duration of the failure to perform; (b) continue its attempts to perform; (c) keep the other party informed of a likely end of the cause of the failure to perform; and (d) perform promptly when again able to do so. Payment is not subject to this force majeure provision. Either party may terminate this Agreement upon notice to the other if the duration of the period of a failure to perform covered by this provision extends beyond thirty (30) days. 18. General Terms: You may not assign or transfer your rights and obligations under this Agreement without written permission of GovOffice.com. Any of the provisions of this Agreement determined by a court of law to be invalid is, to that extent, deemed omitted and the remainder of this Agreement shall be enforced as written. All notices permitted or required to be given must be written and delivered by hand, facsimile, or nationally recognized express mail service to the address of that party as specified in this Agreement or such other address as the party may specify in writing on ten (1 0) days notice in accordance with this provision. All notices shall be deemed to be given upon receipt. GovOffice.com and you are independent contractors, and nothing contained in this Agreement shall be construed to constitute a joint venture or other relationship between them or to give either party any rights whatsoever to bind the other. You understand and accept that Internet use, the Services, and related products and services may require registrations and related administrative reports which may be public in nature. You also consent to the use of your name as a reference in GovOfflce.com's marketing activities. -GOVOFFICE.COM TERMS OF USE POLICY This Terms of Use Policy describes the rules you agree to observe in connection with your creation and use of your GovOffice.com Web Site. GovOffice.com reserves the right in its sole discretion to remove any content for any reason, including but not limited to, your violation of any laws or the terms and conditions of the GovOffice.com Subscription Services Agreement or this Terms of Use Policy. This right to remove inappropriate content does not create an obligation on GovOtfice.com to monitor or edit your Web Site. The rules identified below are in addition to the rules governing content identified in the Agreement. The following rules are provided solely for your guidance. If you are unsure whether any contemplated use, content or action is permitted, you may contact GovOtfice.com. You agree to observe the following rules of use of your Web Site: ■ You agree to use the Web Site only for purposes consistent with the organization for which you have contracted for the Services; • You agree not to download, alter, reverse compile, or examine the source or object code of any software or data provided by GovOffice.com or others in connection with GovOffice.com's provision of the Services; ■ You are responsible for protecting the privacy of your user IO or other bases of restricted access supplied by or arranged in cooperation with GcvOffice.com; • You shall not violate the confidentiality of information stored on or accessible through the Web Site or GovOffice.com's servers, or deposit or upload any materials other than those used directly by you for the purposes contemplated by this Agreement; ■ You shall not use the Service to post any content that is obscene, pornographic, excessively violent, harassing, or otherwise objectionable; • You shall not use the Service to post content that is defamatory, libelous, scandalous, threatening or harassing. You shall not past private information without the permission of the person(s) or entities involved, or post content that may cause emotional distress; • You shall not use the Service to post any content that advocates, promotes or otherwise encourages violence against any business, government, organization, group or individual or which provides instruction, information or assistance in causing or carrying out such violence; • You shall not introduce viruses, worms, Trojan Horses, or other harmful code on GovOffice.com hardware or on the Internet; ■ You shall not use the Service to post any content that violates any copyrights, trademarks, patents, or other intellectual property rights of others; and • You agree to observe other rules of use of the Web Site as GovOffice.com may notify you of them as applicable to GovOffice.com's Web Sites generally; provided, however, that if a new rule so notified operates to create a serious hardship for you, you shall have the opportunity to object within ten (10) days after such notice, in which case you and GovOffice.com may jointly decide on alternative implementation or definition of the rule. In operating your Web Site, you agree to assume sole responsibility for ensuring that your Web Site complies with the above rules. In addition, you agree to assume sole responsibility for the accuracy of all content appearing on your Web Site and that your Web Site is used in a manner consistent with all applicable laws and regulations. You are responsible for properly acquiring all authorization required for hypertext links to other Web Sites. Changes to Agreement and Terms of Use Policy: GovOffice.com may revise or amend this Agreement and Terms of Use Policy. Any changes shall be posted to the GovOffice.com Web Site (www.GovOffice.corn) and GovOffice.com will notify you of such revisions or amendments via mail or e- mail at the addresses you provide. You are responsible to provide GovOffice.com with updated e-mail and mailing addresses, and periodically access the online Agreement and Terms of Use Policy to review them for any revisions or modifications. Except as provided herein, any changes to this Agreement or Terms of Use Policy must be in writing and signed by GovOffice.com and you. (2-08) Quotation for Service Date: March 22, 2010 (Expires on 5-31-10) From: Mike Chaloupka, Sales Representative Upon acceptance of the Quotation for Service, please follow the instructions at the bottom of Page 5. Name of Client: City of Milton, Georgia Site Admin: Jason Wright Today's Population: 15,156 Admin Phone: 678-242-2523 Mail Address: 13000 Deerfield Parkway, Suite 107 Admin E-mail: Jason.Wrighteacityofiniltonga-us City, State, Zip: Milton, GA 30004 Main Phone: 678-242-2500 The Site Admin is the staff member who will serve as the Client's Main Fax: 678-242-2499 primary contact person with the GovOffice Customer Service Center. Service Description Cost License of GovOffice Content Management System (CMS) $2200 • Required, one-time only cost • Includes online training session with the GovOffice Customer Service Center ■ See Pages 2-3 of this Quotation for Service for standard features and services provided Annual Service Package $924 • Required, annual cost • Includes Web hosting, customer support, and our maintenance of the Web servers • E-mail hosting not included in the Annual Service Package • See "Web Hosting" on Page 5 of this Quotation for Service for a description Custom Graphic Web Design Upgrade $4000 • Recommended, one-time only cost • Sce "Premium Solution" on Page 4 of this Quotation for Service for a description Custom Coding—optional) recommended. Custom placement of images displayed in a full summary promotion $525 of a news section on the home page to allow each new item's image to be displayed at the top of the main column of the homepage when the user's mouse is over the news item (rosavllgov.com is a model). URL Re -Direction (eityofmiltonga.us) $75 • Recommended, one-time only cost ■ Sec "Domain Name" on Page 5 of this Quotation for Service for a description. SuperForms Module (online forms system upgrade) 5431 • Recommended; $200 one-time + $231 annual cast (= to 25% of Annual Service Package) • See "SuperForms" on Page 4 of this Quotation for Service for a description Web Content Transfer Service—optionall recommended. GovOffice will transfer (migrate) Web site content— S2625 text, images, documents, and the like` --from the Client's existing public Web site onto the GovOffice system. This is a one-time effort at a one-time cost. Total: $10,780 GovOffice is a Division of Avenet Web Solutions 1300 Godward Street NE, Suite 2625 Minneapolis, MN 55413 Direct Phone: 612-617-5709 www.GovOf£ce.com A 00runder "Standard Feature" means the feature is provided to the Client under payment of the one-time license and the Annual Service Package charges for the GovOffice Content Management System (CMS)_ Features Standard Feature Access to 20 stock design templates; customization of the design is limited to adding your organization's name, slogan, and a footer I/ Up to 1 GB (1,000 MB) of stored uploads, our regular maintenance of Web servers, and your access to the toll-free Technical Support Desk Nightly backups of Web site data locally and weekly backups of Web site data remotely Online training of the GovOffice technology and selected upgrades for staff Quick Tips within the administrative Web site and access to the Govoffice Help Site Subscription to monthly e -newsletter for any number of staff and free Web Site Tune -Up Kit containing over 75 suggestions to ensure an effective online presence Unlimited number of administrative users (staff members) on the GovOffice system Ability to limit access and administrative permissions to each user on the system Preview feature that shows how an unsaved edit would appear if it was saved and activated on the live Web site Live Site feature that allows users to switch between the live and administrative Web sites within one browser window Data storage tracker to help manage your load of Web content Audit log that shows editing activity of all administrative users Generate monthly reports that monitor traffic to and within your Web site X. Flexibility to name and order all navigation menu buttons Import, type, format, spell -check text (and more) GovOfFice is a Division of Ave net Web Solutions 2 13UU Gadward Street NE, Suite 2625 Minneapolis, MN 55413 Direct Phone: 612.617-5709 www.GovOtfice.com Features (continued) Standard Feature Create unlimited number of links to internal pages and external Web sites Upload, resize, position, and caption photos Online forms for questions, comments, and requests to be contacted by staff Post audio and video files Upload and name documents, such as Agendas & Minutes and your newsletters Schedule of events, including recurring events, within a true calendar display 1 I Online opinion polls with controlled responses and option to display the results Image gallery to create a Community Photo Album; includes siideshow capability Ability to add, turn on & of� and easily remove sidebars from all pages �J Directory, including contact information and photos, of Elected Officials and staff' Post news stories with a pre-set release date for automatic display on the live Web site Display job listings with post & deadline dates and post the employment application List Frequently Asked Questions by department or the entire organization Ilighlight "related links" to associated Web sites without posting long URLs Directory of local attractions and links to an online map Site Map for added ease by site visitors in locating a desired section of the Web site "Last Edit" stamp that shows the date on which any Web page was last updated "Printer -Friendly" option and some flexibility in the placement of the icon Search engine that also searches keywords within uploaded documents Option for advanced users to switch to HTML mode for editing—example: to embed community videos from your YouTube Channel or Google Maps of your area Intranet capability for "staff only" areas of the Web site; accessed only by username and password Sulk e-mail tool that allows visitors to opt -in and opt -out of receiving e-mail notifications from your government office RSS feeds "in" from other news -related Web sites GavOftiee is a Division of Avenet Web Solutions 1300 Godward Street NE, Suite 2625 Minneapolis, MN 55413 Direct Phone: 612-617-5709 www.GovO#iice.com "Premium" Custom {Graphic Web Design Upgrade: Overview: The GovOffice Design Team will engage in a full-service design process with the customer. The final version of the design will originate from totally unique drafts. As GovOffice applies the customer's feedback and suggestion for improvement, the fully customized design will strengthen over the course of multiple revisions. Service includes: • 3 draft, 3 revision process All drafts are unique (not limited by the layout or functional properties of a stock template) 1 fully customized banner for the home page (up to 4 images) Up to 4 additional customized banners containing up to 4 images per banner (16 total) 4 shortcut URLs to accompany the 4 additional custom banners • Development of an effective color scheme, including multiple colors • Adjustment of size to the menu, sidebar, and footer areas, as needed • Rollover ("pop out") menu feature, upon request, for simplified navigation of the Website • Split -Navigation feature (vertical and horizontal display of menu items), upon request ■ Liquid display or background color, upon request • Choice of placement of "Search" box, upon request • Creation and implementation of a Favicon {"favorites icon") to the URL bar, upon request • Implementation of"Today's Date Is..." display to home page banner, upon request ■ Addition of dynamic breadcrumbs, upon request, for enhanced site navigation Process: The Premium Solution is a 3 draft, 3 revision process. This means that the GovOf-fice Design Team will create three totally unique drafts that reflect the goals and objectives shared by the customer during the initial interview. When ready, the drafts will be submitted to the customer for evaluation. Upon selection of the preferred draft (I out of the 3) by the customer, GovOffice will fiu-ther develop it with up to three more rounds of revision before asking for final approval. Not Within the Scope of Service: The Premium Solution is strictly a custom graphic Web design service. It does not include the transfer (migration) of Web content—text, images, documents, and the like—from the Client's existing Web site onto the GovOffice system. Also, while GovOffice strives to complete each Client's custom design project as efficiently as possible, we do not guarantee the deployment ("go -live") of a custom design by or on a specified date. SuperForms Module The Client may create an unlimited number of powerful online forms for purposes such as online service requests, employment applications, questionnaires and more with SuperForms. The SuperForms may be configured to include fields for collecting a name, phone number, email address, mailing address, etc., text boxes ("Comment" boxes), radio buttons, checkboxes, pull-down menus, multiple choice lists, and lines of text to separate select fields. Lengthy SuperForms may be divided in multiple pages (pagination) with page breaks using automated, customizable "submit" buttons. The Client may export the forms data into a database for further management and reporting. Training and ongoing technical support of the SuperForms module will be provided by the GovOffice Customer Service Center (Technical Support desk). GovOffice is a Division of Avenet Web Solutions 4 13UU Codward Street NE, Suite 2625 Minneapolis, MN 55413 Direct Phone: 612-617-5709 www.GovOflice.com 90"fp,v Training and Support: GovOffice will provide an online training session (up to 1 hour) for the Client. Subsequently, the Client is entitled to 3 hours of online/ tall -free telephone support through the GovOffice Customer Service Center. If necessary, additional customer service time may be purchased at a rate of $60 per hour (112 hour minimum). Web Hosting: All GovOf ce customers are provided secure, Tier One hosting at a Qwest CyberCenter, which ensures the highest levels of security and firewall technology, powerful and reliable servers and systems, and robust bandwidth for maximum site "up -time" and rapid site access. The Client's Web site data will reside on one of the most advanced OC -192 broadband networks in the world, and Qwest CyberCenters are staffed 2417 with highly trained technical engineers that ensure that GovOffice's applications are available to the Client at all times. The Annual Service Package includes Web hosting for sites up to 1 GB (1,000 MB) of uploaded data, which will be monitored by GovOffice monthly, If more than I GB of storage is needed by the Client, the Extended Storage Plan is available for purchase, and it provides an additional 2 GB of storage at an annual rate of $480. Domain Name: If the Client already owns a domain name, that domain name may be re -directed to the Client's new Web site for a $75 one-time only charge. If the Client does not own a domain name, the GovOffice Customer Service Center will secure a two-year domain name (excludes .gov) registration on the Client's behalf and point that domain name to the new Web site for a $90 charge. Sulk E-mail (Text or HTML -entranced): Clients may send bulk e-mails through the GovOffice broadcast e-mail system. Up to 6,000 subscribers may receive one text or HTML enhanced e-mail per year at no charge (or 3,000 subscribers may receive two e-mails per year, or 2,000 subscribers may receive three e-mails per year, etc.). Overages will be billed on an annual basis at a rate of $.03 per e-mail that exceeds the limit of 6,000. By signing below, you agree t0 the deliverables of the "Prernium" design package as described on Page 4. Also, by paying for or utilizing the GovOffice.com Web service, you agree to the "Terms and Conditions" as they appear on our Web site at www.GovOffice.com/terms. Date: Printed Name and Title: Signature: Steps to begin service with GovOffice: 1. Please verify the Client's contact information at the top of Page 1. Then fax all pages of the signed "Quotation for Service" form to GovOffice at 612417-5741. You will be sent an e-mail that confirms receipt of your fax and outlines the next steps. 2. Avenet Web Solutions (the parent company of GovOffice) will e-mail the invoice to the "Site Admin" named above. 3. After GovOffice has received payment for %z of the contract amount, the "Site Admin" will be contacted by a member of the GovOffice Customer Service Center to schedule the online training session for staff. The remaining %2 of the contract amount is due within 30 days of deployment ("go -live") of the new Web site. GovOffice is a Division of Avenet Web Solutions 1300 Godward Street NE, Suite 2625 Minneapolis, MN 55413 Direct Phone: 612-617-5709 www.GovOMce.com DWe Thank You! Thanks for choosing us to be your new Web technology provider. Please keep the following contact information handy: Customer Service Center Contact us for all technical assistance related to your Web site; Moving forward, the Customer Service Center will be your primary contact with us Toil -Free: 888-353-3221 Web Site: www.help.govoffice.com E-mail: support(@qovoffice.com Billing Department Contact us with questions about future invoices Scott Ploehn, Finance Manager Direct Phone. 612-617-5706 E-mail: s loehn avenet.net Design Department Contact us to initiate your pre -paid custom graphic Web design project E-mail: designagovoffice.corn Sales Department Contact us to purchase a custom graphic Web design package or if any department, economic development, etc. wants a Web site of its own" Mike Chaloupka, Sales Representative Toll -Free: 877-554-4979, Press 3 Web Site: www.govoffice.com E-mail: mike ovoffice.com * repeat customer discount may apply City of Milton 13000 Deerfield Parkway, Milton, Georgia 30004 1 To: Honorable Mayor and City Council Members From: Christopher J. Lagerbloom, City Manager Date: Submitted on March 29, 2010 for the April 12, 2010 Council Meeting Agenda Item: Approval of a contract with Cook Construction Services, Inc. City Manager’s Office Recommendation Ratify the contract with Cook Construction Services, Inc. for the removal of an existing dump site at Birmingham Park. Background In preparation for the Birmingham Park Clean-up in 2009 an old dump site was found off of Old Bullpen Road. Because the site contained broken glass and various sharp metallic objects it was deemed to be unsafe for the volunteers to attempt a clean-up of this site. This contract is to have those materials removed from the site. Discussion Presented before you is a contract with Cook Construction Services, Inc. for the removal of an old dump site at Birmingham Park. The city received three bids for this project and Cook Construction Services was determined to be the lowest responsive bidder with a bid of $2,900. As an additional service Cook Construction Services, Inc was asked to move a number of mulch piles back to this area to act as stabilization at a price of $400 for total contract amount of $3,300. This contract is presented to council for ratification. Funding and Fiscal Impact The contract is based on a not to exceed fee of $3,300. Funds are available in the existing budget to cover the cost of this contract. Alternatives: There are no other alternatives. Concurrent Review: City Manager �,.. _' City of Milton SERVICES AGREEMENT t - SUOR 1 F ORN) :'+CREEMEN'T5 Si1l.000.00 OR L£55 r 3.A This Sen , ices A�wreeient (tht "A reenaemt") is made and entered into the _-_ cia• of '1010-, by and between the CITY OF MILTON, GEORGIA (hereinilier .referred to as the. "City"), attd Conk Construct ton Se¢yices. enc. (hem Ina:ller refurud to as the "Contrac (or '). W1TNF.S�FTH `I'HX1': WHERFAS, the C.1 1% desires to ent plo v a conlractc)r it) perforin the sety iees described her (n i I (tltc; "Work-) _ area WHEREAS. Con tratcwr has ham Mar ized itself ►N itIt the Contract DocuInenrts. as definez! the Work-, and with all local conditions and applicable federal. state and lrxmI lite'. s. ordIIlanees. rules and M-gulaation$. NOW THEREFORE, thre Citi and Comraeto . in CollM dcrat i on of the tnutual pronuscs contai tied herein and ether good and valvabli con-snderatiiort_ the Sufficiency of which is lyG:rth) aAjx)1,dcd cd. agree as folkms: Seetion 1. C mile iet i kwuniewN. i lei-. Ag etallel.tl :Ind the fullowitrg natiml I::,�ltibi4s, anaached hereto mW incorporated herein by referejlee, r:Otastittrtra the �`CUM-LtCt I) �ctmai nts" 1.X1 111 B i I A - WORK DESCRIPTION EM i 1-B I T B INSURANCE EXI]IB1T C — coN'TRAC;TOR AF II:)r VI'T AND AUKi UNI i:\ I 11X111.13.11 1.) — SU BCU.N 1 K AC l (W A -F F1 DAV 1.1 "ftp kho extent that there ntay be an\ con llI et ainonL, Clic Coutmct DOC LIrncnIS. the provision opecatnttg 11105l tta the hetic#it (if t t, City shall co%,ern. Section 2, The Work: Contreaur shall prttie idc a!I 11 on -k deticribed apt the Contract Documents. u.nit:;s ether►~,ise slated in the Contract Doctiments, the Work ;Itall in:Itkic C'nntr.rclor's provision of materials, labor. expenses, and any ether crest car item necessary to comp tc the N1 ctrl,. �%Iiich Is generally described its, REFER TO 1~X.1E31T A - WORK DESCRIP110N. Section 3. Contract Timig; Cutttramw undur-suvids that time is of the essQnce ol't fiiti At^reentent and uaM- ants that it will perform the WDrk in a prompt manner, Which shall M -A impose delays oil tln ltroucss of tlx: Work. It shall commerwt Work puv'suant to ibis Agrekement on ol- beFure a date to be specifI"! , ii a �cI -1ten ".Notice to Proceed- from the Cite, and shall fullY cc',frr1)lCit 111C WPTk 1%ithin 31] tla►s of'tbe "Notice to Proceerl", Seel>ison 4. Work 3ChangjLs: Aray changes to the Work rcquiring an increase in the Contract Paice;, as deiincd bc:lov.'_ Tall .require a change order c\Acc atcd lei the City in accordwice with its purchasing ri pulations. Section 5. C ompSwialion and !Mel hod (o IF Pav,_mcpt City aj�rees to pay Contraclor for thr s.ery ic• performed and coasts incurred by Contractor upon the City's ceat.tfic:atic-RI that the scrvicvs recto a-Q(U \ perFt nned all -Accosts actually incurred inaceordance with this Agreement- Conti pen sari oil for Oen ict• - Performed and. if applicable, reimburse-inettt for costs .inc:trrred shall 1ne paid to Contractor upon tl;c City .4 receipt and approval of an Invoice.. submitted upon completion of the Work. setting forth ill detail the :ervjcc-: 11crlt+rmed nad cois incurred. Invoices shall .rellect charges incurred versus charges bud�.geted. The total airotrnt paid under this Ag:reemeni for the Work Ahali nett. in WIN eraae. eXcud S3,390 (tier "Gontract Price"), except as outlined in Section 4 above. C fonlractor shall take no Calc olatod r:i*k In the performa.11ce 01' the N1 earl;, Specifically, Contractor agrees that in that event it cannot pull-fcarau tlae 1,'011% W itliiit 1.I1 -c t�ud,'Ittary linaittatictis estalhl'uytrccl Without disTC-gitrding sound principles of Contractor's industty, Contractor �-s1] ritten notice Thereof 'am mediately to the City. Seclion 6. Covenants of Contractor A.. Assignor -elft -ol Agreement: Contraclor covenanis and agroes not 10 assign or trattsier am iatterest in, alar dcleglati: an,, duties of'this Agrecnaent, �vitlacartt the prior cNpresa written consent of the City. B. Responsibility of Contraetnr aild Irndcn-ini5c:ation of C its'- Coalractor, coNrenants and agrees to take and assume Ell] responsibility ror the services imidered ill connection with the Work. Contractor shall bear all losses and d.ari ages direc#Iv nr indiT=tly r-esulti>rag, ita it on as Count of the perforntance or claar-atter of' llie sen i€'es rendered pursuiant to this A'A=i-ccinent. COnlr clor shall dedend, indvilliffy and hold h.arinless the C:1:13.. its t i:icers, txaards, commissions. elected and :appointed official -s, employees and agents from and against any and Al clainis, suits. actions. liabi iitv-.,udgrnents, damages. losses. and expenses_ including but not limited rto, attorney's fixs, which may be the resuh c l vv 111ful. neg.tigeut or tortious coaraduct arising out of thu NN ork, po-fortnance of contracted services, Lir operations by Contractor, any subcontractor, aiiNone directly or indirectly employed by Contractur or subcontractor tar Rina one for whose riots C onaractor or subcontractcw max be Iiab.le, regardess of whether or not the negli-e:nt.act is causerl in part .lx%. a party indelrinifoed hereunder. C. Independent Contrac(or: Contractor herebv covcounts and declaros t.har it is cngaged iri an i.ndepe.ndent lousiness rano! .au"s to :perform tfiC Work a .an ittriepende!it ccartta•acior, not 1s niycrnt or entlaluy'ee cal C'ity'. 911asratarc11 as City and {. 0111riaclol- etre colitrtaclors indepeadent of one another,_ :neither hill the dirthurilr to bind the other to av third person or othervv Be to tact in any way as the rep -vel- einative of the otlte.r. un)-us_s cthervv ise expre,slr agi-Qcd to in writing by botlt parties. Contractor agrees not to mpres-enl itself ass City'% agent for an} parr•ix'Ke to any party or to allow any ertlpluyce 10 do s0, unless spo:cifically taufliorit ed. in advance and lit writing, and then only for the limited purrA3se .st-ated in sudi authorization Contractor shall assts me full liability for any contracts or agreements Contrat`tor enters ]MOOD Ibchalfa.)f C IN v. iIhout the e\p.ress kno%vledge and prior Arillert consent of City_ D7 tusurancc: Contractor shall =hav c and Maii1wiil ill !Lill farce and e-tTW font the duratiOn of this Agreement, ansurtrnce aplarcaa ed by the C A%- :as :shown on Exh!lalt S. F. Licenses. Certifications and Pennits: Contractor cov',niants sand dcdares that it has Obtained and will maintain C111 tliplcoanas, certificates, licenses. permits or the like required by any national.. state_ regional, City_ and local buarals_ agencies, cona3aaissioias, curn11ittc4:5 rel 0111:r iegu.latcaa! bodies to pt-rl riu tht Work. Cuntractor shall comply with applicable legal requirements and aneetthe stet'€adard ofqua] ity ordinarily expected of its .hidustryI F. ()�%nwrsh11) of Work:.All reports, drawings, spccifications_ and other items, pi-elyared or In the prijcess of being prepared for the Work by Contractor ("materials") shall be the property of the City and the City shall be entitled to fit() a4ce.ss and copiea of kill materials, All copyrightable subject matter in all materials �s liereby assi=gned tai the City : std Contractor agrees to execute any additional ducunnents nec:essan to ex. idence siich assigmnent. G. Contractor's RevreSentaaive: d , 0 �__ shall be authorized to act on Contractor's bchtalf %) itli .Tcs;pect to the "Fork as Contractor's designated representative. H. Confidentiality: Contractor ackrio■vledges that it may rceci,c confidential information of the City and that it will lxotcct the confidentiality of wtv such confiderili al 1401ia10tiPit uaid �\ ill Teyuim any of its subcoTitracturs, consultatlts, an&or steal- to likewise pmtect such confidential Mforination. i. Meetir�Ls: Contractor shall meet with City's paersonne.i or designated representatives to resolve tcchatical or cornraclatil l pro blenis that allay occur dining the teirm otthe contract, at no add itionaI cost to City. Section 7. Warranty Contractor shall repair all detects in materials, eyuipineni, or workmanship appearing. within one year from the: date of completion of tlsc Work at no additional cost to the City. L Section 8. f'Erniination: 11e City relay- terminate this Agreement for convenience at any time upon �Nritte:n notice to C olltrachc _ Pt oe hied tho no damages are due to the City for Cont rat: trot" s bre avl► oafthis AgrCc.ancaat, the City shall pay t.'omra for for War. :} erl'orrned to clan in accordance vv'ith Section', herein. Section 9. Miscellaneous A_ Governing Law. .l lals Agree.ntent shall be goveriwd by the lames of the Mate of Georgia. B. Counter mils. This Agreement nim be executed in am nuinbcr'o couaneMarts, each ofwwhich shall be deem. ed to .be an oTi®:anal, but allof which loaether s.kiall constitute Anne and the Barras_ insirurmew. C. 50-cr'ei ltnmunid °. .Nothing ;oi aiucd in this Agi-eemem shall be con,,trned to be a 4aiver of the City's sovereign ammunny or any iudiv idual'.�, qualified _good faith or official imm►ini'ties. I). 1" -Verification. Contractor Oall pr vide eN i-aftncc Ou the 11irms ari.3cbvd hereto as F-�hihits "C" and STV' that it anti Contractor's stilxEontractors ccrndti'ct verification of employees as requ lrerl by O_C_G_A_ § 13-10-91 and reIaled rules prornaalgaled b% tilt f�eorgia Depariment of Labor or the Georgia Department of Transportation. The City Manager or his/her designee shall be authorized to conduct inspections of the Contractor's and Contractors subcontractors' verification process to determine that the verification was cflrreet and complete. Compliance wish the requi:renietat.s of O_C.G,At § 13-10-91 and nlawd rules promulgated by the (ief)rgra Department of Labor -or the Goorgi.a Mpartment of Transpoltallon, as applicable, is M andatoi,v. IN WITNESS W EREOF, the parties have iailsod This A reeuwrtt it) be uN.vc ted under seal as of the date first ai ovic �vrrttert. 1CONTRACTOR", . By - its: 745 771v 1lit - [AFFIXCORP ELATE SEALS CITY OF A11Ut'ONT G -ORGIA 4 ExI6-11�;4 OA: cfca, �ti7iJ Pirinirtgh m 1 igzhys a� s�7Q�33 'hone. 675-176-1744 Quote Chante Date: Februarys 3. 2010 From. Ccuk Curlstruction Services, Inc. 14570 Birmingham Highway Alobaretta, 0eorgia 30004 Attention: Marc Arrington Contact- Tac! Cook 676-776-1744 Birmingham Road Park Park 1jeanup, Warm Consists of: � I�ernoval of trash pit in dit li line toward back of property. rased on visual estimadon of debris in ground (4 dumpsters of material) Excavation cf trash pit a1,�ID0.[3[3 4 — 30 yard dumPsLers A- I Dirk placed in cxcavai don pit to fill void .N -ill be trucked from sail spoil area at property frontage to pit. Dirt compacted to match existing grades. Seed and straw disturbed soil area. $1,200.O0 Existing tree Mulch on site will be used fGr ground cover. Subtotal $4,200-00 Discount for donation to City of truck tirne for dirt moving and moving mulch pile -.400.00 IC TOTAL DID AMOUNT $ 3,500.00 :Mote: if estimation of viciterlal tides not fill the dumpsters, savings will be �Jisccunted to the City. � 19 CERTIFICATE OF 'LIABILITY INSURANCE -1'H15 CERTIFICATE IS ISSLIFO AS �1 YIATTEIR OF INFOIi<s6ATl0'N ONLY AND COWERS NO RIGHTS UP014 THE CERTIFICATE HOLDER. MIS CERTIFICATE DOES NOT AMEND. EXT040 OR P Box 78 At TER THE CDVERA'GE AFFORDED BY TME PQUCIES BELOW. jasper, Ga. 30143 706-692--6451 .INSLlRrF45 AFFORDING COVERAGE �lEAIC 4` MLSUIiED ' MISUREt A: Owners .._... ^ ... -- Crook Construction Services, Inc. I v-mrzo -Auvar,ican Zur3.c?Ia i1467070 Birmingham Hwy HGWi i4i I ton, CIA 30004 in5Llre£Ra.._.... _ __---• { I - - COVERAGES _. _.. PROOUCFR Lwsof) Insurance Aye11uy,1m;- 7 TETE POLICIES OF IN3L*UU^7GFLISrED BELCWi-A4VE BEEN ISStIED10THE INS RED NWED A3: 1!E FOR rHE POLICY PFRIDD INDICATED. 11401Wi NSTANDING ANY REOUIREW..NIT. TERM OR CONDITION OF ANY CONTRACT OR OTHER COCUMEN-C VATH RESPECT TO MUCH THI5-ULKIU-IGA I MAY ESL I5SUED OR rcAY PERTAIN. THE N$URANCE AFFOROEf3 BY YHE POLXIFS DESCAMED HEREIN IS S6'BJECT TO ALL THE TERTA5 FXCLU SION$ AND COWNI IONS OF SS1CH Pnl frNF—R AnaRLGATE LIM9TS SHOVVN MAY I WVE BEEN REIDUCED BY PAID CLAVAS. hmd a D'Is .- . T .. PbLIC7 NVfR6Efi rMICY FF=rCTIvr• I i1� Y Yl PCAICY �— 'A.f M - S ys aE+uEnAL LrAynrrY !I EACI1 �CCl1RREidi•E i 1,000,000 _ 13ENFJtA1 _ S+�a b ]C p:1+wF.LL481L]TY cLA>wsslln ri�fx:+:r.l? 09461$-48883661 4 I -23-U9-- 1-23--10 lr1c� HlEDExP wepa�Lx� s _ 5,000 E 1--23--10 -23-11 tMOI+AL nAuwIWMRY s 1,UDO,C�QD _ _._._.._.._........__ rF . Fz , 1, ()()0. coo Mit AGGREGATE UW AP"SKR f PRW'mTS-comPIOP'ACat3 S 1 1000 10'0'0 rF Ta I I Alil'DlIRR7L.E LIA86.f11' r �CONEII�Y]SiHPi.EilYhlt 6 1 0QQ ©0Q 7 V f AANY AUTiF : •` L ax;pensl _ ..... ALr. f.WVWfi TAIiTOS 47-863-661-00 1--23-09 3-23-10 I+'�i LRT �— S(,' _ILILL-UAEIrOS HptFR 1L]1T65 1--2.3 --- 10 1-23-11 f H[7D6i.Y §MlliliY ry AR'}M•QYw"FIEUAifT•.CLi {�� - - I �1 Y L5.1ftFGE • S tVarlm[ierrj t "AGE L.MNUrY AMC iJri1_Y • EA ACCIrw-r i. ANY Avga C'.TFaEfi S'HA1i EA ACC 6 —__-- __j,.,..._ ,431 fp ❑NLY, _.._. EXCESS I VNBRELIA LFALiLLfiY iI'I UGCLIWFL7dCE S CLAIMS NAM........_..._.. -- I! k614�=N T 40 r i WOPA MLOWE95ATLON Vr—STeA.TU-1.—._._. C� I RHDFURPLOYERS' LIARLT7f YIN oFClcsPr�esir twruN�rrnxEcimv� 11.. �?JI (Z2�g-915971 10�-27_09 1D-23-�10 E-L.EACSNACC1l?Eiaf s 1134,OpU„ +4Markdatory io Nit) f E.I_AISEASE---[A EM I'LOY $ QQ {ii�e s.dc�-ibe untlef SQcf�3AL Pf r„�E.4K;vi5CaWw --F.L LWEASE-FQLN:Y LiWT E _500,000 ^%OTHER i — U[i37.'R7Pl$dR�W��-r+'�3+>_i7�Algw�tJn r3+CAGL.l,SitpA3 RUVCU 9FCHVCiCSLISSGlT13�'[L1n�rRDYV7YP`13 CERTIFICATE HOLDER _- CANCELLATION - W J SFIOIII. ❑ ANY OF rHF. AEUV E tiE SCRE6ED F'DLICfES DE CANCELLE4@£FORE TFIE E%PiT+AT1DN 'City of Hilton U•4TE T7iFItEpF, TFC=_ iS51rlNG INSURER YYII.i ENL`c.AVflri TO MAII. _a(L DAYS 50.'R1T7E4 13000 Deerfield Parkway NOT ICS TO THE CER nF1CATE HOL.U[.R NAMED TO THE LE 1' r, BUT FAILURE TO 00 $O SHALL Ste 107 WPOSE NO ORLIGA71014 M UASII,1TY OF ANY KWti UPON TliF INSi1RER,-115 A33ENT5 OR ' Milton, Cia 30[)0111 R�PR'ESEWrA71VrE$. �. v Attn: Mare A-Tringtan I Aun �xlzE>�R� �Fcse:era�rre 2 5 1 20 0 810) @) 1998.2009 ACORD CORPORATION. Ail rights reserWed- Tlie ACORD (tame and logo are registered marks of ACORD STATE OF CEt�RGIA CITE' -OF MILT -ON EXHIBIT °'C" CONTRACTOR AF)F1DAN t VAN m.,fmli-Att' x By excciating IN,; a>fdaNit. the undcrsi&ned comractor verfflws its cornphaznce with-O.C.G..A. 13-10-9.I, stating aftini atively that tlae 1 n [vidual, firm. or corporation which is contracting -,N itli the City of Milton li.as registt:red x6th and .is in a federal work authorization pr-ograin, m accordance with the applicabilily pru� Inions and deadlines establislivd its 0,C.G.A. § 13-10-91. V11C undersigned itirther agrees that_ sliould it einpioy or contract with any subcontractor(s) in connection vk ith the physical purforanance ofseri ices p urstlant 14D tltis conlrac:t N ith the Cion- of :Mi lton, contrr actoT vvill secure from such subcontractor(s) similar verification of compliance with O.C.G.A. § 13-10-91 on the Subcontractor Af>fida-.it provided in Rule 300-10-01-.08 in the form attached hereto as Exhibit -'D.°, Contractor further agrees to niaintain records of such compliance and provide a copy of each such V.Cfi uu li uja to tfie 'CiLy of kliftou Cil the Limo tht sc1: Conti aulor(s) Lo plLn-roa-alk .sucla tic'r% lce- V r Basic Pilot Pro L, rain L'scr lrlentitication Number ___� d2l-� 13 Y 1 Ltlhc�rized [Nicer -or Ageist i)ate j 1 \ ti 1 [.1- CONTRA' VOR NANIF] k714__� fill, of :1i,tliorl/cLl ()lfiis.r or Agent of Contractor �oCCony l'riatted Nanic ref -Wi h orized t_ ) l l icer or Agent DAWN C. CROWLEY SUBSCli,1BED AND SWORN NOTARY PUBLIC BEFORE ME ON THIS THE Cherokee County, GA 0 l _ _1010 My Commission I Expires: July 18, 2013 Ti 1'ithliC v Commission Expires: 5 LXHIBI1_ "LY S'i'A'f F OF 6lE;0RG I A CITY OF MILTON AFFIDAVIT N By executing anis affidavit, thw widersi, c'd sut+contractor vearfies its compliance iaitl�.0 -A, § 0-10- 91, statim, affinnatively lhat the Individual, firm or corporation which is engaged in the physical performance of seri ices under a coxilract with (lame of contractor) on behalf of the City' of Milton has registered with and i -s purticip ating in a federal work authorization program. in accordance with the applicability provisions and deadlieues establisbed in OC.U.A. § 13-10-91, 1 1..'V 1.3mIc Pi1ol Program [user IdeattifcalionNumber BY-. Authorized C):t icer feat air: JfNSE.RT SUBCON ,R_,% WAMEJ --------------------- -- ----__ -- - Title a.i'r' ulhol-._ d C)t 1c r or,Agent of Subcontractor PrimedNamy f A uthorNzcd Offimr ter Agent SUBSCRIBED AND SWORN, BEFORE ME ON T141S THE Notary Publlic My Commission .Lxplres: 6 City of Milton 13000 Deerfield Parkway, Milton, Georgia 30004 1 To: Honorable Mayor and City Council Members From: Christopher J. Lagerbloom, City Manager Date: Submitted on March 29, 2010 for the April 12, 2010 Council Meeting Agenda Item: Approval of a software license agreement between Guardian Tracking and the City of Milton City Manager’s Office Recommendation Approve the attached software license agreement for Guardian Tracking. Discussion Guardian Tracking Software will allow the police department to record and document activities of the police department conducted to comply with State Certification through the Georgia Association of Chiefs of Police. In addition, the police department will share the system with the fire department enabling it to record and document agency operations and administration at the discretion of Chief Edgar. Funding and Fiscal Impact The purchase price of this system is included in the 2010 budget. An optional annual maintenance fee will be budgeted for future budget years. Concurrent Review: Chris Lagerbloom, City Manager Paul Higbee, City Attorney – approved to content and form on March 15, 2010. GUARDIAN TRACKING, LLC End -User Software License Agreement This End -User Software License Agreement (the "Agreement") is made and effective as of the date executed by the Agency below, BETWEEN: Guardian Tracking, LLC, a corporation organized and existing under the laws of the State of Indiana, with its office located at: P.O. Box 2291 Anderson, IN 46018 AND: The City of Milton, a municipal corporation organized and existing under the laws of the State of Georgia (the "agency"), located at: 13000 Deerfield Parkway Suite 107F Milton, GA 30004 LICENSING: The agency understands and agrees that a license to use the software, as defined herein, and the amounts paid to Guardian Tracking, LLC (hereafter "Guardian Tracking") are not intended to and do not fully reimburse Guardian Tracking for the full expenses of developing the software and the agency agrees that payment of any amounts therefore confers upon the agency only a perpetual, non-exclusive license to use the software subject to Guardian Tracking's proprietary rights to the same. Such license does not include the rights to reproduce, publish, transfer, or license any part of the software. Guardian Tracking expressly reserves and the agency expressly consents to Guardian Tracking's reservation of the entire right to protect copyright or otherwise reproduce, publish, transfer, sell and distribute the software to any other consumer. WARRANTY: Guardian Tracking warrants that the software being furnished hereunder is accurate and reliable and Guardian Tracking is responsible for correcting any program errors in the original software. It is expressly mutually understood and agreed that amounts paid to Guardian Tracking pursuant to this agreement do not include payment for any assumption of risk by Guardian Tracking and Guardian Tracking does not hereby accept any financial or other responsibility for any consequences arising out of the use of the software by the Agency. Guardian Tracking is liable only to the extent of contractual payments received from the Agency. The provisions of this paragraph apply not only to the software specifically described herein but also to any further material or modifications furnished by Guardian Tracking to the Agency. The agency understands and specifically agrees that the software is intended for use only with the equipment described in this Agreement and further understands that the software is not necessarily compatible with any equipment other than described herein. Guardian Tracking makes no representation or warranty of any sort that the software will be compatible for use with any equipment other than that described herein. It is mutually understood and agreed that Guardian Tracking makes no representation of any kind whatsoever relative to the proper functioning of the Agency's equipment with which the software is to be used, and that Guardian Tracking has no responsibility or liability of any kind whatsoever for the proper operation of said equipment. Guardian Tracking, LLC Page 1 of 4 End -User Software License Agreement Except as provided herein, there are no other warranties, expressed or implied, including but not limited to, any implied warranties of merchantability of fitness for any particular purpose. This agreement sets forth the entire understanding of the parties hereto and supersedes all other oral or written representations. In no event shall Guardian Tracking be liable for any consequential, incidental, indirect, or special damages of any kind upon breach of any obligation in or arising out of this agreement. The Agency understands and specifically agrees that they will protect and safeguard the software from unauthorized use by any party and in the event that any party has access to the software, that no portion or media, by any means, will leave the agency's premises. This Agreement may be executed in two (2) or more counterparts each of which is deemed an original of equal dignity with the others and which is deemed one and the same instrument as the others_ SOFTWARE LICENSE: Guardian Tracking hereby grants to the City of Milton, Georgia and its Police Department, a perpetual, nonexclusive license to install and use the Software on their Local Area Network, provided the total number of full, or part time employees at the agency does not exceed 100. As used in this Agreement, the term "Software" shall mean: GT2.0, featuring a "super administrator" with the ability to create multiple "stand alone" organizations within the same operating system. The Software is an employee performance documentation system that helps law enforcement agencies to manage employee performance documentation. The unique characteristics of the software include: 1. Browser based, not requiring installation on individual workstations. 2. Database and software hosted on your server not on the Internet. 3. Uncomplicated and easy to use. 4. Collects data to support: ■ Performance Evaluations - Justify high or low evaluation ratings. ■ Employee Awards - Back up your award nominations using records of outstanding performance. • Identifying Training Needs - Identify department and individual training needs using patterns of behavior or specific incidents. • Early Intervention - Save careers, and protect your agency from claims of negligent retention, by identifying early warning indicators as defined by your department policies. ■ Discipline - Defend corrective actions with supporting documentation. • Promotion - Promote employees who have demonstrated leadership knowledge, skills and abilities. Guardian Tracking agrees that the Software shall comply with these specifications, as well as those listed in Exhibit "A," attached hereto and incorporated herein by reference. In the event of any conflict between the terms of this Agreement and Exhibit "A," the Guardian Tracking, LLC Page 2 of 4 End -User Software License Agreement provision that operates most to the benefit of the Agency, as it determines in its sole discretion, shall govern. LICENSE AND MAINTENANCE FEES The agency shall pay to Guardian Tracking for the perpetual, non-exclusive Software License granted to the Agency herein the total, one-time sum of $4000.00. The agency has the option to pay an annual maintenance fee in the amount of 680.40, beginning one year from the date of installation of the Software at the Agency. The maintenance fee provides the agency with continued technical support, as described herein, and all software updates issued by Guardian Tracking. The annual maintenance fee will not increase for three years from the date of installation of the Software at the Agency. Thereafter, the optional maintenance fee will not exceed seventeen percent of that year's software price as published by Guardian Tracking, SYSTEM REQUIREMENTS: Windows 2000/2003 Server • 512 MB RAM 500 MB of free hard drive space for data files TECHNICAL_ SUPPORT: Technical support by Guardian Tracking covers software related problems as determined by Guardian Tracking only. Technical support will be available via email during normal business hours with a response within 48 hours. Technical support will only be provided at no cost on software within the first year from date of Software installation at the Agency, and annually thereafter upon Agency's payment of the annual maintenance fee described above. Guardian Tracking will assist the Agency with Software installation. After installation Guardian Tracking will assist the Agency with set up and training. Guardian Tracking will conduct a training session with the Agency and let the agency decide if it wants Guardian Tracking to provide a training session, or if the Agency wants to train its staff using the user manual and the training checklist Guardian Tracking supplies. This support is done over the Internet using GoToMeeting.com. BACKUP FILES: The agency is responsible for backing up the following data files: MDF and LDF files. SOURCE CODE: In the event the software is no longer supported, Guardian Tracking, LLC will provide the agency with the complete Source Code. SUCCESSORS AND ASSIGNS: The successors or assigns of the parties shall be bound to the terms of this agreement, to the same extent as are the parties. Neither party shall assign any portion of this Agreement without the express written consent of the other party. GOVERNING LAW: This Agreement shall be governed by and construed under the laws of the State of Georgia. SEVERABILITY: If any provision of this Agreement is held invalid or otherwise unenforceable, the enforceability of the remaining provisions shall not be impaired thereby. Guardian Tracking, LLC Page 3 of 4 End -User Software License Agreement NO WAIVER: The failure by any party to exercise any right provided for herein shall not be deemed a waiver of any right hereunder. ABSENCE OF THIRD PARTY BENEFICIARIES: Unless otherwise expressly provided, no provisions of this Agreement are intended or shall be construed to confer upon or give to any person other than the parties any rights, remedies or other benefits under or by reason of this Agreement. COMPLETE AGREEMENT: This Agreement sets forth the entire understanding of the parties as to its subject matter and may not be modified except in a writing executed by both parties. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties have executed this Agreement on the dates set forth first above, with full knowledge of its content and significance and intending to be legally bound by the terms hereof. Guardian Tracking, LLC Wen Jr. yanager is ael A. Reed Manager Date: March --..1.5,.2010 Guardian Tracking, LLC End -User Software License Agreement City of Milton, Georgia Authorized S ture I /ritle Authorized Signature Title Date:.,.,? - 30 - f Page 4 of 4 vuardian I racking 1 Uty of Milton Georgia - Exhibit A - 9 Total Pages `�� GuardianTracking Empfoyae perf"M Ilco 41"Wwwotatian software to support law enfam m.nt. Visit us at vmw.guardian-traching.tam 311 112U 1 L In l�WrWsnTrkY,ng Vk+G r.rr Coarc' Pna m 5.rwx' ���sxe E•��Ka .- �r+s Epee x.e•es snpory ea Q��' yr s.evwras Immediately access toe Recently created documents Chain of Command Uuardian I racking 1 City of Milton Georgia - Exhibit A - 9 Total Pages Ere _ nl -�.r..l •xcavr X. N, " ` " You decide the incident types! •. m 41w�w "^ C" - Eo Create new entries in seconds with ✓k Rlp^YM T,+ convenient dropdown menus and calendars. Attach documents or IInh related incidents! 311 r/2t] 1 C Moss incident creation — Select as many ?� employees as you want then create one entry. Guardian 7radxing will then create stand alone entries for each employee! .5nsia� Guardian I racking / City of Milton Georgia - Exhibit A - 9 Total Pages 3/11/201 C S,OwzVES — !Iw--Fm Printed Format tF— fjw - UUardian I racking / Uty of Milton Georgia - Exhibit A - 9 Total Pages '{rccrss w..S,.. •oar ir. V� Easy in...easy out system! er...F ai Get a qukh "snapshot" view of the types of documentation being entered for all personnel...or just your subordinates to help identify potential training needs. 3/11/201 L -o-e .yew .,. ,�.• .,...r ..x •;» Z Support performance evaluation and other personnel decisions with easy to run reports! d Uluardian I racking / Uty of Milton Georgia - Exhibit A - 9 Total Pages 3/17/201 C Get a quick review of the types of documentation entered on a pa irticular employee. A Guardian Twmr..g P !;cc Dcoar'n,ent, Welcorn e 7o Guard- nTrackiq 'o.tir,.Baker 1133, Recently CmaW and vicAenis Repays Ta Our Intervention feature early makes immediate notification to everyone in the employees chain of command. Printed Fornrick ........ ..... . . . . .......... A Guardian I racking 1 Laity of Milton Georgia - Exhibit A - 9 Total Pages a 4= CMMe Warr PepWB A"Ctne Lop OM Early Inlemyen:ion F !:Sark Smith OcctarW on wft*eday. 83. 2006. EriNnd E Y Jor. Bake- •2.3 2008 prm �awTwJbmOnbnWnlHbelw�vraw wew•]r Sr ex nrn•. Sir i:4 a:.. n.[w .�. e±ar rr+yrzrorRr�it,r.w.oarorr•p•Mverr�eevveeearie.�.rrrrnxeorra+.ra telly Welvertkprs For 8rmsequeM Enmea w�xawr SSW MRnt] AWrr LIM � •:':'•x Once a response is made the Intervention section closes, but will trigger again with each new Incident during the threshold period. a 3/1 If2U1 L � .. ...mo- harts% Creels View umw.Y %L' y RW" Aa a Creak a New Early Inter mum Response IncWer, r,..r�wxe F.x,rw..�o• - p�r`s.c r.w.. s,>•,.. �wvw lye.. ' ...� e.,._....�..� armee Crete Vb Reppne A.rowd _ =ark Inte^+emboP.. For Mark Sn)4h Cuurreo On WHmsday Fya2006 ......err ,a.e uwgrr newRm rp arm u....oxa�..�.Fvw.e4.�>t. rxvr�mrs im • rcr..n.rre�.1er.rM ieamnrwr r.dr...n.�..,e.w.ra�a�avW+amrre Early krt!ervenlpn For. Subs,menl Enlnes wrFen�rwrraa,a7ew AasalARr�ree.rYlLew E,wrre ey � Ams d� 123 -^_:Cd �:�me«n�>,e� - .. -. r..=rr.cxnm+caen re.aoaerreew.gNewmraetnrunn+wrenars M1 .lry ie�araw]�p•" ' - ..A Y.+ef W•s�'w CM ME*e Automatic review by up -line supervision Moat Crass •nee inner.enliw Report% ACCOM uq Ot7 EarlyInter;ent:or. Early Inlwanftn Flag FwSrcam. Mak (IMi WmW on IZaf 0o6 ..wi. �oTl7!n1� CnRr �wpew carr The incidents which triggered the intervention are automatically linked to the flag and response. a 4= CMMe Warr PepWB A"Ctne Lop OM Early Inlemyen:ion F !:Sark Smith OcctarW on wft*eday. 83. 2006. EriNnd E Y Jor. Bake- •2.3 2008 prm �awTwJbmOnbnWnlHbelw�vraw wew•]r Sr ex nrn•. Sir i:4 a:.. n.[w .�. e±ar rr+yrzrorRr�it,r.w.oarorr•p•Mverr�eevveeearie.�.rrrrnxeorra+.ra telly Welvertkprs For 8rmsequeM Enmea w�xawr SSW MRnt] AWrr LIM � •:':'•x Once a response is made the Intervention section closes, but will trigger again with each new Incident during the threshold period. a 3/1 If2U1 L � .. ...mo- harts% Creels View umw.Y %L' y RW" Aa a Creak a New Early Inter mum Response IncWer, r,..r�wxe F.x,rw..�o• - p�r`s.c r.w.. s,>•,.. �wvw lye.. ' ...� e.,._....�..� armee Crete Vb Reppne A.rowd _ =ark Inte^+emboP.. For Mark Sn)4h Cuurreo On WHmsday Fya2006 ......err ,a.e uwgrr newRm rp arm u....oxa�..�.Fvw.e4.�>t. rxvr�mrs im • rcr..n.rre�.1er.rM ieamnrwr r.dr...n.�..,e.w.ra�a�avW+amrre Early krt!ervenlpn For. Subs,menl Enlnes wrFen�rwrraa,a7ew AasalARr�ree.rYlLew E,wrre ey � Ams d� 123 -^_:Cd �:�me«n�>,e� - .. -. r..=rr.cxnm+caen re.aoaerreew.gNewmraetnrunn+wrenars M1 .lry ie�araw]�p•" ' - ..A Y.+ef W•s�'w CM ME*e Automatic review by up -line supervision vuardian I racking / Uty of Milton Georgia - Exhibit A - 9 Tota{ Pages • � .may- y T'; Ural. F.•fu�aa tj - Easy set up for system administrator! 5— C-" 311712-01 C �K .•N 'NV-'nK.6n �'n� a Vou decide the level of access for each employee q—�— KM* V" Reacr5 kCVA A4Er"e 'velar -age Hierafch, RegutS To, Easy set up for any chain of command! Make asslgnmerrts and transfers in seconds! Sumrosa�et 5— C-" 311712-01 C �K .•N 'NV-'nK.6n �'n� a Vou decide the level of access for each employee q—�— 7 Create you osAm li?ddent categories! Set purge dates for individual Categories and mQiae outdated categories Inactive. ow q..M rw. err►...s. . .,w.,. Cpry i.d(r -n+w.. Gnus ��M. 7 Uuardian I racking / Uity of Milton Georgia - Exhibit A - 9 Total Pages Create as many organizations as you need! 3/11/201 C FJK� ro k4 Seua�nn. The "Super AdminiArotor" has the ability to create different oTgnnizatiws within Guordian Tracking. mum v" Repwis kmo Mviap L09 LM Vou choose the type of incidents you want to trach! You set the thresholds! ............ . ... .......... Create as many organizations as you need! 3/11/201 C FJK� ro k4 Seua�nn. The "Super AdminiArotor" has the ability to create different oTgnnizatiws within Guordian Tracking. Createorgonizat lonal administrators within eoch department! 1w! a•rt�1NC Guardian I racking 1 Uty of Milton Georgia - Exhibit A - 9 Total Pages res kxaw wp. .a[� rdanegr Empl7yees a.e a.. Transfer employees and their past documentation from one organization to another! Please call if you have any questions. Contact Irrfvrmotion: Mike Reed milze@guardion-tracl?fng.com (765) 621.8424 Lean Warllembi lean@guardian-tracking.corn (765) 621-6764 :3/1 tiZU'IL Guardian Tracking will help provide proofs for a number of GALEA standards, including: 26.1.a - Maintenance of records of disciplinary actions. 3551.5 - Evaluations - lustily high or low ratings 35.1.6 -- Notification of unsatisfactory performance - at least 90 days prior to the end of the rating period. 36_1.7- Employee Counseling Results of evaluation just completed Level of performance expected Career counseling 35_1.9 - Early Warning System - monitor thresholds or patterns based on time frame, Sz2_1 - Types of eomplairtts to be investigated by ilne supervisors. 52.2.2 - Notification of chief. The less serious -those not requiring Immediate explanation, the notifloation could take place by Guardian Tracking. p YGuardian.%radz' Sc ail dowai3't FS;)C':i: Y:.Y,i:t3£i's 62 -'34-:4 "I s 1� riga ref wn-track if ag...c, Faa 3 Chief Deborah Harrell Milton Police department 13000 Deerfield Parkway Suite 107F Milton, GA 30004 Guardian Tracking, LLC is the creator and the sole vendor of the Guardian Tracking Personnel Performance Documentation 1 Early Intervention Soft- ware. The product is considered a trade secret of our company. No other party is capable of supplying the product or performing the various maintenance responsibilities (i.e. code corrections, product update and techni- ca[ support) since there is no outside access to the source code for the product. Thus, Guardian Tracking, LLC is the sole source for sales and maintenance services on the software in question. In addition we know of no other performance documentation 1 early intervention software offering similar functionality - I hope that this meets your needs. Should you have any questions, or if we may be of further assistance, please do not hesitate to contact me. Sincerely. Leon Wasilewski Co -Owner Guardian Tracking, LLC (!f17�i�il]%k:rr x,r>r �ar•r>3:�r�te cso€:ui�t�:a�tari:;n .zt71 ��ar:� 7 V V = V � C a .0 Ev 0 CL � CL a � o 3 W N 1� a% b ��J 3 0 z E d E 'v -22 W ^ 7 a O -0 C i..f� Q T C y � W V � W C N L f`�^ o 2 W a m [� j= me Qi C w g `aU d a Y 0 C m E a��i :_. G) a U m a �a a3 u1 v w o d d Com• OW o cFl � N � N CL o — C N 3 RM a a c 0 @ o [i = E m E _ 0o L SsM til L o ut33 E � �, A � c13 7 co 7' 0 Q N (D uy=i ID J L1J m o � G [17 z E d G 0 O C A' W W E 2 m V {yQ � W a C = m m � 1 v W O a w u O VrLCL a L'3 C E 44 a G 0 v CU CU = C7 � � f n K O � f N { � y N � Q C i mai f � cog m v i U � O C � L f � f y m � C - LD C �' y � Ctl :Rl Y 47 C 'i . r C C O U v Li'] - N pp N N 0 .,. ^ C+ N _ CN mL ') mU i--���cn� ce F`, 1/► E u 0 E E CL0 0 a s L3 Q m �. a. m V I CL a) E ca or If a v Q L Co o c� � �v cu v 0 r C C O U v Li'] - N pp N N 0 .,. ^ C+ N _ CN mL ') mU i--���cn� ce F`, 1/► E u 0 E E CL0 0 a s L3 a Lb V. L CL s i L O d Q J - E Uv► o ul Q i� 0 QD p {3 v V1 u C ca o E o oa4 E w O N +� Q% E E ;=, -0aQD `-' Q °' ►v �' v cin' 72�—� w 0 C [75 E °i 3-j-10DD CL IL � � o CL s i L d Q - E Uv► o ul Q i� 0 QD p {3 v u C ca o E o oa4 E O N E ;=, -0aQD `-' 0 4° °' ►v �' v cin' 72�—� w 0 C [75 E °i 3-j-10DD CL IL CL s i VR 4 U U Q N 4 D 3 U V � � ate-• M�r� � U- �VLL m a a U dP m �.► � ce u M U AW W ,w L Cl a� a� a a� •� o (1) o CL a E E 4) W 4 U U Q N 4 D 3 U V � � ate-• M�r� � U- �VLL m 79 U dP m ce M U V V L L 0 0 2 4-J L � a os � a E 0 f wE Y A ti �El F-5 Q �u 3 Q as � ■ m � � � U � o � N Z V �] Ed 4J r7 C UaJ Q U G a uiCTO ti �El F-5 �u 3 as � ■ m � � � o � N U V Ed 4J C UaJ �a W f L WIv y o� L .a �g a a m o � V � n -O y q � � � � Vr u�i a rF.i C y $ rn� C G L V -0 N � N � O Q � N Q1 G V C L x d y E IOD t7 C Oi V � m n P raj O C " 9 ID ti �El co CN ; cn � 0 k � R m Cl- � 2 . � 3 S CN Q; a � ( la - $ § co - 2 7 � § L k � � t\ tm N 0 Y U- 4-1 y LLI jgO yp Q � � Q � 4 'L} c � a m ai 0 Y U- 4-1 LLI CL yp Q 4 'L} � a m a �] Q (4ti W C!) �w L CL �. Q to CP =3 ;S 0 Y U- 4-1 CL 0. a cm 0 C M Q) a) 0� Ch rn M 0n C') M M Ot Cft O O gOg O Oi O O O �Ov O O O O O 3C (M ca 00 00 oc ao oa a�o 00 0 o a o O o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 G Q a M d d a c6 ce c6 m cv ce cc ce a m w m To am o c o o 43 8 g c c 4c" -3p o$ 8 c c o Ea C:. ySN N C C C N C7 N N Cfl 03 CV C7 O 47 4 O O O C7 O Cs O O O O cy^7 ^ ^ C'S N c8 Ev r-L O p o a a a T3 m Cd % ccs v � Q V_ U a � ca LL. U Z5 m 0! o m U C M Q) a) 0� Ch rn M 0n C') M M Ot Cft O O gOg O Oi O O O �Ov O O O O O 3C (M ca 00 00 oc ao oa a�o 00 0 o a o O o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 G Q a M d d a c6 ce c6 m cv ce cc ce a m w m To am o c o o 43 8 g c c 4c" -3p o$ 8 c c o Ea C:. ySN N C C C N C7 N N Cfl 03 CV C7 O 47 4 O O O C7 O Cs O O O O cy^7 ^ ^ C'S N c8 Ev r-L O p o a a a T3 m Cd % ccs ILI A � § 0 > t a ■ % .m § co K k k m ƒ � u tuLE � � � O 2 12 \m C CL U- A\ct � K § \ \ % / \ ui 2 3 £ = 9 § e \ 7 A A IS fL-72 T T 2 k k k o k k 0 e A A 2* I w o 0 a V=IP � \ � � / � / cq r4 � aj w \ \ / CL ra ea _o ) k k \ § ] §/ f e e r J J u ... e . ....... xi C cv Q LL b I Q m m J CD pE C ;3 } 3 f [UOCq $ I _ $ co 5 h h h W h LL 3 Ol 01 O] o Ft lit y a a Q ' i l LL _ !d (d LL _ (d (G C Q 0 m Q N O S�3 C aN O O N O $N O �V d) �_ C7'1 5pV 47 07 y7 O C� N m ti ti ti1�! ti ti ti U] Vl N Ul N Vf N N U d} m m m m v us ••��. V■ � � � � N NN I!1 IpA� N U) O C c yN pN� 7CLa,G O Q C G C C C b It W 4� J F.] Q 4�' %A t3 .N E � a o a uma CL V L Qj +� a � �V— ��s 0 N Ch C14 c to ': O N m � �f E Q Q CD i . a � c: Q 4�' %A t3 .N E � a o a uma CL V L Qj +� a � �V— ��s C5 u I co Cl • � � r� _ � v v� G v� v n v n v � n c� �n Y o� 0 4� � 4 > `o[ o € H 0o c a i Q 111 w N CL lei I : mI al ted) Cl N" _. CL c : }¢{ 4-J qa .. `�' � rte ¢ N C •L CL J $ v a iX 446 $ to � $ � c J � � o '� C G p a AF- $2 j cal At7 c7 o d ode r[' u3 I �I C5 u co Cl 0 > `o[ o € H 0o c a i Q C w N m s : mI al ted) N _. m 4] 1 a1 n — `y b T O Ql m 01 W 7 41 Lf. h IL > C7 L 4 a o o 0 4 0 4W u 3 E o L w `k v m a J x < yca '1 a) E a 0 m CD 0 CV rt o 0'+ EJ g n t3 E U— CL I 81! N v OL o d m ami d � W v 3 611 EJ g n t3 E U— CL I mm O U Q 42 co 10 Co N rn rn S' 32 l� I N m m O J Z co Qi y O 7 G Q L2 m - � C_7 S' 32 0 4 % I co � U R A ii xx x x x d m m 5 E2 JCA1ln n u �41 _J t5 Q U (,1 Q 12 0 co U O U U El O v a E E 0 N- 0 r. s _0 aL E w ate.• _ - � O y' C> 6 O� CtiEN�d1�p0N �_ C ��� ce cVYsN�'— -N �e G G? tC�tl d �-9 O q 0 LL Cid V rn �E ��Q m�� �-��O ��A�� g E �7 3+G �"''"� C ff �t z� j,C =A RA QL [C L (air, a c6coCOC63V a E E 0 N- 0 r. s _0 aL E w �.a na - cu [g cz L IF Uk a� a E E 0 N- 0 r. s _0 aL E w X Go a N N C - fl) in rn co r L cu C rr�� V / O LL tm co O U] a i� cu W co Q C7 C3] C 0 a. w `w 0 L EL L o IOUs C s � � s � o 9Q . ... ........ r � . . � � .. y. Q � � � O � �\ � � cri , � � � � � � �\ � m cri � c O d 0 CL CO 2 E § q LU z � o � m rZ- . � W � m W , cc co 0' E& m � , �\ � m ■ � d 0 0 2 E § q LU z , LL � b E 5 n la C � t La 4'7 K-1 a C7 0 J Lco O G7 O N Com] 00 +r O a 4 CD lo in = N N Q �o�yy LJ- p u n w cu Q W ���� cv c 0 04 V 4-J s a� u . Ile ca a L .� CD "is <D EH2 %A S_— o a W � � v coCD C70 rI• CCS U EP cn L u .� as a .a KD CD }, I i Q V 2 —� w C V.I. OD q7 C1 C > r y� vi c 0 E co C LU C" s L:1 UA co �S 0 a �' }� CDCD O LaEnEn L v LLJ tL co O � � r CN Qm S9, _ CID m v � � ei3 v : � 0 G S �+ � � N � o " ui — eti � oci C a' CN M 0 CD m — c 1 0 0 _- S W Un En Un rtrt 05 U) V] O G iLn U 01 LU C — � � 2r Y O 2) 00} Q 0- �+ N cn a L Cl) vi c 0 E co C LU C" s L:1 UA 0 0 J [A r CCS CCS XD Ery C-s� R3 C' (A } c 0 c 7N L C a w (D O] m Cv m 2 ti nC? 0 N O m 7 0 ®i-1 4J W ail C) M" City of Milton 13000 Deerfield Parkway, Milton, Georgia 30004 1 To: Honorable Mayor and City Council Members From: Christopher J. Lagerbloom, City Manager Date: Submitted on March 29, 2010 for the April 12, 2010 Council Meeting Agenda Item: Approval of a contract with PropertyRoom.com City Manager’s Office Recommendation Ratify the contract with PropertyRoom.com for the disposition of evidence and property. Background The City of Milton Police Department currently has an I.G.A. with the Alpharetta Department of Public Safety for evidence and property handling. The City of Alpharetta currently uses PropertyRoom.com for the disposition of items of evidence and property once all disposition procedures through the court have been completed. Discussion The City of Alpharetta currently uses PropertyRoom.com for the final disposition of non- returnable items of evidence and property. Since the City of Alpharetta handles all evidence and property for the Milton P.D. it would be the most efficient and economical for Milton to also use PropertyRoom.com. The City Attorney has reviewed and approved the contract. It comes before the Council at this meeting for ratification. Funding and Fiscal Impact The contract has a slight positive fiscal impact, although estimates are not available. The contract incurs no cost to the City of Milton. Alternatives: Not to use PropertyRoom.com and arrange the disposition of items of property and evidence with current manpower and resources. Concurrent Review: Paul Higbee, City Attorney – approved to content and form on March 11, 2010. AUCTION SERVICES DISPOSITION AGREEMENT TERMS AND CONDITIONS Auction Services Disposition Agreement These Terms and Conditions set forth the terms Upon which PropertyRoom.com, Inc., a Delaware corporation ("PRC"), will handle the auction and disposition of Property provided from time to time by the Contracting Organization or any Sister Agency of the Contracting Organization {jointly and severally, the "Owner") to PRC (the "Disposition Services") on behalf of, and as agent for, the Owner. These Terms and Conditions may be accepted by PRC, on one hand, and the organization to which the Services are provided (the "Contracting Organization") on the other hand, by (i) the execution of a written agreement expressly incorporating these terms, together with any attachments or addenda expressly incorporated therein (the "Executed Documentation"), (ii) the presentment of these Terms and Conditions as part of a proposal letter, proposaf documentation or other written submission signed by PRC and acceptance in writing (whether by fetter, facsimile or e-mail) of such materials by the Contracting Organization without modification (the '"transaction Documentation"), [ill) the presentment of these Terms and Conditions as part of a proposal letter, proposal documentation or other written correspondence signed by PRC and the subsequent submission by the Contracting Organization of Property to PRC for the performance of Disposition Services. These Terms and Conditions may also be accepted by any municipal, county or state governmental agency located in the state in which the Contracting Organization is located (each a "Sister Agency) by the submission by the Sister Agency of Property to PRC for the performance of Disposition Services pursuant to the terms and conditions of an Agreement between PRC and the Contracting Organization. The agreement between the PRC and the Owner (the "Agreement") consists of these Terms and Conditions and (i) if any Executed Documentation exists, such Executed Documentation, (ii) if no Executed Documentation exists but Transaction Documentation exists, such Transaction Documentation. if neither Executed Documentation nor Transaction Documentation exists, then the Agreement shall consist solely of these Terms and Conditions. The Agreement, as so defined, collectively comprises the entire agreement between PRC and the Owner relating to the subject of the Agreement and supersedes any prior understandings, agreements or representations by or between the parties, written or oral, which may be related to the subject matter hereof in any way. The Agreement cannot be modified except in writing by the duly authorized representatives of PRC and the Contracting Organization. 1. Property to Be Sold. From time to time, Owner will designate items of property (the "Property") that it desires to provide to PRC for Disposition Services. PRC retains the right to accept or reject certain items as Property in its sole discretion. Z. Title to Property. Owner shall retain legal title to the Property until it is purchased by auction or otherwise disposed of in accordance with the Agreement at which time owner will be deemed to have transferred title to the purchaser or other acquirer of the item of Property (the `Buyer"). Owner appoints PRC as its 1of10 AUCTION SERVICES DISPOSITION AGREEMENT TERMS AND CONDITIONS representative and instrumentality to hold and offer for sale on Owner's behalf the Property, in accordance with the Agreement. In connection therewith, Owner appoints PRC as its attorney-in-fact to sign any and all documents necessary to assign to Buyers all of owners right, title and interest in and to Property sold or disposed. Owner's Property shall, at all times before sale or disposition, be subject to the direction and control of Owner. Cash receipts, accounts receivable, contract rights, notes, general intangibles, and other rights to payment of every kind, arising out of the sales and dispositions of Property (collectively the "Proceeds") belong to Owner, subject to payment of amounts owed by Owner to PRC and to third parties pursuant to the Agreement, which amounts shall be disbursed by PRC on behalf of Owner as provided in the Agreement. 3. Method of Selling Property. a. Portable Property Items. PRC will, on Owner's behalf as its representative, pick-up, store and list Property for sale by auction to the public on the internet on one or more domain names selected by PRC. To the extent that any Property is not sold by auction, PRC may, in any commercially reasonable manner selected by PRC, dispose of Property. PRC will determine all aspects, terms and conditions of auctions of Property and dispositions of Property not purchased at auction, subject to the ultimate control of Owner. PRC will handle all phases of submitting the Property for auction, including, but not limited to, determining when Property will be auctioned, setting the opening and reserve prices of Property, if any; setting the length of time Property will be auctioned; creating text and graphics to describe and depict Property submitted for auction; collecting Buyer information (such as name, billing address, shipping address, and credit card information); approving Buyer credit card purchase transactions; and collecting auction proceeds for completed sales from Buyers. PRC shall use reasonable commercial efforts in auctioning and selling the Property on the Internet and disposing of Property that does not sell at auction. PRC shall sell and dispose of all Property "as is" without any liability to the Owner. PRC is solely responsible for identifying and resolving sales and use tax collection issues arising from Property sales, including the necessity of charging and collecting such taxes. b. Large Property Items. PRC will, at Owner's request and on Owner's behalf as its representative, list physically large Property ("Large -Items") for sale by auction, including but not limited to cars, trucks, boats, planes and bulk lots of bicycles. For Large -Items, PRC offers Owner different selling options ("Gold" and "Platinum"), each with different service components and associated pricing. (1) In -Place Options. For Gold, PRC will auction Large -Items in-place, and in this context, "in-place" means that PRC will not pick-up and store these specific Items but rather Owner will maintain physical control until transfer of titie to such Large -Items to Buyers. (2) Haul -away Option. For Platinum, PRC will, in conjunction with an agent or subcontractor of PRC and to the extent practical, pick-up and haul -away Large -items, selling via online auction and transferring title and physical possession to Buyers as described in Portable Property Items. (3) Large -Item Service Summary. The Large -item Auction Services Option Table below depicts service components associated with each option. 2 of 10 AUCTION SERVICES DISPOSITION AGREEMENT TERMS AND CONDITIONS Method of Selling Property. Large -item Auction Services Option Table F...,... 1. List Large -Item for online auction PRC PRC 2. Checklist review and coordination PRC PRC 3. Listing write-up and marketing PRC PRC 4. Auction and auction technology management RRC PRC 5. Customer 5upport to Bidders PRC PRC 6. Coordinate Buyer payment and Large -Item pick-up PRC PRC 7. Transaction (payment) processing PRC PRC 8. Photographing, vehicle review, equipment description Owner PRC 9. Provide or procure asset title documentation, as applicable Owner Owner'"* 10. Pick-up and haul -away for off -premises online auction PRC * PRC provides its Platinum service in cooperation with Copart, Inc., ("CPRT") a publicly traded U5 company with over 140 geographically -dispersed vehicle storage facilities. ** At Owner request, RRC and CPRT will acquire title documentation through an agent or subcontractor of PRC. 4. Term and Termination. a. The Agreement will become effective upon formation (the "Effective pate") and will continue for an initial term of one (1) year from the Effective date and thereafter will automatically renew for consecutive one (1) year terms unless written notice of non -renewal is provided by either party to the other at least sixty (60) days prior to the expiration of the then current term. b. The Agreement may be terminated if there is a breach by either party of any obligation, representation or warranty contained in the Agreement, upon thirty (30) days prior written notice to the other party unless the breach is cured within the thirty (30) day period, provided, however, if the breach is not capable of being cured within thirty (30) days, the breaching panty will have a reasonable amount of time to cure the breach if it begins to cure during the thirty (30) day period and proceeds diligently thereafter. The written notice will specify the precise nature of the breach. c. The rights of the parties to terminate the Agreement are not exclusive of any other rights and remedies available at law or in equity, and such rights will be cumulative. The exercise of any such right or remedy will not preclude the exercise of any other rights and remedies. d. Notwithstanding any termination by either party of the Agreement, RRC will continue to remit the Proceeds arising under the Agreement (net of amounts owed by Owner to PRC and to third parties pursuant to the Agreement) in connection with any sales made before the effective date of the termination. At the time of termination, any unsold inventory shall continue to be auctioned by PRC or disposed on behalf of Owner or returned to Owner, at Owner's election and cost. 9of10 AUCTION SERVICES DISPOSITION AGREEMENT TERMS AND CONDITIONS S. Allocation of Sales Proceeds. a. Portable Property Items (1) Sales Price. The total amount of Proceeds paid by Buyer shall be called the "Sales Price." The Sales Price shall include the winning bid amount (the "Winning Bid") and all costs, shipping and handling charges, taxes, and insurance costs associated with the transaction and paid by Buyer. (2) Transaction Costs. PRC shall utilize all costs, shipping and handling charges, taxes, and insurance costs collected from the Buyer (other than the Winning Bid) to pay or remit such costs, shipping and handling charges, taxes, and insurance costs on behalf of Owner and Buyer, as applicable. (3) PRC Commission. For each item of Property, Owner will pay to PRC (by deduction pursuant to the section titled "Payment Terms" below) a fee (the "PRC Commission") equal to fifty percent (50%) of the first $1,440 of the Winning Bid and twenty five percent (25%) of the Winning Sid portion, if any, that exceeds $1,000. The amount of the Winning Bid remaining after deduction and payment of the PRC Corn mission w i i I be called "Owner's Gross Proceeds". (4) Processing Costs. Credit card processing costs ("Credit Card Cost") and affiliate processing fees (the "Affiliate Fees," which include commissions and processing costs paid to third parties IF such a third party sent the winning bidder to the website), will be borne by Owner and PRC in proportion to the ratio of Owner's Gross Proceeds to PRC Commission. Owner's portion of Credit Card Cost and Affiliate Fees (collectively, the "Processing Costs") will be paid by PRC to applicable third parties on Owner's behalf. (5) Net Proceeds. The amount of the Winning Bid paid to Owner after deduction and payment of the PRC Commission and Processing Costs will be called "Owner's Net Proceeds". Portable Item Example. The following example illustrates allocation of proceeds from a Portable Property Item sale. Assume an item of Property sells at auction for a $100 Winning Bid; the Buyer pays shipping and handling of $10, insurance of $2, and sales tax of $6. The Buyer pays the Sales Price of $118.00 ($100 + $10 + $2 + $6) by credit card, and the Credit Card Cost is 3% of the Sales Price or $3.54 (0.03 x $118) and the Affiliate Fee is 4.8% or $4.80 (0.048 x $100). PRC will retain $10 of the Sales Price for shipping and dandling, $2 for insurance and $5 for remittance to relevant tax authorities. PRC will pay itself from the Winning Bid the amount of $50 as the PRC Commission. As the ratio of the PRC Commission to Owner's Gross Proceeds is 1:1, the Credit Card Costs and Affiliate Fees are shared equally, $1.77 each ($3.54 -• 2) for Credit Card Cost and $2.40 each ($4.80 + 2) for Affiliate Fees. The portion of the Processing Fees allocated to Owner (that is, $4,17) will be paid to the relevant third parties out of Owner's Gross Proceeds, with the remainder being the responsibility of PRC. Owner's Net Proceeds equal $45.83 ($140.00 Winning Bid less $50 PRC Commission less $4.17 Owner's share of Processing Costs). (6) Fuel Surcharge. PRC does NOT charge pick-up fees. Instead, a fuel surcharge ("Fuel Surcharge") will be paid to PRC out of Owner's Net Proceeds for each Portable Item manifest when diesel prices rise above a specific level as shown in the Fuel Surcharge Schedule below. PRC tracks benchmark average diesel retail prices as published online by the Energy information Administration of the US Department of Energy and resets its fuel surcharge quarterly based on average weekly pricing from the prior quarter. Fuel Surcharges, if any, are deducted from monthly Owner's Net Proceeds. 4 of 10 AUCTION SERVICES DISPOSITION AGREEMENT TERMS AND CONDITIONS Fuel Surcharge Schedule (7) To the extent that Property is not sold by Auction and PRC disposes of Property in a commercially reasonable manner (see "Method of Selling Property" section), including, but not limited to, sending to a charity, recycling center, landfill, or scrap metal processor, Owner understands and agrees to the following. (a) When Property is not sold by Auction, PRC disposition activities create additional PRC processing costs (the "Disposal Costs") and potentially a disposition Sales Price (the "Disposition Proceeds"). (b) Disposal Costs include, but are not limited to, labor cost of reloading Property onto a truck, labor and vehicle costs associated with transporting Property for disposition, and third -party fees, such as landfill, recycling, and hazardous material disposal fees. (c) Disposition Proceeds include, but are not limited to, a Sales Price obtained for scrap metal. (d) PRC will bear the burden of Disposal Costs. (e) Owner will pay to PRC the Disposition Proceeds, if any, as an offset to Disposal Casts, except if Disposition Proceeds for an item of Owner Property exceed $250, in which case Owner shall be entitled to retain a portion of Disposition Proceeds calculated in accordance with Section 5a above, provided that the Disposition Proceeds will be deemed to be the "Sales Price" and the Disposal Costs will be deducted as a transaction cost under Section 5a(2) above. b. Large items. (1) Sales Price, PRC Commission, Processing Costs and Net Proceeds. Calculated in a manner directly analogous to Portable Property Items. (2) PRC Commission. For each large -item of Property, PRC will be entitled to a PRC Commission equal to a percent of the Winning Bid which varies according to the Large -Item service option employed. In addition, PRC will be entitled to charge to the Buyer a premium paid directly to PRC (the "Buyer's Premium") which will not be included in the Winning Bid. 5of10 Less than $2.50 $ 0.00 $ 2.50 to $ 2.99 $ 12.40 $ 3.00 to $ 3.49 $ 24.80 $ 330 to $ 3.99 $ 37,20 $ 4.00 to $ 4.49 $ 49.50 $ 4.50 to $ 4.99 $ 62.00 $ 5.00 to $ 5.49** $ 74.40 * Divides across locations and/or sub -accounts picked -up same day ** Table continues upward at same rate (7) To the extent that Property is not sold by Auction and PRC disposes of Property in a commercially reasonable manner (see "Method of Selling Property" section), including, but not limited to, sending to a charity, recycling center, landfill, or scrap metal processor, Owner understands and agrees to the following. (a) When Property is not sold by Auction, PRC disposition activities create additional PRC processing costs (the "Disposal Costs") and potentially a disposition Sales Price (the "Disposition Proceeds"). (b) Disposal Costs include, but are not limited to, labor cost of reloading Property onto a truck, labor and vehicle costs associated with transporting Property for disposition, and third -party fees, such as landfill, recycling, and hazardous material disposal fees. (c) Disposition Proceeds include, but are not limited to, a Sales Price obtained for scrap metal. (d) PRC will bear the burden of Disposal Costs. (e) Owner will pay to PRC the Disposition Proceeds, if any, as an offset to Disposal Casts, except if Disposition Proceeds for an item of Owner Property exceed $250, in which case Owner shall be entitled to retain a portion of Disposition Proceeds calculated in accordance with Section 5a above, provided that the Disposition Proceeds will be deemed to be the "Sales Price" and the Disposal Costs will be deducted as a transaction cost under Section 5a(2) above. b. Large items. (1) Sales Price, PRC Commission, Processing Costs and Net Proceeds. Calculated in a manner directly analogous to Portable Property Items. (2) PRC Commission. For each large -item of Property, PRC will be entitled to a PRC Commission equal to a percent of the Winning Bid which varies according to the Large -Item service option employed. In addition, PRC will be entitled to charge to the Buyer a premium paid directly to PRC (the "Buyer's Premium") which will not be included in the Winning Bid. 5of10 AUCTION SERVICES DISPOSITION AGREEMENT TERMS AND CONDITIONS (a) Gold. The PRC Commission will be 5% of the Winning Bic! and PRC will charge Buyer a 15% Buyer's Premium. (b) Platinum. The PRC Commission will be 12.S% of the Winning Bid. For large items that can be hauled on a standard vehicle transporter, the tow services are provided for free when within 30 miles of one of CPRT's 140 facilities. A $25 tow fee applies for every 25 miles over the first 30 free miles. In addition, fees for acquiring titles on behalf of Owner, if any, or for over -sized vehicle (e.g., crane, bus, backhoe, etc.) haul -away fees, will be borne entirely by owner. Large -Item Example. Assume a Large -Item sells at auction for a Winning Bid of $1,000.00 and with no shipping or handling charges yields a $1,000.00 Safes Price. For the Gold option, PRC collects and retains a 15% Buyer's Premium, $150.00 (0.15 x $1,000), from Buyer. With regard to collecting the Sales Price and sharing proceeds, the approach differs by option: Gold. PRC completes the sale by collecting the $1,000.00 Sales Price from Buyer. The underlying Winning Bid results in a $50 PRC Commission, leaving $950 in Owner's Gross Proceeds. Assuming Processing Costs of 3% ($30.40), these would be borne 95% by Owner, $28.50 (0.95 x $30) and 5% by PRC, $1.50 (0,05 x $30), respectively. The Owner's Net Proceeds would equal $921.50 ($950.00 less $28.54). Platinum. PRC and CPRT complete the sale by collecting the $1,000.00 Sales Price from Buyer. The underlying Winning Bid results in a $125 PRC Commission, leaving $875 in Owner's Gross Proceeds. Assuming Buyer pays by electronic funds transfer, as the majority of Buyers do, then Processing Costs would equal 0% and the Owner's Net Proceeds would equal $875. 6. Payment Terms. Once every month, PRC will remit to Owner the amount of Owner's Net Proceeds (less any Title Fees and/or Fuel Surcharges, if applicable) arising from completed sales during the preceding month (after payment of all transaction costs, PRC Commissions, Processing Fees, Title Fee and Fuel Surcharges, as applicable). Sales are deemed completed when all items comprising a line intern on the original manifest or other list of Property are sold. With each payment of Owner's Net Proceeds, PRC wilt make available to Owner, online, a report setting forth the following information for the immediately preceding month: a. The completed sales during the prior month, including the total amount of related Proceeds collected, the transaction costs, the PRC Commissions, the Owner and PRC share of Processing Costs, any applicable Title Fees and/or Fuel Surcharges, and the Owners Net Proceeds; b. Other dispositions of Property during the month; and c. The Property, if any, inventoried by PRC at the end of the month. 7. PropertyRoom's Obligations Concerning Property in Its Possession. With respect to Property in PRCs possession: a. PRC will exercise due care in the handling and storage of any Property; b. PRC shall keep the Property free of liens, security interests, and encumbrances, and shall pay when due all fees and charges with respect to the Property; c. PRC shall sign and deliver to Owner any UCC -1 financing statements or other documents reasonably requested by Owner; and d. PRC shall obtain and maintain insurance in an amount (determined by PRC) not less than the replacement value of Property in its possession. The insurance will cover the Property against fire, theft, and extended 6 of 10 AUCTION SERVICES DISPOSITION AGREEMENT TERMS AND CONDITIONS coverage risks ordinarily included in similar policies. PRC shall give Owner a certificate or a copy of each of the above upon Owner's request. 8. Owner Obligations. Owner will use its best efforts to provide to PRC such Property as becomes available for sale to the public. Owner will complete paperwork reasonably necessary to convey custodial possession of the item of Property to PRC, including a written manifest or list that describes the item of Property in sufficient detail for identification. In addition, to help comply with public notification statutes as well as to support internet traffic flow to the PRC auction website, Owner agrees to place a permanent clickable link (the "Link") to www,_REQpertyRoom com on one or more Owner websites. PRC will supply Link technical requirements, text and images to Owner. Owner agrees that it will not provide Property that is illegal or hazardous or infringes the intellectual property rights of any third party ("Prohibited Property"), including but not limited to explosives, firearms, counterfeit or unauthorized copyrighted material ("knock -offs"), poisons or pharmaceuticals. In the event that any third party asserts a claim that any Property consists of Prohibited Property, Owner shall indemnify and hold PRC harmless from any such claim and all damages, liabilities (whether joint or several), costs and expenses (including reasonable legal fees and expenses), judgments, fines and other amounts paid in connection with such claim, whether or not litigated. In the event of any such claim or if PRC otherwise determined in good faith that any Property consists of Prohibited Property, PRC shall have the right to immediately suspend or cancel (even if completed) any auction or disposal of such Property and may refuse to sell, offer to sell or otherwise dispose of such Property. To the extent requested by PRC, Owner will provide reasonable assistance in determining whether such Property in fact consists of Prohibited Property. In the event that any Buyer asserts a claim that any Property consists of Prohibited Property and PRC determined in good faith that such claim is reasonably likely to be determined to be correct, PRC may, in its discretion, accept the return of such Property and refund the Sales Price for such Property to the Buyer, in which event PRC may then destroy such Property or return such Property to Owner and such refunded Sa#es Price shall be deducted from future remittances of Owner's Net Proceeds made by PRC. 9. Restrictions on Bidding. PRC and its employees and agents may not directly or indirectly bid for or purchase auctioned Property on the PRC web site. 10. Representations and Warranties of Owner. Owner hereby represents, warrants and covenants as follows (the "Conditions Precedent"): a. Property delivered to PRC is available for sale to the general public without any restrictions or conditions whatever and does not consist of Prohibited Property; and b. Owner has taken all actions under applicable law that are required for Owner to auction the Property or to transfer title to the Property to Buyers (including, without limitation, all notice requirements and the like required prior to the sale of Property at auction under local statute or municipal code). 11. Books and Records. PRC will keep complete and accurate books of account, records, and other documents with respect to the Agreement (the "Books and Records") for at least three (3) years following expiration or termination of the Agreement. Upon reasonable notice, the Books and Records will be available for inspection by Owner, at Owner's expense, at the location where the Books and Records are regularly maintained, during normal business hours. 12. Indemnification. Subject to the limitations specified in the Agreement, each party will indemnify, hold harmless and defend the other party and its agents and employees from and against any and all losses, claims, damages, liabilities (whether joint or several), costs and expenses (including reasonable legal fees and expenses), judgments, fines and other amounts paid in settlement, incurred or suffered by any such person or entity (collectively, "Losses") arising out of or in connection with: 7of10 AUCTION SERVICES DISPOSI'T`ION AGREEMENT TERIMS AND CONDITIONS a. the inaccuracy of any representation or warranty made by the party hereunder b. any breach of the Agreement by the party, or c. any negligent act or omission by the party or its employees or agents in connection with the performance by the party or its employees or agents of obligations hereunder, provided the negligent act or omission was not done or omitted at the direction of the other party. 13. Limitations on Liability. UNDER NO CIRCUMSTANCES WILL EITHER PARTY BE LIABLE TO THE OTHER PARTY FOR INDIRECT, INCIDENTAL, CONSEQUENTIAL, SPECIAL OR EXEMPLARY DAMAGES (EVEN IF THAT PARTY HAS BEEN ADVISED OF THE POSSIBILITY OF SUCH DAMAGES), ARISING FROM BREACH OF THE AGREEMENT, THE SALE OF PROPERTY, OR ARISING FROM ANY OTHER PROVISION OF THE AGREEMENT, SUCH AS, BUT NOT LIMITED TO, LOSS OF REVENUE OR ANTICIPATED PROFITS OR LOST BUSINESS (COLLECTIVELY, "DISCLAIMED DAMAGES"); PROVIDED THAT EACH PARTY WILL REMAIN LIABLE TO THE OTHER PARTY TO THE EXTENT ANY DISCLAIMED DAMAGES ARE CLAIMED BY A THIRD PARTY AND ARE SUBJECT TO INDEMNIFICATION PURSUANT TO THE AGREEMENT. LIABILITY ARISING UNDER THE AGREEMENT WILL BE LIMITED TO DIRECT, OBJECTIVELY MEASURABLE DAMAGES. THE MAXIMUM LIABILITY OF ONE PARTY TO THE OTHER PARTY FOR ANY CLAIMS ARISING IN CONNECTION WITH THE AGREEMENT WILL NOT EXCEED THE AGGREGATE AMOUNT OF PAYMENT OBLIGATIONS OWED TO THE OTHER PARTY HEREUNDER IN THE YEAR IN WHICH LIABILITY ACCRUES; PROVIDED THAT EACH PARTY WILL REMAIN LIABLE FOR THE AGGREGATE AMOUNT OF ANY PAYMENT OBLIGATIONS OWED TO THE OTHER PARTY PURSUANT TO THE AGREEMENT AND FOR ANY AMOUNTS CLAIMED BY A THIRD PARTY WHICH ARE SUBJECT TO INDEMNIFICATION PURSUANT TO THE AGREEMENT. NOTWITHSTANDING ANYTHING HEREIN TO THE CONTRARY, OWNER'S LIABILITY IS NOT LIMITED UNDER THE AGREEMENT WITH RESPECT TO LIABILITY ARISING FROM OWNERS FAILURE TO SATISFY TIMELY ALL CONDITIONS PRECEDENT. 14. Assignment. The Agreement may not be assigned, in whole or in part, by either of the parties without the prior written consent of the other party (which consent may not be unreasonably withheld or delayed). Notwithstanding the foregoing, an assignment of the Agreement by either party to any subsidiary or affiliate or a third party acquisition of all or substantially all of the assets of such party will not require the consent of the other party, so long as such subsidiary, affifiate or acquiring entity assumes all of such party's obligations under the Agreement_ No delegation by PRC of any of its duties hereunder will be deemed an assignment of the Agreement, nor will any change in control nor any assignment by operation of law by either party. Subject to the restrictions contained in this section, the terms and conditions of the Agreement will bind and inure to the benefit of each of the respective successors and assigns of the parties hereto. 15. Notices. Any notice or other communication given under the Agreement will be in writing and delivered by hand, sent by facsimile (provided acknowledgment of receipt thereof is delivered to the sender), sent by certified, registered mail or sent by any nationally recognized overnight courier service to the addresses provided on the signature page of the Agreement. The parties may, from time to time and at any time, change their respective addresses and each will have the right to specify as its address any other address by at least ten (10) days written notice to the other party. 16. Interpretation. Whenever possible, each provision of the Agreement will be interpreted in such a manner as to be effective and valid under applicable law, but if any provision of the Agreement is held to be prohibited by or invalid under applicable law, such provision will be ineffective only to the extent of such prohibition or invalidity, without invalidating the remainder of such provision or the remaining provisions of the Agreement. The headings in the Agreement are inserted for convenience of reference only and shall not constitute a part hereof. Nothing in the Agreement is intended nor shall it be construed to confer any rights or remedies upon any person or entity other than the parties named herein and their respective successors and permitted assigns. The parties have participated, or had the opportunity to participate in, the negotiation and drafting of the Agreement or requested, or had the opportunity to request, amendments to the Agreement. In the event an ambiguity or question of intent or interpretation arises, the Agreement shall be construed as if drafted 8of10 AUCTION SERVICES DISPOSITION AGREEMENT 'PERMS AND CONDITIONS jointly by the parties, and no presumption or burden of proof shall arise favoring or disfavoring any party by virtue of the authorship of any provisions of the Agreement, 17. Governing law. The internal law, and not the law of conflicts, of the state in which the Owner is located will govern all questions concerning the construction, validity and interpretation of the Agreement and the performance of the obligations imposed by the Agreement. The proper venue for any proceeding at law or in Equity will be the state and county in which the owner is located, and the parties waive any right to object to the venue. If any proceeding or action is brought to recover any amount under the Agreement, or for or on account of any breach of, or to enforce or interpret any of the terms, covenants, or conditions of the Agreement, the prevailing party will be entitled to recover from the other party, as part of the prevailing party's costs, reasonable attorneys' fees, the amount of which will be fixed by the court, and will be made a part of any judgment rendered. 18. Further Assurances. PRC and Owner will each sign such other documents and take such actions as the other may reasonably request in order to effect the relationships, services and activities contemplated by the Agreement and to account for and document those activities. 19. Relationship of the Parties. No representations or assertions will be made or actions taken by either party that could imply or establish any joint venture, partnership, employment or trust relationship between the parties with respect to the subject matter of the Agreement. Except as expressly provided in the Agreement, neither party will have any authority or power whatsoever to enter into any agreement, contract or commitment on behalf of the other, or to create any 11ab11ity or obligation whatsoever on behalf of the other, to any person or entity. Whenever PRC is given discretion in the Agreement, PRC may exercise that discretion solely in any mariner PRC deems appropriate. PRC shall be not liable to Owner for any Losses incurred by reason of any act or omission performed or omitted by PRC in good faith on behalf of the Owner and in a manner reasonably believed to be within the scope of authority conferred on PRC by the Agreement, except that PRC shall be liable for any such Losses incurred by reason of PRO's fraud, gross negligence or willful misconduct. 20. Force Majeure. Neither party will be liable for any failure of or delay in the performance of the Agreement for the period that such failure or delay is due to acts of God, public enemy, war, strikes or labor disputes, or any other cause beyond the parties' reasonable control (each a "Force Majeure"), it being understood that lack of financial resources will not to be deemed a cause beyond a party's control. Each party will notify the other party promptly of the occurrence of any Force Majeure and carry out the Agreement as promptly as practicable after such Force Majeure is terminated. The existence of any Force Majeure will not extend the term of the Agreement. 9of10 Addendum to Property Disposition Services Agreement This Addendum is attached to and made part of the Property Disposition Services Agreement dated (the "Agreement") between the City of Milton, Georgia ("Owner") and PropertyRoom.com, Inc. {"PRC"). In the event of a conflict between the provisions of the Agreement and this Addendum, this Addendum will govern. The Owner and PRC agree that the Agreement is hereby modified as follows. 1. Paragraph 2, Title to Property. The third sentence of this Paragraph is modified to read as follows: "In connection therewith, Owner appoints PRC its attorney-in-fact to sign any and all documents approved in writing by Owner as being reasonably necessary to assign to Buyers all of Owner's right, title and interest in and to Property sold or disposed." 2. Paragraph 3, Method of Selling Property, (b) Large Property Iteams, (2) Haul -away Option: This subparagraph is modified to read as follows: "For Platinum, PRC will, in conjunction with an agent or subcontractor of PRC approved in writing by Owner and to the extent practical, pick- up and haul -away Large -items, selling via online auction and transferring title and physical possession to Buyers as described in Portable Property Items." 3. Paragraph 3, Method of Selling Property: This Paragraph is modified by adding a new subparagraph (c) to read as follows: "c. Transportation of Items. PRC shall ensure, regarding any vehicle that removes Items from Owner's premises, that such vehicles are insured in compliance with the minimum requirements of Georgia law. PRC shall also ensure that the drivers of such vehicles are in compliance with all applicable federal and state laws and regulations." 4. Paragraph 4, Term and Termination, (a): Subparagraph (a) is modified by adding the following new sentence to the end of said subparagraph. "Either party may terminate this Agreement for convenience by providing at least sixty (60) days prior written notice of termination to the other party." S. Paragraph 8, Owner Obligations: The second paragraph, second sentence of this Paragraph is modified to read as follows: "In the event that any third party asserts a claim that any Property consists of Prohibited Property, Owner shall, to the extent if any allowed by law, indemnify and hold PRC harmless from any such claim and all damages, liabilities (whether joint or several), costs and expenses (including reasonable legal fees and expenses), judgments, fines and other amounts paid in connection with such claim, whether or not litigated." C7 Paragraph 12, Indemnification: The first sentence of this Paragraph is modified to read as follows: "Subject to the limitations specified in the Agreement, each parry will, to the extent if any allowed by law, indemnify, hold harmless and defend the other party and its agents and employees from and against any and all losses, claims, damages, liabilities (whether joint or several), costs and expenses (including reasonable legal fees and expenses), judgments, fines and other amounts paid in settlement, incurred or suffered by any such person or entity (collectively, `Losses') arising out of or in connection with: " All other terms of the Agreement shall remain unchanged and of full force and effect. Those individuals executing this Addendum on behalf of Owner and PRC, respectively, hereby certify that they are fully authorized to bind the entity on whose behalf they are executing this Addendum. for "Owner" p Name/Title: for Prop ltoom.com Inc. P.J. Bel10mo, President 3 - 5 f- 1D Date 4a(-KWo0 Attest: retary [AFFIX CORPORATE SEAL] Date VSA 10 Date PROPERTY DISPOSITION SERVICES AGREEMENT TERMS AND CONDITIONS Owner Information City of Milton Police Department Owner Name Schedules, Supplements & Other Attachments Mark included attachments: 13000 Deerfield Pkwy 107FTerms and Conditions Yes I Address Milton, GA 30004 City, State Zip Code (678) 242-2570 Phone - Email Addendums: This Agreement, including all of the terms and conditions set forth in the attached Terms and Conditions as well as all other attachments indicated in the box above, comprises the entire Agreement between the Parties. This Agreement cannot be modified except in writing by the duly authorized representatives of both parties. Owner City of Milton Police Dep ent Signor Name l oe el'- ^ bra Signor Tille Signature J_�� a� Signature Date PropertyRoom.com Pd Bellotno Signor Name CEO Signor Title Signa 3 �a Signature 16ate PropertyRoom.corn Inc. 26421 Crown Valley Parkway, Ste 200 Mission Viejo, California 92691 +1 (949) 282-4121 Federal Tax ID 86-0962102 1 of 1 City of Milton 13000 Deerfield Parkway, Milton, Georgia 30004 1 To: Honorable Mayor and City Council Members From: Sam Trager, Director of Human Resources Date: Submitted on April 5, 2010 for the April 12, 2010 Regular Council Meeting Agenda Item: Approval to enter an agreement with the Georgia Technology Authority to conduct driver’s histories on all non-public safety employees. City Manager’s Office Recommendation: Approval for the City of Milton to establish an account with the Georgia Technology Authority in order to run drivers’ histories on non-public safety employees. Each staff member would be required to sign a release. Employees with unsatisfactory driving records will not be allowed to drive a city vehicle until corrective action is taken. Ms. Jeanette Citta, City of Milton TAC, will be responsible for conducting the Motor Vehicle Record (MVR) check and maintaining the appropriate records. Background: A representative of the Georgia Municipal Association (GMA) and Local Government Risk Management Services (LGRMS) recently visited the city to perform a site inspection. One recommendation included running drivers’ histories on all employees who may be required to drive as part of their job. In order for the city to conduct the required checks, the city will be required to have an account with the Georgia Technology Authority. The city previously held an account, but it lapsed. The city currently runs public safety checks annually through the Georgia Crime Information Center. Due to legal requirements, the city is not able to run other checks through that system. Discussion The City has a need to ensure employees driving city vehicles maintain a satisfactory MVR in order to limit potential liability and protect the city and residents. LGRMS has recommended the city check employees once every three years. Taking a more proactive approach, we plan to check each employee’s MVR every other year. Funding and Fiscal Impact: There is no initial cost to enter into the agreement with the Georgia Technology Authority. The first year of this program will require the city to run each employee’s MVR at a total cost of approximately $275. Subsequent years of this program, the cost should not exceed $150 per year. Alternatives: No other alternatives. Concurrent Review: Chris Lagerbloom, City Manager Deb Harrell, Police Chief GEORGIA DEPARTMENT OF DRIVER SERVICES Attn: Bulk MVR P.O. Box 80447 Conyers, Ga. 30013 678.413-8847 r P[ TION FOR MOTOR VEHICLE RECORDS an P Y / Com Nam 7 FEIN: Company Rep./Individual Blame: e—a Existing Customer ID C' 10) ❑0e) 4 a Mailing Address: 13 opc) sr r t Iy r -- City: State: Zip Code ± AJ ��� Billing Address: City: State Zip Code: Telephone Number: r� rhe r Fax Nurnlxr: I r �� c 1 � Type of Business: (Select only one) CourtFinancial Institution Insurance!_____ Law Enforcement School—__— City Government__ __L—,- County Government Fire Dept._-,,.,._ Car Rental Corporation State Agency Other Type of Certification Requested: (Select only one) Internet User Bulk Requestor—. — Bulk User_ . Purpose For Requesting MVRs: (Select all that applies) Motor Vehicle Insurance Motor Vehicle Limited Rating Information Other Insurance Credit Rental Car Agency_ Employment (own employees) Other Employment (background check done for hire) Security Question: (Answer only one of the following questions) t What is your mother's maiden name? Answer. IA a (L]. What is your pet's name? Answer: `Yy}i2t- What is your favorite color? Answer: What is your favorite food? Answer: What is your birth month? Answer: k E-mail Address: Do you have a contract with a state agency that requires you to request MVRs? Yes No_.-�` If so, you will need to send in a copy of that contract with your signed application. *nit plication, I hereby certify the above information is true and correct and the information obtained e purpose stated above and in accordance with the Fair Credit Reporting Act. t .% DATE -- — t� 1WR t G 213 ►--t] OCn 1 7"6c!'R PRINTED NAME OIF APPLICANT TITLE AGREEMENT BETWEEN GEORGIA TECHNOLOGY AUTHORITY AND This Bulk User Agreement ("Agreement") is entered into by and between the Georgia Net Division of the Georgia Technoloav Authoritv, hereinafter referred to as "GTA," and a ; , hereinafter referred to as "Bulk User," with its Oincipal office pLt: GTA and Bulk User shall be collectively referred to as the "parties." WHEREAS, pursuant to O.C.G.A. § 40-5-2, GTA has the authority to contract for the electronic furnishing of certain records maintained and compiled by the Georgia Department of Driver Services for certain specific statutory purposes; and WHEREAS, Bulk User desires to obtain abstracts of multiple driver records of individuals licensed by the Georgia Department of Driver Services for specific uses related to motor vehicle insurance or employment information verification as allowed under Georgia Law; NOW THEREFORE, in consideration of the promises and agreements hereinafter set forth, the parties hereby agree as follows: 1. Purpose The purpose of this Agreement is to set out the terms and conditions under which GTA will disclose to Bulk User certain information contained within the official driver records maintained and compiled by the Georgia Department of Driver Services. The use of said driver records information shall be exclusively in connection with either th e: (i) claims investigation, antifraud activities, rating, or underwriting of motor vehicle insurance; or (ii) verification of information provided by the individual whose record is being requested pursuant to a credit agreement; or, (iii) verification of information provided by the individual whose record is being requested as part of an employment process, Information released to the Sulk User under this Agreement is subject to limitations imposed by O.C.G.A. § 40-5-2, the rules and regulations promulgated by the Georgia Department of Driver Services, and the provisions set forth within this Agreement. Such limitations include, but are not limited to, any written authorizations or consents required by the Georgia Department of Driver Services or by law. AGREEMENT BETWEEN GEORGIA TECHNOLOGY AUTHORITY AND 2. Definitions "MVR" or "Motor Vehicle Record" or "Record" shall mean the applicable abstract of an individual Driver's Record licensed to Bulk User under this Agreement. Pursuant to O.C.G.A. § 40-5-2, the contents of the abstract will vary according to the use for which the abstract is requested. "Bulk User" shall mean the party entering into this Agreement who is certified as a Bulk User by the Georgia Department of Driver Services as evidenced by GTA's receipt of a valid copy of the entity's Bulk User Certificate from the Georgia Department of Driver Services. 3. License License Grant. During the term of this Agreement, subject to the terms and conditions stated herein, GTA grants Bulk User a nonexclusive, nontransferable limited license to access and retrieve certain MVRs contained in GTA's Database, at such times as GTA makes said MVRs available to Bulk User, for use in the normal course of Bulk User's internal business. Limitation of License. Except as specifically provided herein, no MVR, either in whole or in part may be published, transmitted, sold or otherwise disclosed, in any form or by any means to another person, company or entity, except as may otherwise be required by federal or state law, without the express written consent of the Georgia Department of Driver Services. Ownership of Records. Except for the license granted herein, all rights, title and interests in the MVRs in all languages, formats and media throughout the world are and shall continue to be the exclusive property of the Georgia Department of Driver Services. 4. Services Subject to terms and conditions set forth in this Agreement, GTA shall provide to Bulk User such MVRs as are properly requested in an electronic format as specified by GTA. Each request for an MVR submitted by Bulk User shall include: (i) the driver's name, (ii) date of birth, (iii) license number or Social Security Number, (iv) use or purpose in requesting the MVR, (v) length of time for which the MVR is sought (3 or 7 year record) and (vi) all parties who will receive the report. AGREEMENT BETWEEN GEORGIA TECHNOLOGY AUTHORITY AND S. Restrictions on Use of Records 6. Audit Bulk User shall take all necessary measures to ensure that the MRS requested and received by Sulk User shall be exclusively used for the purposes of: (i) claims investigation, antifraud activities, rating, or underwriting of motor vehicle insurance; or (ii) verification of information provided by the individual whose record is being requested pursuant to a credit agreement; or, (N)verification of information provided by the individual whose record is being requested for employment or pre-employment information verification purposes. All such uses shall be subject to limitations imposed by O.C.G.A. § 40-5-2, the rules and regulations promulgated by the Georgia Department of Driver Services, and the limitations set forth in this Agreement. Bulk User shall not disclose, supply, or resell MVRs to any other person or company. Bulk User's documentation supporting the reason for the Record request, including but not limited to transaction details, computer software and programs maintained for the purposes defined in this agreement, shall be subject to inspection, review or audit by GTA, the Georgia Department of Driver Services or their respective representatives for a period of four years from the date of the request at no cost to GTA or the Georgia Department of Driver Services. Bulk User agrees to accommodate GTA's or the Georgia Department of Driver Services's request For an inspection, review or audit on one business day's notice and to allow on-site audits during regular business hours. Bulk User shall maintain a log of each request for a MVR for a period of four years from the date of the request. The log shall be immediately available for review at GTA's or the Georgia Department of Driver Services's request. Bulk User shall provide an electronic or "hard" copy of such log upon request. The log format shall provide the following in the order presented: (i) Date of request, (ii) all information specified in Section 4(b) of this Agreement, and identity of person/entity to whom the information was provided. AGREEMENT BETWEEN GEORGIA TECHNOLOGY AUTHORITY AND 7. Representations and Warranties Bulk User represents and warrants that it is a Bulk User as designated by the Georgia Department of Driver Services, and as evidenced by a copy of the Bulk User certificate transmitted to GTA by the Georgia Department of Driver Services, which is appended to this Agreement as Attachment A. Bulk User warrants that it witl maintain its Bulk User status by timely filing a Bulk User certification application at least yearly with the Georgia Department of Driver Services. Bulk User acknowledges that their status as a Bulk User is dependent on GTA receiving evidence of such certification from the Georgia Department of Driver Services. C. Bulk User warrants that it shall take all measures necessary to ensure that the MVRs supplied to Bulls User by GTA will not be divulged, supplied, sold, assigned or transferred to any other person or company except as provided in this Agreement. Bulk User warrants that it shall only use the MVRs transferred to them solely for their internal business purposes authorized under Georgia Law. a. Remedies a. Any breach by Bulk User of the representations, warranties, restrictions, terms, or conditions contained in this agreement constitutes a material breach and shall be grounds for GTA, in its sole discretion, to suspend the services provided by GTA under this Agreement or terminate this Agreement immediately and without notice. Bulk User acknowledges that certain breaches by Bulk User may result in criminal liability. b. Bulk User agrees and acknowledges that a breach of material term(s) of the Agreement shall cause immediate and irreparable harm and damage to the State of Georgia, in which event GTA and/or the State of Georgia shall be immediately entitled to injunctive relief and a return of all Licensed Records without any rebate of any fees or payments, in addition to any other rights and remedies to which it may be entitled, at law or in equity. C. If Bulk User does not make timely payments under the provisions of Section 10 of this Agreement, GTA may terminate this Agreement or suspend the services provided under this Agreement to Bulk User until such time as Bulk User pays to GTA the full amount due to it. GTA will charge Bulk User one and one-half percent {1.511/6} interest per month on its unpaid balance or may exercise any other remedies provided by law. d. The remedies of termination or suspension of this Agreement shall not be deemed to be exclusive remedies, but rather shall be in addition to all other remedies which may be available to GTA, Termination of this Agreement shall release GTA from any and all obligations under this Agreement, but shall not 4 AGREEMENT 6ETWEEN GEORGIA TECHNOLOGY AUTHORITY AND bar GTA from pursuing any remedies it would otherwise have against Bulk User. Failure to maintain or revocation of an entity's Bulk User certification by the Georgia Department of Driver Services shall be grounds for GTA to immediately terminate or suspend the services provided under this Agreement. 9. Term a. This Agreement will become effective on the date it is signed and accepted by GTA, superseding and replacing any and all existing Agreements with Bulk User for the services and subject matter contained herein. b. This Agreement will continue in force until terminated by either party upon thirty (30) days' written notice to the other party, or if otherwise terminated under the terms of this Agreement. 10. Charges and Payment Procedures a. Bulk User shall compensate GTA according to the following schedule: (i) $6.00 per request for each three (3) year MVR requested (ii) $8.00 per request for each seven (7) year MVR requested b, Each month GTA will send to Bulk User an invoice for all charges incurred by Bulk User during the preceding month, subject to adjustments, if any. Within thirty (30) days of receipt of any invoice, Bulk User will pay to GTA the full amount payable thereunder. If Bulk User does not make timely payment, GTA may terminate this Agreement or suspend the services provided under this Agreement to Bulk User until such time as Bulk User pays to GTA the full amount due to it. GTA will charge Bulk User one and one-half percent (1.5%) interest per month on its unpaid balance or may exercise any other remedies provided by law. C. GTA will make an appropriate adjustment to any amount paid or payable by Bulk User for any use of the services which results in faulty retrieval, failure of retrieval, or a loss of retrieved data, except that caused by improper use of the services by Bulk User; provided, however, that Bulk User reports to GTA any such loss immediately upon discovery. These obligations are the full extent of GTA's responsibility to Bulk User For loss; AND IN NO EVENT WILL GTA BE LIABLE TO BULK USER FOR GENERAL, CONSEQUENTIAL, INCIDENTAL, EXEMPLARY, SPECIAL OR LIKE DAMAGES RESULTING IN WHOLE OR IN PART FROM BULK USER'S USE OF THE SERVICES OR RECORDS PROVIDED UNDER THIS AGREEMENT. AGREEMENT BETWEEN GEORGIA TECHNOLOGY AUTHORITY AND 11. Indemnification a. Bulk User agrees to indemnify the "State" and to hold it harmless from all loss and liability, in any way caused, in whole or in part, by act or omission of Bulk User in connection with this Agreement. For purposes of this indemnification, "State" means the Georgia Technology Authority, the Georgia Department of Driver Services, all other departments and units of the state government, all state instrumentalities, and all their officers and employees, plus the insurance programs of the Department of Administrative Services established for their protection. "Bulk User" includes successors and assigns, In the clause, "caused, in whole or in part, by act or omission of Bulk User," "Bulk User" also includes Bulk User's subcontractors, all others acting on their behalf, and their officers and employees. This obligation survives the expiration and termination of the Agreement, the dissolution of the Bulk User and, to the extent allowed by law, the bankruptcy of the Bulk User. b. The Georgia Tort Claims Act will be the exclusive remedy for any loss or liability within its terms. However, upon demand, Bulk User will promptly reimburse the following for any payments made by them, which are covered by Bulk User's obligation to indemnify: the State Tort Claims Trust Fund, the State Authority Liability Trust Fund, the State Employee Broad Form Liability Fund, the State Insurance and Hazard Reserve Fund, and other self-insured funds (all such funds hereinafter collectively referred to as the "Funds") established and maintained by the State of Georgia Department of Administrative Services Risk Management Division (hereinafter "DOAS"). This Indemnification applies even if the State is partially responsible for the situation giving rise to the claim, but not if the State is solely responsible. i2. Disclaimer of Warranties THE RECORDS AND SERVICES PROVIDED BY GTA UNDER THIS AGREEMENT ARE PROVIDED AS IS WITHOUT WARRANTY AS TO ACCURACY OR COMPLETENESS. TO THE FULL EXTENT PERMITTED BY APPLICABLE LAW, ALL CONDITIONS, WARRANTIES, REPRESENTATIONS, LIABILITIES AND OBLIGATIONS, WHETHER EXPRESSED OR IMPLIED, ARISING FROM NEGLIGENCE OR IMPOSED BY STATUTE OR OTHERWISE IN RESPECT TO THE SUPPLY OF MVRs OR ANY RELATED SERVICES HEREUNDER, INCLUDING ANY CONDITIONS OR IMPLIED WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY, FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE OR AS TO CORRESPONDENCE WITH DESCRIPTION, ARE HEREBY DISCLAIMED BY GTA. AGREEMENT BETWEEN GEORGIA TECHNOLOGY AUTHORITY AND 13. Relationship of Parties The relationship of GTA and Bulk User established by this Agreement is of licensor and licensee/independent contractors, and nothing in this agreement shall be construed. (1) to give either party the power to direct or control the daily activities of the other party or (2) to constitute the parties as principal and agent, employer and employee, franchiser and franchisee, partners, joint venturers, co-owners, or otherwise as participants in a joint undertaking. GTA and Bulk User understand and agree that GTA does not grant Bulk User the power or, authority to make or give any agreement, statement, representation, warranty or other commitment on behalf of GTA or to enter into any contract or otherwise incur any liability or obligation, express or implied, on behalf of GTA, or to transfer, release or waive any right, title or interest of GTA, except as expressly allowed within this Agreement. 14, Force Majeure The parties hereto shall not be responsible for any failure or delay in the performance of any obligations hereunder caused by Acts of God, flood, fire, war or public enemy. 15. Waiver and Severability No failure, delay in exercising or enforcing any right or remedy hereunder by GTA shall constitute a waiver of any other right or remedy, or future exercise thereof. If any provision of this Agreement is determined to be invalid under any applicable statute or rule of law, it is to that extent deemed to be omitted, and the balance of the Agreement shall remain enforceable. 16. Taxes All federal state, local and other taxes due, if any, under this Agreement, shall be the responsibility of the Bulk User. 17. Compliance with all Laws Bulk User shall comply with all laws, ordinances, rules and regulations of any governmental entity pertaining to its performance pursuant to this Agreement, including, but not limited to 18 U.S.C. § 2721, O.C.G.A. § 40-5-2 et seq., the rules and regulations promulgated by the Georgia Department of Driver Services, or any other rule or law enacted hereafter. 18. Choice of Law This Agreement shall be governed by the laws of the State of Georgia, without application of conflicts of laws principles. Any suit brought pursuant to this Agreement against the State of Georgia or GTA shall be filed exclusively in the Superior Court of Fulton County, Georgia, and in no other jurisdiction. AGREEMENT BETWEEN GEORGIA TECHNOLOGY AUTHORITY AND 19, Authority Bulk User acknowledges it has full power and authority to enter into and perform this Agreement, and the person signing on behalf of Bulk User has been properly authorized and empowered to enter into this Contract. Each party further acknowledges that it has read this Agreement, understands it, and agrees to be bound by it. 20. Assignment Performance under this Agreement shall not be assigned or subcontracted without the prior written consent of GTA. 21. Headings The paragraph headings used in this Agreement are for reference purposes only and shall not be deemed a part of this Agreement. 22. Amendments in Writing No amendment to this Agreement shall be effective unless it is in writing and signed by the parties. 23. Notice All notices under this Agreement shalt be deemed duly given upon delivery, If delivered by certified mail to the party at the address set forth as follows: GTA: Georgia Technology Authority 47 Trinity Avenue Atlanta, Georgia 30334 Attn: Office of Data Sales Bulk User: i AGREEMENT BETWEEN GEORGIA TECHNOLOGY AUTHORITY AND 24, Survival The respective rights and obligations of the parties under Sections S, 6, 7, 8, 10, 11, and 12 shall survive any termination or expiration of this Agreement. 25. Entire Agreement This Agreement constitutes the entire agreement between the parties with respect to the subject matter; all prior agreements, representations, statements, negotiations and undertakings, are superseded hereby. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, each party, by its respective officers authorized so to do, has executed this Agreement, AGREED: Georgia Technology Authority 6y: Name: Ivan Sumter Title: Director, Office of Data Sales Date: 1 Bul ay: Name:. «7t T L�t�-Raao, Title:err ! MA &24 e4CR Date:���31� •.. ---- GEORGIA DEPARTMENT OF DRIVER SERVICES BULK MVR USER CERTIFICATE User 't'~ Name: Address: —etA Sy�c \� City: S t�Zip Code: Email: Telephone #: Fax #: Bulk Requestor YjYes ❑ No If yes, Name: Used? ccol The company or individual named above certifies that for each driving ree'drrd requested, the information contained therein shall be used solely for one of the following approved purposes: insurance claims investigation, insurance antifraud activities, insurance rating, insurance underwriting, car rental agreements, address verification by a creditor, or as part of a background investigation on an employee or applicant for employment. In the event that an adverse decision is based upon any information supplied to the User by the Department of Driver Services (DDS), then upon request of the driver named in the driving record, the User or the producing insurance agent, if applicable, shall inform the driver named in the record of all information pertinent to the decision. This provision is to be construed as requiring the User to include specific information included in the driver's record. All information is requested only for the User's exclusive use. The User shall not share, sell or otherwise disseminate any information included in the motor vehicle report to any other person or company, except as provided in O.C.G.A. §40-5-2, -18 U.S.C.§2721, et seq., Ga. Admin. Camp. Ch. 375-3-8-.03, any other applicable provision of law, or as provided herein. Any violation of the rules, laws or agreements applicable to the access provided herein to the User shall be considered sufficient grounds for the DDS to refuse to release any additional information on any other driver that the User may request. This administrative action by the DDS shall not be deemed to supersede any other sanctions prescribed by law, including, but not limited to, any applicable civil or criminal penalties. The DDS has the right to inspect and copy all records, files, reports, or any other materials deemed necessary to verify that the User has abided by all terms of the certificate unless such access is prohibited by law. The burden of showing compliance with the provisions of this certificate is at all times on the User. Upon reasonable notice by the DDS, the User must be able to demonstrate such compliance. Users obtaining driving records for any of the aforementioned insurance purposes must have an application for insurance or renewal thereof in order to obtain driving records. Users obtaining driving records for employment or pre-employment background investigations must obtain the written consent of each licensee whose driving record is requested. Access granted to this User via the Requestor named above, if any, shall cease immediately if the DDS terminates the Requestor's access to driving records for any reason. Termination, non -renewal, or expiration of the agreement between the Requestor named above and the Georgia Technology Authority terminates the User's access to driving records for any reason. The person signing below has authority to d*,,D f of the applicant named above. Date Si Titl Position 1 Printed Name Georgia Cities Week WHEREAS, City government is the closest to most citizens, and the one with the most direct daily impact upon its residents; and WHEREAS, City government is administered for and by its citizens, and is dependent upon public commitment to and understanding of its many responsibilities; and WHEREAS, City government officials and employees share the responsibility to pass along their understanding of public services and their benefits; and WHEREAS, Georgia Cities Week is a very important time to recognize the important role played by city government in our lives; and WHEREAS, this week offers an important opportunity to spread the word to all the citizens of Georgia and they can shape and influence this branch of government which is closest to the people; and WHEREAS, the Georgia Municipal Association and its member cities have joined together to teach students and other citizens about municipal government through a variety of different projects and information; and WHEREAS, Georgia Cities Week offers an important opportunity to convey to all the citizens of Georgia that they can shape and influence government through their civic involvement. NOW, THEREFORE, we, the Mayor and Council hereby recognize and proclaim April 18 -24, 2010, as GEORGIA CITIES WEEK in the City of Milton and encourage all citizens, city government officials and employees to recognize this week and celebrate it accordingly. Given under nay hand and Seal of the City of Milton, Georgia on the 12th day of April, 2014. "' a f IIY Mayor Milton High School Boys’ Basketball Day WHEREAS, basketball, the truly American game invented in Springfield, Mass., in 1892, is a sport that requires skillful hand -eye coordination, mental awareness, agility, grace and teamwork, and; WHEREAS, the Milton High School boys’ basketball team has a tradition of excellence and accomplishment in athletic and academic competition reflecting the highest ideals of hard work, training and sportsmanship, and; WHEREAS, the Milton High School boys’ basketball program has been active in the school for decades without a state championship, and; WHEREAS, the 2008-2009 varsity boys’ basketball team competed in the state championship game and returned in 2010 to win both the region and state championships, and; WHEREAS, the 2009-2010 varsity boys’ basketball team was ranked in multiple nationwide polls as a top 20 team in the USA and as high as fourth in the nation, and; WHEREAS, the 2009-2010 varsity boys’ basketball team had three players named to the Associated Press All-State first and second teams and four players garner spots or honorable mentions on the AAAAA All-State and All-North Fulton first and second teams and; WHEREAS, members of the team were named the Milton Neighbor North Fulton Player of the Year and Atlanta Journal and Constitution North Fulton Player of the Year and to that paper’s first team all-state, and; WHEREAS, the 2009-2010 varsity boys’ basketball squad was the first from Georgia to be named a Top Ten State Championship Team and; WHEREAS, the players on the Milton High School boys’ basketball team are champions not only on the court, but in the classroom, in the community and in life and we are proud this great team is located in Milton, Georgia. NOW, THEREFORE, we, the Mayor and City Council of the City of Milton, hereby dedicate Monday, April 12, 2010 as MILTON HIGH SCHOOL BOYS’ BASKETBALL DAY in the City of Milton, Georgia. Given under our hand and seal of the City of Milton, Georgia on this 12 th Day of April, 2010. (Seal) _______________________ Joe Lockwood Mayor STATE OF GEORGIA COUNTY OF FULTON ORDINANCE NO. AN ORDINANCE OF THE MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF MILTON, GEORGIA, TO AMEND THE CITY’S PURCHASING POLICIES TO ALLOW FOR THE OPTION OF PROCURING PROFESSIONAL SERVICES WITHOUT COMPETITIVE BIDDING, AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES. WHEREAS, the Purchasing Policies of the City of Milton currently require that all contracts for services, with certain limited exceptions, be procured through a procurement process; WHEREAS, the Mayor and Council of the City of Milton recognize that the specialized nature of professional services often results in the need to procure such services without utilizing a competitive procurement process; and WHEREAS, the Mayor and Council of the City of Milton thus desire to amend the City’s Purchasing Policies to allow for the procurement of professionals services without the utilization of a competitive procurement process; BE IT ORDAINED by the Mayor and City Council of the City of Milton, Georgia as follows: Section I: Article II, Scope, of the Purchasing Policies of the Financial Management Program contained in Ordinance No. 06-11-05, approved by the Mayor and Council of the City of Milton on November 21, 2006, is hereby amended to read as follows: “I. SCOPE The scope of this purchasing policy covers the procurement of ALL MATERIALS AND SERVICES, except as otherwise provided below regarding Professional Services, as defined below, without regard to the past method by which the material or service has been or is customarily procured. The policy covers all contractual and purchase agreements between the City of Milton and another company or person. The procurement function includes the initial agreement/purchase, renewals, changes and/or re-negotiations. This policy establishes the specific responsibility and authority of the procurement of materials and services. For clarification purposes, these purchasing policies are not required to be followed by organizations providing services, directly or indirectly to the City through service orientation contract personnel. Those contractual agreement of service oriented in nature were procured in conjunction with the creation of the City. However, as part of the audit process, the organizations providing services, either directly or indirectly to the City shall have their internal controls and accounting processes evaluated and a measure of assurance given as a requirement of completion of the City’s annual audit. Professional Services shall not be subject to the bidding or other competitive procurement requirements of these purchasing policies, provided that contracts for Professional Services shall be subject to the approval requirements of Article V(C)(6)(b) of these Purchasing Policies. The City may, in its sole discretion, utilize competitive procurement methods in the procurement of Professional Services. For the purposes of this paragraph, the term “Professional Services” shall mean services requiring a specialized bachelor’s degree or a graduate degree and also requiring licensing or certification by a Georgia statewide authorizing entity, including, but not limited to, engineering and architectural services, accounting services, and legal services.” Section II: This Ordinance Number _____ shall become effective immediately upon adoption by the Mayor and Council of the City of Milton. Any and all existing or pre-existing ordinances covering the same matters as embraced in this Ordinance are hereby repealed, and all ordinances or parts of ordinances inconsistent with the provisions of this Ordinance are hereby repealed. ORDAINED this the ____ day of __________, 2010 ______________________________ Joe Lockwood, Mayor Attest: ________________________________ Sudie AM Gordon, Interim City Clerk City of Milton 13000 Deerfield Parkway, Milton, Georgia 30004 1 To: Honorable Mayor and City Council Members From: Carter Lucas, PE – Public Works Director Date: Submitted on March 29, 2010 for the April 12, 2010 Council Meeting Agenda Item: Approval of an ordinance to revise Chapter 48, Article IV. Traffic Calming and Control of the City of Milton Code of Ordinances Background Staff is recommending a series of changes to the traffic calming ordinance. In November 2008 Street Smarts, Inc. was contracted by the city to review the existing traffic calming ordinance and make recommendations on potential changes to the ordinance. The changes were intended to update the ordinance to current standards and simplify to ordinance where possible. As a result of the recommendations from Street Smarts, Inc. as well as reviews by City Council, DRB and staff the following ordinance is presented for approval. Discussion Enclosed with your packet is a clean version of the proposed ordinance as well as a marked up version of the existing ordinance to give you an idea of the scope of the proposed changes. The revisions are being presented in two parts, an ordinance which will cover the legislative issues and a policy and procedures manual. Most of the changes that you will see to the existing ordinance are being included in the proposed policy and procedures manual which is intended to be presented at the April 26, 2010 meeting. The following table highlights several items that have been the point of discussion during the previous meetings and how those items have been addressed in the proposed ordinance. The final recommendations are as follows: Item Existing Ordinance Proposed Ordinance Speed Threshold 85% speed greater than 10mph over the posted speed limit. (85% of the vehicles are traveling 10mph or less over the posted speed limit) 50% of the traffic volume exceeds the posted speed limit Based on the data we have for the subdivisions that have requested a review the proposed threshold appears to equate to an 85th percentile speed of 6 mph to 7 mph over the posted speed limit City of Milton 13000 Deerfield Parkway, Milton, Georgia 30004 2 Item Existing Ordinance Proposed Ordinance Cost Share 75% city – 25% applicant 50% city – 50% applicant Comment: The cost share would be those costs associated with design and construction of the base traffic calming details presented in the Policy and Procedures Manual. The applicant has the option to upgrade the details provided they pay any additional costs associated with design, construction and maintenance. Applicant Petition Current ordinance is conflicting in that it states both 65% and 75% support for the measures in different sections of the ordinance. It does allow an HOA to approve the measures in lieu of the petition process. Where a mandatory HOA exists and the HOA has the authority to make such decisions the HOA may act on behalf of the subdivision in the approval of traffic calming measures. Where that entity does not exist the petition will need the approval of 67% (2/3 majority) of the study area. Comment: After discussions with several HOA’s staff agrees that where the HOA is mandatory and has been given the authority to act on behalf of the subdivision they should be allowed to exercise that right. Where one does not exist the petition will need to be approved by 67% of the properties within the study area. Study Area Referred to as the “impacted area” in the existing ordinance it includes all property owners along the roadway where the traffic calming devices are to be installed as well as those street segments where vehicles may be diverted to avoid the traffic calming measures and all cul-de-sacs that obtain access from those street segments where the traffic calming measures have been proposed. The study area is a subdivision or neighborhood and includes affected street property owners and property owners fronting adjacent side streets within subdivision or neighborhood where Public Works considers it likely that motorist must travel through the proposed traffic calming measure in order to access their lots. Comment: The definition remains essentially the same except that the study area is limited to a subdivision or neighborhood and it does not include streets where traffic may be potentiall y diverted. To include those streets where traffic may be diverted added unnecessary confusion to the process. Where traffic may go to avoid a traffic calming measure may not be easily determined, speed control rather than volume control is the goal of the program. Staff also feels that due to the configuration of the majority of our neighborhoods the elimination of these streets will not significantly alter the defined study area. City of Milton 13000 Deerfield Parkway, Milton, Georgia 30004 3 Legal Review Concurrent review with Legal by Paul Higbee – Jarrard & Davis for form and content. Attachments 1. Ordinance to amend Chapter 48 Article IV. Traffic Calming and Control of the City of Milton Code of Ordinances, 2. Existing Ordinance marked-up to identify proposed changes. ORDINANCE NUMBER: STATE OF GEORGIA COUNTY OF FULTON 1ST READING: APRIL 12, 2010 2ND READING: APRIL 26, 2010 A ORDINANCE TO AMEND CHAPTER 48, ARTICLE IV. TRAFFIC CALMING AND CONTROL OF THE CITY OF MILTON’S CODE OF ORDINANCES WHEREAS, the City of Milton is authorized by O.C.G.A. 32-4-92 to perform all acts which are necessary, proper, or incidental to the efficient operation and development of the municipal street system; and, WHEREAS, on June 7th, 2007 the City of Milton adopted a Community Services Policy which included traffic calming procedures; and, WHEREAS, the City of Milton wishes to amend and update their traffic calming procedures; NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED, by the Mayor and City Council of the City of Milton, Georgia while in regular session on the 12th day of April 2010 at 6:00 p.m. that Chapter 48, Article IV. Traffic Calming and Control of City of Milton code of ordinances is hereby deleted in its entirety and replaced with a new Chapter 48, Article IV. Traffic Calming as attached hereto. SO ORDAINED AND EFFECTIVE ON THIS 26TH DAY OF APRIL, 2010. __________________________________________ JOE LOCKWOOD, MAYOR Attest: Sudie Gordon, City Clerk (Seal) ATTACHMENT A PE – Preliminary Engineering CST – Construction Attachment A ARTICLE IV. TRAFFIC CALMING DIVISION 1. GENERALLY Sec. 48-235. Traffic Calming Warrants. (a) For the purposes of the traffic calming program, a traffic calming measure may be warranted on a residential street if any of the following are found during a traffic study: (1) 50 % or more of the total traffic is exceeding the posted speed limit; or (2) For pedestrian and other safety related problems, confirmation will be made based on: a. Crash reports; b. Inadequate roadway geometry (poor sight distance, etc.); c. School locations; and d. Other safety parameters. Sec. 48-236. Local Residential Street Defined. The city shall only support the installation of traffic calming devices on local residential streets within the city. A local residential street shall be defined as follows: (1) Those streets classified by the city as primarily used for direct access to property and connections to higher order systems; and, (2) Those streets where the adjacent land use is deemed residential in nature; and, (3) Those streets with posted speed limits of 25 mph or 30 mph; and, (4) Those streets with an average daily traffic count of 400 to 4,000 vehicles per day (VPD). Volumes above 4,000 VPD would be considered a major road per the MUTCD for traffic control purposes, and volumes below 400 VPD would not typically provide enough benefit to warrant the expenditure of public funds for installation and the increased maintenance costs. Sec. 48-237. Policy; Introduction. (a) In order to enhance the quality of neighborhood life and the safety of the city's residents, the Public Works Department is establishing this traffic calming program. The goals of this program are: (1) Reduction of traffic speed to a safe and appropriate limit. (2) Encourage community participation. (3) Encouragement and enhancement of pedestrian, bicycle, and transit systems. (4) Limiting traffic calming to local residential streets. (5) Ensuring emergency vehicle access. (6) Use of effective, efficient, economical, and environmentally sound traffic calming solutions. (7) Multi-discipline input from engineers, planners, police, and fire. (8) Continued monitoring of speeds, traffic volumes, and accidents. (b) The Public Works Department shall review applications for traffic calming measures in accordance with this ordinance and the City of Milton Traffic Calming Policy as may be periodically amended. (c) It is extremely important to realize that the approach taken by the traffic calming program is a systematic one. While each situation may be somewhat unique, the same definitions and criteria, as outlined in this article, are applied. Also, the transportation system of the city should be considered as a whole. Solving one local problem should not cause another problem to appear somewhere else. (d) The traffic calming program is to be used only for local residential streets, as defined in section 48-236. (e) Keeping with the general guidelines and recommendations as set forth in the Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices and Institute of Transportation Engineers aids in the recognition and understanding of traffic control devices. Standardization of these devices will help ensure that any given traffic calming measures including the use of speed humps will be equally recognizable and require the same action on the part of the motorist regardless of where they are encountered. Secs. 48-238--48-256. Reserved. DIVISION 2. PROCESS Sec. 48-257. Traffic Calming Process. The city's traffic calming process shall be defined in the City of Milton Traffic Calming Policy. Sec 48-258. Petition Approval Percentage. (a) Prior to the development of conceptual plans at least 67 percent (2/3 majority) of the homeowners in the study area must vote in favor of the installation of traffic calming measures. Where a neighborhood or other defined study area has a mandatory homeowners' association or other legal mechanism which may legally represent their position on such matters, this entity may replace the petition process as approved by the Public Works Director after consultation with the city attorney. (b) The study area shall be as defined in the Traffic Calming Policy. Sec. 48-259. Fee. Prior to the development of any conceptual plan the Applicant shall pay a fee to the Public Works Department . Said fee shall be in an amount established by the Public Works Department and approved by the Mayor and City Council. Secs. 48-260--48-280. Reserved. Sec. 48-281. Neighborhood Cost Share. (a) Basic installation of the traffic calming devices will be shared by the city (50 percent) and the Applicant (50 percent). If the community chooses upgrades or enhanced versions of a traffic calming device, the community will pay the entire cost of design, construction, maintenance and other related charges above those of the basic device, as defined by the traffic calming details provided in the traffic calming policy. (b) Any landscaping, including maintenance, will be paid entirely by the applicant. (c) Easement and right-of-way acquisition shall be provided by the applicant (d) Repair and routine maintenance of all traffic calming devices, excluding landscape maintenance and design enhancements, will be the city's responsibility. Sec. 48-283. Removal of Traffic Calming Devices. (a) If the Applicant decides that they no longer want the previously installed traffic calming devices, they must follow the same procedure to obtain 67 percent or HOA approval as defined in Section 48-258 for installation. (b) Active traffic calming devices should remain in place at least 12 months before removal. If devices are removed, the road and right-of-way must also be brought back to city standards. (c) Removal shall be done by a qualified contractor at no cost to the city, where the Applicant assumes all related cost in the removal of traffic calming devices. (d) The city reserves the right to remove traffic calming devices for any reason. Upon approval of the City Manager, the Public Works Director may order the Applicant to remove a traffic calming measure in accordance with Section 48-283(c). Sec. 48-284. Permit Required. Any work completed by the applicant within the right-of-way shall require a right-of-way encroachment permit as directed by the Public Works Department. Sec. 48-285. Variance Request. Variance requests to the requirements of these regulations shall be submitted in a form as prescribed by the Public Works Director, along with such fees as shall be established by the Mayor and City Council. Each variance request shall be coordinated with all other affected city departments. The Public Works Director shall be authorized to approve variance requests related to design and construction standards established in the City of Milton Traffic Calming Policy. All other variance requests shall be heard by the mayor and city council in accordance with standard operating procedures. Sec. 48-286. Appeals. Any person aggrieved by a decision of any City of Milton staff member in the application of this ordinance shall have the right to appeal that decision to the Mayor and City Council within 30 days of the date of the decision. Secs. 48-287--48-301. Reserved. ARTICLE IV. TRAFFIC CALMING AND CONTROL DIVISION 1. GENERALLY Sec. 48-235. Traffic Calming Warrantsproblem defined. (a) For the purposes of the traffic calming program, a traffic problem calming measure may be warranted on a residential street exists if any of the following are found during a traffic study: (1) The 85th percentile speed in a local residential street is greater than ten miles over the posted speed limit. 50 % or more of the total traffic is exceeding the posted speed limit; or (2) For pedestrian and other safety related problems, confirmation will be made based on: a. Crash reports; b. Inadequate roadway geometry (poor sight distance, etc.); c. School locations; and d. Other safety parameters. (b) If the results of any traffic study show that a residential traffic problem exists, based upon the criteria contained in subsection (a) of this section, the transportation division will produce a traffic calming report, as explained in section 48-258. (Ord. No. 07-06-32, § 1, 6-7-2007) Sec. 48-236. Local residential street defined. The city should shall only support the installation of traffic calming devices on local residential streets, located within the city.: A local residential street shall be defined as follows: (1) The term "local streets" means tThose streets classified by the city as primarily used for direct access to property and connections to higher order systems , and;. (2) The term "residential streets" means those Those streets where the adjacent land use is deemed primarily residential in nature, and;. (3) Those streets with posted speed limits of Only 25 mph and or 30 mph roads qualify for traffic calming, and; as O.C.G.A. § 40-14-8(b) states: "Thoroughfares with speed limits of 35 mph or more shall not be considered residential streets." (4) Those streets Only roads with an average daily traffic count of 400 to 4,000 vehicles per day (VPD). should be considered for traffic calming device installation. Volumes above 4,000 VPD would be considered a major road per the MUTCD for traffic control purposes, and volumes below 400 VPD would not typically provide enough benefit to warrant the expenditure of public funds for installation and the increased maintenance costs. (Ord. No. 07-06-32, § 1, 6-7-2007) Comment [CL1]: This section actually says “residential district” and is referring to the ability to post a residential district and enforce speed limits less than 10 mph over posted. Sec. 48-237. Policy; introduction. (a) Citizens are often concerned about excessive traffic speed through their residential neighborhoods. The primary function of local residential streets in neighborhoods is to allow direct access to the properties and connections to higher order systems. When neighborhood streets are being used with excessive speed, the quality of life and the safety of residents is diminished. (ba) In order to enhance the quality of neighborhood life and the safety of the city's residents, the transportation divisionPublic Works Department is establishing this traffic calming program. The goals of this program are: (1) Reduction of traffic speed to a safe and appropriate limit. (2) Encourage community participation. (3) Encouragement and enhancement of pedestrian, bicycle, and transit syste ms. (4) Discouraging traffic from using local residential streets to bypass collectors. (5) Limiting traffic calming to local residential streets. (6) Ensuring emergency vehicle access. (7) Use of effective, efficient, economical, and environmentally sound traffic calming solutions. (8) Multi-discipline input from engineers, planners, police, and fire. (9) Continued monitoring of speeds, traffic volumes, and accidents. (b) The Public Works Department shall review applications for traffic calming measures in accordance with this ordinance and the City of Milton Traffic Calming Policy as may be periodically amended. (c) It is extremely important to realize that the approach taken by the traffic calming program is a systematic one. While each situation may be somewhat unique, the same definitions and criteria, as outlined in this article, are applied. Also, the transportation system of the city should be considered as a whole. Solving one local p roblem should not cause another problem to appear somewhere else. (d) The traffic calming program is to be used only for local residential streets, as defined in section 48-236. It is also a goal of the program to have the speed limit of all local residential streets posted and enforceable at 25 mph. (e) Keeping with the general guidelines and recommendations as set forth in the Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices and Institute of Transportation Engineers aids in the recognition and understanding of traffic control devices. Standardization of these devices will help ensure that any given traffic calming measures including the use of speed humps will be equally recognizable and require the same action on the part of the motorist regardless of where they are encountered. (Ord. No. 07-06-32, § 1, 6-7-2007) Secs. 48-238--48-256. Reserved. DIVISION 2. PROCESS AND REPORT Sec. 48-257. Traffic calming process. The city's traffic calming process shall be defined in the City of Milton Traffic Calming Policy. is as follows: (1) Homeowners' association, neighborhood group, or individual reports a speeding problem in their neighborhood. (2) Transportation division will make a field review of the area to determine what studies should be conducted. (3) Transportation division will conduct appropriate studies, as approved by city manager, to determine the existence and extent of the problem. a. If the results of the study indicate there is no traffic problem, the neighborhood will be informed in writing. b. If the results of the study indicate there is a traffic problem, transportation staff will develop a traffic calming report, including suggested solutions. (4) Transportation staff schedules a public neighborhood meeting to discuss study findings, suggested solutions, and traffic calming process. (5) The neighborhood must show support for the proposed solution by submitting a petition showing 75 percent support to the transportation division for verification (see section 48-279 for details). The service area necessary for the petition will be determined by the city engineer or his or her designee. (6) Once the petition is verified, the public works staff will develop a final project design and cost, based on the suggested sol ution, which will be presented to the neighborhood. (7) Passive measures and any needed modifications or temporary measures may be implemented and studies for effectiveness before active measures are installed. (8) Final design and cost will be presented to the mayor and city council for funding and approval. (9) Upon city council approval, the traffic calming project will be implemented at the city manager's direction. (10) Within six months of the project installation, the transportation staff will conduct followup studies to measure project effectiveness. (Ord. No. 07-06-32, § 1, 6-7-2007) Sec 48-258. Petition Approval Percentage (a) Prior to the development of conceptual plans at least 67 percent (2/3 majority) of the homeowners in the study area must vote in favor of the installation of traffic calming measures. Where a neighborhood or other defined study area has a mandatory homeowners' association or other legal mechanism which may legally represent their position on such matters, this entity may replace the petition process as approved by the Public Works Director after consultation with the city attorney. (b) The study area shall be as defined in the Traffic Calming Policy. Sec. 48-258. Traffic calming report. (a) Request for traffic study. A homeowners' association, neighborhood group, or individual requesting a traffic study in their neighborhood must submit a written request clearly stating their concerns. (b) Review procedures. (1) The transportation staff will analyze the results of the traffic study for a neighborhood and determine if a problem, as defined in section 48-235, exists. If there is no problem, a letter is sent to the requestor informing them of such, and the transportation division will archive the traffic study results for comparison to future studies. (2) If a traffic problem, as defined in section 48-235, does exist, then the public works staff will analyze the data to determine: a. The severity of the problem. b. The causes of the problem. c. Whether the traffic problem is local or systemic. d. What feasible traffic calming solutions may solve the problem. (3) The transportation staff will develop a traffic calming report giving the results of the traffic study, identification of the problem, and the proposed traffic calming solutions, in a prioritized list with anticipated effectiveness and cost. Copies of the study will be given to the fire department, police department, and any other appropriate agency, organization, or individual as determined by the transportation director. (Ord. No. 07-06-32, § 1, 6-7-2007) Sec. 48-259. Fee. Prior to the development of any conceptual plan the Applicant shall pay a fee to the Public Works Department . Said fee shall be in an amount established by the Public Works Department and approved by the Mayor and City Council. Secs. 48-259260--48-277. Reserved. DIVISION 3. MISCELLANEOUS PROVISIONS Sec. 48-278. Feasible alternative solutions. The feasible alternative solutions are classified into two categories. The first is passive traffic calming measures and the second is active traffic calming measures. In general, passive measures are quicker to implement, easier to undo, cost less, and should be considered prior to the implementation of active measures. Division 4 of this article presents many of the possible traffic calming solutions that are used by the transportation division. Transportation staff will continue to monitor other agencies' results in their traffic calming programs and will have staff attend seminars pertaining to traffic calming. Therefore, solutions presented here may be altered, removed, or expanded as experience in this field grows. (Ord. No. 07-06-32, § 1, 6-7-2007) Sec. 48-279. Neighborhood petitions. (a) The city requires that there be wide support from the community for implementing traffic calming measures in its neighborhood. All of the property owners in the impacted area should be contacted and given an opportunity to sign the petition, indicating their opinion concerning the installation of the traffic calming device. Any abstention or indication other than a "yes" will be considered a "no." The term "impacted area" means all property owners along the roadway or street segment where a traffic calming device is to be installed or a roadway or street segment that would cause vehicles to be diverted to another roadway or street segment as to avoid such devices. In addition, the impacted area will include all cul-de-sacs that obtain access from the roadway or street segment where a traffic calming device is to be installed. (b) A spouse's signature will not be acceptable if he or she is not the legal owner. If both husband and wife are joint legal owners, both signatures are required. A "Mr. and Mrs." signature is not acceptable. All owners must sign individually, including owners of undeveloped lots. Renting tenants are not an acceptable substitute for the legal homeowner. The percentages will be calculated, based on individual lots where the owners sign affirmatively, divided by the total number of lots in the neighborhood. Each lot counts as only one lot regardless of the number of owners signing . At least 65 percent of the homeowners in the neighborhood must vote in favor of installing the traffic calming device before the petition will be accepted. Where a neighborhood has a homeowners' association or other legal mechanism allowing a group less than the previously stated required percentages to represent their position on matters such as these, this mechanism may replace the petition process as approved by the city manager after consultation with the city attorney. (c) The completed petition must be returned to the public works department where it will be checked against tax records and land lot maps to ensure that it meets all requirements. The petition will be presented to the city council for action. The city reserves the right to set a reasonable expiration date on petition signatures. See section 48-280 for example petition letter and forms. (Ord. No. 07-06-32, § 1, 6-7-2007) Sec. 48-280. Sample petition letter and forms. Formatted: l0, Indent: First line: 0", Tab stops: Not at 0.5" (a) Two sample petitions follow. The first is an example of a single sheet per property design which could be included in a home owner's association newsletter or passed out by volunteers. The second is a petition form that includes multiple signatures and could be carried around by volunteers or kept in a central location. Either form, or reasonable variations of either, is acceptable. Neighborhoods have had success with multiple distribution methods, and community services staff is available to offer advice and suggestions. (b) Regardless of exact format, all petitions must have certain features. Most importantly, the property owners must clearly indicate they are in favor of traffic calming devices on the neighborhood streets. The street address of the property should be indicated, along with printed name of the owner. Please note that all listed property owners must sign the petition or a "no" vote will be recorded for the property. (c) Submitted petitions should include a cover letter from the home owner's association board, neighborhood president, or other responsible party attesting that all signatures are correct and valid to the best of their knowledge. The letter should also specify that the petition supports the type of and number of traffic calming devices proposed by community services staff as the suggested solutions. City of Milton Department of Community Services C/o Traffic Calming Program 13000 Deerfield Parkway, Suite 107C Milton, Georgia 3004 678.242.2500 PETITION FOR TRAFFIC CALMING I, the undersigned, being the owner of real property located at _________________________ in the City of Milton, in the ________________ neighborhood, do hereby petition for the installation of _________________________ for purposes of improving the safety of the neighborhood streets for all users of the roadways. I do hereby pledge and consent to the installation of traffic calming devices on the roadways adjacent to my property and in the neighborhood that are constructed within the public right-of-way and conform to the design and safety standards for such devices as determined by City of Milton Community Services Department. TABLE INSET: ________ __ Print Name (First, Last) ________ __ Signature ________ __ Date ________ __ Print Name (First, Last) ________ __ Signature ________ __ Date PETITION FOR TRAFFIC CALMING We, the undersigned, do hereby record our preference on the installation of ________________ traffic calming devices adjacent to our property and in our neighborhood, which would be constructed within the public right-of-way and conform to the design and safety standards for such devices as determined by City of Milton Community Services Department. TABLE INSET: Printed NameStr eet Address Yes/Note Neighborhood: ________________ Page _________ of _________ (Ord. No. 07-06-32, § 1, 6-7-2007) Sec. 48-281. Neighborhood cost share. (a) Basic installation of the traffic calming devices will be shared paid by the city 75 (50 percent) and the community Applicant 25 (50 percent). If the community chooses upgrades or enhanced versions of a traffic calming device, the community will pay the entire cost of design, construction, maintenance and other related charges above those of the basic device., as defined by the traffic calming details provided in the traffic calming policy. (b) In addition, Aany landscaping, including maintenance, will be paid entirely by the communityapplicant. Installation costs include, but are not limited to: (1) The demolition and removal of existing pavement; (2) Construction of the devices; (3) Sign and pavement marking modifications; Formatted: l0, Tab stops: Not at 0.5" (4) Landscaping; (5) Necessary easements; and (6) Right-of-way acquisition (c) Easement and right-of-way acquisition shall be provided by the applicant. (dc) Repair and routine maintenance of all traffic calming devices , excluding landscape maintenance and design enhancements, will be the city's responsibility. If the city receives more requests than can be accommodated by the budget in a fiscal year, the transportation division will develop a recommended priority list based on measurable criteria, such as: (1) Volumes; (2) 85th percentile speeds; and (3) Crash experience. (Ord. No. 07-06-32, § 1, 6-7-2007) Sec. 48-282. Review and analysis of applied solution. (a) Within six months after a traffic calming project has been implemented, the public works department will conduct another traffic study to determine the effectiveness of the solution. This traffic study will encompass surrounding streets that may also have been affected by the solution implementation. (b) The transportation division will place its findings in a report as to the effectiveness of the solution, citing before and after data. Of particular importance will be whether the stated goals have been accomplished and to what degree. Copies of the final report will be made available to all interested parties. (Ord. No. 07-06-32, § 1, 6-7-2007) Sec. 48-283. Removal of traffic calming devices. (a) If the neighborhood Applicant decides that they no longer want the previously installed traffic calming devices, they must follow the same procedure to obtain 65 67 percent or HOA approval support by petition as listed defined in Section 48-258 above for installation. (b) Active traffic calming devices should remain in place at least 12 months before removal. If devices are removed, the road and right-of-way must also be brought back to city standards. (c) Removal should shall be done by a qualified contractor at no cost to the city, where the community Applicant assumes all related cost in the removal of traffic calming devices. (d) The city reserves the right to remove speed humps traffic calming devices for any reason. Upon approval of the City Manager, the Public Works Director may order the Applicant to remove a traffic calming measure in accordance with Section 48-283(c). (Ord. No. 07-06-32, § 1, 6-7-2007) Formatted: l0, Tab stops: Not at 0.5" Sec. 48-284. Permit Required Any work completed by the applicant within the right-of-way shall require a right-of-way encroachment permit as directed by the Public Works Department. Sec. 48-285. Variance Request Variance requests to the requirements of these regulations shall be submitted in a form as prescribed by the Public Works Director, along with such fees as shall be established by the Mayor and City Council. Each variance request shall be coordinated with all other affected city departments. The Public Works Director shall be authorized to approve variance requests related to design and construction standards established in the City of Milton Traffic Calming Policy. All other variance requests shall be heard by the mayor and city council in accordance with standard operating procedures. Sec. 48-286. Appeals Any person aggrieved by a decision of any City of Milton staff member in the application of this ordinance shall have the right to appeal that decision to the Mayor and City Council within 30 days of the date of the decision. Secs. 48-284287--48-301. Reserved. DIVISION 4. PASSIVE MEASURES Sec. 48-302. Purpose. The primary use of passive measures is to reduce the speed of traffic while raising awareness of the traffic problems in residential areas. These methods are less costly than active devices, as they do not affect the geometry of the roadway or require extensive construction. Passive traffic calming measures include radar trailers, restriping, and installing signs. (1) General advantages of passive geometry traffic calming measures: a. Pose no restrictions for bicycles or pedestrian traffic. b. Do not affect intersection capacity or operation. c. Cheaper than active traffic calming devices. d. Raise awareness of drivers to speeding problems. e. No impacts to transit or emergency services. f. Can be done regardless of the grade of the road. (2) General disadvantages of passive traffic calming measures: a. Not necessarily enforceable. b. Not always effective over time. (Ord. No. 07-06-32, § 1, 6-7-2007) Sec. 48-303. Radar trailer. (a) Description. The city is considering the operation of a number of portable radar speed meters capable of measuring vehicle speed and graphically displaying the speed of the motorist. (b) Primary purpose. Reduce vehicle speeds by raising the awareness of the driver to their speed. (c) Advantages. (1) Possible speed reduction for short intervals at the radar trailer location. (2) Opportunity to collect volume and speed data, dependant upon equipment. (d) Disadvantages. (1) Not an enforcement tool. (2) Minimal effectiveness on reducing traffic speeds over time. (Ord. No. 07-06-32, § 1, 6-7-2007) Sec. 48-304. Narrowing lanes. (a) Description. Striping is used to narrow travel lanes to ten-foot widths. (b) Primary purpose. Reduce vehicle speed by creating the percep tion of a narrower road. Generally, speeds are lower in ten-foot wide lanes than in 12-foot wide lanes. (c) Advantages. (1) Restriping can include bike lanes or bike-friendly shoulders. This reduces the vehicular lane width while also providing a safe place for bikes to travel. Striping to include bike lanes also reduces the potential for driver to drive outside the lane. (2) Striping is easily modified when done with a concurrent asphalt resurfacing program. (d) Disadvantages. Citizens do not always perceive striping to be an effective traffic calming technique. (Ord. No. 07-06-32, § 1, 6-7-2007) Sec. 48-305. Signs and signals. Advisory and regulatory signs and signals can assist with many problems addressed by traffic calming. Installation of any signs and signals should conform to the standards set forth in the Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices (MUTCD), as established by the Federal Highway Administration. (Ord. No. 07-06-32, § 1, 6-7-2007) Sec. 48-306. One-way treatment. (a) Description. One-way treatment involves having streets or roadways upon which vehicular traffic is allowed to travel in one direction only. (b) Primary purpose. Increase the safety of a roadway by reducing the number of conflicting movements. One-way treatment is not a traffic calming method, but can be used to manage traffic flow in an area. (c) Advantages. (1) Increases the safety of the roadway by reducing the number of conflicting movements. (2) One-way treatment of a roadway is enforceable. (d) Disadvantages. (1) Changing a street from a two-way operation to a one-way operation takes a lengthy implementation process. (2) Changing a street from a two-way operation to a one-way operation may impact emergency services or transit systems. (3) Changing a street from a two-way operation to a one-way operation requires the consideration of the impact on the local system. Steps should be taken to ensure that making a roadway one way will not move the problem elsewhere or create new problems. (4) Works best in a system comprised of parallel roads. (5) Residents may be inconvenienced changing traveling behaviors within the subdivision. (e) Other considerations. Emergency services and transit routes should be considered when changing from two-way operation to one-way operation. Their opinions will be solicited and weighed appropriately. (Ord. No. 07-06-32, § 1, 6-7-2007) Sec. 48-307. On-street parking. (a) Description. On-street parking provides designated parking spots on the sides of roadways. (b) Primary purpose. On-street vehicular spaces provide both additional parking and traffic calming benefits. Drivers tend to travel more slowly when driving past a lane of parked cars due to a reduction in the perceived travel way. (c) Advantages. (1) May reduce the speeds of the through traffic. (2) Increase pedestrian safety on-street parking provides a greater buffer between the sidewalk and the traveling vehicular lanes. (d) Disadvantages. (1) Common perception that on-street parking is not aesthetically pleasing. (2) Possible difficulty seeing pedestrians crossing at mid-block locations. (e) Other considerations. (1) Parking spaces should be prohibited at least 100 feet from an intersection and at least ten feet on both sides of a fire hydrant. (2) Create a wide single lane where on-street parking would be promoted. (Ord. No. 07-06-32, § 1, 6-7-2007) GRAPHIC LINK: Click here Sec. 48-308. Gateway and pavement treatments. (a) Description. Gateway treatments are decorative entrances indicating transition from one area to another. Pavement treatments involve decorative pavement in the form of different colors and textures. (b) Primary purpose. Gateway and pavement treatments visually alert the driver that they are entering a new area, such as a residential area from an arterial road. Gateway treatments can include signs, decorative walls, arches, pillars, hedgerows, etc. Pavement treatments can include colored concrete, stamped concrete, or bricks. (c) Advantages. (1) Versatile and easily individualized for each specific neighborhood. (2) Aesthetically pleasing. (3) Easy to implement with active traffic calming devices. (d) Disadvantages. (1) Limited utility in speed reduction. (2) Maintenance and replacement costs can be costly and difficult to address. (e) Other considerations. Gateway treatments should not obscure proper sight distance, therefore making the intersection less safe. Structures are not permitted in the public right-of-way. (Ord. No. 07-06-32, § 1, 6-7-2007) Sec. 48-309. Increased patrolling and target enforcement. (a) Description. Police can intensify coverage for an area of concern, most commonly to enforce speed limits and stop signs. (b) Primary purpose. Increase in awareness to the traveling public of law enforcement and to encourage them to obey traffic laws. (c) Advantages. (1) Citizens perceive as achieving results with an increased police presence. (2) Decrease in traffic violations in the general area. (d) Disadvantages. (1) Police generally do not have the staff to regularly patrol most residential areas. (2) Time that police officers spend patrolling for traffic violators is not directly spent in reducing violent crime. (3) Many residential roads have insufficient geometric alignment for radar enforcement. (4) Increasing patrols and enforcement only reduces speeds in the general area during the period of intensified attention. Once the intensity subsides, the traffic violators typically return to their previous habits. (5) Enforcement applies to all residents in violation. (e) Other considerations. If heavy truck traffic is an issue, citizens can request that the road be added to the truck route prohibition list. (Ord. No. 07-06-32, § 1, 6-7-2007) Sec. 48-310. Neighborhood safety and awareness program (neighborhood watch). (a) Description. Teach techniques motorists, pedestrians, and parents can use to help address speeding issues, and increase awareness of their driving habits. Unique programs can be developed for specific cases, such as crime awareness or parking enforcement. (b) Primary purpose. Increase the awareness and activity of the neighborhood. Frequently, it is members of the neighborhood who are the most flagrantly violating traffic ordinances (i.e., stops signs or the speed limit). (c) Advantages. (1) Involves the neighborhood actively and regularly in the solution. (2) Easily combines with other traffic calming techniques. (d) Disadvantages. (1) Citizens do not always perceive neighborhood watch programs as effective traffic calming techniques. (2) Program effectiveness is proportional to the level of neighborhood association involvement. (Ord. No. 07-06-32, § 1, 6-7-2007) Sec. 48-311. Right-of-way clearing. (a) Description. Clearing of brush, limbing trees, trimming shrubs or o ther objects in the right-of-way that obscure signs or sight distance either along roadways or at intersections can improve safety. (b) Primary purpose. Maintain minimum sight distances along roadways. Sight distances over a certain length may increase the traveling speed of along a roadway, but sight distances below the minimum may adversely affect safety. Clearing the right-of-way does not assist in traffic calming, but does assist in improving safety. (c) Advantages. (1) Potential quick turnaround on a request for the clearing of the right-of-way. (2) City program is already in place to trim trees and clear the right-of-way. (3) Improve safety of intersections and roadways by providing ample view of signs and improving sight distances. (d) Other considerations. The city encourages homeowners' associations to keep the rights-of-way clear. Rights-of-way clearings performed by city work crews is done without regard for existing landscaping or vegetation. (Ord. No. 07-06-32, § 1, 6-7-2007) Secs. 48-312--48-330. Reserved. DIVISION 5. ACTIVE MEASURES Sec. 48-331. Purpose. The primary purposes of active traffic calming devices are to reduce the speed of traffic, improve bike and pedestrian safety, and raise awareness of traffic pro blems in a residential area. These methods are more expensive than passive devices because they often affect the geometry of the roadway, which requires extensive construction and maintenance. Active traffic calming devices include speed humps, traffic circles, and splitters. (1) General advantages of active traffic calming devices: a. Effective at solving specific traffic issues, especially speeding. b. Raise awareness of drivers to speeding problems. (2) General disadvantages of active traffic calming devices: a. May pose restrictions for bicycle traffic. b. May negatively impact transit or emergency services. c. Higher cost than passive traffic calming measures. (Ord. No. 07-06-32, § 1, 6-7-2007) Sec. 48-332. Standard speed humps. (a) Description. The standard speed hump is a 22-foot long, four-to-six-inch-high hump, constructed of asphalt or concrete, and extending the entire width of the roadway which causes vertical displacement of the vehicle. The hump consists of two six-foot-long ramps flanking a ten-foot flat section. Humps can be colored and textured to add aesthetic appeal. (b) Primary purpose. Reduce vehicle speeds by providing vertical displacement of the vehicle that result in a jolt if the vehicle's speed is too high. (c) Advantages. (1) Reduces vehicle speeds (encouraging 25 mph vehicle speeds). (2) Pose no restrictions for bicycles. (3) Does not affect intersection capacity or operation. (d) Disadvantages. Potentially increases traffic noise from braking and acceleration of vehicles, particularly buses and trucks. (e) Transit service impacts. 22-foot speed humps create a minor impact to transit scheduling. (f) Emergency services impacts. When speed hump designs are selected for any street, one should consider whether it is used as a primary response route. Minor impacts to response time may occur. (g) Other considerations. Speed humps should not be considered on grades of eight percent or greater. (Ord. No. 07-06-32, § 1, 6-7-2007) Sec. 48-333. Intersection humps. GRAPHIC LINK: Click here (a) Description. Similar to the speed hump, the intersection hump slopes are all straight lines and are typically constructed out of concrete with a surface treatment or patterning. The top of the intersection hump is flat, and the one pictured in this section extends beyond the boundary of the intersection providing a spot close to the curb for pedestrians to safely cross. The structure does not extend into the gutter areas for necessary drainage concerns. (b) Primary purpose. Reduce vehicle speeds at intersections by providing vertical displacement of the vehicle that result in a jolt if the vehicle's speed is too high. They may also provide a place for pedestrians to safely navigate the intersection. At an intersection where an all-way stop is unwarranted, an intersection hump forces motorists to navigate the intersection more slowly, making them more likely to yield the right-of-way to other motorists and pedestrians. (c) Advantages. (1) Reduce vehicle speeds (encourage 25 mph vehicle speeds). (2) Pose no restrictions for bicycles. (3) Increase pedestrian safety by providing a distinct location for drivers to yield right-of-way. (4) Increase intersection safety by providing a distinct location for drivers to yield right-of-way to other legs of the intersection. (d) Disadvantages. (1) Potentially increase traffic noise from braking and acceleration of vehicles particularly buses and trucks. (2) Noise from tires hitting the structure. (3) Perception from real estate industry that speed tables affect property values negatively by advertising "a speeding problem." (e) Transit service impacts. Intersection humps do not significantly impede transit services. (f) Emergency services impacts. When intersection hump designs are selected for any street, one should consider whether it is used as a primary response route. Intersection humps may cause difficulty with the turning radii of large vehicles. (g) Other considerations. Intersection humps should not be considered on grades of eight percent or greater. Intersection humps may also pose challenges with surface water management. (Ord. No. 07-06-32, § 1, 6-7-2007) Sec. 48-334. Neighborhood traffic circles (roundabouts). GRAPHIC LINK: Click here (a) Description. Traffic circles or roundabouts consist of a landscaped island in the center of the intersection with appropriate signage and marking. A driver enters a traffic circle by turning right, after yielding to any traffic coming from the left. All turns from a roadway intersection that has a traffic circle are right-in, right-out. (b) Primary purpose. Reduce speeds through intersections and assist drivers in proper yielding. (c) Advantages. (1) Increase operational safety by reducing the number of conflicting movements. (2) Reduce speeds in the intersection. (3) Cannot be ignored like an intersection controlled by stop signs. (4) May improve intersection capacity and operation. (5) Accommodates intersections with a wide range of access points (i.e., three to five-way intersections) and can include driveways in the intersection. (d) Disadvantages. (1) Provides a potential obstruction for collision. (2) Maintenance costs increase over all-way stop due to increased landscaping and pavement. (e) Transit service impacts. Traffic circles can be designed such that buses can navigate left turns by going the wrong way through a traffic circle. On roads with high average daily traffic that would make such maneuvers infeasible, traffic circles should be designed large enough for buses to navigate. (f) Emergency services impacts. Traffic circles can be designed such that emergency service vehicles can navigate left turns by going the wrong way through a traffic circle. On roads with high average daily traffic that would make such maneuvers infeasible, traffic circles should be designed large enough for emergency service vehicles to navigate. (g) Other considerations. (1) Driveways can directly access the traffic circle. (2) Installation of a traffic circle typically requires modifying the existing corners. While this work can typically be done within the right-of-way, it impacts perceived property. (3) Visibility of the device should be optimized through the use of raised pavement markers, striping, and signs. (Ord. No. 07-06-32, § 1, 6-7-2007) Sec. 48-335. Splitters (short median). GRAPHIC LINK: Click here (a) Description. Splitter islands divert traffic laterally, often narrowing the roadway, while providing one-way flow for short intervals. Splitters are frequently landscaped for aesthetic appeal. Splitters must maintain a 20-foot wide lane for emergency services. (b) Primary purpose. Reduce though traffic speeds. (c) Advantages. (1) Reduce speeds on roadways through lateral deflection and roadway narrowing. (2) Provide areas for landscaping and improving the aesthetic value of the neighborhood. (3) Provide locations for safer mid-block pedestrian crossings. (4) Allowable on grades of eight percent or higher. (d) Disadvantages. (1) Create obstructions for potential collision. (2) Expensive design that may require right-of-way to be acquired to promote the concept. (3) Maintenance costs increase due to increased landscaping and pavement. (e) Transit service impacts. There is no significant impact to transit services. (f) Emergency services impacts. There is no significant impact to emergency services. (g) Other considerations. (1) Driveways with access directly to the splitter are not allowable. If there is hardship in the placement of splitters due to driveway locations, chicanes could be considered instead. (2) Installation of a splitter island requires modifying the adjacent property. While this work can usually be done within the right-of-way, it impacts perceived property. (3) Visibility of the device should be optimized through the use of raised pavement markers, striping, and signs. (Ord. No. 07-06-32, § 1, 6-7-2007) Sec. 48-336. Chicanes (deflectors). GRAPHIC LINK: Click here (a) Description. Chicanes change the physical characteristics of a roadway section from an existing straight alignment to a series of horizontal curves, causing horizontal displacement of the vehicle. (b) Primary purpose. Reduce vehicle speeds by providing horizontal deflection and a narrowed vehicle travel path, as well as potentially reducing sight distance that is too great for desired speed. (c) Advantages. (1) Reduce vehicle speeds with less impact on emergency service vehicles. (2) Pose no restrictions for bicycle. (3) Allowable on grades of eight percent or higher. (d) Disadvantages. (1) Existing driveways can limit placement. (2) Create obstructions for potential collision. (3) Maintenance costs increase due to increased landscaping and pavement. (4) May pose challenges with surface water management. (e) Transit service impacts. There is no significant impact to transit services. (f) Emergency services impacts. There is no significant impact to emergency services. (g) Other considerations. Visibility of the device should be optimized through the use of raised pavement markers, striping, and signs. (Ord. No. 07-06-32, § 1, 6-7-2007) Sec. 48-337. Chokers (neck-downs). GRAPHIC LINK: Click here (a) Description. Chokers narrow a street at an intersection or mid-block by construction of a wider sidewalk, landscape strip, or gateway treatment. Alternativ ely, lanes can be reduced to ten feet by moving the curb lines. (b) Primary purpose. Reduce vehicle speeds by providing horizontal deflection and a narrowed vehicle travel path, as well as potentially reducing sight distance that is too great for desired speed. (c) Advantages. (1) Reduce vehicle speeds with less impact on emergency service vehicles. (2) Provide shorter pedestrian crossing distances and better motorist-pedestrian visibility. (3) Discourage truck traffic. (4) Allowable on grades of eight percent or higher. (d) Disadvantages. (1) Existing driveways can limit placement. (2) Create obstruction for potential collision. (3) Potentially impede bicycle safety and mobility. (4) Maintenance costs increase due to increased landscaping and pavement. (5) May pose challenges with surface water management. (6) May result in the loss of curbside parking. (e) Transit service impacts. There is no significant impact to transit services. (f) Emergency services impacts. There is no significant impact to emergency services. (g) Other considerations. Visibility of the device should be optimized through the use of raised pavement markers, striping, and signs. (Ord. No. 07-06-32, § 1, 6-7-2007) Sec. 48-338. Exit-only/one-way entry treatment. GRAPHIC LINK: Click here (a) Description. Similar to a choker, this treatment restricts the intersection such that either entry or exit movements are allowed, but not both. (b) Primary purpose. More effectively manage traffic patterns within a neighborhood. (c) Advantages. (1) Reduce the number of conflicting movements in that intersection. (2) Reduce the need for future installation of traffic signals. (3) Restrict vehicular access while retaining bicycle and pedestrian access. (4) Provide safer areas for pedestrians to cross the intersection. (5) Do not create dead-end streets, making routes more direct, compared to road closures. (6) Reduce motorist speeds. (7) Alternative to a one-way street designation that allows residents within the block to continue to use the street for two-way travel. (d) Disadvantages. (1) May relocate traffic to other locations where the desired movement opportunities exist. (2) May inconvenience local residents who may be forced to drive longer, more circuitous routes to reach their destination. (3) Maintenance costs increase due to increased landscaping and pavement. (4) Easy to violate because they only block half the intersection. (e) Transit service impacts. To minimize the negative effect transit routes should be planned to accommodate barriers. However, they should not be placed at any location where transit service performs a relevant turning movement. (f) Emergency services impacts. There is no significant impact to emergenc y services. (g) Other considerations. These treatments should be planned considering the impact on overall traffic patterns in the area. Stormwater drainage can be a significant consideration. (Ord. No. 07-06-32, § 1, 6-7-2007) Sec. 48-339. Curb extensions. GRAPHIC LINK: Click here (a) Description. Curb extensions narrow the roadway to make pedestrian crossing faster and safer. They can be installed either at intersections or mid-block. (b) Primary purpose. Improve pedestrian safety by reducing the street crossing distance and increasing sight distance. Curb extensions are similar to chokers (neck -downs) and chicanes, but their primary purposes differ. (c) Advantages. (1) Reduce pedestrian crossing distance and time. (2) Make pedestrian crossing points more visible to drivers. (3) Prevent vehicles from passing other vehicles that are turning at an intersection. (4) Provide transition from a through lane to on street parking, dependant upon road width. (5) Visually enhance the street through landscaping or textured treatment. (d) Disadvantages. (1) May reduce the amount of on-street parking. (2) Make accommodating full bicycle lanes difficult. (e) Transit service impacts. Enhance service by moving the curb so riders step directly between the sidewalk and bus door. (f) Emergency services impacts. There is no significant impact to emergency services. (Ord. No. 07-06-32, § 1, 6-7-2007) Sec. 48-340. Modified intersections. GRAPHIC LINK: Click here (a) Description. Barriers that restrict movement may be located at problem intersections. Pictured in this section is a right-in, right-out intersection that restricts all left turn movements to and from the minor road. Other possibilities include increasing or decreasing the curb radii to encourage different turning speeds at the intersection. (b) Primary purpose. Control traffic flow though neighborhoods. (c) Advantages. (1) Improve safety by reducing the number of conflicting movements in t hat intersection. (2) Reduce local street volumes. (3) Reduce the need for future traffic control. (4) Restrict vehicular access while retaining bicycle and pedestrian access. (5) Provide safer areas for pedestrians to cross the intersection. (6) Reduce the speeds at intersections. (d) Disadvantages. (1) May relocate traffic to other locations where turning opportunities exist. (2) May inconvenience local residents who are forced to drive longer, more circuitous routes to reach their destination. (3) Maintenance costs increase due to increased landscaping and pavement. (e) Transit service impacts. To minimize the negative effect, transit routes should be planned to accommodate modified intersections. They should not be placed at any location where transit service performs a relevant turning movement. (f) Emergency services impacts. Even though these barriers would restrict turns for emergency vehicles, they can be designed and installed to provide for emergency access. If desired, the modification can be constructed with breakaway posts and striping, which would allow emergency services while strongly discouraging the target movements. (g) Other considerations. Striping is easily violated. (Ord. No. 07-06-32, § 1, 6-7-2007) Sec. 48-341. Median barriers. GRAPHIC LINK: Click here (a) Description. Provide a physical barrier on the major street at an intersection that can effectively eliminate left turns from the major street onto the minor street as well as eliminate minor street straight-through traffic and left turn traffic across the major street. Median barriers usually consist of a concrete curbed island with a decorative landscaping and surface treatment. (b) Primary purpose. Restrict traffic flow. (c) Advantages. (1) Improve safety by reducing the number of conflicting movements in that intersection. (2) Reduce local street volumes. (3) Negate the need for future traffic signals. (4) Restrict vehicular access while retaining bicycle and pedestrian access. (5) Provide safer areas for pedestrians to cross the intersection. (d) Disadvantages. (1) May relocate traffic to other locations where left-turn opportunities exist. (2) May inconvenience local residents who may be forced to drive longer, more circuitous routes to reach their destination. (3) Maintenance costs increase due to increased landscaping and pavement. (e) Transit service impacts. To minimize the negative effect, transit routes should be planned to accommodate median barriers. They should not be placed at any loc ation where transit service performs a relevant turning movement. (f) Emergency services impacts. Even though median barriers would restrict turns for emergency vehicles, they can be designed and installed to provide for emergency access. If desired, the median can be constructed with breakaway posts and striping or rollback/mountable curbing, which would allow emergency services while strongly discouraging left turns. (g) Other considerations. A full median with no breaks can also be used to prohibit all left turns. (Ord. No. 07-06-32, § 1, 6-7-2007) Secs. 48-342--48-360. Reserved. Prepared by the Community Development Department for the Mayor an d City Council Meeting on April 12, 2010 (First Presentation) 4/5/2010 Page 1 of 20 U09-03 PETITION NUMBER(S): U09-03 PROPERTY INFORMATION ADDRESS 2880 Mountain Road DISTRICT, LAND LOT 2/2, 249 OVERLAY DISTRICT Northwest EXISTING ZONING AG-1 (Agricultural) ACRES 10.3380 EXISTING USE Single family residence/horse farm PROPOSED USE 145 foot Monopole Cell Tower with a 4 ft. lightning rod for a total of 149 feet OWNER Jan C. Hines ADDRESS 80 Milton Avenue Alpharetta, Georgia 30004 PETITIONER/REPRESENTATIVE T-Mobile South, LLC/Shawn Blassingill ADDRESS 4 Concourse Parkway, Suite 300 Sandy Springs, GA 30328 PHONE 404-964-9212 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT RECOMMENDATION U09-03 – DENIAL INTENT To obtain a use permit for a 145 foot tall monopole cell tower with an additional 4 foot lightning rod for a total of 149 feet (Article 19.4.7). Prepared by the Community Development Department for the Mayor an d City Council Meeting on April 12, 2010 (First Presentation) 4/5/2010 Page 2 of 20 U09-03 PLANNING COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION – MARCH 23, 2010 U09-03 – DENIAL 7-0 Mr. David R. Gilley of Georgia Tax and Regulatory Solutions, LLC presented his findings regarding U09-03. He concluded “that wireless coverage does not meet the level desired by the Applicant in this area, but that there is no coverage gap. Therefore the Applicant is not being prohibited from providing coverage, but desires to improve its level of coverage. A review of the topography of nearby properties indicate that there are properties that would provide better screening of the tower and therefore minimize its adverse aesthetic impact. Accordingly, GTRS recommended that this Application be denied.” After hearing many public concerns regarding the quality of life, lack of need for an additional tower for residents in the community, weather the applicant will build the tower for future profit, proximity of 21 homes within 1,000 feet of the tower, lack of buffering from adjacent homes, and potential negative effects on the value of the homes. The Planning Commission discussion included the following issues: 1. Property values affected by cell towers. 2. T-Mobile’s ability to co-locate on other towers and potential construction time for this request. 3. Submittal of engineered drawings of the structure in regards to wind load. 4. Amount and type of coverage in the area. 5. Property owner is not the current resident. Please note the following: • The applicant has not submitted additional items for U09-03 as of March 30, 2010. • An additional Design Review Board (DRB) meeting will be held on April 6, 2010 to meet the zoning ordinances required advertising for the DRB. Prepared by the Community Development Department for the Mayor an d City Council Meeting on April 12, 2010 (First Presentation) 4/5/2010 Page 3 of 20 U09-03 LOCATION MAP Prepared by the Community Development Department for the Mayor an d City Council Meeting on April 12, 2010 (First Presentation) 4/5/2010 Page 4 of 20 U09-03 ZONING MAP Prepared by the Community Development Department for the Mayor an d City Council Meeting on April 12, 2010 (First Presentation) 4/5/2010 Page 5 of 20 U09-03 FUTURE LAND USE MAP Prepared by the Community Development Department for the Mayor an d City Council Meeting on April 12, 2010 (First Presentation) 4/5/2010 Page 6 of 20 U09-03 REVISED SITE PLAN SUBMITTED FEBRUARY 10, 2010 Prepared by the Community Development Department for the Mayor an d City Council Meeting on April 12, 2010 (First Presentation) 4/5/2010 Page 7 of 20 U09-03 Distances from property lines/structures Prepared by the Community Development Department for the Mayor an d City Council Meeting on April 12, 2010 (First Presentation) 4/5/2010 Page 8 of 20 U09-03 SUBJECT SITE – View of house and barn in background SUBJECT SITE – View toward corral Prepared by the Community Development Department for the Mayor an d City Council Meeting on April 12, 2010 (First Presentation) 4/5/2010 Page 9 of 20 U09-03 SUBJECT SITE - View of Stream south of pond SUBJECT SITE – View of Interior of property looking west Prepared by the Community Development Department for the Mayor an d City Council Meeting on April 12, 2010 (First Presentation) 4/5/2010 Page 10 of 20 U09-03 Tower Simulation looking west from Hopewell Road Tower Simulation looking from subject tract to the north Prepared by the Community Development Department for the Mayor an d City Council Meeting on April 12, 2010 (First Presentation) 4/5/2010 Page 11 of 20 U09-03 SUBJECT SITE: The subject site is a 10.3380 acre tract of agriculturally zoned land, located on the northern side of Mountain Road. The subject site is developed with a single- family residence and a small barn. It is located within the Agricultural, Forestry and Mining Land Use designation on the Focus Fulton 2025 Plan which was still in place at the time of this application’s submittal. Existing uses and zoning of nearby property The subject site is surrounded by lots ranging in size from one acre to approximately 30 acres. They are developed with single family residences within the AG-1 (Agricultural) district. Many of the tracts are working horse farms and other related agricultural uses. Further to the south, east and southeast is The Manor subdivision and golf course. The parcels within the subdivision are a minimum of one acre and developed with large estate homes ranging in size from 5,000 square feet to over 10,000 square feet. Further to the north is the Fulton/Cherokee County line. Staff notes that the Mayor and City Council denied a request for a Use Permit (U08-01/VC08-01) for a Landscaping Business located on Land Road on March 17, 2008. In the interest of the public health, safety and welfare, the Mayor and City Council may exercise limited discretion in evaluating the site proposed for a use that requires a Use Permit. In exercising such discretion pertaining to the subject use, the Mayor and City Council shall consider each of the following as outlined in Article 19.2.4 of the Zoning Ordinance; Use Permit Considerations. Staff has reviewed said items pertaining to the subject use, and, offers the following comments: A. Whether the proposed use is consistent with the Comprehensive Land Use Plan and/or Economic Development Revitalization plans adopted by the Mayor and City Council: Focus Fulton 2025 Plan Map: Agricultural, Forestry and Mining The proposed monopole cell tower is inconsistent with the intent and following policies of the Focus Fulton 2025 Comprehensive Plan (this plan was still in place at the time of the applicant filing this request): •••• Encourage development consistent with the surrounding scale, transition of densities and uses, and Comprehensive Plan policies, where appropriate. •••• Protect the existing rural character of Northwest Fulton. Prepared by the Community Development Department for the Mayor an d City Council Meeting on April 12, 2010 (First Presentation) 4/5/2010 Page 12 of 20 U09-03 B. Compatibility with land uses and zoning districts in the vicinity of the property for which the use permit is proposed; The proposed 145 foot monopole with 4 foot lightning rod is inconsistent with the adjacent land uses of single family residences on large agricultural parcels and associated agricultural uses such as barns and riding rings. The closest residential structures are 304 feet, 317 feet and 331 feet from the cell tower to the east, northeast and north respectively. Although the proposed cell tower meets the use permit standards for setbacks, it is Staff’s opinion that it is incompatible based on the location of the tower in an area of residential structures. Further, the tower appears to be located such that it will be significantly higher than the tree stands and will not be visually screened from the road as depicted in the tower simulation photos above. C. Whether the proposed use may violate local, state and/or federal statutes, ordinances or regulations governing land development; Staff has determined that the subject site contains state water which requires a 50 foot undisturbed buffer and 25 foot non-impervious setback as required by Chapter 14, Environment of the City Code. The revised site plan indicates that no portion of the tower facility encroaches into the required buffer and non-impervious setback. D. The effect of the proposed use on traffic flow, vehicular and pedestrian, along adjoining streets; The proposed monopole cell tower is an unmanned operation that will generate only an occasional trip to the site for maintenance. Staff is of the opinion that the proposed monopole cell tower will not impact traffic flow along adjoining streets. E. The location and number of off-street parking spaces; For occasional maintenance trips to the site, space is available next to the gate of the 2,025 square foot leased area. Staff is of the opinion that parking will not impact the surrounding areas due to the size of the large parcel and the location of the leased area toward the center and rear of the site. F. The amount and location of open space; The applicant’s site plan indicates a leased area of 2,025 square feet and an additional access easement. The remainder of the property is Prepared by the Community Development Department for the Mayor an d City Council Meeting on April 12, 2010 (First Presentation) 4/5/2010 Page 13 of 20 U09-03 developed with a small single family residence and barn. The parcel is approximately 10 acres which provides a large area of open space. G. Protective screening; Although the submitted site plan meets the requirements of Article 19.4.7 to provide a 10-foot landscape strip planted to buffer standards exterior to the required fencing not less than 6 feet in height, Staff recommends that the applicant provide a 20-foot landscape strip in lieu of the required 10-foot landscape strip planted to buffer standards to provide additional screening of the tower and associated facilities. This requirement will be reflected in the Recommended Conditions. H. Hours and manner of operation; The proposed monopole cell tower is an unmanned operation that will generate only an occasional trip to the site for maintenance. Staff will condition the site maintenance to be completed between the hours of 8:30 a.m. and 5:30 p.m., Monday through Friday except in cases of emergency or when an after-hours permit is obtained pursuant to the City of Milton Noise Ordinance. I. Streetscape lighting; The applicant has not indicated any streetscape lighting for the site. In addition, no lights will be attached to the monopole tower. Staff notes that any security light utilized in the maintenance area must comply with the Northwest Overlay District and/or Night Sky Ordinance standards for site lighting. J. Ingress and egress to the property. The applicant’s site plan indicates that access to the leased property will be derived from the existing driveway into the site off of Mountain Road. Given the limited use of the subject site for regular maintenance, Staff is of the opinion that the proposed development’s ingress and egress will have limited impact upon the community when conditioned to the limited times listed above. SITE PLAN ANALYSIS Based on the applicant’s revised site plan submitted to the Community Development Department on February 10, 2010. The original site plan submitted on November 30, 2009 was amended so the proposed tower would not encroach into the stream buffer and non-impervious setback. Staff offers the Prepared by the Community Development Department for the Mayor an d City Council Meeting on April 12, 2010 (First Presentation) 4/5/2010 Page 14 of 20 U09-03 following considerations based on the Use Permit standards for cell towers as indicated in the City of Milton Zoning Ordinance, Article 19.4.7, prior to the adoption of the Telecommunications Ordinance by the Mayor and City Council on December 7, 2009: Use Permit Standards – Article 19.4.7 1. Towers must be set back a distance equal to one and one-half (1½) times the height of the tower adjacent to residential and/or AG-1 zoned property. The closest AG-1 zoning property is located 229 feet from the proposed cell tower location. The minimum required is 223.5 feet which includes the lighting rod. Therefore, it meets the required one and one-half times the height of the 149 foot tower. 2. Height shall not exceed 200 feet from existing grade. The proposed height of the tower is 149 feet and is below the maximum height allowed. 3. Tower and associated facilities shall be enclosed by fencing not less than six feet in height and shall also be equipped with an appropriate anti- climbing device. The site plan and associated plans indicate a new six foot high chain link fence with 3 strands of barbed wire. Staff notes that all chain link fencing shall be black vinyl clad. Although barbed wire is permitted in this use and zoning district, Staff recommends that the barbed wire not be utilized which will be reflected in the Recommended Conditions. 4. A minimum 10-foot landscape strip planted to buffer standards shall be required surrounding the facility exterior to the required fence unless the City Arborist determines that existing plant materials are adequate. The site plan indicates a 10-foot landscape strip planted with Leyland cypress. Staff recommends that a 20-foot landscape strip in lieu of the required 10-foot landscape strip be planted to buffer standards per the specifications of the City Arborist to provide additional screening of the facilities from adjacent single family residences. 5. Antennas or towers shall not have lights unless required by federal or state law. Prepared by the Community Development Department for the Mayor an d City Council Meeting on April 12, 2010 (First Presentation) 4/5/2010 Page 15 of 20 U09-03 The proposed tower and antenna will not have any lighting, as it will be less than 200 feet per the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) and the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA). Staff notes that any security light utilized in the maintenance area must comply with the Northwest Overlay District and/or Night Sky Ordinance standards for site lighting. 6. Towers shall not be located within one-half mile from any existing telecommunication tower above the district height, excluding alternative structures. Staff has confirmed that no existing towers are located within one-half mile from the proposed tower. 7. The tower shall comply with applicable state and local statutes and ordinances, including, but not limited to, building and safety codes. Towers which have become unsafe or dilapidated shall be repaired or removed pursuant to applicable state and local statutes and ordinances. The applicant has stated that the proposed tower will comply with all state and local ordinances as listed above and will apply for building permit approval prior to any construction. The applicant is aware and agrees to removal requirements for unsafe or dilapidated wireless facilities. Staff has determined that the subject site contains state water which requires a 50 foot undisturbed buffer and 25 foot non-impervious setback as required by Chapter 14, Environment of the City Code. The revised site plan indicates that no portion of the tower facility encroaches into the required buffer and non-impervious setback. 8. Facilities shall not be artificially lighted except to assure human safety or as required by the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA). The applicant has stated that the facilities will not be artificially lighted. Staff notes that on page C3.3 of the construction plans, lighting is indicated. Staff notes that any security light utilized in the maintenance area must comply with the Northwest Overlay District standards and/or the Night Sky Ordinance for site lighting. 9. Communication towers shall be designed and constructed to ensure that the structural failure or collapse of the tower will not create a safety hazard to adjoining properties, according to applicable Federal Standards which may be amended from time to time. Prepared by the Community Development Department for the Mayor an d City Council Meeting on April 12, 2010 (First Presentation) 4/5/2010 Page 16 of 20 U09-03 The applicant has stated that the proposed tower is designed by certified structural engineers to ensure proper safety according to applicable Federal standards. 10. Telecommunications facilities shall not be used for advertising purposes and shall not contain any signs for the purpose of advertising. The applicant has stated there will not be any advertising on the proposed wireless facility. 11. Any telecommunications facility may co-locate on any existing tower, pole or other structure as long as there is no increase in height to the existing facility. The applicant has stated that the proposed facility may accommodate two additional carriers without increasing the height. 12. A commercial telecommunication facility that ceases operation for a period of 12 consecutive months shall be determined to have terminated and shall be removed within 90 days of termination at the property owner's expense. It shall be the duty of both the property owner and the tower owner to notify the City in writing of any intent to abandon the use of the tower. The applicant has stated that Section 19.4.7(B)(12) will be met. 13. Communication facilities not requiring FAA painting/marking shall have either a galvanized finish or [be] painted a dull blue, gray, or black finish or shall be screened through fencing and landscaping. The applicant states that the facility will be galvanized steel and screened behind fencing and landscaping. Staff notes that the City Design Review Board shall make the final recommendation for the finish of the structure. 14 An application for a telecommunications facility shall be submitted in accordance with the Department’s Plan Review submittal requirements. The applicant states that the facility will adhere to the above requirements. 15. An application for a telecommunication facility shall include a certification from a registered engineer that the structure will meet the applicable design standards for wind loads. Prepared by the Community Development Department for the Mayor an d City Council Meeting on April 12, 2010 (First Presentation) 4/5/2010 Page 17 of 20 U09-03 The applicant states that a certified/registered structural report will be provided for the proposed facility. 16. Communications facilities shall not be located in 100-year flood plain or delineated wetlands. The applicant states that the proposed communication facility is not located in a 100-year flood plain or delineated wetlands. Staff has confirmed these findings to be correct. OTHER CONSIDERATIONS Transportation Engineer – No Comments Building Official – No Comments City Arborist – There will be no specimen trees affected by the proposed cell tower. PUBLIC INVOLVEMENT On Thursday, January 13, 2010 the applicant was present at the Community Zoning Information Meeting held at the Milton City Hall. There were approximately 70 to 80 people in attendance from the community of which 20 people indicated interest in U09-03 on the City’s sign in sheet. Public Comments – Staff has received e-mails which are attached expressing both opposition and support of the request. Staff has met with the adjacent property owners on two occasions. In addition, about ten residents have called Staff to express their opposition to the proposed cell tower. City of Milton Design Review Board Meeting – January 5, 2010 Staff notes that another meeting before the Design Review Board is required based on the Zoning Ordinance’s requirement to publish the DRB meeting in the newspapers as well as include it in the adjacent property owners’ notice. This meeting will occur on April 6, 2010. Although this meeting will occur after the Planning Commission, any new comments received at the meeting will also be included as an addendum to the Staff report prior to the Mayor and City Council meeting. The following recommendations were made by the DRB: • Board/Applicant comments: Prepared by the Community Development Department for the Mayor an d City Council Meeting on April 12, 2010 (First Presentation) 4/5/2010 Page 18 of 20 U09-03 o The Board stated that their purpose is to examine the aesthetic aspects of the proposed towers; land use/location is not for them to decide. o The applicant states that the tower will be a standard grey tower, as this is the best option for blending in. The Board states that they preferred this to the fake tree option. o Applicant states that they are willing to meet City standards in terms of fencing. They are willing to remove the 3 rows of barbed wire topping the chain link fencing. o Board inquired as to whether the Applicant would be able to screen the cell tower compound that is adjacent to the power easement (New Providence). The applicant states that the compound is at least 15’ away from the easement, and that the existing trees will remain. o Board informed the applicant that the trees used to screen the compound had to be a mix of evergreens that would provide screening in one year; Leylands are not allowed according to the Ordinance. o Only towers above 200’ are required to be lit. o Stealth products include: light pole, flag pole, mono pine. o The Board reminded the residents that the Board has the responsibility to protect the Code, and therefore the applicant. They ask the public to help by providing as much information as possible. o A balloon test has been flown; applicant has pictures taken from 20 different locations. These pictures would be on display at the CZIM meeting scheduled for Thursday, January 7th at 7:00pm. o There appears to be a Code disconnect. The Code states that a tower “buried far from the ROW is better.” Did not anticipate that homes would be so nearby. • Public comments: • The cell tower is a commercial use; not appropriate for rural, residential area. Should be on commercial property. • The tower would ruin the land value of the surrounding area. • The tower would be an eyesore. This is not for the good of the community; not in the spirit of what the City was dreamed of. • The residents would like to explore options for tower camouflage. • The applicant should look into other collocate options first. • Does the code require a propagation study to access the need for more towers? (This is included in the submitted documents). • Resident expressed his frustration and displeasure with the process. • Resident stated that his house was 327’ from the proposed Mountain Road tower location; trees less than 100’ tall. Feels that this location was not a good choice for a cell tower. • It is important for the Council/Board to visit the sites before they made any decisions. • Residents asked if Board considered areas that are highly populated as undesirable for cell towers. (Board reminded her that their purview is limited to aesthetics.) • It is incumbent upon Board to understand the unique requirement of the Milton rural community. Prepared by the Community Development Department for the Mayor an d City Council Meeting on April 12, 2010 (First Presentation) 4/5/2010 Page 19 of 20 U09-03 • Resident asked if a fall zone analyses is required. (Towers are designed to collapse within itself.) • Resident is concerned about environment impact of tower, especially the poisoning of the spring fed pond if the tower was to fall. Public Participation Plan and Report This petition was administratively deferred to the March 23, 2010 Planning Commission meeting. Staff received an updated Public Participation Report on March 15, 2010 which meets the required submittal date of seven (7) days prior to the Planning Commission meeting. The applicant will be required to submit an updated public participation report 7 days prior to the Mayor and City Council meeting. CONCLUSION It is Staff’s opinion that the proposed cell tower is inconsistent with the adjacent land uses of single family residences on large agricultural parcels and incompatible based on the location of the tower to adjacent residential structures. In addition, the proposed cell tower is inconsistent with the surrounding scale, transition of densities and does not protect the existing rural character of Milton. Therefore, Staff recommends DENIAL of U09-03. Prepared by the Community Development Department for the Mayor an d City Council Meeting on April 12, 2010 (First Presentation) 4/5/2010 Page 20 of 20 U09-03 RECOMMENDED CONDITIONS If this petition is approved by the Mayor and City Council, it should be approved USE PERMIT for an Antenna Tower and Associated Structure to Exceed the District Height (Article 19.4.7.) CONDITIONAL subject to the owner’s agreement to the following enumerated conditions. Where these conditions conflict with the stipulations and offerings contained in the Letter of Intent, these conditions shall supersede unless specifically stipulated by the Mayor and City Council. 1) To the owner’s agreement to restrict the use of the subject property as follows: a) One monopole communications tower and equipment slab(s) and/or building(s). b) The tower shall not exceed 145 feet with a 4 foot lighting rod. 2) To the owner’s agreement to abide by the following: a) To the revised site plan received by the Milton Community Development Department on February 10, 2010. Said site plan is conceptual only and must meet or exceed the requirements of the Zoning Ordinance and these conditions prior to the approval of a Land Disturbance Permit. Unless otherwise noted herein, compliance with all conditions shall be in place prior to the issuance of the first Certificate of Occupancy or Certificate of Completion. 3) To the owner’s agreement to the following site development considerations: a) To provide a 20 foot landscape strip planted to buffer standards around the leased area. b) All chain link fencing shall be black vinyl clad. c) No barbed wire will be permitted on top of the minimum 6 foot high security fence. d) All site maintenance to be completed between the hours of 8:30 a.m. and 5:30 p.m., Monday through Friday except in cases of emergency or when an after-hours permit is obtained pursuant to the City of Milton Noise Ordinance. Robyn MacDonald From: Norvell [pippi08@att.net] Sent: Monday, January 25, 2010 9:46 AM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Fw: T -Mobile towers ----- Original Message ----- From: Renee Pierce To: i08 att.net Sent: Thursday, January 21, 2010 10:37 AM Subject: T -Mobile towers I am sending this e-mail in support to the petition AGAINST the towers. Renee Pierce 824 Bethany Green Court Hotmail: Free, trusted and rich email service. Get it now. Robyn MacDonald From: Ravi Prakash [rp_bowling@hotmail.corn] Sent: Wednesday, January 20, 2010 1:25 PM To: Robyn Macdonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications ❑ear Sir/Madame: All three sites will improve wireless coverage in Milton, especially in areas where T need it most - at home and in my neighhorhood. T moved to Milton in Dec 2005 and it is almost impossible to talk using our cell phone from home and even in most places around my entire Lake Deerfield community. We are very frustrated and hope that you can assist by giving permit to T -mobile for new towers. Thank you. Sincerely, Ravi Prakash Mailing Address: Ravi. Prakash 12877 Deer Park Ln Milton,GA 30004 Rob n MacDonald From: Rohan Patil [maverickrohan@yahoo.co.in] Sent: Wednesday, January 20, 2010 2:02 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T --Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. All three sites will improve wireless coverage in Milton, especially in areas where I need it most - at home and in my neighborhood. I want to talk, check e-mail or get online with my wireless device from wherever I am, particularly at home. Having poor coverage in a place like Milton is simply unacceptable. In order to have reliable coverage, we need the necessary infrastructure to provide it. I've dropped my landline phone and I rely solely on my wireless phone. It is absolutely imperative that I have reliable wireless coverage to stay connected, particularly in an emergency. Wireless phones have become vital personal and public safety tools in Milton. Please make certain that citizens continue to have the best coverage possible throughout our community. My wireless phone has become a necessity. I use it to check in with my children wherever they are in our community. More importantly, I want my children to always be able to reach me or a 9-1-1 operator in an emergency. I use my wireless phone to stay connected with work, family and friends. Having reliable coverage is important to me. Reliable wireless coverage at home and in my neighborhood is essential for me. Wireless phones are no longer a luxury, they are a necessity. Sincerely, Rohan Patil Mailing Address: Rohan Patil 31003 Deer Trail Milton,GA 30004 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Evilson Rodrigues [wellbonitodemais@hotmail.com] Sent: Wednesday, January 20, 2016 2:46 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Appiications Dear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. I want to talk, check e-mail or get online with my wireless device from wherever I am, particularly at home. Having poor coverage in a place like Milton is simply unacceptable. In order to have reliable coverage, we need the necessary infrastructure to provide it. Sincerely, Evilson Rodrigues Mailing Address: Evilson Rodrigues 1121 northpark In milton,GA 30004 I Robyn MacDonald From: Carolyn Medrano [cmed715@hotmail.com] Sent: Wednesday, January 20, 2010 2:54 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: A new Target Supercenter opened in Milton and there is no service inside the facility for T - Mobile customers. There have been many situation in which family members tried to contact me, with urgent situations and I couldn't be reached while in Target. I also agree the most with the three statements below. All three sites will improve wireless coverage in Milton, especially in areas where I need it most - at home and in my neighborhood. My wireless phone has become a necessity. I use it to check in with my children wherever they are in our community. More importantly, I want my children to always be able to reach me or a 9-1-1 operator in an emergency. Reliable wireless coverage at home and in my neighborhood is essential for me. wireless phones are no longer a luxury, they are a necessity. Sincerely, Carolyn Medrano Mailing Address: Carolyn Medrano 9324 Deer Trail Milton,GA 30004 1 Robyn MacDonald From: loan Turc [icturc[7a gmail.coml Sent: Wednesday, January 20, 2010 3:28 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. All three sites will improve wireless coverage in Milton, especially in areas where I need it most - at home and in my neighborhood. I want to talk, check e-mail or get online with my wireless device from wherever I am, particularly at home. Having poor coverage in a place like Milton is simply unacceptable. In order to have reliable coverage, we need the necessary infrastructure to provide it. I've dropped my landline phone and I rely solely on my wireless phone. It is absolutely imperative that I have reliable wireless coverage to stay connected, particularly in an emergency. Wireless phones have become vital personal and public safety tools in Milton. Please make certain that citizens continue to have the best coverage possible throughout our community. I use my wireless phone to stay connected with work, family and friends. Having reliable coverage is important to me. Reliable wireless coverage at home and in my neighborhood is essential for me. wireless phones are no longer a luxury, they are a necessity. Sincerely, Ioan Turc Mailing Address: Ioan Turc 13561 Weycroft Circle Milton,GA 30004 I Roba`Donald wrr� w � i From: Cindy Carter (ccarte r611@a aol.com] Sent: Wednesday, January 20, 2010 1:18 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: Please approve the cell site locations for T -Mobile which is desperately needed! Thank you! C. Carter Homeowner City of Milton Sincerely, Cindy Carter Mailing Address: Cindy Carter 611 Sandringham Dr Milton,GA 30004 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Joy Uoy.albert@gmail.com] Sent: Thursday, March 11, 2010 4:17 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. All three sites will improve wireless coverage in Milton, especially in areas where I need it most - at home and in my neighborhood. Wireless phones have become vital personal and public safety tools in Milton. Please make certain that citizens continue to have the best coverage possible throughout our community. I've dropped my landline phone and I rely solely on my wireless phone. It is absolutely imperative that I have reliable wireless coverage to stay connected, particularly in an emergency. Reliable wireless coverage at home and in my neighborhood is essential for me. Wireless phones are no longer a luxury, they are a necessity. Sincerely, Joy Mailing Address: ]oy Tang 10090 ]ones Bridge Rd Unit 12 alpharetta,GA 30022 Robyn MacDonald From: Tom Oliff [tomo2006@belIsouth.net] Sent: Thursday, March 11, 2010 5:18 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. All three sites will improve wireless coverage in Milton, especially in areas where I need it most - at home and in my neighborhood. Wireless phones have become vital personal and public safety tools in Milton. Please make certain that citizens continue to have the best coverage possible throughout our community. Sincerely, Tom Oliff Mailing Address: Thomas Oliff 14750 Wood Rd milton,GA 30004 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Alicia Griffin [alicia.griffin a@t-mobile.coml Sent: Thursday, March 11, 2010 5:19 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. I've dropped my landline phone and I rely solely on my wireless phone. It is absolutely imperative that I have reliable wireless coverage to stay connected, particularly in an emergency. Wireless phones have become vital personal and public safety tools in Milton. Please make certain that citizens continue to have the best coverage possible throughout our community. Sincerely, Alicia Griffin Mailing Address: Alicia Griffin 7391 North Point Parkway Alpahretta,GA 30022 I Robyn MacDonald From: Laryn Alfred [lalfred@comcast.net] Sent: Thursday, March 11, 2010 5:47 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications ❑ear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. Wireless phones have become vital personal and public safety tools in Milton. Please make certain that citizens continue to have the best coverage possible throughout our community. My wireless phone has become a necessity. I use it to check in with my children wherever they are in our community. More importantly, I want my children to always be able to reach me or a 9-1-1 operator in an emergency. Sincerely, Laryn Alfred Mailing Address: Laryn Alfred 40 Arabian Ave. Milton,GA 30094 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Don Hogan [me@dhogan.name] Sent: Monday, March 08, 2010 2:32 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. All three sites will improve wireless coverage in Milton, especially in areas where I need it most - at home and in my neighborhood. Reliable wireless coverage at home and in ray neighborhood is essential for me. Wireless phones are no longer a luxury, they are a necessity. Sincerely, Don Hogan Mailing Address: Donald Hogan 3284 Kentworth Lane Milton,GA 30004 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Mary Michels [no3puttca@yahoo.com] Sent: Wednesday, March 10, 2010 510 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. I am tired of having to turn my cell phone off the minute I enter my home. The only reason I still have a landline is because of the lack of current service I have. Wireless phones have become vital personal and public safety tools in Milton. Please make certain that citizens continue to have the best coverage possible throughout our community. Sincerely, Mary Michels Mailing Address: Mary Michels 513 Northumberland Street Milton,GA 30004 1 Robyn MacDonald From: LynnAnn Agnew [Iynnann@gmail.corn] Sent: Wednesday, March 10, 2010 3:48 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: All three sites will improve wireless coverage in Milton, especially in areas where I need it most - at home and in my neighborhood. Sincerely, LynnAnn Agnew Mailing Address: LynnAnn Agnew 330 Marshalls Cove Milton,GA 30004 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Adam Agnew [adam.agnew@capgemini.com] Sent: Wednesday, March 10, 2010 3:47 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: Wireless phones have become vital personal and public safety tools in Milton. Please make certain that citizens continue to have the best coverage possible throughout our community. Sincerely, Adam Agnew Mailing Address: Adam Agnew 330 Marshalls Cove Milton,GA 30004 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Judy Whalen Dudyaw2@gmail.com] Sent: Wednesday, March 10, 2010 1:47 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. All three sites will improve wireless coverage in Milton, especially in areas where I need it most -- at home and in my neighborhood. I use my wireless phone to stay connected with work, family and friends. Having reliable coverage is important to me. Reliable wireless coverage at home and in my neighborhood is essential for me. Wireless phones are no longer a luxury, they are a necessity. Sincerely, 7udy Whalen Mailing Address: Judy Whalen 2495 Hopewell Plantation Dr Alpharetta,GA 30004 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Parul Sharma [ram.sharma77 a@gmail.com] Sent: Wednesday, March 10, 2010 5:35 PM To: Robyn Macdonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: Dear Respected Local Official, I am buying house in City of Milton on Crabapple Road under new subdivision named as Crabapple Crossroads. One of the hindering factor is that I could not make and receive calls in and around this subdivision as this is a newly developed subdivision. This is very close to on of the 3 sites proposed by T -Mobile. These 3 sites will enhance my confidence about my kids going to schools, while I go to Pediatrics when my kids get cold or other, when we go to shopping center (Kroger on Arnold Mill and Crabapple), when I go to play Golf on Atlanta National Golf on New Providence Road. I not only hope but confident that we all have similar concerns for our work and family, irrespective of whatever Carrier/Mobile Operator we use. I want to talk, check e-mail or get online with my wireless device from wherever I am, particularly at home. Having poor coverage in a place like Milton is simply unacceptable. In order to have reliable coverage, we need the necessary infrastructure to provide it. I've dropped my landline phone and I rely solely on my wireless phone. It is absolutely imperative that I have reliable wireless coverage to stay connected, particularly in an emergency. Reliable wireless coverage at home and in my neighborhood is essential for me. Wireless phones are no longer a luxury, they are a necessity. Sincerely, Parul Sharma Bailing Address: Parul Sharma 1728 Hemingwway Lane Alpharetta,GA 30075 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Erica [ericadorris@gmail.com] Sent: Monday, March 08, 2010 2.05 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: My phone doesn't work from Wal-Mart all the over to Zagby's. I have roadside assistant and if something were to ever happen between the 2 locations, i will be medded up. T -Mobile is the cheapest National Provider out there right now. And with these hard times we are facing these days, I need all the help I can get. SO that's why I decided to go with T -Mobile blc of the price. I am an AT&T emplyee and it is cheaper for me to go to T -Mobile even with my companies discounts. That's how important the savings are to me. And now I can't get 1005 of service because of this tower issue. I just want my phone to work. Sincerely, Erica Mailing Address: erica Dorris 5006 Lake Union Hill Road Alpharetta,GA 30004 Robyn MacDonald From: Shirley A. Slaughter [shirleyann012000@yahoo.com] Sent: Monday, March 08, 2010 2:47 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. All three sites will improve wireless coverage in Milton, especially in areas where I need it most - at home and in my neighborhood. I want to talk, check e-mail or get online with my wireless device from wherever I am, particularly at home. Having poor coverage in a place like Milton is simply unacceptable. In order to have reliable coverage, we need the necessary infrastructure to provide it. Wireless phones have become vital personal and public safety tools in Milton. Please make certain that citizens continue to have the best coverage possible throughout our community. I use my wireless phone to stay connected with work, family and friends. Having reliable coverage is important to me. I use my wireless phone to stay connected with work, family and friends. Having reliable coverage is important to me. Reliable wireless coverage at home and in my neighborhood is essential for me. Wireless phones are no longer a luxury, they are a necessity. Sincerely, Shirley A. Slaughter Mailing Address: Shirley Slaughter 1473 Mayfield Road Alpharetta,GA 30009 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Maria -Luisa Beatriz Halbert [emma_bachi@yahoo.comj Sent: Monday, March 08, 2010 5:03 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject. Approve T -Mobile Applications ❑ear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. All three sites will improve wireless coverage in Milton, especially in areas where I need it most - at home and in my neighborhood. I want to talk, check e-mail or get online with my wireless device from wherever I am, particularly at home. Having poor coverage in a place like Milton is simply unacceptable. In order to have reliable coverage, we need the necessary infrastructure to provide it. I've dropped my landline phone and I rely solely on my wireless phone. It is absolutely imperative that I have reliable wireless coverage to stay connected, particularly in an emergency. I use my wireless phone to stay connected with work, family and friends. Having reliable coverage is important to me. Reliable wireless coverage at home and in my neighborhood is essential for me. Wireless phones are no longer a luxury, they are a necessity. I am a pet -sitter and am constantly driving down the back roads of Milton and am constantly losing service or not having service at all which is very frustrating. The new towers are located not only on the road i live on but on the back roads that I work on Wireless phones have become vital personal and public safety tools in Milton. Please make certain that citizens continue to have the best coverage possible throughout our community. Sincerely, Maria -Luisa Beatriz Halbert Mailing Address: Maria -Luisa Halbert 16675 Hopewell RD Alpharetta,GA 30004 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Sent: To: Subject: Dear Sir/Madame: Julie Burns gulieb_1961@yahoo.corn] Wednesday, March 10; 2010 1:00 PM Robyn MacDonald Approve T -Mobile Applications I want to talk, check e-mail or get online with my wireless device from wherever I am, particularly at home. Having poor coverage in a place like Milton is simply unacceptable. In order to have reliable Coverage, we need the necessary infrastructure to provide it. I've dropped my landline phone and I rely solely on my wireless phone. It is absolutely imperative that I have reliable wireless coverage to stay connected, particularly in an emergency. Sincerely, 3ulie Burns Mailing Address: 7ulie Burns 123 North Park Lane Alpharetta,GA 30004 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Jay Call ins UaycI bird@gmai1.corn] Sent: Wednesday, March 10, 2010 1:10 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. All three sites will improve wireless coverage in Milton, especially in areas where I need it most - at home and in my neighborhood. I've dropped my landline phone and I rely solely on my wireless phone. It is absolutely imperative that I have reliable wireless coverage to stay connected, particularly in an emergency. Sincerely, Jay Collins Mailing Address: Jay Collins 16058 Inverness Trail Milton,GA 30004 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Toni Santos [chatwmstoni@gmail.com] Sent: Wednesday, March 10, 2010 1:46 PM To: Robyn Macdonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I am a home owner, tax payer and registered voter in Alpharetta. I am also a TMobile customer. The addiion cellsites provides better service for those of us that live up here. These sites I am sure can be utilitzed in some way to support our state and county services. I don't know the infrastructure of our emergency services but potentially we will need more access to more of these technologies. I'm sure the government has all the legal support to make sure they make the most of this situation. Please support the cell site builds. Reliable wireless coverage at home and in my neighborhood is essential for me. Wireless phones are no longer a luxury, they are a necessity. Sincerely, Toni Santos Mailing Address: Toni Santos 2180 Brookridge Terrace Alpharetta,GA 30004 Robyn MacDonald From: Laryn Alfred flalfred@comcast.net] Sent: Thursday, March 11, 2010 5:47 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. Wireless phones have become vital personal and public safety tools in Milton. Please make certain that citizens continue to have the best coverage possible throughout our community. My wireless phone has become a necessity. I use it to check in with my children wherever they are in our community. More importantly, I want my children to always be able to reach me or a 9-1-1 operator in an emergency. Sincerely, Laryn Alfred Mailing Address: Laryn Alfred 40 Arabian Ave. Milton,GA 30004 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Alicia Griffin [alicia.grifFin&-mobile.com] Sent: Thursday, March 11, 2010 5:19 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. I've dropped my landline phone and I rely solely on my wireless phone. It is absolutely imperative that I have reliable wireless coverage to stay connected, particularly in an emergency. Wireless phones have become vital personal and public safety tools in Milton. Please make certain that citizens continue to have the best coverage possible throughout our community. Sincerely, Alicia Griffin Mailing Address: Alicia Griffin 7393 North Point Parkway Alpahretta,GA 30022 1 Robyn MacDonald -PI - - IA IPI PIIII From: Tom ❑lift [tomo2006[7a bellsouth.net] Sent: Thursday, March 11, 2016 5:18 PM To: Robyn Macdonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. All three sites will improve wireless coverage in Milton, especially in areas where I need it most - at home and in my neighborhood. Wireless phones have become vital personal and public safety tools in Milton. Please make certain that citizens continue to have the best coverage possible throughout our community. Sincerely, Tom Qliff Mailing Address: Thomas Qliff 14750 Wood Rd milton,GA 30004 ]. Robyn MacDonald From: Joy Uoy.albert@gmail.com] Sent: Thursday, March 11, 2010 4:17 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear SirMadame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. All three sites will improve wireless coverage in Milton, especially in areas where I need it most - at home and in my neighborhood. Wireless phones have become vital personal and public safety tools in Milton. Please make certain that citizens continue to have the best coverage possible throughout our community. I've dropped my landline phone and I rely solely on my wireless phone. It is absolutely imperative that I have reliable wireless coverage to stay connected, particularly in an emergency. Reliable wireless coverage at home and in my neighborhood is essential for me. Wireless phones are no longer a luxury, they are a necessity. Sincerely, aoy Mailing Address: Toy rang 10050 hones Bridge Rd Unit 12 alpharetta,GA 30022 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Parul Sharma [ram.sharma77 a@gmail.com] Sent: Wednesday, March 10, 2010 5:35 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: Dear Respected Local Official, I am buying house in City of Milton on Crabapple Road under new subdivision named as Crabapple Crossroads. One of the hindering factor is that I could not make and receive calls in and around this subdivision as this is a newly developed subdivision. This is very close to on of the 3 sites proposed by T -Mobile. These 3 sites will enhance my confidence about my kids going to schools, while I go to Pediatrics when my kids get cold or other, when we go to shopping center (Kroger on Arnold Mill and Crabapple), when I go to play Golf on Atlanta National Golf on New Providence Road. I not only hope but confident that we all have similar concerns for our work and family, irrespective of whatever Carrier/Mobile Operator we use. I want to talk, check e-mail or get online with my wireless device from wherever I am, particularly at home. Having poor coverage in a place like Milton is simply unacceptable. In order to have reliable coverage, we need the necessary infrastructure to provide it. I've dropped my landline phone and I rely solely on my wireless phone. It is absolutely imperative that I have reliable wireless coverage to stay connected, particularly in an emergency. Reliable wireless coverage at home and in my neighborhood is essential for me. Wireless phones are no longer a luxury, they are a necessity. Sincerely, Parul Sharma Mailing Address: Parul Sharma 1728 Hemingwway Lane Alpharetta,GA 30075 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Mary Michels [no3puttca@yahoo.com] Sent: Wednesday, March 10. 2010 5:10 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. I am tired of having to turn my Cell phone off the minute I enter my home. The only reason I still have a landline is because of the lack of current service I have. Wireless phones have become vital personal and public safety tools in Milton. Please make certain that Citizens continue to have the best coverage possible throughout our community. Sincerely, Mary Michels Mailing Address: Mary Michels 513 Northumberland Street Milton,GA 38884 1 Robyn MacDonald From: LynnAnn Agnew [lynnann@gmail.com] Sent: Wednesday, March 10, 2010 3:48 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: All three sites will improve wireless coverage in Milton, especially in areas where I need it most - at home and in my neighborhood. Sincerely, LynnAnn Agnew Mailing Address: LynnAnn Agnew 330 Marshalls Cove Milton,GA 30004 I Robyn MacDonald From: Adam Agnew [adam.agnew@capgemini.com] Sent: VVednesday, March 10, 2010 3:47 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: Wireless phones have become vital personal and public safety tools in Milton. Please make certain that citizens continue to have the best coverage possible throughout our community. Sincerely, Adam Agnew Mailing Address: Adam Agnew 339 Marshalls Cove Milton,GA 30004 Robyn MacDonald From: Judy Whalen Hudyaw2@gmail.com] Sent: Wednesday, March 10, 2010 1:47 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T --Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. All three sites will improve wireless coverage in Milton, especially in areas where I need it most - at home and in my neighborhood. I use my wireless phone to stay connected with work, family and friends. Having reliable coverage is important to me. Reliable wireless coverage at home and in my neighborhood is essential for me. Wireless phones are no longer a luxury, they are a necessity. Sincerely, ]udy Whalen Mailing Address: Judy Whalen 2495 Hopewell Plantation Dr Alpharetta,GA 30004 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Toni Santos [chatwmstoni(a gmail.com] Sent: Wednesday, March 10, 2010 1:46 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I am a home owner, tax payer and registered voter in Alpharetta. I am also a TMobile customer. The addiion cellsites provides better service for those of us that live up here. These sites I am sure can be utilitzed in some way to support our state and county services. I don't know the infrastructure of our emergency services but potentially we will need more access to more of these technologies. I'm sure the government has all the legal support to make sure they make the most of this situation. Please support the cell site builds. Reliable wireless coverage at home and in my neighborhood is essential for me. Wireless phones are no longer a luxury, they are a necessity. Sincerely, Toni Santos Mailing Address: Toni Santos 2180 erookridge Terrace Alpharetta,GA 30004 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Jay Collins bayc1bird @gmai 1.corn] Sent: Wednesday, March 10, 2010 1:10 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. All three sites will improve wireless coverage in Milton, especially in areas where I need it most - at home and in my neighborhood. I've dropped my landline phone and I rely solely on my wireless phone. It is absolutely imperative that I have reliable wireless coverage to stay connected, particularly in an emergency. Sincerely, Jay Collins Mailing Address: Jay Collins 7.5058 Inverness Trail Milton,GA 30004 I Robyn MacDonald From: Sent: To: Subject: Dear Sir/Madame: Julie Burns Julieb_1961@yahoo.corn] Wednesday, March 10, 2010 1:00 PM Robyn MacDonald Approve T -Mobile Applications I want to talk, check e-mail or get online with my wireless device from wherever I am, particularly at home. Having poor coverage in a place like Milton is simply unacceptable. In order to have reliable Coverage, we need the necessary infrastructure to provide it. I've dropped my landline phone and I rely solely on my wireless phone. It is absolutely imperative that I have reliable wireless coverage to stay connected, particularly in an emergency. Sincerely, 7ulie Burns Mailing Address: Julie Burns 123 North Park Lane Alpharetta,GA 30004 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Maria -Luisa Beatriz Halbert [emma_bachi@yahoo.com] Sent: Monday, March 08, 2010 5:03 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. All three sites will improve wireless coverage in Milton, especially in areas where I need it most - at home and in my neighborhood. I want to talk, check e-mail or get online with my wireless device from wherever I am, particularly at home. Having poor coverage in a place like Milton is simply unacceptable. In order to have reliable coverage, we need the necessary infrastructure to provide it. I've dropped my landline phone and I rely solely on my wireless phone. It is absolutely imperative that I have reliable wireless coverage to stay connected, particularly in an emergency. I use my wireless phone to stay connected with work, family and friends. Having reliable coverage is important to me. Reliable wireless coverage at home and in my neighborhood is essential for me. Wireless phones are no longer a luxury, they are a necessity. I am a pet -sitter and am constantly driving down the back roads of Milton and am constantly losing service or not having service at all which is very frustrating. The new towers are located not only on the road i live on but on the back roads that I work on Wireless phones have become vital personal and public safety tools in Milton. Please make certain that citizens continue to have the best coverage possible throughout our community. Sincerely, Maria -Luisa Beatriz Halbert Mailing Address: Maria -Luisa Halbert 16675 Hopewell RD Alpharetta,GA 30004 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Don Hogan [me@dhogan.name] Sent: Monday, March 08, 2010 2:32 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. All three sites will improve wireless coverage in Milton, especially in areas where I need it most - at home and in my neighborhood. Reliable wireless coverage at home and in my neighborhood is essential for me. Wireless phones are no longer a luxury, they are a necessity. Sincerely, Don Hogan Mailing Address: Donald Hogan 3284 Kentworth Lane Milton,GA 30004 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Shirley A. Slaughter [shirleyann012000@yahoo.com] Sent: Monday, March 08, 2010 2:07 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. All three sites will improve wireless coverage in Milton, especially in areas where I need it most - at home and in my neighborhood. I want to talk, check e-mail or get online with my wireless device from wherever I am, particularly at home. Having poor coverage in a place like Milton is simply unacceptable. In order to have reliable coverage, we need the necessary infrastructure to provide it. Wireless phones have become vital personal and public safety tools in Milton. Please make certain that citizens continue to have the best coverage possible throughout our community. I use my wireless phone to stay connected with work, family and friends. Having reliable coverage is important to me. I use my wireless phone to stay connected with work, family and friends. Having reliable coverage is important to me. Reliable wireless coverage at home and in my neighborhood is essential for me. Wireless phones are no longer a luxury, they are a necessity. Sincerely, Shirley A. Slaughter Mailing Address: Shirley Slaughter 1473 Mayfield Road Alpharetta,GA 30009 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Erica [ericadorris@gmail.com] Sent: Monday, March 08, 2010 2:05 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: My phone doesn't work from Wal-Mart all the over to Zagby's. I have roadside assistant and if something were to ever happen between the 2 locations, i will be melded up. T -Mobile is the cheapest National Provider out there right now. And with these hard times we are facing these days, I need all the help I can get. 50 that's why I decided to go with T -Mobile b/c of the price. I am an AT&T emplyee and it is cheaper for me to go to T -Mobile even with my companies discounts. That's how important the savings are to me. And now I can't get 100% of service because of this tower issue. I just want my phone to work. Sincerely, Erica Mailing Address: erica Dorris 5006 Lake Union Hill Road Alpharetta,GA 30004 Robyn MacDonald From: venkataraju thimaiah [shyamusa@aol.com] Sent: Friday, March 19, 2919 1:55 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: please kindly approve the t -moble applications thanks venka thimaiah Sincerely, venkataraju thimaiah Mailing Address: venkataraju thimaiah 455 waterhaven lane alpharetta,GA 30004 Robyn MacDonald From: Edward Chase [kamauski@gmail.com] Sent: Friday, March 19, 2010 1.54 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. I am unable to attend the Planning Commission Hearing on January 25. However, please accept this e-mail as a show of support for these site applications. I've dropped my landline phone and I rely solely on my wireless phone. It is absolutely imperative that I have reliable wireless coverage to stay connected, particularly in an emergency. Sincerely, Edward Chase Mailing Address: Edward Chase 524 Sandringham Drive Milton,GA 30004 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Doug and Tiffany Ray [Tifforay@aol.com] Sent: Friday, March 19, 2010 1:53 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: My wireless phone has become a necessity. Z use it to check in with my children wherever they are in our community. More importantly, I want my children to always be able to reach me or a 9-1-1 operator in an emergency. Sincerely, Doug and Tiffany Ray Mailing Address: Doug Ray 2685 Highland pass Alpharetta ,GA 30004 I Robyn MacDonald From: Dennis Fulton [dennis.fulton@crowncastle.com] Sent: Friday, March 19, 2010 1:43 PM To: Robyn Macdonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. Sincerely, Dennis Fulton Mailing Address: Dennis Fulton 12725 Morris Road extension Alphereta,GA 30004 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Saad Mandi [smimo@hotmail.com] Sent: Friday, March 19, 2010 1:32 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: Wireless phones have become vital personal and public safety tools in Milton. Please make certain that Citizens continue to have the best coverage possible throughout our community. Sincerely, Saad Mandi Mailing Address: Saad Mandi 1409 Treeridge Pkwy Alpharetta,GA 30022 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Linda K_ Elliott [maggiezone@comcast.net] Sent: Friday, March 19, 2010 1:26 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. Wireless phones have become vital personal and public safety tools in Milton. Please make certain that citizens continue to have the best coverage possible throughout our community. I am unable to attend the Planning Commission Hearing on Danuary 26. However, please accept this e-mail as a show of support for these site applications. Sincerely, Linda K. Elliott Mailing Address: Linda Elliott 318 Karen Dr. Alpharetta,GA 30009 1 Robyn acDonald From: joe pfaff Uoepfaff@hotnnail,com] Sent: Friday, March 19, 2010 1:16 PM To: Robyn Macdonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: All three sites will improve wireless coverage in Milton, especially in areas where I need it most - at home and in my neighborhood. Sincerely, joe Pfaff Mailing Address: joe Pfaff 105 quay cir. alpharetta,GA 30009 Robyn MacDonald ■ � - �rr�w-w�rw From: eliane pacheco [epacheco02@grnaiLcom] Sent: Friday, March 19, 2010 1:02 PM To: Robyn Macdonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: All three sites will improve wireless coverage in Milton, especially in areas where I need it most - at home and in my neighborhood I am unable to attend the Planning Commission Hearing on January 26. However, please accept this e-mail as a show of support for these site applications. I am unable to attend the Planning Commission Hearing on January 26. However, please accept this e-mail as a show of support for these site applications.l am unable to attend the Planning Commission Hearing on 7anuary 26. However, please accept this e-mail as a show of support for these site applications_ Sincerely, eliane pacheco Mailing Address: Eliane Pacheco 702 Northpark lane Alpharetta,GA 30004 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Greg [grsears@grnail.com] Sent: Friday, March 19, 2010 1:01 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I greatly support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. T -Mobile is a very Customer friendly Company ( vs The Dinosaurs ) and Happy customers are happy voters : ) Thanks, Greg Sincerely, Greg Mailing Address: Greg Sears 457 Windstone Trail Alpharetta,GA 30004 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Dana Luck [datz rnr.luck a@hotrnai1,conn] Sent: Friday, March 19, 2010 1:01 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I feel it would be a great benefit to those of us in the Milton area with T -Mobile service if you would allow these towers. I, as many of us, use my cell phone when at home and sometimes lose signal when otherwise I have awesome service! I sometimes do have to avoid Bethany Bend due to a couple of dead zones along that route between McGinnis Ferry and Highway 9. I will not be able to attend the meeting because of work and ask you to accept this email as a show of support for this proposal!, All three sites will improve wireless coverage in Milton, especially in areas where I need it most - at home and in my neighborhood. I want to talk, check e-mail or get online with my wireless device from wherever I am, particularly at home. Having poor coverage in a place like Milton is simply unacceptable. In order to have reliable coverage, we need the necessary infrastructure to provide it. Wireless phones have become vital personal and public safety tools in Milton. Please make certain that Citizens continue to have the best coverage possible throughout our community. I use my wireless phone to stay connected with work, family and friends. Having reliable coverage is important to me. Reliable wireless coverage at home and in my neighborhood is essential for me. Wireless phones are no longer a luxury, they are a necessity. Sincerely, Dana Luck Mailing Address: Dana Luck 822 Deerfield Point Milton,GA 30004 1 Robyn Macdonald From: Eran Fainshtad [eranfain c@yahoo.ccrn] Sent: Tuesday, March 16, 2010 10:14 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. All three sites will improve wireless coverage in Milton, especially in areas where I need it most - at home and in my neighborhood. I want to talk, check e-mail or get online with my wireless device from wherever I am, particularly at home. Having poor coverage in a place like Milton is simply unacceptable. In order to have reliable coverage, we need the necessary infrastructure to provide it. My wireless phone has become a necessity. I use it to check in with my children wherever they are in our community. More importantly, I want my children to always be able to reach me or a 9-1-1 operator in an emergency. I use my wireless phone to stay connected with work, family and friends. Having reliable coverage is important to me. Sincerely, Eran Fainshtad Mailing Address: Eran Fainshtad 3124 Commonwealth Milton,GA 30004 1 Robyn MacDonald From: sarah shafor [s_shafor@yahoo.com] Sent: Tuesday, March 16, 2010 10:13 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. All three sites will improve wireless coverage in Milton, especially in areas where I need it most - at home and in my neighborhood. I want to talk, check e-mail or get online with my wireless device from wherever I am, particularly at home. Having poor coverage in a place like Milton is simply unacceptable. In order to have reliable coverage, we need the necessary infrastructure to provide it. I've dropped my landline phone and I rely solely on my wireless phone. It is absolutely imperative that I have reliable wireless coverage to stay connected, particularly in an emergency. Wireless phones have become vital personal and public safety tools in Milton. Please make certain that citizens continue to have the best coverage possible throughout our community. My wireless phone has become a necessity. I use it to check in with my children wherever they are in our community. More importantly, I want my children to always be able to reach me or a 9-1-1 operator in an emergency. I use my wireless phone to stay connected with work, family and friends. Having reliable coverage is important to me. Reliable wireless coverage at home and in my neighborhood is essential for me. Wireless phones are no longer a luxury, they are a necessity. I am unable to attend the Planning Commission Hearing on January 26. However, please accept this e-mail as a show of support for these site applications. Sincerely, sarah shafor Mailing Address: sarah shafor 1465 mayfield rd alpharetta,GA 30009 I Robyn MacDonald From: Steven Spalding [spaIdingsm@yahoo.corn] Sent: Tuesday, March 16, 2010 6155 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I agree with the proposals presented by TMobile. I receive horrible service in this area, especially my house, and feel that we need additional coverage. Sincerely, Steven Spalding Mailing Address: steven spalding 13085 morris road #7002 alpharetta,GA 300e4 Robyn MacDonald From: Daniel Harry [dr_harry@comcast.net] Sent: Tuesday, March 16, 2010 5:52 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. I've dropped my landline phone and I rely solely on my wireless phone. It is absolutely imperative that I have reliable wireless coverage to stay connected, particularly in an emergency. Wireless phones have become vital personal and public safety tools in Milton. Please make certain that citizens continue to have the best coverage possible throughout our community. Thank -you. Sincerely, Daniel Harry Mailing Address: Daniel Harry 112 Laurel Ridge Drive Alpharetta,GA 30004 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Glenda (martstha@yahoo.com) Sent: Tuesday, March 16, 2010 5:47 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. I want to talk, check e-mail or get online with my wireless device from wherever I am, particularly at home. Having poor coverage in a place like Milton is simply unacceptable. In order to have reliable coverage, we need the necessary infrastructure to provide it. Wireless phones have become vital personal and public safety tools in Milton. Please make certain that citizens continue to have the best coverage possible throughout our community. My wireless phone has become a necessity. I use it to check in with my children wherever they are in our community. More importantly, I want my children to always be able -to reach me or a 9-1-1 operator in an emergency. Reliable wireless coverage at home and in my neighborhood is essential for me. Wireless phones are no longer a luxury, they are a necessity. Reliable wireless coverage at home and in my neighborhood is essential for me. Wireless phones are no longer a luxury, they are a necessity. I am unable to attend the Planning Commission Hearing on January 26. However, please accept this e-mail as a show of support for these site applications. Sincerely, Glenda Mailing Address: Glenda M PQ Box 723 Alpharetta,GA 30007 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Rohan Patil [maverickrohan@yahoo.co.in] Sent: Tuesday, March 16, 2014 5:46 PM To: Robyn Macdonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications ❑ear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. All three sites will improve wireless coverage in Milton, especially in areas where I need it most - at home and in my neighborhood. I want to talk, check e-mail or get online with my wireless device from wherever I am, particularly at home. Having poor coverage in a place like Milton is simply unacceptable. In order to have reliable coverage, we need the necessary infrastructure to provide it. I've dropped my landline phone and I rely solely on my wireless phone. It is absolutely imperative that I have reliable wireless coverage to stay connected, particularly in an emergency. Wireless phones have become vital personal and public safety tools in Milton. Please make certain that citizens continue to have the best coverage possible throughout our community. My wireless phone has become a necessity. I Use it to check in with my children wherever they are in our community. More importantly, I want my children to always be able to reach me or a 9-1-1 operator in an emergency. I use my wireless phone to stay connected with work, family and friends. Having reliable coverage is important to me. Reliable wireless coverage at home and in my neighborhood is essential for me. Wireless phones are no longer a luxury, they are a necessity. I am unable to attend the Planning Commission Hearing on January 26. However, please accept this e-mail as a show of support for these site applications. Sincerely, Rohan Patil Mailing Address: Rohan Patil 31003 Deer Trail Milton,GA 30004 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Ravi Prakash [rp_bowling@hotmail.comj Sent: Tuesday, March 16, 2010 5:45 PM To: Robyn Macdonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: Dear Milton City Council, I am a resident of Milton since Dec 2005 and live right across from your office. In all these years we have had T -Mobile and we have almsot no coverage inside our home or in the entire subdivision. Please this is not a luxary these days, it is a bare necessity. I am unable to attend the Planning Commission Hearing on January 26. However, please accept this e-mail as a snow of support for these site applications. Kindly look into this matter and I thank you in advance for your time and consideration. Sincerely, Ravi Prakash Mailing Address: Ravi Prakash 12877 Deer Park Lane Alpharetta,GA 30004 1 Zoning may regulate building height, lot coverage, and similar characteristics, or some combination of these. Zoning is used to prevent new development from interfering with existing residents or businesses and to preserve the "character" of a community. 10th Ammendment "The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people. " The rights granted to the wireless companies by the TCA of 1996 were not granled to it by the constitution and the local governments did not give up those rights. In my research on cell towers I have found {3) important articles in which I feel should be read by the Mayor, all council members, City Manager and City Attorney. These articles have some very interesting information which should help in the decision that this City of Milton needs to make. Mobile Impact: Stop Cell Towers and Antennas in Residential Neighborhoods www.brandonfarmswatertower.com Operation Cell -Out www.cell-out.org Lawyers Weekly USA htt p:llwww.fe b. se/emfpu ru/Law/town-re iect. htm] The wireless folks give the impression that they have the right to place an antenna anywhere they want. This is not true. While the Telecommunications Act of 1996 gave them some power over local governments to provide service to areas, it did not give there the right to place antennas wherever they want. It is our community and it should not be needlessly destroyed. Sometimes, zoning regulations sidestep the issue by specifying that they are not taking health into consideration— the purpose of zoning regulations in most state statutes is to protect the health, safety, well-being, and property values of a community. Tower Company - Tower companies get money from leasing towers. The more towers, the more money they make. It is to their advantage to find locations that will require more towers, not less. Since tower companies do not have any rights granted by the FCC like a wireless company does, they often strike a deal with a wireless company to push the permit through. Trash the Neighborhood o Once a tower of any height is installed, it is much easier to ask for a taller tower later. The argument that "it is either add another tower to the area or raise the height of this existing one". o Once a tower is placed in one part of a neighborhood, the compatibility argument is lessened. It is much harder to say you don't want a tower in a new location when there is one right next door. Industry representatives also point out that the RF emissions of cellular towers are far below the federal standards, which they often are. They liken the power output of the technology to 100- and even 25 - watt light bulbs, hoping to assuage people's fears with familiar comparisons. What they leave out is that 100 watts is the power output per channel, and one antenna may host dozens of channels. As user demand increases, channels can be split. Plus, unlike 60 -hertz light bulbs, these installations function in the microwave, UHF bands, where questions about safety go back to the 1940s and remain unanswered today. As cell technology emerged, in 1984, cell phones (and their transmissions) were specifically exempted from pre -market health testing, in a proviso called the low power exclusion. Insurance companies, from 2004 to 2005, have refused to insure the cell phone industry against health damage claims. Many people worldwide are becoming sick from exposure to wireless technology radiations. On T-MobiI's literature "Cell Sites and Your Health" is a section for the "FCC regulates RF emissions." FCC regulates RF emissions to ensure public safety To ensure that routine exposure to cell sites is safe, the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) regulates the level of radio frequency that a site may emit. (T-MoIniI had this literature available at their rneeting with the citizens of the City of Milton.} However, can FCC website it states the FCC Does Not Monitor RF emissions. DOES THE FCC ROUTINELY MONITOR RADIOFREQUENCY RADIATION FROM ANTENNAS? The FCC does not have the resources or the personnel to routinely monitor the emissions for all of the thousands of transmitters that are subject to FCC jurisdiction. However, the FCC: does have measurement instrumentation for evaluating RF levels in areas that may be accessible to the public or to workers. If there is evidence of potential non-compliance with FCC exposure guidelines for an FCC -regulated facility, staff from the FCC's Office of Engineering and Technology or the Enforcement Bureau can conduct an investigation, and, if appropriate, perform actual measurements. It should be emphasized that the FCC does not perform RF exposure investigations unless there is a reasonable expectation that the FCC exposure limits may be exceeded. Potential exposure problems should be brought to the FCC's attention by contacting the FCC at: 1-888-225- 5322 or by e --mailing: rfsafetyL@fcc.goy www.fcc.ciov/oet/rfsafety/rf-fags.html Under Index look for: Does the FCC routinely monitor radiofrequency radiation from antennas? 5o, how will the City of Milton ensure citizens are not being overexposed to RF emissions? The purpose of zoning regulations in most state statutes is to protect the health, safety, well-being, and property values of a community. No Text Robyn MacDonald From: Leslie Wicks [lawicks@bellsouth.net] Sent: Monday, March 01, 2010 9:56 PM To: Joe Lockwood; Julie ZahnerBailey; Alan Sart; Bill Lusk; Burt Hewitt; Joe Longoria; Karen Thurman; Chris Lagerbloom Cc: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Info for Cell Tower- Mountain Road Attachments: CeIlTowers4mi.doc.docx To all City Council Members, Planning Commission Members, Mayor Joe Lockwood, City Attorney and the City Manager, There are already existing towers inclose proximity to 2880 Mountain Road. It seems there is nota need to clutter where we live, so a corporation can profit. Did you know: depending upon the height of the tower and the surrounding terrain, a wireless signal can be reliably received or transmitted over a distance of two to four miles(as a general rule) between the phone handset and the antenna. We already have cell towers in less than 2.5 miles from 2880 Mountain Road. 2121 Mountain Road (Fulton County, 1.46 miles), 7057 Holbrook Campground Road (Forsyth County, 2.27 miles) and 3240 Hopewell Road (Cherokee County, 2.1 miles). (The miles I have specified here are mapquested, not miles as the crows fly, which would be less than what is indicated. See attachment for towers in a 4 mile radius from 2880 mountain road. Registered and Unregistered towers, there are more towers within 2 rniles) In one city in North Carolina they will not allow towers any more than 2 miles apart and the state has passed a bill on Cell Tower Zoning. See NC Senate Bill 831, middle of page 3, http://www.carolinaswirelessassociation.com/news/pdfs/3951. 001.0fj. Up the fees on the permits (make them pay) and include a cost to the telecommunications company (not to the city or taxpayers) to require an RF Emissions testing either once or twice a year to monitor the emissions coming from the tower, every year, by an independent engineer of the city's choosing. Again, as part of the fees required at the telecommunications company's expense. (NYC is trying to pass new legislation). www_nvpost.com/p/news/local/brooklyn/item AoICT2RIPIt2ui4D4LToll Studies have been done in other countries documenting that living close to cell towers increase your risk for cancer. It is not right that towers be erected with RF Emissions and then are left unmonitored. Citizens of this City do not want these towers trashing where we live. We will not be compensated. Who are large I corporations to come in and degrade where we live and benefit making millions while ruining our property values and possibly our health? Our biggest investment in our lives is our homes. Due to the economy it is very hard to prove this will affect property values. No homes have sold in our neighborhood in more than 2 years. Homes around High Tension lines do have depreciation. Also, a safe distance is 1,500 feet. A cell tower gives off RF Emissions which are in the microwave and many of us will be less than 1000 feet from the tower. It does not take an appraiser to realize a loss in property value. Who wants to live near a tower, we will have no choice given to us. The members of the City Council and the Planning Commission needs to take the time if they already have not done so and go out and look to see exactly where these towers are going to be located, all need to understand by site how this will look, as well as how close to other homes towers will be. Cell towers should not be placed where residents live. The Federal government, not the FCC, not the wireless company will be responsible when the City says "yes" for a tower to go up. Any issues will then be the City's responsibility for allowing the tower to go up, as well as the Landowner for allowing it on their property. Emissions need to be monitored. Attached document gives cell tower information registered and unregistered in a 4 mile radius from 2880 Mountain Road. Please note the number of unregistered towers within 2 miles of address. Do we really need more? Thank you. Please do not allow T -Mobil to degrade our neighborhood. Leslie Wicks 2870 Mountain Road 770-521-9925 http://www.antennasearch.corn Registered (1) Mobilitie Investments li. Llc 199 feet 1.30 miles . (2) Crown Castle Pt, Inc. 215 feet 1.72 miles (3) Verizon Wireless [yaw] Llc 285 feet 2.47 miles (4) Sba Towers Inc 270 feet 3.39 miles (5) Sba Towers, Inc. 235 feet 3.67 miles (6) Verizon Wireless vaw Lie 299 feet 3.75 miles (7) Towerco Assets Llc 189 feet 3.95 miles Not Registered (1) T-mobile. Usa 160 feet .14 miles (2) Sawnee Electric Membership Corporation 183 feet .69 miles (3) Spectrasite Communications Inc 188 feet 1,57 miles (4) AW Mobility Llc--mc 185 feet 1.86 miles (5) Bellsouth Mobility Ll c 196 feet 2.04 miles (6) AM Mobility - Southeast Region 187 feet 2.09 miles (7) American Tower 199 feet 2.t8 miles (8) Intercel Powertel Inc 155 feet 2.20 miles (9) Bellsouth Mobility 218 feet 2.36 miles (10) Bellsouth Mobility 182 feet 2.40 miles (11) Spectrasite Communications, Inc 101 feet 2.65 miles (12) Towercom 195 feet 3.41 miles (13) Powertel Inc 195 feet 3.62 miles http://www.antennasearch.corn Robyn MacDonald From: Leslie Wicks [lawicks@bellsouth-net] Sent: Tuesday, January 19, 2010 4:14 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Excellent article on Cell Tower Liability Robyn, Please forward to the Planning Commission and City Attorney. Thanks. Leslie Wicks ---- Forwarded Message ---- From: Leslie Wicks < lawicks@ bellsouth. net> To: joe.lockwood@cityofmiltonga.us; Chris..Lagerbloom@cityofmiltonga.us; burt.hewitt@cityofmiltonga.us; bill.lusk@cityofmiltonga.us; alan.tart@coofmiltonga.us; karen.thurman@cityofmiltonga.us; julie.zahnerbailey@cityofmiltonga.us; joe.longoda@cityofmiltonga.us Cc: Robin.MacDonald@cityofmiltonga.us Sent: Mon, January 18, 2019 9:52:11 PM Subject: Excellent article on Cell Tower Liability To Mayor Joe Lockwood, Chris Lagerbloom, all City of Milton Council, and Planning Commission, Please forward to City Attorney. In the attached article excepted from Cell Towers, discusses: Independent tower companies are invariably set up as limited liability corporations (LLC). T -Mobil LLC. It is still your obligation to do everything possible to protect the health, safety and welfare of the community and its citizens. Towns can legally disallow towers built on speculation. The Telecom Act only preempts for providers of the service, not independent speculators. No town should allow itself to be intimidated by telecom service providers or adjunct industries like tower companies. There is a growing volume of good case law to back up local decisions. Please read this article on the below website, it is less than 3 pages. http://bethpa2eceiltower.com[Docu mentslLevitt%2OLiabi lity %20(1).pd Thank you for your time. Leslie Wicks 2870 Mountain Road Robyn MacDonald From: Andrew Shepard [ashepard@shepconsult.com] Sent: Wednesday, January 27, 2010 8:52 AM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: U09-03 Mountain Road Cell Tower Balloon Test Attachments: [MG_0027.JPG; IMG_0029.JPG; IMG_0048.JPG; IMG_0054.JPG Robin, Attached are a couple of photos from the balloon tests from last Saturday. As you can see the wind was not cooperating. The balloon man did make an effort and actually killed 2 balloons in the process. In both instances the winds pushed the balloons into the pine trees to the west where the balloons were ripped open. The conditions were so windy that the balloon man was unable to stand at the tower location and the entire time the balloons were angled to the northwest from his ground location. However we were able to get a few pictures that show how close the tower will be to our house and the impact a cell tower will have on our house. When looking at the shots from the front, keep in mind that the tower will rise higher and will stand a keit more to the right. The other shots are from our back deck and show how close the tower will be. Andrew Shepard, AIA I Principal Shepard Consulting Group, Inc. 815 Mimosa Boulevard I Suite C I Roswell I GA 30075 Office: 678-990-4986 lEmail:ashepard _.shepconsult.com The information in this message and attachments ("Message") may be confidential or otherwise protected by law. If you are not an intended recipient, please immediately notify the sender, delete all copies of the Message, and do not disclose or make improper use of it. Electronic messages are not secure or error free, may contain viruses and may be delayed or tampered with, and the sender is not liable for any such occurrences. The sender reserves the Tight to monitor, record and retain electronic messages. AW l No Text r. 4- Y�r _. ��_ Prepared by the Community Development Department for the Mayor and City Council on April 12, 2010 (First Presentation) 4/5/2010 Page 1 of 19 U09-04 PETITION NUMBER(S): U09-04 PROPERTY INFORMATION ADDRESS 14495 Hopewell Road DISTRICT, LAND LOT 2/2, 691, 692 OVERLAY DISTRICT Northwest EXISTING ZONING AG-1 (Agricultural) ACRES 26.4294 EXISTING USE Single family residence/horse farm PROPOSED USE 150 foot Monopole Cell Tower with a 4 ft. lightning rod for a total of 154 feet OWNER Ronald Bogino ADDRESS 14495 Hopewell Road Milton, GA 30004 PETITIONER/REPRESENTATIVE T-Mobile South, LLC/Shawn Blassingill ADDRESS 4 Concourse Parkway, Suite 300 Sandy Springs, GA 30328 PHONE 678-612-7489 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT RECOMMENDATION U09-04 – DENIAL INTENT To obtain a use permit for a 150 foot tall monopole cell tower with an additional 4 foot lightning rod for a total of 154 feet (Article 19.4.7). Prepared by the Community Development Department for the Mayor and City Council on April 12, 2010 (First Presentation) 4/5/2010 Page 2 of 19 U09-04 PLANNING COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION – MARCH 23, 2010 U09-04 – DENIAL 7-0 Mr. David R. Gilley of Georgia Tax and Regulatory Solutions, LLC presented his findings regarding U09-04. He concluded “that wireless coverage does not meet the level desired by the Applicant and there are areas with gaps in coverage. A review of the topography and natural vegetation of nearby properties indicates that there are properties that would provide better screening of the tower and therefore minimize its adverse aesthetic impact. Applicant’s own RF Engineer has already approved these sites as capable of providing the Applicant’s coverage needs. In addition, the alternate sites are located closer to the areas where the coverage gaps exist and would provide more consistent coverage at the desired coverage level. Accordingly, GTRS recommended that this Application be denied.” After hearing many public concerns including visibility from Hopewell Road and the tower extending 60 feet above tree line, not being visibly consistent with the agricultural character of the area, the fact that the FCC Act of 1996 only requires that cell service be available; not that every carrier is available, lack of need for the additional tower based on excellent cell service tested by the community, proposed cell tower will negatively impact values of residential properties, and T-Mobile has not demonstrated a significant gap in service. The owner of the subject property stated that rural character is not subdivision after subdivision and his certain property rights should be considered. Another nearby resident stated that if the application meets the standards of the use permit and it is denied, then they are denied their property rights. The Planning Commission discussion included the following issues: 1. The applicant will verify if sealed engineered drawings were submitted for U09-04. 2. The applicant verified that the property owner resides on the property. 3. The number of co-locaters that can be installed on this tower. 4. Questions regarding the appraisal performed by Greystone Valuation Services. Please note the following: • The applicant submitted a set of revised site plans/engineered drawings for U09-04 on March 30, 2010. It appears that the only revision made to the plans was the change from “preliminary, not for construction” to plans sealed by a registered engineer. • No further additional information submitted. • An additional Design Review Board (DRB) meeting will be held on April 6, 2010 to meet the zoning ordinance’s required advertising for the DRB. Prepared by the Community Development Department for the Mayor and City Council on April 12, 2010 (First Presentation) 4/5/2010 Page 3 of 19 U09-04 LOCATION MAP Prepared by the Community Development Department for the Mayor and City Council on April 12, 2010 (First Presentation) 4/5/2010 Page 4 of 19 U09-04 CURRENT ZONING MAP Prepared by the Community Development Department for the Mayor and City Council on April 12, 2010 (First Presentation) 4/5/2010 Page 5 of 19 U09-04 Prepared by the Community Development Department for the Mayor and City Council on April 12, 2010 (First Presentation) 4/5/2010 Page 6 of 19 U09-04 REVISED SITE PLAN SUBMITTED MARCH 30, 2010 Prepared by the Community Development Department for the Mayor and City Council on April 12, 2010 (First Presentation) 4/5/2010 Page 7 of 19 U09-04 Distances from property lines/structures Prepared by the Community Development Department for the Mayor and City Council on April 12, 2010 (First Presentation) 4/5/2010 Page 8 of 19 U09-04 SUBJECT SITE – Looking south into entrance from Hopewell SUBJECT SITE – Looking south toward cell tower location Prepared by the Community Development Department for the Mayor and City Council on April 12, 2010 (First Presentation) 4/5/2010 Page 9 of 19 U09-04 SUBJECT SITE – Approximate leased area PHOTO SIMULATION OF TOWER FROM HOPEWELL ROAD Prepared by the Community Development Department for the Mayor and City Council on April 12, 2010 (First Presentation) 4/5/2010 Page 10 of 19 U09-04 PHOTO SIMULATION OF TOWER FROM SADDLESPRINGS DRIVE LOOKING NORTH SUBJECT SITE: The subject site is a 26.4294 acre tract of agriculturally zoned land, located on the south side of Hopewell Road. The subject site is developed with a single- family residence and Seven Gables Horse Farm. It is located within the Agricultural, Forestry and Mining Land Use designation on the Focus Fulton 2025 Plan which was still in place at the time of this application’s submittal. Existing uses and zoning of nearby property The subject site is surrounded by lots on average ranging in size from one acre to approximately 15 acres. They are developed with single family residences within the AG-1 (Agricultural) district. Stratford Estates is located to north on the north side of Hopewell Road developed with single family residences zoned AG-1 (Agricultural). North Fields is located further north of Stratford Estates and developed with single family residences zoned AG-1 (Agricultural). Wyndam Farms is located further to the southeast and developed with single family Prepared by the Community Development Department for the Mayor and City Council on April 12, 2010 (First Presentation) 4/5/2010 Page 11 of 19 U09-04 residences zoned AG-1 (Agricultural). Sunnybrooke Farms is a large lot equestrian subdivision zoned AG-1 (Agricultural) located directly to the south of the subject site. Greystone Farms subdivision is zoned CUP (Community Unit Plan) with a minimum lot size of one acre with a minimum heated floor area of 4,000 square feet located north of the subject site. Staff notes that the Mayor and City Council denied a request for a Use Permit (U07-08/VC07-13) for a Landscaping Business located on Hopewell Road on December 13, 2007. A. Whether the proposed use is consistent with the Comprehensive Land Use Plan and/or Economic Development Revitalization plans adopted by the Mayor and City Council: Focus Fulton 2025 Plan Map: Agricultural, Forestry and Mining The proposed monopole cell tower is inconsistent with the intent and following policies of the Focus Fulton 2025 Comprehensive Plan (this plan was still in place at the time of the applicant filing this request): •••• Encourage development consistent with the surrounding scale, transition of densities and uses, and Comprehensive Plan policies, where appropriate. •••• Protect the existing rural character of Northwest Fulton. B. Compatibility with land uses and zoning districts in the vicinity of the property for which the use permit is proposed; The proposed 150 foot monopole with 4 foot lightning rod is inconsistent with the adjacent land uses of single family residences on large agricultural parcels and associated agricultural uses such as barns and riding rings. The closest residential structure is approximately 354 feet from the proposed monopole cell tower located on the subject site. Other residential structures are located 618 feet, 663 feet and 751feet to the west, south and southeast respectively. Although, it meets the use permit standards for setbacks, it is Staff’s opinion that it is incompatible based on the location of the tower to adjacent residential structures. Further, the tower appears to be located such that it will be significantly higher than the tree stands and will not be visually screened from the road as depicted in the tower simulation photos above. C. Whether the proposed use may violate local, state and/or federal statutes, ordinances or regulations governing land development; It is Staff’s opinion that the proposed use does not violate local, state and/or federal ordinances or regulations governing land development. Prepared by the Community Development Department for the Mayor and City Council on April 12, 2010 (First Presentation) 4/5/2010 Page 12 of 19 U09-04 D. The effect of the proposed use on traffic flow, vehicular and pedestrian, along adjoining streets; The proposed monopole cell tower is an unmanned operation that will generate only an occasional trip to the site for maintenance. Staff is of the opinion that the proposed monopole cell tower will not impact traffic flow along adjoining streets. E. The location and number of off-street parking spaces; For occasional maintenance trips to the site, space is available next to the gate of the 2,500 square foot leased area. Staff is of the opinion that parking will not impact the surrounding areas due to the size of the large parcel and the location of the leased area away from Hopewell Road and behind existing barns. F. The amount and location of open space; The applicant’s site plan indicates a leased area of 2,500 square feet and an additional access easement. The remainder of the property is developed with a single family residence and working horse farm. The parcel is approximately 26 acres which provides a l arge area of open space. G. Protective screening; Although the submitted site plan meets the requirements of Article 19.4.7 to provide a 10-foot landscape strip planted to buffer standards exterior to the required fencing not less than 6 feet in height, Staff recommends that the applicant provide a 20-foot landscape strip in lieu of the required 10 foot landscape strip planted to buffer standards to provide additional screening of the tower and associated facilities. This will be reflected in the Recommended Conditions. H. Hours and manner of operation; The proposed monopole cell tower is an unmanned operation that will generate only an occasional trip to the site for maintenance. Staff will condition the site maintenance to be completed between the hours of 8:30 a.m. and 5:30 p.m., Monday through Friday except in cases of emergency or when an after-hours permit is obtained pursuant to the City of Milton Noise Ordinance. I. Streetscape lighting; Prepared by the Community Development Department for the Mayor and City Council on April 12, 2010 (First Presentation) 4/5/2010 Page 13 of 19 U09-04 The applicant has not indicated any streetscape lighting for the site. In addition, no lights will be attached to the monopole tower. Staff notes that any security light utilized in the maintenance area must comply with the Northwest Overlay District and/or Night Sky Ordinance standards for site lighting. J. Ingress and egress to the property. The applicant’s site plan indicates that access to the leased property will be derived from the existing driveway into the site off of Hopewell Road. Given the limited use of the subject site for regular maintenance, Staff is of the opinion that the proposed development’s ingress and egress will have limited impact upon the community when conditioned to the limited times listed above. SITE PLAN ANALYSIS Based on the applicant’s revised site plan submitted to the Community Development Department on March 30, 2010, Staff offers the following considerations: Use Permit Standards – Article 19.4.7 1. Towers must be set back a distance equal to one and one-half (1½) times the height of the tower adjacent to residential and/or AG-1 zoned property. The closest AG-1 zoning property is located 269 feet from the proposed cell tower location. The minimum required is 231 feet which includes the lighting rod. Therefore, it meets the required one and one-half times the height of the 154 foot tower. 2. Height shall not exceed 200 feet from existing grade. The proposed height of the tower is 154 feet and is below the maximum height allowed. 3. Tower and associated facilities shall be enclosed by fencing not less than six feet in height and shall also be equipped with an appropriate anti- climbing device. The site plan and associated plans indicate a new six foot high chain link fence with 3 strands of barbed wire. Staff notes that all chain link fencing shall be black vinyl clad. Although barbed wire is permitted in this use and Prepared by the Community Development Department for the Mayor and City Council on April 12, 2010 (First Presentation) 4/5/2010 Page 14 of 19 U09-04 zoning district, Staff recommends that the barbed wire not be utilized which will be reflected in the Recommended Conditions. 4. A minimum 10-foot landscape strip planted to buffer standards shall be required surrounding the facility exterior to the required fence unless the City Arborist determines that existing plant materials are adequate. The site plan indicates a 10-foot landscape strip planted with Leyland cypress. Staff recommends that a 20-foot landscape strip in lieu of the 10- foot landscape strip be planted to buffer standards per the specifications of the City Arborist to provide additional screening of the facilities from adjacent single family residences. 5. Antennas or towers shall not have lights unless required by federal or state law. The proposed tower and antenna will not have any lighting, as it will be less than 200 feet per the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) and the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA). Staff notes that any security light utilized in the maintenance area must comply with the Northwest Overlay District and/or Night Sky Ordinance standards for site lighting. 6. Towers shall not be located within one-half mile from any existing telecommunication tower above the district height, excluding alternative structures. Staff has confirmed that no existing towers are located within one-half mile from the proposed tower. 7. The tower shall comply with applicable state and local statutes and ordinances, including, but not limited to, building and safety codes. Towers which have become unsafe or dilapidated shall be repaired or removed pursuant to applicable state and local statutes and ordinances. The applicant has stated that the proposed tower will comply with all state and local ordinances as listed above and will apply for building permit approval prior to any construction. The applicant is aware and agrees to removal requirements for unsafe or dilapidated wireless facilities. 8. Facilities shall not be artificially lighted except to assure human safety or as required by the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA). Prepared by the Community Development Department for the Mayor and City Council on April 12, 2010 (First Presentation) 4/5/2010 Page 15 of 19 U09-04 The applicant has stated that the facilities will not be artificially lighted. Staff notes that on page C3.3 of the construction plans, lighting is indicated. Staff notes that any security light utilized in the maintenance area must comply with the Northwest Overlay District standards and/or the Night Sky Ordinance for site lighting. 9. Communication towers shall be designed and constructed to ensure that the structural failure or collapse of the tower will not create a safety hazard to adjoining properties, according to applicable Federal Standards which may be amended from time to time. The applicant has stated that the proposed tower is designed by certified structural engineers to ensure proper safety according to applicable Federal standards. 10. Telecommunications facilities shall not be used for advertising purposes and shall not contain any signs for the purpose of advertising. The applicant has stated there will not be any advertising on the proposed wireless facility. 11. Any telecommunications facility may co-locate on any existing tower, pole or other structure as long as there is no increase in height to the existing facility. The applicant has stated that the proposed facility may accommodate two additional carriers without increasing the height. 12. A commercial telecommunication facility that ceases operation for a period of 12 consecutive months shall be determined to have terminated and shall be removed within 90 days of termination at the property owner's expense. It shall be the duty of both the property owner and the tower owner to notify the City in writing of any intent to abandon the use of the tower. The applicant has stated that Section 19.4.7(B)(12) will be met. 13. Communication facilities not requiring FAA painting/marking shall have either a galvanized finish or [be] painted a dull blue, gray, or black finish or shall be screened through fencing and landscaping. The applicant states that the facility will be galvanized steel and screened behind fencing and landscaping. Staff notes that the City Design Review Board shall make the final recommendation for the finish of the structure. Prepared by the Community Development Department for the Mayor and City Council on April 12, 2010 (First Presentation) 4/5/2010 Page 16 of 19 U09-04 14 An application for a telecommunications facility shall be submitted in accordance with the Department’s Plan Review submittal requirements. The applicant states that the facility will adhere to the above requirements. 15. An application for a telecommunication facility shall include a certification from a registered engineer that the structure will meet the applicable design standards for wind loads. The applicant states that a certified/registered structural report will be provided for the proposed facility. 16. Communications facilities shall not be located in 100-year flood plain or delineated wetlands. The applicant states that the proposed communication facility is not located in a 100-year flood plain or delineated wetlands. Staff has confirmed these findings to be correct. OTHER CONSIDERATIONS Transportation Engineer – No Comments Building Official – No Comments City Arborist – There will be no specimen trees affected by the proposed cell tower. PUBLIC INVOLVEMENT On Thursday, January 13, 2010 the applicant was present at the Community Zoning Information Meeting held at the Milton City Hall. There were approximately 70 to 80 people in attendance from the community of which 33 people indicated interest in U09-04 on the City’s sign in sheet. Public Comments – Staff has received e-mails which are attached expressing both opposition and support of the request. Staff has met with the adjacent property owners. In addition, about five residents have called Staff to express their opposition to the proposed cell tower. City of Milton Design Review Board Meeting – January 5, 2010 Staff notes that another meeting before the Design Review Board is required based on the Zoning Ordinance’s requirement to publish the DRB meeting in the Prepared by the Community Development Department for the Mayor and City Council on April 12, 2010 (First Presentation) 4/5/2010 Page 17 of 19 U09-04 newspapers as well as include it in the adjacent property owners’ notice. This meeting will occur on April 6, 2010. Although this meeting will occur after the Planning Commission, any new comments received at the meeting will also be included as an addendum to the Staff report prior to the Mayor and City Council meeting. The following recommendations were made by the DRB: • Board/Applicant comments: o The Board stated that their purpose is to examine the aesthetic aspects of the proposed towers; land use/location is not for them to decide. o The applicant states that the tower will be a standard grey tower, as this is the best option for blending in. The Board states that they preferred this to the fake tree option. o Applicant states that they are willing to meet City standards in terms of fencing. They are willing to remove the 3 rows of barbed wire topping the chain link fencing. o Board inquired as to whether the Applicant would be able to screen the cell tower compound that is adjacent to the power easement (New Providence). The applicant states that the compound is at least 15’ away from the easement, and that the existing trees will remain. o Board informed the applicant that the trees used to screen the compound had to be a mix of evergreens that would provide screening in one year; Leylands are not allowed according to the Ordinance. o Only towers above 200’ are required to be lit. o Stealth products include: light pole, flag pole, mono pine. o The Board reminded the residents that the Board has the responsibility to protect the Code, and therefore the applicant. They ask the public to help by providing as much information as possible. o A balloon test has been flown; applicant has pictures taken from 20 different locations. These pictures would be on display at the CZIM meeting scheduled for Thursday, January 7th at 7:00pm. o There appears to be a Code disconnect. The Code states that a tower “buried far from the ROW is better.” Did not anticipate that homes would be so nearby. • Public comments: • The cell tower is a commercial use; not appropriate for rural, residential area. Should be on commercial property. • The tower would ruin the land value of the surrounding area. • The tower would be an eyesore. This is not for the good of the community; not in the spirit of what the City was dreamed of. • The residents would like to explore options for tower camouflage. • The applicant should look into other collocate options first. • Does the code require a propagation study to access the need for more towers? (This is included in the submitted documents). Prepared by the Community Development Department for the Mayor and City Council on April 12, 2010 (First Presentation) 4/5/2010 Page 18 of 19 U09-04 • Resident expressed his frustration and displeasure with the process. • Resident stated that his house was 327’ from the proposed Mountain Road tower location; trees less than 100’ tall. Feels that this location was not a good choice for a cell tower. • It is important for the Council/Board to visit the sites before they made any decisions. • Residents asked if Board considered areas that are highly populated as undesirable for cell towers. (Board reminded her that their purview is limited to aesthetics.) • It is incumbent upon Board to understand the unique requirement of the Milton rural community. • Resident asked if a fall zone analyses is required. (Towers are designed to collapse within itself.) • Resident is concerned about environment impact of tower, especially the poisoning of the spring fed pond if the tower was to fall. Public Participation Plan and Report This petition was administratively deferred to the March 23, 2010 Planning Commission meeting. Staff received an updated Public Participation Report on March 15, 2010 which meets the required submittal date of seven (7) days prior to the Planning Commission meeting. The applicant will be required to submit an updated public participation report 7 days prior to the Mayor and City Council meeting. CONCLUSION It is Staff’s opinion that the proposed cell tower is inconsistent with the adjacent land uses of single family residences on large agricultural parcels and incompatible based on the location of the tower to adjacent residential structures. In addition, the proposed cell tower is inconsistent with the surrounding scale, transition of densities and does not protect the existing rural character of Milton. Therefore, Staff recommends DENIAL of U09-04. Prepared by the Community Development Department for the Mayor and City Council on April 12, 2010 (First Presentation) 4/5/2010 Page 19 of 19 U09-04 RECOMMENDED CONDITIONS If this petition is approved by the Mayor and City Council, it should be approved USE PERMIT for an Antenna Tower and Associated Structure to Exceed the District Height (Article 19.4.7.) CONDITIONAL subject to the owner’s agreement to the following enumerated conditions. Where these conditions conflict with the stipulations and offerings contained in the Letter of Intent, these conditions shall supersede unless specifically stipulated by the Mayor and City Council. 1) To the owner’s agreement to restrict the use of the subject property as follows: a) One monopole communications tower and equipment slab(s) and/or building(s). b) The tower shall not exceed 150 feet with a 4 foot lighting rod. 2) To the owner’s agreement to abide by the following: a) To the revised site plan received by the Milton Community Development Department on March 30, 2010. Said site plan is conceptual only and must meet or exceed the requirements of the Zoning Ordinance and these conditions prior to the approval of a Land Disturbance Permit. Unless otherwise noted herein, compliance with all conditions shall be in place prior to the issuance of the first Certificate of Occupancy or Certificate of Completion. 3) To the owner’s agreement to the following site development considerations: a) To provide a 20 foot landscape strip planted to buffer standards around the leased area. b) All chain link fencing shall be black vinyl clad. c) No barbed wire will be permitted on top of the minimum 6 foot high security fence. d) All site maintenance to be completed between the hours of 8:30 a.m. and 5:30 p.m., Monday through Friday except in cases of emergency or when an after-hours permit is obtained pursuant to the City of Milton Noise Ordinance. Robyn MacDonald From: Norvell [pippi08@att.net] Sent: Monday, January 25, 2010 9:46 AM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Fw: T -Mobile towers ----- Original Message ----- From: Renee Pierce To: i08 att.net Sent: Thursday, January 21, 2010 10:37 AM Subject: T -Mobile towers I am sending this e-mail in support to the petition AGAINST the towers. Renee Pierce 824 Bethany Green Court Hotmail: Free, trusted and rich email service. Get it now. Robyn MacDonald From: Ravi Prakash [rp_bowling@hotmail.corn] Sent: Wednesday, January 20, 2010 1:25 PM To: Robyn Macdonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications ❑ear Sir/Madame: All three sites will improve wireless coverage in Milton, especially in areas where T need it most - at home and in my neighhorhood. T moved to Milton in Dec 2005 and it is almost impossible to talk using our cell phone from home and even in most places around my entire Lake Deerfield community. We are very frustrated and hope that you can assist by giving permit to T -mobile for new towers. Thank you. Sincerely, Ravi Prakash Mailing Address: Ravi. Prakash 12877 Deer Park Ln Milton,GA 30004 Rob n MacDonald From: Rohan Patil [maverickrohan@yahoo.co.in] Sent: Wednesday, January 20, 2010 2:02 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T --Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. All three sites will improve wireless coverage in Milton, especially in areas where I need it most - at home and in my neighborhood. I want to talk, check e-mail or get online with my wireless device from wherever I am, particularly at home. Having poor coverage in a place like Milton is simply unacceptable. In order to have reliable coverage, we need the necessary infrastructure to provide it. I've dropped my landline phone and I rely solely on my wireless phone. It is absolutely imperative that I have reliable wireless coverage to stay connected, particularly in an emergency. Wireless phones have become vital personal and public safety tools in Milton. Please make certain that citizens continue to have the best coverage possible throughout our community. My wireless phone has become a necessity. I use it to check in with my children wherever they are in our community. More importantly, I want my children to always be able to reach me or a 9-1-1 operator in an emergency. I use my wireless phone to stay connected with work, family and friends. Having reliable coverage is important to me. Reliable wireless coverage at home and in my neighborhood is essential for me. Wireless phones are no longer a luxury, they are a necessity. Sincerely, Rohan Patil Mailing Address: Rohan Patil 31003 Deer Trail Milton,GA 30004 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Evilson Rodrigues [wellbonitodemais@hotmail.com] Sent: Wednesday, January 20, 2016 2:46 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Appiications Dear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. I want to talk, check e-mail or get online with my wireless device from wherever I am, particularly at home. Having poor coverage in a place like Milton is simply unacceptable. In order to have reliable coverage, we need the necessary infrastructure to provide it. Sincerely, Evilson Rodrigues Mailing Address: Evilson Rodrigues 1121 northpark In milton,GA 30004 I Robyn MacDonald From: Carolyn Medrano [cmed715@hotmail.com] Sent: Wednesday, January 20, 2010 2:54 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: A new Target Supercenter opened in Milton and there is no service inside the facility for T - Mobile customers. There have been many situation in which family members tried to contact me, with urgent situations and I couldn't be reached while in Target. I also agree the most with the three statements below. All three sites will improve wireless coverage in Milton, especially in areas where I need it most - at home and in my neighborhood. My wireless phone has become a necessity. I use it to check in with my children wherever they are in our community. More importantly, I want my children to always be able to reach me or a 9-1-1 operator in an emergency. Reliable wireless coverage at home and in my neighborhood is essential for me. wireless phones are no longer a luxury, they are a necessity. Sincerely, Carolyn Medrano Mailing Address: Carolyn Medrano 9324 Deer Trail Milton,GA 30004 1 Robyn MacDonald From: loan Turc [icturc[7a gmail.coml Sent: Wednesday, January 20, 2010 3:28 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. All three sites will improve wireless coverage in Milton, especially in areas where I need it most - at home and in my neighborhood. I want to talk, check e-mail or get online with my wireless device from wherever I am, particularly at home. Having poor coverage in a place like Milton is simply unacceptable. In order to have reliable coverage, we need the necessary infrastructure to provide it. I've dropped my landline phone and I rely solely on my wireless phone. It is absolutely imperative that I have reliable wireless coverage to stay connected, particularly in an emergency. Wireless phones have become vital personal and public safety tools in Milton. Please make certain that citizens continue to have the best coverage possible throughout our community. I use my wireless phone to stay connected with work, family and friends. Having reliable coverage is important to me. Reliable wireless coverage at home and in my neighborhood is essential for me. wireless phones are no longer a luxury, they are a necessity. Sincerely, Ioan Turc Mailing Address: Ioan Turc 13561 Weycroft Circle Milton,GA 30004 I Roba`Donald wrr� w � i From: Cindy Carter (ccarte r611@a aol.com] Sent: Wednesday, January 20, 2010 1:18 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: Please approve the cell site locations for T -Mobile which is desperately needed! Thank you! C. Carter Homeowner City of Milton Sincerely, Cindy Carter Mailing Address: Cindy Carter 611 Sandringham Dr Milton,GA 30004 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Joy Uoy.albert@gmail.com] Sent: Thursday, March 11, 2010 4:17 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. All three sites will improve wireless coverage in Milton, especially in areas where I need it most - at home and in my neighborhood. Wireless phones have become vital personal and public safety tools in Milton. Please make certain that citizens continue to have the best coverage possible throughout our community. I've dropped my landline phone and I rely solely on my wireless phone. It is absolutely imperative that I have reliable wireless coverage to stay connected, particularly in an emergency. Reliable wireless coverage at home and in my neighborhood is essential for me. Wireless phones are no longer a luxury, they are a necessity. Sincerely, Joy Mailing Address: ]oy Tang 10090 ]ones Bridge Rd Unit 12 alpharetta,GA 30022 Robyn MacDonald From: Tom Oliff [tomo2006@belIsouth.net] Sent: Thursday, March 11, 2010 5:18 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. All three sites will improve wireless coverage in Milton, especially in areas where I need it most - at home and in my neighborhood. Wireless phones have become vital personal and public safety tools in Milton. Please make certain that citizens continue to have the best coverage possible throughout our community. Sincerely, Tom Oliff Mailing Address: Thomas Oliff 14750 Wood Rd milton,GA 30004 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Alicia Griffin [alicia.griffin a@t-mobile.coml Sent: Thursday, March 11, 2010 5:19 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. I've dropped my landline phone and I rely solely on my wireless phone. It is absolutely imperative that I have reliable wireless coverage to stay connected, particularly in an emergency. Wireless phones have become vital personal and public safety tools in Milton. Please make certain that citizens continue to have the best coverage possible throughout our community. Sincerely, Alicia Griffin Mailing Address: Alicia Griffin 7391 North Point Parkway Alpahretta,GA 30022 I Robyn MacDonald From: Laryn Alfred [lalfred@comcast.net] Sent: Thursday, March 11, 2010 5:47 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications ❑ear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. Wireless phones have become vital personal and public safety tools in Milton. Please make certain that citizens continue to have the best coverage possible throughout our community. My wireless phone has become a necessity. I use it to check in with my children wherever they are in our community. More importantly, I want my children to always be able to reach me or a 9-1-1 operator in an emergency. Sincerely, Laryn Alfred Mailing Address: Laryn Alfred 40 Arabian Ave. Milton,GA 30094 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Don Hogan [me@dhogan.name] Sent: Monday, March 08, 2010 2:32 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. All three sites will improve wireless coverage in Milton, especially in areas where I need it most - at home and in my neighborhood. Reliable wireless coverage at home and in ray neighborhood is essential for me. Wireless phones are no longer a luxury, they are a necessity. Sincerely, Don Hogan Mailing Address: Donald Hogan 3284 Kentworth Lane Milton,GA 30004 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Mary Michels [no3puttca@yahoo.com] Sent: Wednesday, March 10, 2010 510 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. I am tired of having to turn my cell phone off the minute I enter my home. The only reason I still have a landline is because of the lack of current service I have. Wireless phones have become vital personal and public safety tools in Milton. Please make certain that citizens continue to have the best coverage possible throughout our community. Sincerely, Mary Michels Mailing Address: Mary Michels 513 Northumberland Street Milton,GA 30004 1 Robyn MacDonald From: LynnAnn Agnew [Iynnann@gmail.corn] Sent: Wednesday, March 10, 2010 3:48 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: All three sites will improve wireless coverage in Milton, especially in areas where I need it most - at home and in my neighborhood. Sincerely, LynnAnn Agnew Mailing Address: LynnAnn Agnew 330 Marshalls Cove Milton,GA 30004 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Adam Agnew [adam.agnew@capgemini.com] Sent: Wednesday, March 10, 2010 3:47 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: Wireless phones have become vital personal and public safety tools in Milton. Please make certain that citizens continue to have the best coverage possible throughout our community. Sincerely, Adam Agnew Mailing Address: Adam Agnew 330 Marshalls Cove Milton,GA 30004 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Judy Whalen Dudyaw2@gmail.com] Sent: Wednesday, March 10, 2010 1:47 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. All three sites will improve wireless coverage in Milton, especially in areas where I need it most -- at home and in my neighborhood. I use my wireless phone to stay connected with work, family and friends. Having reliable coverage is important to me. Reliable wireless coverage at home and in my neighborhood is essential for me. Wireless phones are no longer a luxury, they are a necessity. Sincerely, 7udy Whalen Mailing Address: Judy Whalen 2495 Hopewell Plantation Dr Alpharetta,GA 30004 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Parul Sharma [ram.sharma77 a@gmail.com] Sent: Wednesday, March 10, 2010 5:35 PM To: Robyn Macdonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: Dear Respected Local Official, I am buying house in City of Milton on Crabapple Road under new subdivision named as Crabapple Crossroads. One of the hindering factor is that I could not make and receive calls in and around this subdivision as this is a newly developed subdivision. This is very close to on of the 3 sites proposed by T -Mobile. These 3 sites will enhance my confidence about my kids going to schools, while I go to Pediatrics when my kids get cold or other, when we go to shopping center (Kroger on Arnold Mill and Crabapple), when I go to play Golf on Atlanta National Golf on New Providence Road. I not only hope but confident that we all have similar concerns for our work and family, irrespective of whatever Carrier/Mobile Operator we use. I want to talk, check e-mail or get online with my wireless device from wherever I am, particularly at home. Having poor coverage in a place like Milton is simply unacceptable. In order to have reliable coverage, we need the necessary infrastructure to provide it. I've dropped my landline phone and I rely solely on my wireless phone. It is absolutely imperative that I have reliable wireless coverage to stay connected, particularly in an emergency. Reliable wireless coverage at home and in my neighborhood is essential for me. Wireless phones are no longer a luxury, they are a necessity. Sincerely, Parul Sharma Bailing Address: Parul Sharma 1728 Hemingwway Lane Alpharetta,GA 30075 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Erica [ericadorris@gmail.com] Sent: Monday, March 08, 2010 2.05 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: My phone doesn't work from Wal-Mart all the over to Zagby's. I have roadside assistant and if something were to ever happen between the 2 locations, i will be medded up. T -Mobile is the cheapest National Provider out there right now. And with these hard times we are facing these days, I need all the help I can get. SO that's why I decided to go with T -Mobile blc of the price. I am an AT&T emplyee and it is cheaper for me to go to T -Mobile even with my companies discounts. That's how important the savings are to me. And now I can't get 1005 of service because of this tower issue. I just want my phone to work. Sincerely, Erica Mailing Address: erica Dorris 5006 Lake Union Hill Road Alpharetta,GA 30004 Robyn MacDonald From: Shirley A. Slaughter [shirleyann012000@yahoo.com] Sent: Monday, March 08, 2010 2:47 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. All three sites will improve wireless coverage in Milton, especially in areas where I need it most - at home and in my neighborhood. I want to talk, check e-mail or get online with my wireless device from wherever I am, particularly at home. Having poor coverage in a place like Milton is simply unacceptable. In order to have reliable coverage, we need the necessary infrastructure to provide it. Wireless phones have become vital personal and public safety tools in Milton. Please make certain that citizens continue to have the best coverage possible throughout our community. I use my wireless phone to stay connected with work, family and friends. Having reliable coverage is important to me. I use my wireless phone to stay connected with work, family and friends. Having reliable coverage is important to me. Reliable wireless coverage at home and in my neighborhood is essential for me. Wireless phones are no longer a luxury, they are a necessity. Sincerely, Shirley A. Slaughter Mailing Address: Shirley Slaughter 1473 Mayfield Road Alpharetta,GA 30009 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Maria -Luisa Beatriz Halbert [emma_bachi@yahoo.comj Sent: Monday, March 08, 2010 5:03 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject. Approve T -Mobile Applications ❑ear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. All three sites will improve wireless coverage in Milton, especially in areas where I need it most - at home and in my neighborhood. I want to talk, check e-mail or get online with my wireless device from wherever I am, particularly at home. Having poor coverage in a place like Milton is simply unacceptable. In order to have reliable coverage, we need the necessary infrastructure to provide it. I've dropped my landline phone and I rely solely on my wireless phone. It is absolutely imperative that I have reliable wireless coverage to stay connected, particularly in an emergency. I use my wireless phone to stay connected with work, family and friends. Having reliable coverage is important to me. Reliable wireless coverage at home and in my neighborhood is essential for me. Wireless phones are no longer a luxury, they are a necessity. I am a pet -sitter and am constantly driving down the back roads of Milton and am constantly losing service or not having service at all which is very frustrating. The new towers are located not only on the road i live on but on the back roads that I work on Wireless phones have become vital personal and public safety tools in Milton. Please make certain that citizens continue to have the best coverage possible throughout our community. Sincerely, Maria -Luisa Beatriz Halbert Mailing Address: Maria -Luisa Halbert 16675 Hopewell RD Alpharetta,GA 30004 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Sent: To: Subject: Dear Sir/Madame: Julie Burns gulieb_1961@yahoo.corn] Wednesday, March 10; 2010 1:00 PM Robyn MacDonald Approve T -Mobile Applications I want to talk, check e-mail or get online with my wireless device from wherever I am, particularly at home. Having poor coverage in a place like Milton is simply unacceptable. In order to have reliable Coverage, we need the necessary infrastructure to provide it. I've dropped my landline phone and I rely solely on my wireless phone. It is absolutely imperative that I have reliable wireless coverage to stay connected, particularly in an emergency. Sincerely, 3ulie Burns Mailing Address: 7ulie Burns 123 North Park Lane Alpharetta,GA 30004 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Jay Call ins UaycI bird@gmai1.corn] Sent: Wednesday, March 10, 2010 1:10 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. All three sites will improve wireless coverage in Milton, especially in areas where I need it most - at home and in my neighborhood. I've dropped my landline phone and I rely solely on my wireless phone. It is absolutely imperative that I have reliable wireless coverage to stay connected, particularly in an emergency. Sincerely, Jay Collins Mailing Address: Jay Collins 16058 Inverness Trail Milton,GA 30004 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Toni Santos [chatwmstoni@gmail.com] Sent: Wednesday, March 10, 2010 1:46 PM To: Robyn Macdonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I am a home owner, tax payer and registered voter in Alpharetta. I am also a TMobile customer. The addiion cellsites provides better service for those of us that live up here. These sites I am sure can be utilitzed in some way to support our state and county services. I don't know the infrastructure of our emergency services but potentially we will need more access to more of these technologies. I'm sure the government has all the legal support to make sure they make the most of this situation. Please support the cell site builds. Reliable wireless coverage at home and in my neighborhood is essential for me. Wireless phones are no longer a luxury, they are a necessity. Sincerely, Toni Santos Mailing Address: Toni Santos 2180 Brookridge Terrace Alpharetta,GA 30004 Robyn MacDonald From: venkataraju thimaiah [shyamusa@aol.com] Sent: Friday, March 19, 2919 1:55 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: please kindly approve the t -moble applications thanks venka thimaiah Sincerely, venkataraju thimaiah Mailing Address: venkataraju thimaiah 455 waterhaven lane alpharetta,GA 30004 Robyn MacDonald From: Edward Chase [kamauski@gmail.com] Sent: Friday, March 19, 2010 1.54 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. I am unable to attend the Planning Commission Hearing on January 25. However, please accept this e-mail as a show of support for these site applications. I've dropped my landline phone and I rely solely on my wireless phone. It is absolutely imperative that I have reliable wireless coverage to stay connected, particularly in an emergency. Sincerely, Edward Chase Mailing Address: Edward Chase 524 Sandringham Drive Milton,GA 30004 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Doug and Tiffany Ray [Tifforay@aol.com] Sent: Friday, March 19, 2010 1:53 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: My wireless phone has become a necessity. Z use it to check in with my children wherever they are in our community. More importantly, I want my children to always be able to reach me or a 9-1-1 operator in an emergency. Sincerely, Doug and Tiffany Ray Mailing Address: Doug Ray 2685 Highland pass Alpharetta ,GA 30004 I Robyn MacDonald From: Dennis Fulton [dennis.fulton@crowncastle.com] Sent: Friday, March 19, 2010 1:43 PM To: Robyn Macdonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. Sincerely, Dennis Fulton Mailing Address: Dennis Fulton 12725 Morris Road extension Alphereta,GA 30004 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Saad Mandi [smimo@hotmail.com] Sent: Friday, March 19, 2010 1:32 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: Wireless phones have become vital personal and public safety tools in Milton. Please make certain that Citizens continue to have the best coverage possible throughout our community. Sincerely, Saad Mandi Mailing Address: Saad Mandi 1409 Treeridge Pkwy Alpharetta,GA 30022 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Linda K_ Elliott [maggiezone@comcast.net] Sent: Friday, March 19, 2010 1:26 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. Wireless phones have become vital personal and public safety tools in Milton. Please make certain that citizens continue to have the best coverage possible throughout our community. I am unable to attend the Planning Commission Hearing on Danuary 26. However, please accept this e-mail as a show of support for these site applications. Sincerely, Linda K. Elliott Mailing Address: Linda Elliott 318 Karen Dr. Alpharetta,GA 30009 1 Robyn acDonald From: joe pfaff Uoepfaff@hotnnail,com] Sent: Friday, March 19, 2010 1:16 PM To: Robyn Macdonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: All three sites will improve wireless coverage in Milton, especially in areas where I need it most - at home and in my neighborhood. Sincerely, joe Pfaff Mailing Address: joe Pfaff 105 quay cir. alpharetta,GA 30009 Robyn MacDonald ■ � - �rr�w-w�rw From: eliane pacheco [epacheco02@grnaiLcom] Sent: Friday, March 19, 2010 1:02 PM To: Robyn Macdonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: All three sites will improve wireless coverage in Milton, especially in areas where I need it most - at home and in my neighborhood I am unable to attend the Planning Commission Hearing on January 26. However, please accept this e-mail as a show of support for these site applications. I am unable to attend the Planning Commission Hearing on January 26. However, please accept this e-mail as a show of support for these site applications.l am unable to attend the Planning Commission Hearing on 7anuary 26. However, please accept this e-mail as a show of support for these site applications_ Sincerely, eliane pacheco Mailing Address: Eliane Pacheco 702 Northpark lane Alpharetta,GA 30004 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Greg [grsears@grnail.com] Sent: Friday, March 19, 2010 1:01 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I greatly support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. T -Mobile is a very Customer friendly Company ( vs The Dinosaurs ) and Happy customers are happy voters : ) Thanks, Greg Sincerely, Greg Mailing Address: Greg Sears 457 Windstone Trail Alpharetta,GA 30004 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Dana Luck [datz rnr.luck a@hotrnai1,conn] Sent: Friday, March 19, 2010 1:01 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I feel it would be a great benefit to those of us in the Milton area with T -Mobile service if you would allow these towers. I, as many of us, use my cell phone when at home and sometimes lose signal when otherwise I have awesome service! I sometimes do have to avoid Bethany Bend due to a couple of dead zones along that route between McGinnis Ferry and Highway 9. I will not be able to attend the meeting because of work and ask you to accept this email as a show of support for this proposal!, All three sites will improve wireless coverage in Milton, especially in areas where I need it most - at home and in my neighborhood. I want to talk, check e-mail or get online with my wireless device from wherever I am, particularly at home. Having poor coverage in a place like Milton is simply unacceptable. In order to have reliable coverage, we need the necessary infrastructure to provide it. Wireless phones have become vital personal and public safety tools in Milton. Please make certain that Citizens continue to have the best coverage possible throughout our community. I use my wireless phone to stay connected with work, family and friends. Having reliable coverage is important to me. Reliable wireless coverage at home and in my neighborhood is essential for me. Wireless phones are no longer a luxury, they are a necessity. Sincerely, Dana Luck Mailing Address: Dana Luck 822 Deerfield Point Milton,GA 30004 1 Robyn Macdonald From: Eran Fainshtad [eranfain c@yahoo.ccrn] Sent: Tuesday, March 16, 2010 10:14 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. All three sites will improve wireless coverage in Milton, especially in areas where I need it most - at home and in my neighborhood. I want to talk, check e-mail or get online with my wireless device from wherever I am, particularly at home. Having poor coverage in a place like Milton is simply unacceptable. In order to have reliable coverage, we need the necessary infrastructure to provide it. My wireless phone has become a necessity. I use it to check in with my children wherever they are in our community. More importantly, I want my children to always be able to reach me or a 9-1-1 operator in an emergency. I use my wireless phone to stay connected with work, family and friends. Having reliable coverage is important to me. Sincerely, Eran Fainshtad Mailing Address: Eran Fainshtad 3124 Commonwealth Milton,GA 30004 1 Robyn MacDonald From: sarah shafor [s_shafor@yahoo.com] Sent: Tuesday, March 16, 2010 10:13 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. All three sites will improve wireless coverage in Milton, especially in areas where I need it most - at home and in my neighborhood. I want to talk, check e-mail or get online with my wireless device from wherever I am, particularly at home. Having poor coverage in a place like Milton is simply unacceptable. In order to have reliable coverage, we need the necessary infrastructure to provide it. I've dropped my landline phone and I rely solely on my wireless phone. It is absolutely imperative that I have reliable wireless coverage to stay connected, particularly in an emergency. Wireless phones have become vital personal and public safety tools in Milton. Please make certain that citizens continue to have the best coverage possible throughout our community. My wireless phone has become a necessity. I use it to check in with my children wherever they are in our community. More importantly, I want my children to always be able to reach me or a 9-1-1 operator in an emergency. I use my wireless phone to stay connected with work, family and friends. Having reliable coverage is important to me. Reliable wireless coverage at home and in my neighborhood is essential for me. Wireless phones are no longer a luxury, they are a necessity. I am unable to attend the Planning Commission Hearing on January 26. However, please accept this e-mail as a show of support for these site applications. Sincerely, sarah shafor Mailing Address: sarah shafor 1465 mayfield rd alpharetta,GA 30009 I Robyn MacDonald From: Steven Spalding [spaIdingsm@yahoo.corn] Sent: Tuesday, March 16, 2010 6155 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I agree with the proposals presented by TMobile. I receive horrible service in this area, especially my house, and feel that we need additional coverage. Sincerely, Steven Spalding Mailing Address: steven spalding 13085 morris road #7002 alpharetta,GA 300e4 Robyn MacDonald From: Daniel Harry [dr_harry@comcast.net] Sent: Tuesday, March 16, 2010 5:52 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. I've dropped my landline phone and I rely solely on my wireless phone. It is absolutely imperative that I have reliable wireless coverage to stay connected, particularly in an emergency. Wireless phones have become vital personal and public safety tools in Milton. Please make certain that citizens continue to have the best coverage possible throughout our community. Thank -you. Sincerely, Daniel Harry Mailing Address: Daniel Harry 112 Laurel Ridge Drive Alpharetta,GA 30004 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Glenda (martstha@yahoo.com) Sent: Tuesday, March 16, 2010 5:47 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. I want to talk, check e-mail or get online with my wireless device from wherever I am, particularly at home. Having poor coverage in a place like Milton is simply unacceptable. In order to have reliable coverage, we need the necessary infrastructure to provide it. Wireless phones have become vital personal and public safety tools in Milton. Please make certain that citizens continue to have the best coverage possible throughout our community. My wireless phone has become a necessity. I use it to check in with my children wherever they are in our community. More importantly, I want my children to always be able -to reach me or a 9-1-1 operator in an emergency. Reliable wireless coverage at home and in my neighborhood is essential for me. Wireless phones are no longer a luxury, they are a necessity. Reliable wireless coverage at home and in my neighborhood is essential for me. Wireless phones are no longer a luxury, they are a necessity. I am unable to attend the Planning Commission Hearing on January 26. However, please accept this e-mail as a show of support for these site applications. Sincerely, Glenda Mailing Address: Glenda M PQ Box 723 Alpharetta,GA 30007 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Rohan Patil [maverickrohan@yahoo.co.in] Sent: Tuesday, March 16, 2014 5:46 PM To: Robyn Macdonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications ❑ear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. All three sites will improve wireless coverage in Milton, especially in areas where I need it most - at home and in my neighborhood. I want to talk, check e-mail or get online with my wireless device from wherever I am, particularly at home. Having poor coverage in a place like Milton is simply unacceptable. In order to have reliable coverage, we need the necessary infrastructure to provide it. I've dropped my landline phone and I rely solely on my wireless phone. It is absolutely imperative that I have reliable wireless coverage to stay connected, particularly in an emergency. Wireless phones have become vital personal and public safety tools in Milton. Please make certain that citizens continue to have the best coverage possible throughout our community. My wireless phone has become a necessity. I Use it to check in with my children wherever they are in our community. More importantly, I want my children to always be able to reach me or a 9-1-1 operator in an emergency. I use my wireless phone to stay connected with work, family and friends. Having reliable coverage is important to me. Reliable wireless coverage at home and in my neighborhood is essential for me. Wireless phones are no longer a luxury, they are a necessity. I am unable to attend the Planning Commission Hearing on January 26. However, please accept this e-mail as a show of support for these site applications. Sincerely, Rohan Patil Mailing Address: Rohan Patil 31003 Deer Trail Milton,GA 30004 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Ravi Prakash [rp_bowling@hotmail.comj Sent: Tuesday, March 16, 2010 5:45 PM To: Robyn Macdonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: Dear Milton City Council, I am a resident of Milton since Dec 2005 and live right across from your office. In all these years we have had T -Mobile and we have almsot no coverage inside our home or in the entire subdivision. Please this is not a luxary these days, it is a bare necessity. I am unable to attend the Planning Commission Hearing on January 26. However, please accept this e-mail as a snow of support for these site applications. Kindly look into this matter and I thank you in advance for your time and consideration. Sincerely, Ravi Prakash Mailing Address: Ravi Prakash 12877 Deer Park Lane Alpharetta,GA 30004 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Laryn Alfred flalfred@comcast.net] Sent: Thursday, March 11, 2010 5:47 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. Wireless phones have become vital personal and public safety tools in Milton. Please make certain that citizens continue to have the best coverage possible throughout our community. My wireless phone has become a necessity. I use it to check in with my children wherever they are in our community. More importantly, I want my children to always be able to reach me or a 9-1-1 operator in an emergency. Sincerely, Laryn Alfred Mailing Address: Laryn Alfred 40 Arabian Ave. Milton,GA 30004 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Alicia Griffin [alicia.grifFin&-mobile.com] Sent: Thursday, March 11, 2010 5:19 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. I've dropped my landline phone and I rely solely on my wireless phone. It is absolutely imperative that I have reliable wireless coverage to stay connected, particularly in an emergency. Wireless phones have become vital personal and public safety tools in Milton. Please make certain that citizens continue to have the best coverage possible throughout our community. Sincerely, Alicia Griffin Mailing Address: Alicia Griffin 7393 North Point Parkway Alpahretta,GA 30022 1 Robyn MacDonald -PI - - IA IPI PIIII From: Tom ❑lift [tomo2006[7a bellsouth.net] Sent: Thursday, March 11, 2016 5:18 PM To: Robyn Macdonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. All three sites will improve wireless coverage in Milton, especially in areas where I need it most - at home and in my neighborhood. Wireless phones have become vital personal and public safety tools in Milton. Please make certain that citizens continue to have the best coverage possible throughout our community. Sincerely, Tom Qliff Mailing Address: Thomas Qliff 14750 Wood Rd milton,GA 30004 ]. Robyn MacDonald From: Joy Uoy.albert@gmail.com] Sent: Thursday, March 11, 2010 4:17 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear SirMadame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. All three sites will improve wireless coverage in Milton, especially in areas where I need it most - at home and in my neighborhood. Wireless phones have become vital personal and public safety tools in Milton. Please make certain that citizens continue to have the best coverage possible throughout our community. I've dropped my landline phone and I rely solely on my wireless phone. It is absolutely imperative that I have reliable wireless coverage to stay connected, particularly in an emergency. Reliable wireless coverage at home and in my neighborhood is essential for me. Wireless phones are no longer a luxury, they are a necessity. Sincerely, aoy Mailing Address: Toy rang 10050 hones Bridge Rd Unit 12 alpharetta,GA 30022 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Parul Sharma [ram.sharma77 a@gmail.com] Sent: Wednesday, March 10, 2010 5:35 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: Dear Respected Local Official, I am buying house in City of Milton on Crabapple Road under new subdivision named as Crabapple Crossroads. One of the hindering factor is that I could not make and receive calls in and around this subdivision as this is a newly developed subdivision. This is very close to on of the 3 sites proposed by T -Mobile. These 3 sites will enhance my confidence about my kids going to schools, while I go to Pediatrics when my kids get cold or other, when we go to shopping center (Kroger on Arnold Mill and Crabapple), when I go to play Golf on Atlanta National Golf on New Providence Road. I not only hope but confident that we all have similar concerns for our work and family, irrespective of whatever Carrier/Mobile Operator we use. I want to talk, check e-mail or get online with my wireless device from wherever I am, particularly at home. Having poor coverage in a place like Milton is simply unacceptable. In order to have reliable coverage, we need the necessary infrastructure to provide it. I've dropped my landline phone and I rely solely on my wireless phone. It is absolutely imperative that I have reliable wireless coverage to stay connected, particularly in an emergency. Reliable wireless coverage at home and in my neighborhood is essential for me. Wireless phones are no longer a luxury, they are a necessity. Sincerely, Parul Sharma Mailing Address: Parul Sharma 1728 Hemingwway Lane Alpharetta,GA 30075 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Mary Michels [no3puttca@yahoo.com] Sent: Wednesday, March 10. 2010 5:10 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. I am tired of having to turn my Cell phone off the minute I enter my home. The only reason I still have a landline is because of the lack of current service I have. Wireless phones have become vital personal and public safety tools in Milton. Please make certain that Citizens continue to have the best coverage possible throughout our community. Sincerely, Mary Michels Mailing Address: Mary Michels 513 Northumberland Street Milton,GA 38884 1 Robyn MacDonald From: LynnAnn Agnew [lynnann@gmail.com] Sent: Wednesday, March 10, 2010 3:48 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: All three sites will improve wireless coverage in Milton, especially in areas where I need it most - at home and in my neighborhood. Sincerely, LynnAnn Agnew Mailing Address: LynnAnn Agnew 330 Marshalls Cove Milton,GA 30004 I Robyn MacDonald From: Adam Agnew [adam.agnew@capgemini.com] Sent: VVednesday, March 10, 2010 3:47 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: Wireless phones have become vital personal and public safety tools in Milton. Please make certain that citizens continue to have the best coverage possible throughout our community. Sincerely, Adam Agnew Mailing Address: Adam Agnew 339 Marshalls Cove Milton,GA 30004 Robyn MacDonald From: Judy Whalen Hudyaw2@gmail.com] Sent: Wednesday, March 10, 2010 1:47 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T --Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. All three sites will improve wireless coverage in Milton, especially in areas where I need it most - at home and in my neighborhood. I use my wireless phone to stay connected with work, family and friends. Having reliable coverage is important to me. Reliable wireless coverage at home and in my neighborhood is essential for me. Wireless phones are no longer a luxury, they are a necessity. Sincerely, ]udy Whalen Mailing Address: Judy Whalen 2495 Hopewell Plantation Dr Alpharetta,GA 30004 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Toni Santos [chatwmstoni(a gmail.com] Sent: Wednesday, March 10, 2010 1:46 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I am a home owner, tax payer and registered voter in Alpharetta. I am also a TMobile customer. The addiion cellsites provides better service for those of us that live up here. These sites I am sure can be utilitzed in some way to support our state and county services. I don't know the infrastructure of our emergency services but potentially we will need more access to more of these technologies. I'm sure the government has all the legal support to make sure they make the most of this situation. Please support the cell site builds. Reliable wireless coverage at home and in my neighborhood is essential for me. Wireless phones are no longer a luxury, they are a necessity. Sincerely, Toni Santos Mailing Address: Toni Santos 2180 erookridge Terrace Alpharetta,GA 30004 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Jay Collins bayc1bird @gmai 1.corn] Sent: Wednesday, March 10, 2010 1:10 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. All three sites will improve wireless coverage in Milton, especially in areas where I need it most - at home and in my neighborhood. I've dropped my landline phone and I rely solely on my wireless phone. It is absolutely imperative that I have reliable wireless coverage to stay connected, particularly in an emergency. Sincerely, Jay Collins Mailing Address: Jay Collins 7.5058 Inverness Trail Milton,GA 30004 I Robyn MacDonald From: Sent: To: Subject: Dear Sir/Madame: Julie Burns Julieb_1961@yahoo.corn] Wednesday, March 10, 2010 1:00 PM Robyn MacDonald Approve T -Mobile Applications I want to talk, check e-mail or get online with my wireless device from wherever I am, particularly at home. Having poor coverage in a place like Milton is simply unacceptable. In order to have reliable Coverage, we need the necessary infrastructure to provide it. I've dropped my landline phone and I rely solely on my wireless phone. It is absolutely imperative that I have reliable wireless coverage to stay connected, particularly in an emergency. Sincerely, 7ulie Burns Mailing Address: Julie Burns 123 North Park Lane Alpharetta,GA 30004 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Maria -Luisa Beatriz Halbert [emma_bachi@yahoo.com] Sent: Monday, March 08, 2010 5:03 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. All three sites will improve wireless coverage in Milton, especially in areas where I need it most - at home and in my neighborhood. I want to talk, check e-mail or get online with my wireless device from wherever I am, particularly at home. Having poor coverage in a place like Milton is simply unacceptable. In order to have reliable coverage, we need the necessary infrastructure to provide it. I've dropped my landline phone and I rely solely on my wireless phone. It is absolutely imperative that I have reliable wireless coverage to stay connected, particularly in an emergency. I use my wireless phone to stay connected with work, family and friends. Having reliable coverage is important to me. Reliable wireless coverage at home and in my neighborhood is essential for me. Wireless phones are no longer a luxury, they are a necessity. I am a pet -sitter and am constantly driving down the back roads of Milton and am constantly losing service or not having service at all which is very frustrating. The new towers are located not only on the road i live on but on the back roads that I work on Wireless phones have become vital personal and public safety tools in Milton. Please make certain that citizens continue to have the best coverage possible throughout our community. Sincerely, Maria -Luisa Beatriz Halbert Mailing Address: Maria -Luisa Halbert 16675 Hopewell RD Alpharetta,GA 30004 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Don Hogan [me@dhogan.name] Sent: Monday, March 08, 2010 2:32 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. All three sites will improve wireless coverage in Milton, especially in areas where I need it most - at home and in my neighborhood. Reliable wireless coverage at home and in my neighborhood is essential for me. Wireless phones are no longer a luxury, they are a necessity. Sincerely, Don Hogan Mailing Address: Donald Hogan 3284 Kentworth Lane Milton,GA 30004 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Shirley A. Slaughter [shirleyann012000@yahoo.com] Sent: Monday, March 08, 2010 2:07 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. All three sites will improve wireless coverage in Milton, especially in areas where I need it most - at home and in my neighborhood. I want to talk, check e-mail or get online with my wireless device from wherever I am, particularly at home. Having poor coverage in a place like Milton is simply unacceptable. In order to have reliable coverage, we need the necessary infrastructure to provide it. Wireless phones have become vital personal and public safety tools in Milton. Please make certain that citizens continue to have the best coverage possible throughout our community. I use my wireless phone to stay connected with work, family and friends. Having reliable coverage is important to me. I use my wireless phone to stay connected with work, family and friends. Having reliable coverage is important to me. Reliable wireless coverage at home and in my neighborhood is essential for me. Wireless phones are no longer a luxury, they are a necessity. Sincerely, Shirley A. Slaughter Mailing Address: Shirley Slaughter 1473 Mayfield Road Alpharetta,GA 30009 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Erica [ericadorris@gmail.com] Sent: Monday, March 08, 2010 2:05 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: My phone doesn't work from Wal-Mart all the over to Zagby's. I have roadside assistant and if something were to ever happen between the 2 locations, i will be melded up. T -Mobile is the cheapest National Provider out there right now. And with these hard times we are facing these days, I need all the help I can get. 50 that's why I decided to go with T -Mobile b/c of the price. I am an AT&T emplyee and it is cheaper for me to go to T -Mobile even with my companies discounts. That's how important the savings are to me. And now I can't get 100% of service because of this tower issue. I just want my phone to work. Sincerely, Erica Mailing Address: erica Dorris 5006 Lake Union Hill Road Alpharetta,GA 30004 Robyn MacDonald From: paulineedavid@aol.com Sent: Monday, January 04, 2010 12:23 PM To: pippi08@att.net; Imdstrader@yahoo.com; lab172@bellsouth.net; bfiler@mac.com; givmc@bellsouth.net; jandmharris@bellsouth.net; builtfast@aol.com; celeste@babytalktherapies.com; nasrinl99@yahoo.com; jane@gen-tran.com; lakesidecottage@comcast.net; mc539@aol.com; yipyoo2@att.net; heatherscoggins@comcast.net Subject: Re: Signing Petition Please add our names to the petition! I could not imagine how imposing a 15 story structure could be until seeing many cell towers of approximately the same height near rural Cleveland, GA. I am astounded that anyone is even considering placing one near a residential area. It is not just the height of the tower that is alarming, but the many appendages that could be anchored to the structure. Pauline and Art David 2450 Saddlesprings Dr. ---original Message ---- From: Norvell <pippi08@att.net> To: Lisa Strader <Imdstrader@yahoo.com>; Lew and Linda Brinkley <lab 1 72@bellsouth. net>; Pauline David <paulinecdavid@aol.com=; Brenda and David Filer <bfiler@mac.com>; Joe and Cindy Gaston <givmc@bellsouth.net>; Mike and Jillian Harris <jandmharris@bellso uth. net>; Mike and Cookie Haynes <builtfast@aol.com; Celeste Jackson <celeste@babytalktherapies.com>; Mike and Nasrin Lofti <nasrinl99@yahoo.com>; Jane Mandula <jane@gen- tran.com>; Jud and Suzanne Marvin <lakesidecottage@comeast.net>; Michael and Carolyn McAlpin <mc539@aol.com ; Carolyn Pace Cyipyoo2@att.net>; Heather and Scott Scoggins <heatherscoggins@comcast.net> Sent: Sun, Jan 3, 2010 5:01 pm Subject: Signing Petition Dear Neighbors, A few neighbors were braving the cold today to gather signatures for the petition to present at the council meeting on Thursday, Jan. 7. We were not able to make it to all the homes due to time and the cold. We would like to have everyone's signature that is opposed to the cell tower by the meeting on Thursday. If I missed you and you would like to sign it, I will have it on my front porch until Thursday. Another way would be for you to email me directly with your intentions and I can attach that to the petition. If you would like me to bring it to your house at a specified time, I would also be willing to do that. It is important that we show our support. The petition is important but your presence on Thursday night is even more important. I would encourage all of you to be willing to support the neighborhood in this effort to deny the cell tower petition even if you will not be able to view the tower from your house please consider those of us that will. Thank you, Kay Norvell ---- Original Message ----- From: Lisa Strader To: Lew and Linda Brinkley ; Pauline David ; Brenda and David Filer; Joe and Cindy Gaston ; Mike and Cookie Haynes; Celeste Jackson; Mike and Nasrin Lofti ; Jane Mandula ; Jud and Suzanne Marvin ; Michael and Carolyn McAlpin ; Carolyn Pace ; Heather and Scott Scoggins ; Lisa Strader Sent: Sunday, December 27, 2009 4:00 PM Subject: [Bulk] Milton Community Meeting re: cell tower installation at 7 Gables Farm Sunnybrook Farms Neighbors, am sending this e-mail to be sure all Sun nybrook Farm residents are aware of the proposed cell tower construction on the property backing up to our neighborhood. I am not sure if everyone in our neighborhood received the letter regarding an application by T -Mobile to obtain a Use Permit for a 150 foot tall Monopole Cell Tower with an additional 4 foot lightning rod to be erected on the Seven Gables Farm behind our subdivision on Hopewell Road. It is encouraged that Robyn MacDonald From: Mc539@aol.com Sent: Wednesday, January 06, 2010 3:09 PM To: Robyn. MacDonald@cityofmilton.us Cc: pippi08@att.net Subject: T mobile tower on Hopewell Rd Robyn - my name is Michael T McAlpin. My wife Carolyn and I reside at 2380 Saddlesprings Dr. also own the adjacent land at 2390 Saddlesprings Dr. The placing of a 154 foot tower in a residential area is anathema to what the Milton area represents am adamantly against it. We purchased here by choice. It is a serene, pastoral, equestrian community that has its appeal based on the serenity of its surroundings, and it's unique scenic appeal_ The economic gain of Seven Gables should not be at the expense of it's surrounding neighbors. Please log my opposition to this proposal. Michael T McAlpin 2380 Saddlesprings Dr. 770 753 9844 Robyn MacDonald From: Angie Cheshire [angiecheshire@comeast.net] Sent: Thursday, January 07, 2010 8:39 AM To: pippi08@att.net Subject: T -Mobile petition Please include our names in support of the petition against the T -Mobile cell tower to be placed at 14495 Hopewell Road. Thank you for your efforts on behalf of our community! Shawn & Angie Cheshire 760 Stratforde Drive Milton, GA 30004 770/663-8480 (phone) 7701663-7817 (fax) anciecheshiro comcast.net Robyn MacDonald From: Lisa [lisa_dawn@comcast.net] Sent: Tuesday, January 05, 2010 7:13 PM To: pippiO8@att.net Subject: cell tower I am emailing a statement as follows concerning the proposed cell tower @ 14495 Hopewell Rd. I stron-gly strop-lsupport the petition AGAINST the bui g of a cell tower at 14495 Hopewell Road as this is not in keeping with surrounding residential use. There would not only be a negative impact asthetically, but such a structure is not in keeping with the rural, residential use of surrounding properties. The potential for a negative environmental and health impact of such towers has not been disproven. (If anyone has time - there should be an environmental impact study filed with the city of Milton or Fulton County as part of the application process for T -Mobile depending on requirements - worth checking into prior to the meeting on Thursday night - you can also request a copy of the application as well - all public information - I successfully fought one of these going up adjacent to my property (house) in NC many years ago) Regards, Lisa Renko We must become the change we want to see. Mahatma Gandhi Robyn MacDonald From: Robert B Stephan [rstep321 @bellsouth.net] Sent: Wednesday, January 66, 2010 6:19 PM To: pippi08@att.net Subject: T -Mobile My wife (Holly H Stephan) and I want to extend our support and add our names to the petition protesting the request for a T -Mobile tower to be placed at 14495 Hopewll Road. We will try to attend the meeting if at all possible. If you prefer an actual signature please let me know and we will be sure to come by tomorrow. Thanks for bringing this to our attention. Robert B. Stephan 125 Crabapple Way Milton GA 30094 770.410.0914 office 404.291.4856 Cell 815. 927.0240 Fax rstep321 @bellsouth.net Robyn MacDonald From: pstimme2@comcast.net Sent: Thursday, January 07, 2010 1:01 PM To: pippi08@att.net Subject: APPLICATION OF T -MOBILE Please include my name in the petition to protest to this application. Thanks for your work on notifying the neighborhood. I will try to make the meeting tonight. Sincerely, Patricia C Stimmel 770 Stratforde Drive, Alpharetta 30004 Robyn MacDonald From: artworley@gmail.com on behalf of Art Worley [artworley@remax.net] Sent: Friday, January 08, 2010 11:05 AM To: Norvell Subject: Re- Need Information regarding your cell service Hi Kay, Great letter! We both have Verizon, like you, and have great coverage/service. We will write letters of our opposition to this, but could you please provide the appropriate names and e-mail addresses? I will see you at the meeting next Wed. You and Polly can coordinate when we reschedule our dinner - no problem! See you soon, Art On Fri, Jan 8, 2010 at 14:47 AM, Norvell <pi pi08 �,att.net> wrote: Good morning neighbors! It is beautiful outside but slick on the roads. Be careful! I had a very informative meeting last night with the HOA president of Greystone, Bob Buseemi. He has worked in city planning for many years and has a background in writing city zoning laws. His conclusion about winning this fight against the cell tower installation on Hopewell Road is that we need to prove that there is not a gap in service in our area. T -Mobile's application states this is their reason for placing the tower in our area. Bob attended the Design Review meeting on Jan 5 where he made the city aware of the need to examine the propagation study completed by T -Mobile by a unbiased third party. This is the study that shows a need for a tower in a specific area. City Councilman Bill Lusk was in attendance at this meeting and said that Milton would pay for this to be done- If it can be proved there is no gap in service, the tower can be denied by the city but the city will not deny it even if need cannot be established if there is not enough opposition to it. We can also assist in this by gathering information in each of our subdivisions regarding cell coverage. I know personally, I have Verizon and have no problems with dropped calls. The tower at Birmingham Crossroads is a Verizon Tower as well as the tower on Tidwell road. T•Mobile could possibly co -locate on one of these towers to increase their coverage. There are numerous other towers in our area. 1 searched online and discovered there are 77 antennas and towers in a 4 mile radius of our homes! Do we really need another one? My husband has T -Mobile and has good service at the house. Could each of you email me whether or not you have good service and who you are with. I will compile these emails to take to the meeting along with the petition. Please canvas your neighborhoods and/or email those friends who are in the area to ask if they will participate in gathering this information. Also, if you have not already, please write our council members, mayor, and Robyn MacDonald concerning your support opposing the tower. We believe that these 3 tower applications will set the precedence concerning future applications. Unfortunately, we are the guinea pigs by which future zoning laws with be written. Thanks for your support. Robyn MacDonald From: mc539@aol.com Sent: Friday, January 08, 2010 11:22 AM To: pippi08@att.net Subject: Re: Need Information regarding your cell service We have ATT (formerly Cingular/Bell South) and have great connectivity. Michael T McAlpin and Carolyn McAlpin 2380 Saddlesprings Dr Alpharetta, GA 3004 770 753 9844 i K7 Tx�-& OF _. si �w • w� 7 ■ � -.r -6 .l No Text From, Ka Mn r �kWc.+rFy C gwi1.wrnj Sent: TFruestlayr, January 14, 2010 A:27 PM Tw Rob" j ACL)vald sublon; Fwd_ T. rrmb* call Wers appatc=n -Sorry - Lol. ypur L: -mCi I %ldru-55 wwn� the ti rst t11110.aLomw. Ilegin t� i rvvartl rd mitigagv, Firm: Karen Cufry -tkvweurryamuil, m> Data: January 14- 2010 3-.55:18 PM EST To:h ris: Lagerb I cat ofmilton cia. us, B i I I. I ask Git�gfrni Itonrra, bq.r1hew1g2c #.ypfrni Itgr 1ga: u . Rob-Vn . Ma cdorl a Ids c€IVOfM i Itort. u s, krarer i.th firman cilyofr nilto nq a _ u , Eu lie n nerba rieyr catyGfm i It:orlqa, us, lee. IorigodaR obefrrttlto ng a. us, ioe lc ckvv00dCitV0fM i Ito nag. Ips Subject.- T -me bi le cel I towefs app Ircaton A1tilt r ti LtL-ntiing 1 he 1 nftirm2ltivu mucting nt KI i lion City I I riJ l 9wt cvcn_1nlj_,, l un7 ww ttsnv inL�ci ft VAOO lila tQ3YM Ulk! not .L rwcv51 ty i❑ 11kc c Lbuas o r Mll"i, T-Mv Iii to splisim tit% nL!.L!Ly I& l[we s f ght.q'rrr+ pcmvd ?�[h thew �, x ra Gr th iF U 1 �fiers i11 lh�s rrtFle rac lFu�_ 17iek c xpl uncal +luu LUr-1d iU frT gUMr.Y, thcy Cm>1�t Lit tibe same frequenc y us A I & f, Sprint o r VeMilu ►,, and it i-,; v�cessary 1br rl M 11AI I �Uthl tlleSt� tOWLM ItFr - H;10 mc. wc have on 1 `;u1JL' v I'stip}PI v ;Ind dcmund hcrV. I F M-1 Ron T -M. r+h1I V j;ustoin4-r5 arC f n(j i aj� [in untLr, LLIJ ►iroppu-c.l tall Issm, perhaps they �JnFuhl luttk; :11 PNI! Of'thL' csrrlV-rN iiL dLid; arm Lh:LL LIttiL}_L t1k1t e_ NN i01ILy- 11LUL It k 11ol an 1.9sw. 411' 1 hr D.00CMAly 1 Pf a LAI phony Fcrr Mir tritiiun-,% ILlt whnl i wv crav kt wo rks Ri r thG res i&n.L " For v, �rnpk, T would 10.vu 1t} pLwvh&1 v 11w i-phol)c_ bill T know AT & T experimwes ari lrra l froq Ljoncy of dropped cat Is in the Ailanw area_ There 1 c7re- I s -kill hove -a cel I f houe, wsd will ilia] Main etsver v WWI Verb -on until A I'LT -%% %irk ��ur khri r kin1 , ti,r rnWc h.i-;L.� 1 hr Orpid. Van', t.kv's 5olitwi im 1 o the i- Phcmv. -M 11taa is LM ttl L16Man clammurlty, ;; 01 Iwtlic� earl w k_;m ll,mP vnv--cru lt,ts, Cilk?Xtt� (inc to ing rpystl11 ivavv P&I {1e;IT1 x t(3 klIf0t-a th1S'1 M I`Nt� k:; 1'10 sw ! his struoury t nd'1'tn spruki aLl of the ono rit 7 grubics) fruni J lopcwtl I Mid. aria many of the 11-eighbor1100dS nWILDd it iN untYir to Jus cwn wtity _ The t?3Flw of Se-v:m f ablcs state % tlte_ nmcture )ruu I d twt E%c seek, b w I bL-- mai' L, r by hig rLtigh hors 4w 1 L7 the ime N F'l'u r, Nil vvh n Js K,k ing al thc- ph+FtL)w prL §cn1vd 1n I v n iLhtt m-vt:i hig. k ins blalZint I v Inc omG I I unipalhiyk7 svith the mvmT due 10 the oconom iC turndomi, and LVL)u,_t ni ut h mr1wr 4 his Emm d a.0 Lill 0k -r gubLhv i siLm or sc hoo l i ri that awa, �o pi�rlraps it i?� 1 }+r 1 kne Orr 45m to irhQTgv ahs v i yit�im.lo his-FrLIPCIty lu hal P %V1 di thu i:xxes. ate, 114 n1 u r. L -ad uw, I M0WIC_ of ekrMa, V. GuOw W mise dILtir h,}LtlIILl 1irtu. lrut 1 fur ;mr.t1iink.the-y,Lhauld do It 1ciI?IL! w11a_'7t! JJ L!. Alum (kws mlt Vj& iwbv cu M l6%3Ycrs , rhe= ;fry 01 hVT LS, get 5Vr' ieCL n= -Li you f<)r YOUV OZCnliorl lir 111 w L -pan i Un Karen Curry 2145 Double Creek LAne Millon. C' A 3w W4 Ftiatry n MacDonald From-, Kim T i @wick Serif; Thtaso19y, JiOnkiaryr 14 2010 2 26 PM To; Robyn Macdari@ld 5u13jerl' FVV. PliWpsal fpr 3 T -Mobil@ cell jawnr$ iso ttu� City :01 Milton I:rarn: psdmme2,8:cl-Inu_-35t.ner tmEAto:p5tlmme2CDsLnetj Sent: ThUrsiiw, Jamiiary 11. 26 113 - ,.Z PM To: '<-.m Tr.�Lyitk Subject, FIroposal for _1 T-Robile cell towers in the Urty uF Millon Attie' C,mmuait� Duvelopment, Mtn- R-Dbin LicD n -81d I -am a resldi� rTt of M'ftan, living eff Hepewe li Road. I am opposed to the aPp rix-ve I of the a ppli cati5nS from T -Mobile to erect any of sl is 3 cell towers far any purpose in the preposed resideMal are -as. f attended the meeting Inst n,.g I'it at City H ail and wl Il attend th a menu ng agal n Gn Tuesd ay the 261 h We hEwe a baauffut eq uestadan country -aide, farm W nd residential area. We moved hexe rer I hat rea sari. Milton proms& -d la perserve the be;3Uty of I hese residenti;�ih are as a nd we're g ping tG -fig ht to see Lhat Ifte elected officals we ap pu iWed keep Ihei r pr'orrtise. S9naeredY. Patrkia timmel Stralfr rde Estates q)D ftobrp MauPonald Pram~: NurveR 1plpplm aU. mtl Sent: Thvrsdal. Jantwf,+ T4, 2010 &2 7 A1`0 To: #fcbyrn ?.fir-Donard- Taran Sbcktiis. RubVe slid Dutch Mills. RobeFt-Smphan, psdinm!112 �a-57t ret; Ppu int WYW, Milne and Narprin Lemli: A+Fike and Jillian Horrir�: Mipfielli� Ver SIEHmh. Nlrn relle and a P&Mastffr; Michael and Camiryn McAlpirr, MiGrIaer and Sr-qrhf a FIV; k p n Rauckhm5t Lisa, Laww a. -id Linda adnkley+; Jod ,and Suzapne Markin; and C:Lndy Gastor1. Jana hlandui�i. Heals f and Smtt Scoggins; Cmeste J-ackson. C-aioly n Pnu. Eluscemi; Sruce.Norvel g.4lmc com. Rw a and David FIT+sr; ARTHUR K WORLEY: Artq-� CNe-s#airk, HALL, LINEtA C (ATTSr). Pasheli Scott, SMtry Volliarns6n. Jenny: C -1 -vis tagerhrmm- 'Dawld,Lmnda Hall: Joe Longoria; Julb ZahnerBaIlay, tealrer �rps.Onn: mst-:lo L2wlcks ballsouth Pat thcr grroil cora, pamge!_le mmoa,%t. nel; i6a"@y imhm. corn Cc; proteomilton000l Cpm, trnenlu ayl C.Dm SubkL Fw- U writ - Holp Lmprove Your T-VnMa Cawarrage Altarhm i W. picZl604 gif.. piGD44BL9.gif. piQ9744 glf Goe ld N1 LffluaTi f xl Ic lw .9 uppo rtm-r'. It wii:& g pat gutt,r,� t,I itv%Lt #,11 r,rVo4 111:4 nigbl rlt f11.0 1-00-11-11mg- Thm, iK u+att7Inhiirg riIEiPik k N I A rmm Ila -r?mw, ta1:11 1pi. iT -p a ul 4T1Tk1Ut1jIy 44}gIA11 iLl' I u m �1fid 1ii 1v in fhiti fight wit II :ill 4d' yotl. lhoughl n4 mal,lht Im Int -L -n s'tA-41 1a iin- trtaiil t h; - I my n(I lv' mivoI at tho ean4iU4vrn Of 4)(11- 1110011114; ISI night lv ith T-Nf h i 11 X11 'I 10w kt : i tk i I VNI.41 I b -!a Whole thm1 3,- `l' h o -re &re p tom ret tktl rlel1_rrloni.6 rv, WOR I Think IL 4V`!Mlcl 11C� PXI'd 110 Writky ick 111-10 C-=411 AkIdFk',;4 inchid-ed tO 110 thrl1n knrnv 111A L i ratr g,? IS IinO i h r- %v: Ly i t iq+ MV l' 1kAlffrid'L M -r' IC6 wz t 11 "J"M 1) h 111 - rlrH',F, ItoF rl.0t'r-r I F k hu npgraded. 1 think this is a r.-aher hn- kharkdod wciv Esq g.-imer Rktippnrt for 61:13' pCtitJon, I RM aW wondcTill-, Why- they Wait ed to s end t hilz t r; t lieir ,-ub-�criber:� illi t ii :ifLer our mecting- Are thk y 0 aiai,r. VnDfl" 1 Ihi nk so- l think t ivy -ihuuld bu . Aft fir thi, Ilvel y A. -;L! ktKq in lY hist in ight. 1 c.rl ntjL mvti i y t1Y. nk-Ing ffi it mw ill fOr l.hj! [11109A1 ng I�u1 1 h}iG tllu}' Wj�N }11331.. nbt. 114-.1a1U fi.Irrlir -Ohr with rill t.hl!ir WrliUNE' 1111t3t`1- it.bin OPOLIt 4'1`3Vi'rc11�1:: +a 1I p nc pi re ti-tiT�`IU o--9 kxr I til,; fi gh t I iy rr; L40 -n- r.h In K i1 nit t!d tti:1 L r,rn g i Pur:1cAves; on how vti 4` i mn +min ttLii+ lcrgu�ther. Thu cova ra kre in oiir € l-ViL 1.9 uLlc q MI (-U. T- Nlubile lh�ecla W Upgra<d-c, their I'quipulent to o; Ever t111l� FATen Vn tai I c wor4 x.11 kheLcl III o)m Inoruin I areas II' kB V12MM11 IL Fid AT&T. ThcLy h-a-ve rhe: htirden U proof Lo pvpve. W -e &M. Stwy &c>«u?A. ge t }our neighhpa-s invc lyL-ict. yr rite t o T - NIc I bili �, and eDme t o the meetmg- a>p Jan.. 26 prcp:ared tip win LEI* Thank vrau 'Lk1I fur s tipprurt and wnct: rn for this s lma ntiftll comm aluty thIL t we ars j,riVile pe -1 t -a h VI. uti mid 1--u re kiT KILY Nkirvell --w oronal Mem FT)pm- ID.raq�_N"rtir�Q2_VmggZm To: pjpN.t$J§..at ng Sent; T11ul563y, Jan uar� 14, a 1.0 7.14 AM Subject; Fw: Lfrperit - Help Irnpmye YOLIr Ti-M-Dbllo Govo gig Hti 1k er. the `f-Mobkle OMiall shat I raroC11PIXI laxt 11111111111. Oil 1:11 Y B fi dUrillu the root�xin,g. G 4im rin maif1, 4s They sugge,9 -incl liavr �1i :Q, mt~UP for anyone to rlo, hta that I [?r. NrT 7Lmt the Ko3wgrs, I Vii"-I'mi4cm I ['011n: l i i i by DivisItm Cie acsis U ndunw-icing Nlmlagcmcn L Comp�irkx 13 KLal mom Ucnkr.Su'i!c 1401.1 a 1 -3 6-5-6,i 16 Pliom 4D4 -36S; -6&U FAX 81)0-782-9679 I rLL �. c�rvtli,rY}t�r�tt.L� �rii 11L1�I=?r Vw+ V4 r1E'S] !�i C;.qncsi5 - A Mcmbcr of 1 he � ierwrt1 I�L! Urt,t.lp un�l rV Ilei k,;Idrt 11 atha3ti ay C'rrnl park� .,.._ VkYr%%-. Lrilr.d by t;ruvc 'kiorvu l '0 C_\1,SIIt 0 LN 1.5tk 01;'14 r, 01 U U7 10 :1 M I Alobde t"tire - GML-T Harrlthurel To t-r�a�ll�R1�_��iti�k lirL.Lt:�•.iscar��ll ��urn�_�:�m COO I -rg-runs - HOT, Inapr-1-ve Yr. LwT-MttNk Now w5y ad to -rwrcNk.-ami" -ca!411%1ei iiia 17176 A565 3 13a3��r*l��i�cnml�a a' TL:5,11rL"m1L1C, 1;m -r 1=i'nail WL LtisiaJaybIg t;L mnTLV C I}"2 V i t %% I L itt wItur hMW'; fr. t Emhvddizd imgP,;: tnciv��T lir 5J9, pic2l W,gi f I l Lml��i�:Li iirrr��� moti� Cci �i fir: Pa WV 1 114 M. 111-0 yuaiI%V of z c0%,:mgc in Mi ltotL 15O what [L should bo our ULLELDI Ll 2TS rL ll " t1h1v 45 ELL tip MR- ihCa- a-rhnil stir kc4 onfinc frimm shelf Wirrlcsa L;1-L:L? W110fd%-L r And wltem-ver, Usvvc Ud l}' Lia komu. hit rhm. brivi ng poor Lm crap! is simply nnA- Or_ptL+lc- Vhdx "liv I A114H I L I., Scuki ng. a Pewmit Isar I hNe m m is ld ,iitcs ire Millan rsut} map a right). j bm ,tC-%v sites wr� rrccded iv u -n imce car uagc in The conn u w bitty bjvj I in You Cwi Help oke iL 1LLpjx-tu poll Mi11rm IIIPP �ids Yvil War11 l3cm-Of CL74•L'mp- ti on JaTiw�r} �6; Lhac f} li lt0rl 13.1=Lng COM11Lq%W rL Wi I I Tm,low T -Mobile's' t h we *l LL: or jcnim rur V,901 si#c, TTw ?fibrin City c ouru i I Wl [.coluder dw LIMMV144i(,n .PrO an A +4 I i nul do isian in February- Local ehruar - Local tiltliei uL,� sued to pec hd parr fTg)l'n L!LCQLI I�" Iiku NVLL Wha 34 Unt better LMV0aLN and om 7 ,!w OM le's N1 []toil col [ sk VVLIVL,a IS. i1fro aM 11VL1 WftV; Vi Fu rALl hop; . �'-'LiLI W1 t-flL311 110 %%- tO rnz N -I it oo I'lipnrli n Q Comm SILM gild Cry COWII?i I_ Juq Mkl€ a moment [p click aEroMb sLmm bri f me aM i rkdl"tC k ow Suppon tstr the Rh rcc prnprtQs. ?, A[!.Vn�i %L: Millon 111 onning. Commi M im rn cink vrt J"LLU'.V }Y. Yow-prec,cIick :61 tltii� M-Oakki-I %% I I l L!a -a long way Tl}k%-,Lrd �,Vc4r[Tlg -L[5prL%%' a1 i r1' thC---L CI -V i14 I c !V t ITIC 1 w1 f � uu would OQrksider atten ji itis ibis mmrinp.. Your clTurt-q w hk;Jp lmpt' -vCv ' ��r x4 ti c}Jo''criwe in kjIII On ;ire gmally alspivi,a, cd. L nilk-L ded 1 mwlk' nim -rd ltk B I o (.Wev l hx 11410,-1 rE7$. n1 ('r,zi. 6cdded lune ma%Vd to J 11v; pi.v 21)74 4 L!l fp i{:IMI-2010 T-Moblk USA. rrw k f�r�hakWic Li imrsi; 'mov+ d to 1-1 1c: PPL!(�$U$_gi f� rvms LL U-w('Embeddcd i izmL-, c rr wnd tri file: tA "166 19.J� t) Gm s & C_Onji1-cons(Fmht!Qc l imp rm sired to is It: pielY 7 19. il-)Nvacv Ymi :ire sull�curik-d aS- bructf-iYL'n a I;u-aLi1i��.L'tIii; I''1G�k h� 1 mG1 — — 42 .yo i i r s mal l spa 1�sk rips i on pre fercnkztiss.(. iiti:k fiat 14r ru r*I v lig N5 anal i wl Lil'tti7.,I i i}scribd in th,) SLLb t t(i UMUb�C ri1x', lrnTJI tli i n list Lrr if }ou I�-L!I VL IN] 1ILL%1� (cVciVL:d i %!S tllo$ap 1!1 erIfOT. I-hii Tnu%.Vlg�-, xv.!LS Wr)i fro m T- ktobl' Iu LrS.1.. i4 ck hvw W rc port c in€ii I a13tt . -I Ir'L� tr.mmW0rL iiicliL4iRQ UtinchrnErM-I; N It1t4arLded rci r Ibr. Nr5u-n ikr vompnnv wimcd and MUV - rPntdin M" fl rlcn BrIl crrrtVor I L -gal I v prl vi legvd Irkfurmatiott. U tu,ullwri. 4 di ��F uiie, copyi rtg Of USO � l f this 1 n Itormili Kin m is)- bv tmlaw Fill and i'; pmbi hi L"l. I i- YMI ut: nrft the ititeikk'ti recipiimt. rica - dcic tk! lilt ufi-;i❑al and oill roluCg ow this lri ns-mi%]orr and enol i Cy the awrulor, Robyn M;§cDntwald From: mike:�dE2t&m 9,At nil Soret: Monmday, �af%uary 13,'010 4.3() RM To: Ra$hEQ 13�B Cr.: DhrLs LNerblDom. Raby-n MaGDonall, Burt Hewlt Bilk Lus}: Karen Tbrlrrnarn,.,Jtjlie Z$hnE zOley. ,Io -a L..nrioaria: Joh Lcek1%!4c4 Subject= PLS. Tr4mrade mo-nDpolf in Seven Gahle5 Fwm Dear Mayor Luawood and C Q unQii Mambers, I'm writi ng this emal I to express my strong. oon rn and objeaboo to T- mobIWS application to plaCe a monopfllC- Cel[ tower In Seven ambles Farm ber-oss the street fro rn my neig hborhobd StiratFoTde Esters on Hopewell Fid. Thi� is not only} an unsightly ohstrucn iorl in nut beautiU rnmmu nity, but there is no need tor it as oto r cellular sovarago j-s� just lino in our commwiity. II hs nal -only an aestetio wncern hitt also riot knowing if there are heAh TisR5 from su r,� structures. Pvaa se tonsideK deny'09 T- Mot)i le amass to Our cbTnmu nity for such sitru tures_ Thank you veiy inuoh, Deid re Bel me 730 Strak(urde Dr Malian 30OD4 678-2$7-110$ Robn MacDonald Frorrc K.Athy G (kaihVgrx&mac.=mj Sang VVedrie5Jandary t3, 2-a9O 124 PM To, Rgobyr1 MgcDnrold Subject: T-Mgb1m Qen Tc*ar 1)6nr Robyn. As you will m,,:lll. rant. ,aC i hu rnava reV-401)1; Mitb0n h ftmil! n Mit` WAii t C F ru.iklb skirt*.WEI mr1intraIII-ed ca cis' "venin try -1 i ke" n [m uuphrn�e. A T- Mabil�., - eca H tower gue-,% n int I L I l of what we hrk d hoped fi r Lma in this c -Earns nitY_ l N Tn a rp-,q ijull 1111 C hc, (i rLay Lot rin4j 4'�11tin m U ni 1.,' rk nd ILM i n by JPMi tirA to ti the F rot)raE;kf1 L'I Pp lic-Lk t eon to erecR I hii, ci?II C93Wk-I' +1 Hk713f-wv !Il Tared Tho vlack- mont 4 p r.lht- In yr wilI cvvlitp &n Unsigh r. ly- VIC1W( I C t ht+ timr[`.r fmm ru y hams' i; W L41 n s Car. L�irvr)i;in Hjg nrn'g111?L)r5, I t 11inJti- i t I4 rr<ri.L.0n:ible fUr PC-13pis. to be M' u.CyML'rl ikbOUt thC* Ui CU9 Of prtrxinlity to m-11 ulnar p Iniac? t mvcr : on he alth, t he u' propei .ori I rata. and the iir<Eit hall ug of n horrte'6 ktinri -cam - Thoi,n Lim maul, lowers nlmnady exigtJ M] ,P t hr-QU. J Ut M lltf3n A n� I l 47;151110't 9 *t! t hjb IxE11, rl f4),r yl.t JIM01.11Vr_ 1 wsrultl U91 tip LUD6 c- milt, thi- IMP11r1g ttiOn 4kuIiy r4 dUly LFxl1trilt]#1cl 13Y ki filiMl pirl.y tai i1k'tc5nil Mg- lh4t Iin 0Ali-nMi i'#1 n W I L 114- e4G-141q'jItk'11 oft ark k; [tig C.4- 11 J.C;W+F-', I W0141LI kks 11)c, that tht1 V jt.+ int M i I rJlj i i, poi yit!d (i � 241 k rul lie! h i rLi l R ht-ir 6 6:12it:< W.ho h rvo nik,uted yDu U1 b5 rV(I 11 ri kl ku.; in pn~ uvujwi K our furan-cial 1'nvF_1 St 1nC1nt * _ T k.�in1C YOU ithl-citt €jr7,rr1zia*ki Robyn MacDonald From: Ti$h SII [hrhbl�all@i�rnalLCMMJ SL.n Wediwsday. Jan uary 1 a, 201'0 11-53 AIS To: Ch-ti6 Laq,5-rblobm; FtbbVn MACME%ald. ke Lockmod, Burt �1&uitt: Bill Lusx::%arei7 Tnurn�an: ,1WIpe Zahne�k�; Jve LQriunra subject: 7-Mdbdo T - IU)M It 111;1 ' C011-2 alt'! o rrsidkat df I [ Rom_ mid [ ain wrft Much aZuin}t a cell pbL5nc [o %wcr 1c -In a pia -&d on this boa Ld r W.c rtocd W prO c the "U-Lrl LFFL11 -Rini] "V 0131711TY fee! [ n rA Iph:wi „ [��j 7�9 W IMt ht-Uti dT-J%Vit Pf#}�1 e W tHN aMIL '9 o. oarYwn erLDJ [�1! t1113". lrea WJ 110itl}� dri%'.0 �-)p IQ uIA-V 1'116M ►' do POT b] I DW th 15; hugc ttmw to k P1 �cd cin f.[olx:wt 11 ROIL -RP M.-1 w 13cQ11 Robyn M=Mnatd From: Qhris rM. V*drles *, Jamuaryr 13.201a 11:53 ASA Su = Fir -GO Ptwr1L'T ri Frum: prDIe=Rt awl.rxm pr�k ilt r aa#,oam To; 0urt Fliew1a; ,be t.nr.]nrla; Igen Thurrton, )ufln Zahnr�lley-, Alan Tart-, BRI Lur.1t; ke Lnd6v od; ChrLr Lagerhloom Sent- Wed ]an 13 1L_50:10 2-010 Subject; Cell PNx&TawerS Di�:mt .Nrlgsir mid C(f(ina� It hili Iii' tt btNt.lght to I rift 21 tQ-1`16 1f1 13V 1 it X IH in M ilrr,n rhnt rlti'err arc .L er Ii JIML-iic tivwcrM tau-& ntly I)eir)g alldruMtLI frar.V4%C ' cTtt In �.IIIFOIt 13rI,1 M NikkFn 6 CEMX-L-M4rd 01 ii 1Iii thl p6CCJ11{111 1 1 f t hrs4: T1 lgri�l 1 ku1 t d'.It 5%k, [1ri1%jtJjit3' to tt:j1C1d e7 N icy .1"tilwo win i ate 3jut m favor Thr plact:r, viii i5f Thc--v 11 iWk- N wd 11101 1 ckk LI 16,C1 r1, 090, urrtnnl 1.1100 11C jwx'nt 1{ I Them bear IVJ LLffp_t the p=AU J.jld-T r i f t sur :erlritti ,L)MITItart M , l it Is, ipv I tic; { 'Al y will.1 TAC ug. emu ful CcA.rLJvTviT'K)n t,, tht!St 143'LVCJN :Ls tht!y M M r=xrri'Ldlx J31-1 arrrh tkgt FLipm (hakt 5mur, 1 hClpV L13C urs• Ls Ln CQWiUJLra00n rQr new rtNErl.Clir-ns ;L❑d Lmitn 1]] pparr t�M pianru rlux 10771L'i upc 3334 1Ywr ct cru i'rI Sr7I fig MU-- t lV�X i 3 1 N 11} t15E-C! LUgr. 7onr C _tiR pante*. whfir-h w uki m LJri wE! don't inadvEitrittlY IL'.Lvt U 611 IT i )lv11 111 the filuurc It}r , iL,r Iir11l -w yt! t" bu i unie 1 ai ul L nrl. gg aL'd 13V dic 111T{rL1L.�. Of L L']! P114 SLIL' 1.911k J t '%it f : tt t. Thoo l Pit 111,.6ca Urwar rR ,ha 111M 11 . 14;L4 "l M -1I -M- I I I VV V4 bu 111V IL:ay r ILTg1:1 VUDg Ota 115L' r 1S1 111�i- 'C7ti p nFpertr r. yXTM r hMS :3 (It ELWIV. r11,k i 1 I I t�I i1 L U a L:4 I114 75 VT r111 1110 Lgqup".. bul th v r ;r1 V 1 rh)m 1 WC Lgh dir. fr et on 1110 Mi r n t rh r CEM oncl iA ter Merl L-. We m3c1e it a pr F111t v - 1.7e diI't'etrri r x-11 er1 we l}tcamc rp uity, ;LnL[ rptrFctcd h71kal mJ L1s .I IlLi ,71;11 1kr i 1 L , I rl Ll in. 41 J %V[A1]L'l73'1 tirl l 11 leer, fau 1413 der Y ILL'. 90 retie -Enitm 4 ;Lr3d Ii.SffL{CjORK. KQ rJA' LISW CO L1110V Ch=. Pr1)Isx r MMrun. I ftL Robyn KacDonaid From. j13MEE Dace sent: Tuesca . Jsnu.gwy 12. 21010 W.41 AM Tin - Rahy-i Mr--Dani;ld Sia tkjacL, SII T Locw�m • HopeyyO Rwd - Sawn Gable vFwm W u rc%ceiwd nati Fiirilion of tha t-tropowd End- (or Oe MI town ut ti ey : m Gables harm two daN- 5 L%efofc I 11-i srnn Ltq «tid heel this 1-9 iLlSuffic.ient tirm: foo the okimmurkhv tc) addrti&-, i hui i ssuc and vcry imixusid-urivu LIM Lila, Cm%hal placL-mc n G mml rc.gtilati i Mti k4 chc:x 1 OWCTti am ncrjA IQ wr% u (Tut emire Cuirumui i IV. 'Aura Uarrning ]s -&d ad W0,lfflIJWt suL+[-1orl th IN V1: I Io%.%r,r iiciw. C:awlyn '2" 2 r" Sridd lowup Drivc Milton, C;:t. 301M 7711-667 -6273- Robyn MacDorra ld 5ram: Lisa [IImi r,, -Il SerLi` Monday, January 11. M10 0:11 PM To: Chris L a�reF hlccrh Ce:-Norwall'; Julie ZahrwBaAay; R616yn. WeDonald Subjec-1: T4&ibile Applicaflorl Cell Tower on HgpeweV Rwd- r%lr LagEtt?lagm, H8r8 is inforninL-an that bmn :;ILvi!n 1D rrra ftm ona rpt our resldL;n1s In CrWrbirmkaSuediwit-4iLm with regapds t:) the T. Mobile appiicaum fnr a6diiicnaJ call towertsl -Dekwe th@ hoard. and hls opposifinn- I harm ftirW id,ad th is to Ytmj With Mr. Wer's pm�rmis=_kvi Pl;ase f wourd 1a Oih t" -rt altnmq. Thank you for Vour asisstanc-@. Pease I@Lt me k now you ara In of this arrrail. ti�a a R �nko 14669 Timber mint —Orlrglrsal Message— Fmm. Ahs! Saner [nna�W-5arK-r460Il$i?uth.nvtj Funk: Flortday, Januar+,+ 11, 2010 8=01 AM To-, I3'sa-dlavm@crxita5t.net Cc� Gilk..,r Saner Subject: Fw: C=rrol's response T-Moblle-CeO Tower on Hopewell Rad- HELP NEEDED T hig s Ahniet Swicr- M v wife Uidc r Ltn d T I iV.L! a[ 14680 linibcr PQ]1nt..WLF dully � ppOrt Votir act ivlti�5 sLpains t this navy Vru jcP #:i;,:LI bokaer. I hi;W ;t 4111 ick WOTCh [mil ill my (311iilitarL. thv n: is no =Son 14) bav (,- U new vpweir in that= - They. cm mi m G7ir ag itx,.k s �y lmWving ilwlr a uipmeaE and a,nwinina tilt - M -Ore ars rV w sof isiv I mcU nds 015d L 1 11i11101 s_ rik,:Lse rtouz that tltiis hii;)rtilal i mils tl,ii vita it-olit my - [nvQ .ti @ utisr rt and 111th ti,Vrl 114:J With T-Mrtihi IL ttir ill-..! 11 s1 _.I rt I1 ti.11Y Lr Ucimp06-S- T-Mubily ewenOv tilos the A lo% i ne tea yuT- in MI11on, b It eipbCr. 4-4 S h Ii Sw Of A I phut ttLt AMR! rLA HI R L3 (1-01- ?4.1261 l 1 Lia- X84.225 S 33)11 Typic, ow -CIF. Sir"LarL height: 76 TM C)VCrpl I hci ghf : W.1 rn IL,gistranv, Ameri a t Tow rs_ liw-, I S �A 1- land Leri -'e. StAte A, -Marietta, PA, Y1 7-F P h nu- ( 679 i 265 -6n p 'Chis iN our: of i he P( -(' regissr red I i iwt� r% in Al pha rets WNW i Ron sirt:i. Th r fin) lkivied new- vrl I tinver in ]jqjp1V.1We11 rfE.t41 0r, 1- .A% l.11 stn � m Hem Vrom I his l43et$ i{Fn, It k na GI n-vcc.4.4a ry to ha -V40 cell t kwe r!6 this€ Oain , in 1%iLa I wrc:i%. 1 r'll -,'% While hits pr1j blehts in I It a fine plaxc{I nins cell lower a rear, i Ivey 61 n in a reale I he 1 i-.1 rpsmi i for pow e" .in I he i xijs -"g k cif toxxer iuntl :iilmi A 4n p�c lbt« A n tai tilt #q; i,,xpnn d the eon era go trt m tli 6 tom -c r. if then h ay.- i kapAe 111• kSsar. thy- trine 04 pAn d lh cit u n It at thj$ 124:031iu hiiM tr 10112.11 ii(Prt 10 It a&Ve ma re c hitr neLLa a -%-a lliihle <Dr the Call tramv. '1 -lure i L, nnol hcT cxistitig l+}" r :a1 [he a�k9dt ss {#ir�c1 to he ti �} tivtti tot+r��r a nnI ter tiEhfi �I FI wv ); Ch rrqi rte A V vrrr, I1'1 I i I I livy t) N ft --31: ,14-(Ai66 a I. t}n- -84.� MM), ' j YPC-. l 0%VVr, StTUUL1rr ircig%1- 54.9 m. Ovi rail hci ht: z9 4 m PLC Mm rjml : t n i3 in all I I U. i 10(j ri Orsi L )ri k c_ t_'=03IN1%LJr; - I'A 1 17, 1' IUM12 ; _; f, j 6-4; -2� 14. I _kll: d 1 t''i'=Mubl ic` ncfidsi 10 add .3 nfahtur Bell in N1 it Ion. I h q ca n rpse Lhis e � imtink lu-% v r Bio h v x e ne Nw hlmtL -�La>; iron. Ibey eu n 2Agn a Ic u;-`.2grt,etnOut -with C'ripyr-n C-Astle USA on rp irati«n.1 ars wis u m inn that R h is 6 p a I h in I. di fifer-Vn[ flFty II Ii* c urrt n I II row4,-RT thty use from A m L! ricau 7'ONVOrS. I u{--. rk IJIDVc Lor1 Andersuki lid. Thi• I�rL,pj2;ud cL:J l t wi r location at 1lopc L%%;l l roLLJ -LS'Aor a S-Uitable kiCal icm 1ki r k v lI 1 ow -us- Sincc- Lhi, pJ;iL:v i s DOL 1 hU hlghc:�i Iaul i na, the g grurllical Ivnpl ,- lie! :mwd ih s toy i ani req ukre 41�Ji !cr.! 11 to%ytr 143 t Uvi-- rea1 oiiabJe -covj-,FuL!f t 1Iwv heed to hm-c hl pji -inl vn na lower tp have ix vi 51hl.; E. lh, v n,. -cd to hayc more I nu-im1 551oq p4,xk'rr 34 hich 1 % trot &--',',1V J I'L it the c I i ocu i L W; I I prLivi-da to th-f hutstari%; (�,qjecial Lr n1ir rhi [dreil I iflsd anifflaN (IlLWI-s_ pe Ls nd i -Clio I Ivi ng unimak iu dic areal r: Fu rl hermore. I here i% n ri d dt:l t ra n.wpn r1 u etwo rk conn ec iivily At th v rice%i rei9 n etir unto ww Irocu I iirn i Go rn rr�- the x' i f- v urid :lt t ra fii* lip the fin la Eic -rc is p iku roc, Sy x ICTrrs. TH ecPu n-vet This umv cA l to the Ir dll`tYvvyk eit he r i Ii cy iv it I d iF ul w :m d bring Tl' corn nect l -v illy frPosn Lind erprown d cl r tJh cr'.wi II e,se m iO rtp%v*% v tra ns P4) rl Ii n k % 11 i -V11 W ill bVt%ult UlIk011kir d4knger to or, r euX-i r0r1 ikkeuL N nhcody wan1p. m is rowave n -w -en likes igu;ds tn'k elling, nu r over head. [r1 mt i Ppin ionL 111V rk-' ' k V11 14 fW',-r L2 Iii 11 1IcL!k7S Et V, 1 -64, bike 01311 W3 IYe LAT tLIWOrA in LLie 41,~u ( I I w v ,rrr leas [herr, LLVO miles lfom the TICIV Ic,c {l11011.) Md UffH e]mprUVV, c,.-i2!irg FacilisJc-�: to e�d-cnd Lh Mr CAI vcroLI, e Ise I Crit j- UIt,lxi,tg 11110 ;i 3V. u 1t)VaIiUML I r is riot U6SUIUke I]�shy for the 4c) pa ;um and Mil to EL Chv C= 6I should recceI h i �n� roj,niwzc`c1 ilii r 1 C141C.5T. 'I.liirl:t Saiwr lrifunTmilon ftm EST -7 ?vOD32 AnLjvITl15, ►eobar)tM CIf 4'ii'W; S i gftturu datclbul l ` -17:54 (3111 FHM 1 i}$) Hit wi-ssapr r+wuN tiltcekvd by _ NODI 2 Ani -1O iM'�. hit r1; i 44'W%. L etaL1i11 Itiforuii Ion i'rL;rrl FES FT NOP -32 Anii1 j nkk L. %-er5lcirl or vlrw, ,' gmi kre 4amhuw dim o i ow i i,) The me Igo tt,�s -cI1i ckL4 by ES 1;-l' NC -)1).12 ANikiru:�- ftk�y.n MacDonald From; pltn �ott Cott@bf-ll5ov1;h.m1] SuF *wiinyr, i2nuar� 11. 201-D ib:!5b AFS To: ]Zn4rp iw c.DprLaH: Jar�- Loekyvood BuFt Hawt, Jap Lgrm�oria. Bill Lusk, N art Tart; KC rp-c) ThUrixarr Julie ZahrierBade-f ft �ellwulh net Subject= T -Mobile Nell Ptione Te er Civil mci-rning;. qty wik Fe ,°ind T r¢';idir1 thi: Girc'L"-I nc S ubd i visJ¢ri o LT o C F lop-j%v l l Rd. q'kr mvm dpx dpi?In Lcd to rcna v F an dpplicuilu!] W411 thu CLL}` from T-N-101hil- to L!ii-ct a 134,ft, iLil PiLOUL: LOWLT 011 tlu prL)POL(W OrSov n Gables 1-rrrm w 1449; 1 T &pci ul I Rd. TMS sill: Is It-Katud a Few h La ridred l Up thCL fOad ;LW at M frUM (}gar suhIVIA0a. W e op pos - ibis proposed appl IcC.YdouL for a numW of t roll`.. We �tronL3I i fes 1 t]�lat the JAL- f- othl. -�Il' sil k, �� I ��� �� VVI 1I C (O[C all unLgagwy } iCU- 0 C' i1 from aur h"Ime l� WO I I a& Jtt)rai Ch��� (lie r5ttt rLelghhs1M, h% CL µe47 Foul t�-L1 i t i i rmr-ormb I L: 1.Lp bp- wv=wd above ffiv onpagt a CO iulaarph�aw tmw-T ha -r on licalth, pwTmny v LW X. W VJ I I W tlOilIW(ILIS 01 t I W �Luftlutxl iiL 141!11L apC_ We andL!f:samLxi that them qm of lier iiawei'%- lra d Y evistirlg tluciu Ilrl LL NI I I i o n Lu id -.%v- ca LA 7xuc khe lx c'[.I t'or mother. We wnt to 6 L, -%k thai. the pRpIgAi nn 4 . 'ES dkj Iv VY�Wr01 rl!d by *Lh I ttclu Nild-mi thitid ptl rLy c imtt' clur 10 dric- mTtuc- 1 F -1avh N towor i s r-cisily rmunsxary- .,Md. for i F it an 1 -pa nt=hod or rr ltica d tD .3n LFx IstiiLL-) vu l l i(i WL, -r Oca! L.. butt. 'A+e X71 pr-O4101E 3'11131 CL MILLMMI ll) 1]7g4)kir l=L iilt�ia.4ts imij those of Lw n-FmraLknIi f vverall_ Wig h47fie you WL11 Wrik)II Y COT15Ulir oar COWCrnS rmd sUFrpOrl 115 in PA-Itccti W11' COY OUr ClAj FTI�nt. but vur h0mcoN&Tner 711Lk:k1r1]�lLliN Wt!l1. F'h=� V4Q- RL gjwvfi i I Iv. K affiv &' .10h1l 5171I1 M F t, 11�1l Il�u� klio %-T i 11on, GA 3004 s lay Tzmobi I r TO ObtU11L n Linc 17121711 it CO r a 150 Fcaot CW1 i!IOUbPO le cell [Lzy.cr +A I11 an 111 iitntml 4 rfirps Ij'ghVtirig n,j for a toatj 0I 1 -5-4 Ee5n (Article 19-4-7? Robyn MacDonald From: Chris F_ageerblo n Som: Monday, Jonugry 11. ZJ14 14.11 AM TD-. Robyn MadaltE S Ubject= FW- Proposed T. Mqbila SII Thr >rrorm Lisa tmalito`Iis#_diawn@comra5.net] Saq#; 5awrdap, Jamory D9, 2SID U 2=41 PM To: Tisa Replof fie: Chris Lagerbkwm: hurt Hiewit[;.BM Lusk; Karen Ti hiirman; ]ode 2,�hnorGokffy; Jk)i--- L-mgoriai Joy Lr wuod: 'Nory+4I' subject: "osed T-Mobffe CeII.Tr r bear r .1p1 ax rMr-n nd T_teclk d C`nn nc it Iolirmb r .. ks a hrknr{ tPw n -r 1n f' Ira rl3 rntiLt! *u k3til %isjott c& -F vivvi-s ROM] .1 u Pa runct-rnieil v LMibut :1 ry CVM Al M11li-URtd HI f ilod l r� 'f- It LMI ELIC I LM CULIS tl'uc I & I Et, r VJJ I EM 1'r n L srrh� U n 144'5 1 I OJ M -MC 11 R -U.1 1. I I I ;L3'tF la-UL!n i rl cW1I:tt t r� i#.fit a�ri�p a'1 N. om-11to m 4 unm I3-rcPA F:e rm s i-cT ardin m I h ig 1 ow-rr 11gi] hnvv t he f[rrllmi ng cnnct mr : • E'hi p1weern-ent of Ow �4w.crvrllj rr-vdt.� all railsr;; l;tiarenkl oift i+ muni-I.ricl a1��.5�3•'kfdMl ];-v mwer hi!r.'+ tfw C?rLltri ~ Lu xw -thrunsu Gonalhi Robyn MacDonald _ FarOEfi:: Chris 1-4gerbWM 900: Mondj3g, Jana ryr •11. n10 1 G 08 AM T.7. RQbyn MacDbn�ld $o*t; FW. 0Ippcs1tiDm to T.Uubile pelltion frsrcall tower on 14+485 -Hopewell R-DaC Ftvm. NqNd f m ftt it l d �ttn,et] s"; Friday, hrwaiyr D&. 2010 1.151 PIM To: Chris Lager r rra SUbjt;CC: 0"Q'SIkiDn Eu T-Mlckllie piAlb art Far cell tomf on 14495 Flr�pFwMl Road [Uov Mr. I,,x�L`r]lldM1711 This I'S ]Brio N L) L'4 -C'1 I. 1 n til i n o«Ir .;; Gooks to 1-bi) pnipam! tl T•Alobdcr 1 ;94' m unopale on l Holl-L`W(I11 Re) 11(1. 1 h.,krl n n1C'f'tirk9 WEtb Rob Dus4mnu_ the IIOA Tmr sic1ont Of(irflV11b-Mf• u noigh Norhund rLcrr)f;s t he tit rr e! I. fi-01tl I ItE, V rQ 130. 41d. >tQW LFr. HE IM 4 11V L-11 LL City p 1 yin MU i n l. h v Pa y I. i L nd Wrirtt`il numu l-ous vl.rltu ng l aw r: t i+ prat( nu i -,171iri rho )tip Erom i ia1-1.:r11 ri # io:t +kf c -t`11 t I IW+I r 1 fe h rta ugh II up w--; that € hould bo eiplorotl bt tht- efty. ratornoy t`E'. P�f) Y1 L11 �Lr r_xI,!Z! In;; VC -11 covcrtl gc,. «(! mg I:wo nec!d a n u alai -Lr ped third panty- to -evaluate 1.hu jutilm gu Dun �411t1}' iiiittated by T -Mob ih4 w, to t ho me fl For Lm>_telth-or tow L_`f. l'1a4vI` ir0L!0ivf-d Pikl]Ileycii.L4 eMWIS TO-ikidlil1g t}V.1V116?n1l 1.141 ill tbiL. lLri`iL_ it 3mlFb!.Li nib' 1Y011�l`r 54'Ij 'L'LS 171`L!tl LI7��[ll[`I' [tr' 'E`1'. '�'hr_T:' Lire f f I'L+;'tktjg4l'L.`Lk II raIl LtLIVHglw1.L.•i041 Vo 11 uIWL`r: Plnd i FJlt.El'i11C9 H V4li hill A -1 M 1 k- 1`Aaliu:: t I f S{' VUn ( i i Flim• ]' ar[nr:. IN I I ar I. o f Hui wr+ f 7 ii FI - W 31 hi 11 2 Mi1fij� of i iii:; location. My h u y] w n&a T -M ul Filr7 L;L�ry ic+i nt a;ur aliltlrL`.---..s 4i gurl(l. T tip il nLk W1 Lli Leo 610 i k1W-3t19#LtxFi1 ave m,,4 digo).vi,, r tlu t -ft cofl mvel'a 4ze is :tdoclua L tO. rind a0l�Drdin � I u tai+F lE•' `: rulitif,F rerd ink rn�i �ti Lr-iY1ai Ii t ar�M p rf)N' Ecjia1: I C`LJ�'L' i igt! tht+ e1r �vcjr�lil l all Fl�� LI'I ck-,-n ' Wi? Ilcu raon bn,;L-d On �i d E`q uate r.4`rY]J!L' 1L [ j'V tt(J y U-ML4 -. The t:it.y neerk tv.tit+ cau iour-, wht`n IIre.Lvdiur- With thuLig. F1+!11t 1i)r]F SMI' EIIJr7r %VklI 111' I It.PL!. f_ -d til Lh+• v uLa L -r; L1 P1 11.x` Df :711 MU913 [MY110 Cdr- iii L�JIJLog I`srr cr;ll triNvj, J• ja I i 14'1! Ulk! 11t alt 1 1}t, L wkiit L tuy rFeighbL7rhta(Ili Lk, bL- i hL` t k -.ti ing ffrOtLlld.1 i'rjr 111D C'itV Of MID i Irl vigr,i k rJ i 11>< 1 -ho la 1:7 vc ►11�!TIt of towers in regi U-nr.ivl a rr!rE�;. Thi3 nk Y4)11 fhr }'rrur Elm C.. Re�,,FI L;UMly. Robyn MaGDorr81d Fran: Cera Libgetloum Sent: Voi-.-Jay. J anuaty+ r 1, 2010 10_137 AM To: Rsib� n Nl�r_E analjj Su"17, Fes: Proper3ad T -Mehl& Call T6w@r at Says n Gam Farms Fmm. ]u9Ie Zahner5 !le? Sant: Frldyrr )anriiar1+ CK3, 2010 12;20 PM Tom: Chrk5l rbh�" W Km Jarrard Subject: FW: Pmoused T461oaik Cell Tower at men Cable, F�Jmis FYI. From: Tere5a-5t]L1kels [rrrgay@.wahm,com] Sent: Thursday, aftCrnber-3ar ID09 LI:4I AM To: Dort FlEk,rrtt, SWI Lusk,{ Alan Tare races E Th us man, Julle Zahn iley , Joe LockwoDd, be Loregana Subs VrQroye1 T•"Ile 02h Toww al Seen fxibles Fi�rn-L5 Dear Mayor and Council Membem, I wonder if I could asR you to do me a favor9 Wh-en you are at home, go stand on your front porch and F❑ok alit over your yard. I'll bet Ift an lovely, view, c ne In which you tale pride Now,. imagine that view ,marred by the p re8ence of a 154 foot call Bower Fight In front of you! Can you "Ine hcrw that ,night k ok, and how it might affect not only your enjoyment of your horn, but a the p roperty va lue? Now, 9 y uu'll indwige m€, o no ma re time: ,mag Ine that a oe Ii tower has bin propos8d to be built in view M YO UR home Can you honestly tell rnu-- that yDU would v** "y�-" to this proposal? It you wouldn"I vote to -put it in view of your own home. I would respectfLllly+ ask that you riot vote to put It in front of mine_ Tere5sa Sticke Is S unnytb rwk Fa rias- Resii:Wnt Ro n MacDonald From, Chr;s Li�qerblrsdnn .Sent, i andayr, Januar' 1 t..201a 1-7 D7 AM To: Rgbyn Mac-❑x5roM $ubjue7 : FW. T4&Ie CF.11 Traver ori HopoWaU Road Irngorlarj-Pe: I1I11h From: ILLN? hrler82L]1e'p Sent: Kruayr, 36nuary 08, 2010 1-219 PM To. Chris Lacgerblo� Cc: Ken aarraM Subjed-P FS4; T-MotNle CeIi Tower on �IwewEN Raad Importan= High FYI From: N-urvd jP1PPi0B ;fijtL' net] t-. ThuFWay, 13emniber 31, 21)W 11'_21 AM TG; !�,ait ;- ewikt; E itl ; Ftarf-Lo Thurman; Jules 7a hreF5nk1L-y,' JLC LbOwbW SL!.bje rtr T Mobilu, X11 Tcwff. cm Hopemtll RLvd [)car kl nno rabk Mayor and E I-mcd Ci+wn it kl embpi _q, ijm M hL, mLm i "11et' kv ffit! Stuirivbi%txik F r, mq not lxarlioDd_ l r�Ltnily rL' t. i vf�d a letwr emicc.ming I hL�, P. crit'��rL drL�asti 'r -Mobilo ft,rvrin'SSL ti3 ce.ri!.rtp= o 11 4 fuol i77om)pu6 on thL: [)rral�my iii u �rL i -a t es 1=nn Ic tod 111 1-14 k� 5 I hi "A I Rod wli Lch J�i A[T_1m Cnt W jay ] 13�LrV Q ViC%%cLt d 12 SftU nLap FL, r pI ac yr rn� 13f i11V www_ fly. plaCL-mcitil 0r1I Lr tim" r wil] orwic Ian 11risightly.view of thL, 1mwr. fmm MY frow porcll as, "M11 as I t r 21rr�� Lpnid' q i LeighbVI'S. I I' the I ower L.N III UVCLI at %_k0l0 1 ��i!ak I S, ihr, 01TV I.iUautsful driti� al�,ng l la,lxiV KLm4 wilt 1V. LIi.ST11111eLl �1.9 L -DIL ai"rO&-A thi s bE;Lut i 1151 1:1tlo f:7rm LLs the hie SEatI4111 4r1L1 1 LAA. -N W'] U k in ful l w11UNV Ca;}alr itW Fuad. YOLr Cat. dri-'O tO HifrLibigbmn ( ms nxick a37d SLLWIWt that Jj)V&r h,J:5 Jc,,,e �U ThLLt Lame brn u Li f li :ircu ;PS WJ' I M� 011 U bnpplc Ruud bd I nd fliv l.'ydbappk i nol I vettOr dry V1 in ic. 1 rnm O To %.] dton in Nlav D F 2Nlt},4 M tkp im, Inv bor.�4 ;r ffilm R os..wl [ W Viij m. a MLJ rc rur;kl, ,L.Cs;t lc L -3 -CLI I IV P IuaLm rLL-1 zn �; ITOMti PC in -win-ch W hmLk%j rn y tiaelg], Jx, n LL -3_ [ rLx*V:d from a na«i di% i i Irood i n RopLvell amt pled w..,tL!r tL7wLpj w i11iin -,�f o 1eL:t Lei' m w front pore h I haul ii ti-ej iju! re tips. 17 y iim i a 1,uud I Ld surmundings. ] rLCVL-T i rra;kgar,.2d 1 ���c�AI [to 1-LiC Vd "* the distur[)-3nc� L� I L 1 a� I r+til ��1 r l; rti1 � r Cr�ti���lJ � �r11���L! i rL ni} li Ltiiil yard- This iii L: is r1 �llt i rL did mir div ,pf .9 rr sidvni i L11 w6,1 11 IJL�d w A home in l Itk- til idd I -c to u pp� r tfL� hraLA vt pri %v1,1 [gig lVli 1161 L WI th. gcn-CiAI'I"' 6LV CLLwR. Our nv-igh hoffio [ ii apTuMe4.[ Qt thti LhouP 1L 4ti I` t]& t+�'A U r I0s}n] irsS IA e r k, ur rreigHporhok id a,s lviti ] I u� stLrrroond I ni< tLv i-1Itihorhoods_ You Will hC .9bTc 10 SC -e this t(nv cr fIr mi [cfi no n Lin ct h g)w T -L lobihl, want s 1 o dispi5v i L. I 1 hint: -it Is r-rasonablc I;:�r pgciplc up Kl eonL%r'U -d about lliv 4 t1co4 Of r)�irnity TO L•t1] i 111 it pfiorw 1 o%tem kin lie.,tItl1_ their pn3p rLy k u I mb. L111d the :105Lhc rle!s of is hii Me... knrtid_sra}ur_ TI .,If Ltnl-oir W 'd ismi tis lai em iatc-rc-stg ag mLTcly Nyrnpls}i ; of tho "not-in-my-h�Lckvayd" sx-n onik! :u3d_ iliercRim. intere-511_ W be iUnvrCd NVIWI).T W [IrLaj Glt?rLLLik)rL Of ceUul Lar p]iont %ke%� 6 ai SlAu. - Wv may. kazmt to :L;suniti that I -C'(:' }r'.131J irLIS for ale.trr7rLt tmc1is i m1-bi( wiil fari)Wet. q1c pubric ht�llh, _� LL-sUMption is prCm Lal LLM, i x cr1 il�� ]:u c Lam L7L1111 71` cin cii I M ies iti t u; rtisver. t on the qul-j NL L cuIAAbe lick d 4 iCLIT vomcljt%, iJ ps, l,he E: UC Wei 9 tulLx th,.L1 Mk.Ladl irI t[tii-.4 orw ry I rale d LO ]ti urrrrvi haul th 111 LI -�a fc-1 �' 12� OMOjn� mJ 1I14 v�on � Lu rt' n1Tm!d1d&N1 -Njm; 1 -ani ks aM PiOo ih Ij! :111 1 iii I��ri 1'.V. W- rh That Odni.1 tt2Li u00mAimy. tt iS uwcasomi.blc u3 to imidarLls ELI Wildly accopt Lho dctn ludicating that ffiLm? is mi Iwakl1 rusk :ts�c 6ri.Led'.Nitk Vxposwru. iu I�,.L&o Prequetw-w I R.F I o iw rVy tuJiatud 6} c�11tii1: Roll�y n Marpom Id From;- MIc�noe Ver.Stee-gin [mVarvee pmuas�niatj Sent: Sunday, January 1 r), 2010 7:25 PM 7n; NoNell-. Fancy Cuter 'Raeh'eJi SCOW; 't�eq,Vidu Thipmes' 'Krystaj. T " [ Iso' 'FSM,kdl Luxton'_ 2jv2i.D9',rld PrWmcW: Uke,Dee Belrrve ; 'Donald, Valerie MurnW, 'PatTiWZ S:irrrrnr�l'. 'Lmda,kamid KahvEuadeh'; 'Tc:im,Shannrl Washhurrl'; 'Davld,Llnda Fail'; '1 inuonl.Margarel Willratft! 'Bdl.l urrllko jkmiesmi', 'Debra LaryJr-Li rti , 'a ngie,5h n Che5hira 'Jw-k. Michw-!]a IIwasn' 'Shawn, Camrina $irrrrwT,s'; 'R-pn �Wtk; UimiOla 1�okgrt' Cc; Chris Lagefflo m; Robyn Macaorard, Burt Mawr; Bnl LuskKaren Thurman; ,PuliF,- ZahnerSailey, Joe Longoria; J 1. ockwQQsl,'Eddie Lea BMWW. paTtiaihra m41: Cnm subjoet; Be: Cell TOWET - in su ppurt Atltac.hirlent ; Erncuinn 1. g11 One of the reasons we are op posed is th-e potential health risks to children. I have heard of studW-s inking cell towers to a higher risk of leukemia jamongogrer nsk5) and thisreaIts y cares me h Just seems that th Is Is still relsllvely new technology & we d onrt iu illy know -all t I, e potential d a ngers - I a IveRys recpad sumefx s ng h t to do wh-at Ihey ware will h thei I awr1 property, bowever, I J ust n't support it if it could potenil istly h a rm my ; i ,.,just a nother thought ... of cGorsia I enders "d & respect your thoughts as yell Nsrscy.& Eddie Lee '-' From, Norvola Seat:: Sunday, Januiuy+ 10, 21010 7;M PM TQ. r�-nor _ 'L!e�Vlck1 DAV*1,Linda Half Yimnt.M �t WI� ; 'gill YUYndM 4M son ; 'bra Landrum' ; Am rdlrhelle ty.0Ii,' i' ,m, Cpmlini� Slrfniam' ; 'Jell, MIc I,elJer�e ' : 'Rpm F Cc, ; bUrt-h t tyQfrniltnrlaa_Ug �11LJ��K,x��milton,�a.us ; k.ar�rr.thurmanfa:tiL�raFmilk�rl�a_us ; uMlc �ahrrer�a;l�cit�o�fmll�r�a.� ; �,l���or�it';roimllt� �,sis ; lc�_Ir_��nad�'s,�1t�r�fr. �dtcrl�t a _rte ; '�di� L� 8r►+t�[�1'. � �P�b51� �rF����vr[3 Subje4fft: Iia: Ili Tower - In, srupgort � )M- r1r1illi ti1.3H- d L'[]tiuM(3nt, MLwtk. T'MnViliL 3i'Ljnta t j 4.pUt thi,,: X11 Lex Vr+ in +Fi#r LxrrrtrltWaMl-' rtrlt WIL R re lCli'_k' U Lr lLi�Jl {'.I]4 vrt1 gty but be -e -i tiRi. T�U.Y tl ru bi R:�y 7� f!k'Jven I ga - 117 i h t6 ai r4,�1- T W �.' LAII 0ji -ir IL' -i yr- an (th-L v I (mean; thuril. K-T%re thi_L 11 r{.;J gU11 � nit:61Y ATM ltli I Vt{' 1!t rirl j F I i 3J'1 �d in voli1 M r�N-a i�l �r-rsr: h tit t hav want their uw rL t o cur t€1 o)q l vun tt� e,th.01- J -31M a�lr� e4 tv h ,i! t Own n r1llow 0ir4ro If l 21-041P M11110n2Z from Charry1114-7 recn�i_ Am. You bu-P,11 ing Lo s012' whit i, [1 tiaPp�! TL I ng Its-rk) ? T1 +.' Xtirs P t(i Ir{! fl lMUt I7-13r`ri] 11- L E'L` - CQ 3 3 d M -511'e rLbUll I IVI)O lz �n rTLg ! 0 P-P*fit r 1j+- M r gir W Ili 1-f. I 1W - poor i - poor re-gidenTs- iy ho didn't need the service in t hrz Jurat ]1,1 111,912- I Lre i ht sari i w• on 4,.s lr. f 1. mit i t i n t Its* 4.1)1(1- ,U tic 1, M r,Bn' a- hay. only frw nee t 11t- propfLA-y for 12 yeq rrh. Wh 7evv l- this H- j rm Litt " rrr u rn ci-M • I i vo thort- w i t}i thom_ Bim l'Clli�g hDrst-s x!l not Choir firs; Li 1 ; Lnd h Li t tt-r_ Al rw}, l 1 ]tin k 14vi ll sLe rho ci-Al r-nwFLr l��>3Y- aft er F' m Uanth_6 bl" 1s. L�nr-i1. Wk! 1111 [ Wil I I'll 0 It t1 V. �}1121 t� 4 tear rk1 d.rzry n w ii rn Al r t11ir tLrvvipx W h-L-ro Won- a 11 funnag wiil U- p lamd an ti p. U.V. 4 xrc -911re, W -L, tire v ry w till i nfL, rr� otIl IR4twu +!� o. rrx;L kv a cir�uLzjion that c-an't lic rove i•�.aL Ka 1�Tui-vall + -- clCIJIniEi Message -- From: Nang gLft T -q: 'PAShell SCO' ; ,}irk, a, e stag TgnDrake' ; 'R6tP,J0d I Lukbixl' ; 'Ziun.cam PfikbWlrah' ; Mixa. Beirne' ; 'Do�;ald V31erie-MurraV, ; 'P$tri+sla. met 'l rjQy ar,!� rfi'. _ 'TT m. hangs V h urn' . 't]A�rltt.Linda Hall' . nthfiarraarBt Vyilliam�' ,'Bd I,Yvm+kq Jiarr n' ' tarp Lan ruM'; _�iaU E Ghg-A- k Michell ry+l I r_ ; '8riawn, Caroli nEp Sirnmons' '.�eF Miciielie Vei-Sgaa h' , �Ryon Soak" ; 2an6ll , Ce: pIRPiD89atLiniat ; Ch 1215 Lag rt> [n Tk Ott 1 ; Bain dVfaaxJanal it4dhrriltpr�d ITL1 _ t}urt iltanra_Lxs . bill Tusk cAyijFmii tcgcw.gs ; Lrarprr.6htlnrpnU "gnLii; lud��fsrterhalla.5rii'�11r�fm��ra�a.us.•, Ia�lan�graa�ri�CrFmilGan�a u� . jva.�ac3r�.r.�dw�imiHQrEn� �Ir} •, 'fir � L� _ rrattlslhrm� Corr, grrt: S llxd�j�., J-dtlk acy 10, 2D1 G 6:25 FIM Sulhlocl, C611 Tawe-r - In suppoil Pew Nc3 hharr, It L. lulmarE Llomm rhm we Lake for L-rjaLrd diCjWr gq. COLa VOU of aYejy4 r lire, owcT'JPain�L [ISE price We 11ee11 TO DIY SOF dion. rhrle A a popmal W pwt a zmU pl�e Wwttr In mir cumrnuliitY" Man) people wtld -yieW. kh6 � oil ev&%Afe wvA vow m Mirk 1', mcop fiz ermsinLu n. I would likt fa* to to IWp huck and tal-W,1 rook _u ibe Iizgget pitAAm. Seem LOabks It� %n nmi-to Our "Minuaaly. TIsa owwrr'q mmne k L•6jrrltioel 11 Ls rls}' -pudLvnLnnOLI:tt_RthAL hV JUS 1.1 11.0xC hvfnra r1wily {+k the I�rwaaha rrG built l� t wren i anw me fti tie tlf�.]Fkrd hLiyiny 11m cLitlritry ,lrtni�,rhl:ILL vhnn'E16 dhVr bu,ILI5n2 +1I yltt+�Fiw'k�iowl# rol�rti[l h In prtrtaL�rxti' I htiu•ovm, he 6NN bmn •wecy MOO to u� and ill of �- na ft' w0cmtriiry w4• vome to Lune to Bryn n 13'011s 14111121 VT�O� ht+ rnVr l%1jriV I f } 1111 ha%v mit luk Cv tlh�! UppvrtLin iLY It,'4isi1 I1LiMIML. I irr-v ) ow 1�5 Lb w FJe wc1 clnLrs It% to rc-mc ir1Aidl: ihL` glov.3, ,ind mi Ik mound - Wk'Itih- I IV SON � Y'Dil I k ILIPGIU Ilnd mlaiilLLl-C IaUnC% piue thtt ix a wide ransc PF m4htir ;LNimalA MMI YOU rtlLnnt}I 114V ITLIm 11m. roml I Iv nnsl flfs nrL`tallL:at IN trul} :iln ome c! h, cmi L;vmmmnLliy. 1 -irn• FkIILd wiL1L.Isr%' DYL:ry trntc J drive by vd 1001% to -art W W1[ ahrrmiJs MV iM aIle CnrrLT pns1 art lhal dau. Tim rrtsuvr: a I' S,C-yCh i~WhIc UFMIy incr-cases the vuJur Lrf -nLrr pr{rpM,r. 1 L emrnn FlarmLm' � msln wEaumz of bmum r Is from .qk4 Jrtg ilMhE'% mrkd -ke in g some pLrat&. Hlar.e and rtre Jjuw Irr0a� IMILllvr{.t in thL�r "ry hLSf'4 hveii iriald hitt by he dowrl [Ella in tkC t Ommny Pelimv fL4rsr im-nxrs hjd la sn11 hnrscs bozow r f lh-L raped risc in f MLI prkce. Eddle Lei iml I hak f i 141es m ILhI Fn1 I im JmH timrr..i nn,! IluVr to X11 Lite Twopvrty to :1 lk.vv6[+rxr. I P Shat rhoullO llnppce thT� l w•tit110 be JI iy! and pussibkv repL,i"d by n 14 11 drmiry d4vcrLLpm-i:nt to- hell brink m:nre- tax Lrwvmr Lig Mllt-mm thk +k41111A1 LIC I ifillel� Ie. J LLI A LleC liar= m our PTW1rr1Y vrLIUM.. hthm famnVrw aruvoLl. thm tL1+rr my hn" IImrLI IIS Immin., part L-Pr iFr¢ir land im -w iml;m i]IK or ctrl I umt- r3 I F ftp a cell i,rw L7 al. 5a:wl rp Cgbk6 11.1111 duabk. &M in may. in bmine5i uh[t bi; a vmilm ] nritLhbur rur }xurs iso- risme- t .ten A I fLLT a.11mvinT a cell Unver dpi be rdiW li an hint pv l}•, Thiti• Ix a big p Iron Pr IahLI died It 13 E+Laxslhle 161 yriu wire"l be Lhlr.1L� met r1m hAvur gall. I um HUM WE 8LL Lcmern ber Il1r! 4mtra@e mg 6clt AWn pimp Ic sLirmL3ndi`Ip vnr•of Lwr 43traU4dL- ucighbufs prulxrt} thtruttincd bii husiac;-q by LTHL'nrfatink to mtriOt few lte CaUld use Itis pmpCm+ NLIWthat Ihr rubles are lum[i:� I w61uW rn€<lLlF1 Mtlt rV11JUJ1L1w'r titid lusw n LLad *nr attrmpt ujprenlutSewn C'sah cs 1Toln iLiinp this pmpmy in a wnv Ih�t %jiuld iOtow thtm uq rd1 girl b"It11y. We liked in £ollFumia For mmW yms: As InomAnd more rryh•Ictliv% were pact cm t1Lt' I+w of luud,.mllny ghmll b>jsft egsArr 104 their .dhili3y ris Ull'}'lup, alld M•r u•:.IIL110d ffrnx'rr fiLld.1 i IL1118r IL11Lr FlcHVIO NPDL.L LA m nlso la& at OYIV ftwrl rIL411t4s114P.11I Ilk 1h [$. TF4CM1I Pl OM-R ;OHkF Mks &I Mul 111901141 "PLULL1 14 pmY'P(lr Ihcirgruw r3E ukl5 imar lm-e VL ilh t ki ,;Iodil i ml 4:Jpai; iEv for Wo" iu TT111g arld G 3 S"VLC� rltc� 54tit1Id hi it lm spmldhir -, mwimun to laird tlhuse ttiwcm YOM 1IL4F }44c ave rtitid Paddy. bell will tl+� M NeV rkWs. I r yDu ur4 LTpDwd la+ rhO5. imL et. I11 rmizlin IogKoll ytw 6OULd r mtel }4�itr �:cll plmw 15e, I­Y lie. T VR dwt MOAt fArl'41 9 ill c1LIt MNt ViSiuh Ian 4r.! ill uhiply v*It phem N Elim are inud fur Le.k3ia� 4W] m-milim mimmu ic4ims. ralW*;Nit kir rm Llclm. Wv. WkAl +r by LIpPO.kArls lhl!l tel I iivi aw .3Itd mkeZBt I Ilat you 11.11-ft Li1:9 N7r11r Sr,LaKe. YOU HA LMin?= 4 5+nhM17IK P- tNmh(lL1 l Lja�e$ Ia IM-; wrP[rEul i,pLm I,pacc hL1t__-1;.! fmmi, all is 1�I1.H L VftkjthE Ag Y61J Wili'll.tiwdLa noiiOLP -M AjjcTjkQl`It6 - N:uw%- Cinterand EEL- L,ix Spawn RoUn MacDonald frim= NorveJ1 [pippiN att mt] Sent: SundAyr, Jahixgry 1 �] 2(11 a t. D.2 ISM T¢; Nancy Ci diet 'RasheIJ art'; 'L arr,Vii Thames: 'Kryslal TMV Oram!'; 'Roh,Joidl Luxlcn' 'Zi,rapa + d Pmkolrlct r. 'MIkp, Die MIrC4e% 'Dcxialil,valerle MI.I ma r'; 'Fatriv+a Stimimi�; 'Linda. Hamij Kahvazadeh'- Tom.Shgnvn VYashbwFri' 'Dovid, L1•,tLa Half; Vincent, Marge{el Miatrs'; '18i1L,Yu ni c5 Jarrrasciri ; 'Dabra Ladd ruun','ami ,uhawn Cte5hire ; 'Jack Khphg1h-= McAIYallx'. 'Sh"n, rcpIIna Simmarrs', 'Jeff. 1111 ]BII 6r tR� h'; 'F I SMtt'' 'Dignic4le. C Chfris ugarbidipTil, Robyn MacDDnatd; Burt H wwiti, NO L. 5k: Kai" Thurman, Jolla Zahnw58 ifeyr; Jtde Lan ia; Jae Lvr_l(w; 'Eddie L! LO 1�r*rrr'1'_ pait+silwa mac:cam SU:13juct Re: Cell Truer - tri nupPan L 11111Ltt1t1i1;1 I'0MIII f.`JtL_ Mainry T•A'Icibile %vnntt� tcL pgjt i III ;'C'El 1.1WILr in n 14 Viim 11111llji.v rvit I I I ':, Lt 4t- kV I rL r�- 1, tck i.I § t* 11 ['fit's ge but bc-ciiuso THEY Urc 111+k -Ing v)%,V" g0 in r 1, i ; s r> Ilt. Tb p.v i' -I rl i'tI-it11 'LL1 151L Iii E11• I' ItF '4`1' LhM. AL3rvn the muern {1kl]C- Jll(•L` v :ind have heeri pIjioed it) 1', 1ITFPl OOML9l ai reau 6ul I l ire' V.r9w thoir Ll% -n tAIWti r Lr I cti''inc.-I Le of her pnsvir;1{'i~ w hic. L C b o d #1 I lowt the rpt tc) rMP mil] i6n K t'I�rr,ti 1! h,(1irg1fl9' &P �_ f rxL Y01J irr,.��i�ning: tO.�r+r! Wh:lf 14 h.l I)INr n I rtL' h 1Ire? 1t remwa tOhK:� 4111011t. rl1-udIfig zind morx1 iibout w ho B gning to profit the TLSrmL w hjlc chl I}ot,r' nmid LTJ L L, vir h�, 1-11 rl r1'r. Itr•1.t l k 114.�1 LL% Si -LS ill thi} fire P �;1CYF :il'E+ t h+j]� � only r I' y k-1.1 r Iit1l in t.h�� �'1,] d . Al:{i>,. S1ii 1 ti i W T;M 11 111 �, r'1.1 Li - rl .� 14 112 yuL a fry. NV' 11ift vcLr Lhk; H LLnU4 Mn ili mil it. only l vcL them wi t h I. hent, Rfmrdiuy 111.11'S- 3n I I I I I t I I I! jr 7btcrji4id 111111 Irtilttr-.r. A]--(5. 1 I.hzn'k 1 w 1 ] ] {rrc i hk% r,.(d l tfnv t - t' I ng; fl flo r 6 xtmonthg 1>k s jr�l-soil . WL-, Jh x i1L Th6y hit v -L, Ftu T7 k4r futfir. L-XpLL.nr%iraa for this tower WIL,'r1' Liat1fib forit(innaR W111 15(1 phic-'ed.illl too - J,(�Vg br-j gLire RAF} iirc- vcty well Illfk m{+d bdore vm.m�Lt a dL' uklion f h a r 4'A1n't Twi rl~v{1nicd_ Kay No rwJ I — OtiglHar MgWaP From; t+far,cw Cutler T : 'L shill Sett' , 'tee. is p T1 Thr n Q[i�k! ; ;Roh .Jodi Luxtr 1' ; ` wa. yid Pick lc 1' ; 'M13ce_Oee Ba,r ' :-Donaln,Val fie Mumu _Pat - - $D. nMnE P; _Lyda id h fah, 'tom Shwmr+ W=iburn' 'Dwid,L]Ada He Wdlranls- _ 'Blll_Ytjmlka ,lerrlaeon' -'Der I� r� it m' ; '�h4iir Shawn Ck rtr, e , 'deck. Mlehell r+ n' : 'Shawn, Oafo ane Simmr5' ; '&f, LN Ver8.W : '1R 911' : 'Danielle 9lakerf Cc: t51Qp�LMaCLtl t, CrMrl .{ +�erblp�rn[ r��r rry ,fm 4 y ; pyrn.MacdonaldCC�CAYOfrrialU3rW2.L1'S. t3Lfrt11ewdI lCaC rndC .u3 , blll.tus�prnL -=3r$n th!prrranQc3twflfrn11!OncW tJ% IIJbim.�hrl rbail I cll�afmihpan��.us , I�-n rq n it rlmific�r.na us , �3e.leckwocdOc tYafMIItatiga.Us . -Eddie Lee &CW11' ; oaML5IIv2mac Com Sort. E�urLday+, ,banLj.ary 10. icy 0 '5^ 5 FINA SubJac7; Cep T"-aF • In suppclrt Mar ; kj$hbfim It. 11 hwtQM rimae dia Ac LaAe 1br u4mcd IIIC JsP�,C Lmd LY I`!VCO r cR Of 0,eeydak' li fe'r ofxrJWVpgg rho price we. n* to plat' rnr t[imtl. 17hLua u e prup sal If, put a ct1I pbaft wk�cr In 1}r MY lV Will VjVW R11IN JeL iia OVC-913C and V*1i to 31'13r],ALI tilop Ili cdmuit+ 515- I u e,Lld Itice-foe us:ta Mtp bad -and I:tk-L! a link w 111c.biggrr pichrro, ,�;k1,:�i -Giablcs iy :rn -vs to oslr cvin am Tltr uwNr'r nnrw is U3rML3n l[ i9'irt}+ t�rld�i�laL�d� tIy1L11� 11 3 Yl�en Tti 6cfi'� rewh�' cel the wbid Iwisium were N Ill III rNii KtH 14111. iUM 01111 #te L�ir;liLetl hnYbLU die L:4%u =7 uLiumpboe Ch,- ipJ k?y the Ni1iIT1rfiG', of -jubdivisions Z!'Mund his pmp4lt�'. l I uweV r_ 11%3 ILR6 �'ejL "% l0 Ild 131 uK aniJ.311 of you by w--lt.-rntuli evervo w Iia cunte Iii S Kr1 €'rablcs and cnjm' $is mcniquIc I I yriu havt rwl cAvn llw nppwhllwi 10 ti'GSII KINPOIr I Lu yt,o W do L`i. He we1v{Imcs 4Iti to CLAIM inoode Illi !(7.90.013d %Vdi.-jimund - pcll;ahl; die goLiii_ -YIN't Ihd OruRtp gmd uniR1111t a h�L i, pLup d3= i5a tri& range Lei'ottler g11'11, 1413 TkU CoA r=MOL See lr.Drn thr mal }ice aW 1111 apera4inn L* tally M art tLr out ctimlltlml;!} . 14411 €iflud with joy tv.vry I Line I di IVLI k�} Ie1d krdk 10 cte wkl:it fmhmol i err ill die rrdrlf p murc Lhhl dh+ VIC- prmncc of Sovr, Ll& -A ly intreusea 1tLc<%- ILx nf-klur p1)poki1 . 11 mLeau NmucHrr'ry maut 1utJm. i3rincu, IL u it I)LIJ �A;Lbljn'j l7 r4o X11111 .kellfflg 5rJ1IL gWitx, 1 tut A 15'rkMM 7L1LI dk bliMiLlUk ti 011 U I VCd ICI LkLrci re have bcm hard ha in the dorm nirn idi IhC %cM110iny, KJ3nV h8C53 %-YWt3CFa haJ 3a Sell huriicsr e-Lijuse 01'4NI rap4VY m In f>!La911a-Ice{- "- Le Ler and I h3wr bctm 1humeet LirM 1-twu Ciablo m 1Lt fail um hard tinLxx Lmd haat Ili mH thr property Lo a davcloc'r I I' IhziL mhuki Id hjpTnC I II IS aw,& you Ick bc I1ti_it and fo wiEL1y replaced L -v a high dt!nS3ty { C%-CI0p.InKrl I to bvp b.rinp more ux inuv to I t, OI un: if111 VM' Lild 6: miWl} Irad iu u dCL I iX3C Irl Mir pr13PUM ti"aIM9. �MtmY ALrrnxN Lttuund thevu�ft� hA%.lr tLIMk! 0 1.u Icaiking,pirr -11 kl%Eir Lacy I;)rvmdimki6 arccU tuwm..lf IIA �,Jng u Cr IuLv;r aL gcven bub - will I vTw4Je them 10 mUy ail ba�iuess and 4t ,I ViLkCd-m-Fibor filar years to romc. Lon ail fW �IlLawinLr iL L:i' li ILawi r to b,,- pf3l~d an IhdL psopetl*. mi3 is a bi pfine -Jt Lang Luid i I L5 � 51131r thllt k-ULI WutC L be able tO qm" the 115wet wrl 1. L ,dial Num 4vv all. rmL rAb47 qtld outrli we cell w by r< pcACwpkC sLlrruslndtr tl3u Int our �irllt Fi��14' n� `te}cbt1r' u I+mperty Ihre�epW hi b�t�u5LSS bar wIrm]TIu1v 10 FeNrLuL hu -LY Ise muIJ u9c L+ts pngnrLy Now 01b2 the tables are LLrmud, L wuuJd envuu1LLI;e um to r mat bet tITat Ic&�= wkd Llt'1 ilticntipl tio�p"rn rcvva4 rt even ;�k ba Er im using lhra pmperty in -.1w.,iy due ;YcliuJd aLL.Dw them LD cumin frleolthv- W E rived In Cmiii6 rJw.f*r aky yffars_ As morcnnd rl7nr�rf5rr��t7orri �� pui: an rile: u"x, DJ land. muny 911S�F bmrdikc-c-� S lcxq L wi:T 4biti� Ira survive. bird we wale ILtd flu'% r flekhL Likm c i= fEUI1LV DupLts- I.,e ui ILISLI LLvk at owiywo bivula�JLIL'JLL int}kis. tfDell plk t! G '{ inp!itli�3 L54 4101.maed to L'!LpmaW pi;m'Y I,6 OM, VUWiiI}g L!UItLlrl7Ul hmr. %Y iLb the addi6ijml.£npmcL1v foe VQk-C�r 1LxLiMAL, Iniad Cp3 Imp They. wr�u� not he �Pedid tyt F+mwr�% V Gadd *.NO JI)w;m Yuy IFI�1{• r+t�Jx'L'- �wd uuti' [LL 1L7Jay, 1}IIL Wi Il mar .1 uao r- sem, I I -pui q�?.1 oppy.0 w Lhr�r G 1 in. Its J�IILAI�1 loit l cs�rL�I�eHI. 'r+m I.ILiu.ili aimpul y-mor.eell phone sofwk4t L u.,Llw L;ImkmpU eon iRea im Vw 6LIbdi:%;k- tr111uLVV tr 4rlplo %!aII pbOM 1 -hist M uWLI run waing Ra11L1!oxr43k-qv �-orDJJLldllklttltiIgy, r4dwr r1i.1p far t2?jwriL'MU y� We WU4 bL L!�'JXVUil , tISLa L'[II E6*k:r and 9uaCsi. Out } uu ti LILplidef lakgk4' Olt s�17Lc' Slallce. V L% ri k- li"smbt ii. VMIIIDF� P40- bmMpa¢ w;-ior 111 lhi'l %vaude dui cr XLn 4pM0 hIDrsc FlL330. J11t rl i hlowk- uni-ned IIIS yogi vv4m 14irt1L:4 in lix ITi[wlh$, - Ha4wy CIJltirr and Eddie L.= J3nvwti Robyn MacDonald From; Norvell lF 1ppiOO g.@':I. nUt'i S(trw ;Sunday, January 10 201'J 6.47 PM Ti_ Nancy Cumr• 'Ra.shall Smit. 'Le a_Vii�ki Tiiamee. Xrysaal, Tboy Drake','Rbb. d LU xiorf. Tiva,Dawxi PFEkavKh•. 'M1ke.Dee Be4jrpe'_'Ctnald,Va[Ef1e Murray', 'P -stimenBr. • Linda. Hamlcl Kahvauaiterv. Tc, m, Sh;inorp Wamrlhum'. 'Daviij,:Linda Hall'- Vini;Rnt.Marlpm2 Wir!G:mS', '6i14,Yurmik6 jamesrxl' 'D4ibri� L��ICLru '; ' eaFSh �+m chc-shore. 'Jack. Mfiol& Mallvain', 'Sn@wn, Carcr 1ne S im.morm 'JL -fl, MldheTl�a VerSlm % ' Ryan S' t1' 'DanLelle Ce; Chris Lagvbinom, RoNii MaGDrald, Buirt Hewrtl. Bill Lusk Karn Thurman; Julie ZahnarBaik�y; lue LoNortia;• Joe Lccq od; 'Eddie Lee Brgwn'; p"llwaQmac•r,:vrri Subject: Fla• CP_41 Tower - In supart 1. am afraid 1.:0 1n gpirk -�T to havo U1 d I s;ag-r.De with vom N=► y. Tha n L -t ual ownr_ r t Iia t this T -Mobile - ;0 JIJPT i p:iriGrl s_: w r i est n rG is Rig n Id L_ lii)ginp. Ho ourrsn this Frc-ry Ibm ,L; ruk ttrunt a n Ind by the ]cooks r.If 1134 ;1111111 lira iris tho 41 i'arml)tiLvw ;)rirl :1I I thc- rLow fonc'-, �m4talli'd thiw }'-L`iar. I would ?;�a}- ffie axrr.- Ti II h1ir11TPg 11TO) 1-36;U 11y, 1 I hAII iIIscl 11 f+71ic-I- ;rrimur1 my pt' 5pLrty W!,it ytlar -jnd hjiti t4i dig an the mriiim;iI kJIri)1' I)ET.;rxGbL- [ MAl 11L1I .i 1J111-41 1,h 131I'l t1 4Nu1. lila+ Itk, iIM. «i:i f1}neL+ wiq.ti a rtintnruni of .� L�I,IMGMII-�(E,iM1117. A I.1.11 k. -I JIL,, I t 1. 1 Wil Pul(i rtla11 riSl Vid fj�tl r SPLI• R TKIW' Uhdj� i flj0A thUn h4V0 Iny I)V keit 11 Ll Ud 113'I,PL-Y11v Vc'lj kl(` fcli-,u lrR4` Il{'{r [d USE, ofUL! 11 tow (L f'• Sev.0 n TCdtks '�i I I F nlot be q itis. the k} l7 t to I ho. 'hUh.@ hurtx w4 tow c*r Imm ire "' ovL�r L hu arc`._ If we refill y w, i nt. tc- p mpm•t ht` it ma aml farm then M mi. b"d tho t rna'. r. They strknd to irLn Irc 11.•Fubst H rLti;ii a Lm OUT] t (af m+)ney Ian' t Ire 1(tUt . 1 ri()n't t h111k I r4tUa1IVC d A I(1�tf!x' f miu.the= &sling if wo w nrrald like. to slip rye iit the 1F mint 3- bec.-I tii qe it W1 CI czq use rrxtr prrrpc rt y V;111W6 1<n r1nt4Uf_-_ I tII Uld uk;c+ rxnlnr. tafra{ ' M af%t th.L .1TROunt dd aMmtY I 41ai`llfl CLR& rn-13n6 tarx Im y :J1141 6)(111_ � I e 11E- 13rir4xiCytkl h� n!_ J hi�_-y %vm ftM l2i.!JJ1Y 41nd WL'_ Nay ND IT"re-1l Sminybrook Fay — Original Ma5aage — FMrr1.• Naw QUO Tw- 'Rae hall Swill . 'Lm Vicki Tnames' . rv-Mal Tanw Drakt- : 'F6b Jcxi1 ! n', 'tea. Dayld Ftk�&L ; 'J&ff, Q� nakrr.E '00rrald Vinlerle MrJremrr' . Tatma St,mmf�' , 'Linda,Haind KpliQa.Jeh' ; 'Tmr .5ytanon Wa5hbalm`; 'OyoKI.LirtdJa Hnir .vincargN pimarer Vvilliams lailLY•1arr11ko ,1ammcin . ' tire Landrum' .-orkmia-,�klmn !Phi�sfaig ; 'Jam ; Mr11,rair1' • Shawn Carolma .9,';mlTyr n?:'Jeff, W ch,�IFe Ver-1-te ' , `R yon Scx1#t' ; Tan'AkIP B?ke-rt' Cc, pinoitl8 Gn nEl _ Cnii% I.agertic r i Jig 1, - . .. Wriga ii burt.hinwalAcltyofmamrga u ; bill losk r �; n.1lkt a �l : karen t�;10 �! ,Jk 1 u1.& zahnarbai kyQd1yefmll1r)n%ga, u& , Jia a aril Fi�c�rrlil n� l ,19 I �+''r l�'t�Ill!i 5 r+ ,C , 'fiddle Lee :8rnwh' , palttilwa0irnacxom Scatz s urM,day, January 11), 2010 6.25 R M Sgbou_ X11 T nAvr -1n support L'�L'nx �`�.yg15bt11'} It a burn' h p;d, Ll>al wa Like fur mnl%:d She jO%-� ,II Id 4VJ14 UMOIC65 LJ f 041E 'k1 TLfCL (A1JF *) J1t Jt lhr slv�d 5LI 1u%. t4ir 1] cm_ Z huc k u prupos:d] iv put :J ml I phime rowrr Irl uur L01111nlm AV. k'I,in%- P11p9r w III worn' lhiv nm ml cyuvore n11L1 +•I,w 9LJ *wk to %wp Itm JrcrAMc-1hm_ I would &x fur ll!I 1a 3wp b ck- and Lie u �uok ui 1)IJ bipgm Pbmw`. &-ft11 4iu.!l*1cA 6 un avu-l. to uur vr'LW My1JlE '. T�c vwilt'r s nt11Rt_ IN How= IL Q-mti' 1rl1d1!Th 3Dd3F5g &A I14 11U9 bevy 1'14' TJFilllly o I'Thc faiM Iok vi4k w�rc t511I Ir In LNs urw I pm sure fbat k o-&-Klikpd-1gving Jhe coumr)• mmmpherr chmigcd b}' line bui Iomr, or : �uWi imiLinq PwLiuncb lim pfopefL}'. �IAswvvor. he 1= bmo vim' ScbW ut vs =41 L111 -BE V-Lkd Ur weLLormi rig,_C4'M1.1111f Ro 4oM w &YLM i�ll�lal alp,! I k1 is Rncnn[ I1�. I f 3 �}u �,Jg1C qct Int en iia gppopunir}' ;cF ti'Li II � �Jrn7tm. 141rg� you da wn I I* wcicurneJl as Ip ci)mc m%rj% Ifiv �-ak-., .ind w -alk nrAin41 - pcttiuq ih-r gam_ wm I h e :Ilpnc.i ,ind nkmL.aure bn pbtp More im rt vicid rmW of nLhe r a131rrfi 1A lb.11. "I L -annul jig firpm 11w r�-:Ii I Fie and hi -N f,.pL-T;Li ikm JN' IrUdy Rn OWL 10 ail L 4nrnnnUffh. I am LiVeLl. N•ith 1(w tv4fy rir[Ic drrve by -md 10L,k qo nc 5+hm ilnim-lx We in the I'rs�nl. p�Ir1�e diul day. The prew cc u 1' �xvrt Ophle Sural}' wrel9eq i In Vy1uc VC MI.T It i" -ah; ilar IIKI14L9 Ht;LIIk AMNO or IjLCLIL1Ld i, 1•rrum xt4 jtI jLIJuf�.VM ;Md �-mIIirllt �I,mti ", III-H5k i?w4iwt PAW theJ&"itwm—t inw-l- •e+1 Li4 d7tlt Caro ILakO IVO hard hIr I)Y the 910µ II. II= nM the- o.Lwnorny, Ntimy horu irLynerb hud 10 sell ho ws hex3Use 4it Tbg rapPLI risV In fftd pr1c{i, F.dda� I -m uncl I Illtn- IxoIL WL -1 t IU�d.!lwt Siren (FAlak-s ntrglls fall -un iwA 1iltMr Awl. fMr v 10 sr'I I rh m II kiLwalopu O' l Ikw Omid hulklxn 111M I;IL L x nuld be• ittisL P!Md perjQFbly �c@d by n hWr dctlsky 4welrrpmoir io h0p bn'Fm mury l ox ]hCO111C! 111� M'1I10rl; 191`15 W111-110 &-finlfi2Iy 106d w .r Jkdl-ML: in Lyw pru, 1p le. ]Iwm MIA11Y fiunLlar'-4MkhL1010 VOUMtr} hays! 1Llrtk�l Tu 44sml� loaf a1• Mhk!It 14hLI fVlf Ni illL11h11IN nr rill 1otveir;, If lll:Mui a Cid I I wwr rr r11 -y" V)r&dQs wily unablk, Lheim to til -ti In l+umnkr5� and bo p valuvil ncI2hbor (of vew.4 iQ u=. I am all br rdlowirm in cell Iowcr to be plipec i muhm pngvLly- fhk is :;I Mj;� p4!- c u1• cmd arid it is poseiblr 9lIn1 yc*Ir -Ls n-1 be hl?ta W.&= Lha um-cr wrII I Lim ijlm uC LL11 Tem"k a Mhe 1mTtT p w• iWL wh; n pr%T.le wmuunding C tnU tIr UIIr'DtTaLrL3D& rye ighLgT'spropgty. *Trutm% d h is business say ntlftn rlipL-h is- TL-wLTLVI i115%V h4` �UUJLL kw. JI Ia j nT. Lit K" thltt I kv I.l1:7105 I Ire Iwrn[Ll� I wKmId-vriL't�In 7Lg6 m la r-rjgemkvr t15IIt E N.ura and mA awTrpt Mt, prevent 3c h -Cinbk� L't'rLnL rising N-4 properry in a %YW Ihm %yould uAOW' them to Mmin I mdlF y • We 1 iwrd In Vali 1�7mia tw mwiy -ycus: A3-maae wm rTn rre restri L -d m were Fm Li Li Lhc use ofbuid. maw mmulT 15Lrjiorasse!� lb Kt I11eir ;Lhi I its- I;b surdwe, jIrni wr wLri;hpLl llmttr 1 i -ION thanp� intLI Muriv Ekw3 Lel Ml 01.11 ILKkl' si nur ElWn 111TWIN-CMIrrll m IhIA II cell phnne cumpaai:t5 dict nul nred I s•xpsnd La FTniOda tbElf µ4iLlp OLiiO1LmF Ims� with Me adddivnak tur 5'ULLe, texIin�: and f.;; sm?i:.ek then wtnlld nog be Fptnding r�5uram to liW4thffx jaweys. ,Yghu M;qv MCCI •r guod {uu� ,nr Liddy. hili will 1101. u4 a:ir ri. H CJ• ti Qtl ILre npM,�-LL 10 Lhis Ij3wr r- iso remWrl II I'FOLJ I ly Lf�I5hLk1�^I}t, } I u1 � bind cancel yMT�u call ph�iarr.smTi" I cspea th a1 mum Ihrnil ics in nur subd4, inion huur pTu Itipk CiTL pbnpcs tlTat 3rL. I15td for lrmin. -md necdI S3 a; mrdlznTL:1Imm{ , rIhcF than 1•rrr emcr =lms. Wr * H I �iy.%r br uppminp 1h IR c:e1 119MLLT and wTFggC M r.hrti vl Ld emmldrr t&Ll-. OIC samr; MEIOLM Year rids JUNjrLY, u "ILWIhk. TLcighbofhmd mum ih tILi3 wmderi:ul. Opon lipme hn€N ", DI * h1LICk' --a wLhhw& }nu wou-t pS+4:m no4ieci m tio, wwohp-, - Nvey t_t1. ur and•L-&Rc I-Lv $rum. FZobv n MacDonald Froin: Ri�!5hell 5ggtt [r 5e9twAgme.tDiA 5ornt: Sunda' , JanuRry 11D, 201-D 13.54 Pm To: Nancy crater cc ' Lee,Virki Th2invs% Wrygal, Tony -Drake - 'Rr Ix Jpdi "I xhw', 'ZiMa, blaard Plskowlch ; MiKe, DE -f-- Berrne'; Vanald,Valerts= Murry', 'PablrAa Stmrnel%'LJr1aa Hamid Ka�.va7adeh'. Tom Sha11K.Ir; wasf`.I}ur , 'Da,rid, LLIcfe Half: VinuanWaWry Mliarrig 'e d1 Yu mik.o Jamey -an'; 'Dabrfa Larrdfum'. 'nr,gir ; -hmvn (;hashlr-_'.'Jack, CarS ble 5slnrrlgrrf '.Jeff, Mich=lie Var�te€glh' -Ryan Scoff. Danlel�e Baked_ piWiDa alt nit: Chris Limgefbb m, R?jbyr1 MacDonald, Burt Hpwiv Gill Lusk;Kar-ark Thtulrr an. Ju11L. ftner-Bailey. Joe Lortgoda Joa Lv,cKvmcmJ, 'E�ddii� Lie Brown'. pakdsjjya@rrar_corn subjac#: 'J�a Cell Tu&er - Irr support ho%. 'A Qum wo k-11mv that Hummn wiUMi r his is wt� pltLtL� on his propertv,1 wvv I d as5kimc hi.: diem' I.1 In I �!.;S, %v weTe its Dear Front him m. yr,11 hzkk.,� t1ply b+L:c-juge it -wi nis I ik kith know hi n1. 14 F1 co t%:(1 Ldt l'i wknl 11 inl I I £{} jhkA Of Ih;LL ijtu_s_;, is 11x ii doed in ids r n I' 11w, h:Lppvn i o-` 1. 1 Lava .L!en new on Thr b 1 nuc %Fri I I I i � PMPQ IIYA Wil LA i h krlk i i lit W24 i I L r1LUNWIal -�Vu V. V.1C thL'LL 11tiF-� ti; i W I tin' L hi� 031 J51 10, 2010, at 3:25 PPI L NL%Ti ry Ck1�Lrt IVNAL: Ivbt N.O. 15L5111 , A is )1 UI imi r1a1w 0 LIUJ 54 C takti• 11 hT'SnnIC*I rI1L' j4n-L: alul viii yvi n111.tift 10f 4WVIYdM+jiFL`, iiYCl1I00&3L1L_' LhC TY6L' L%C nLwd bO pRY Ik3r t1l4th• '1IrL is o III LIP&.; 11 t11 11131 a 4[lL plrofle LA+'cr in 1]5rr cviislnuiigl} Many 110ple will 1di?W 1h1a as un k}ycsore;Lid Y11YY to work rp AOp Yt-s CahsIMalL11:1, I WkIL1 ILI I it" i rur us Ib} %Lrp biLk alul 1,1kf 41 knjk ax My Jrb �!l' [AMM ScYL-16 GIOITe1. Isan W1,%ot to MW cL511nmun31}. Thr. OYMer'9 hurntr iH PtrrML3M [Ok Ik1� 1:1110 MLLJIdLu11, fhtd lac hof. IXLC i hetr Kvfuhr rR1`m. Lei for sLIWiV ISSL11 IN 5s4XC bUJ t ill til iS Lreti 141rn Warr 1hLL1 he d i!;Ntk M h0iVing 1`11a Vrualry dff WAPfW-IW;fid by the buildirse qt' N U11d IV 15 u1n% i1ri5unL1 II iw PMIP!St} 111 wavu. be. h�-� I=ii ti'1_I-t !- in,1 W I% ILns1 ul 111f �-Is14 15V Vp1CICLtR'1111R FWxL. yolk. W cuLat to *.,fMj Fitbks and erkiny Ilex mca1,12eriC- I f }%011 hAVO d.514. E llL7k Iho LT..pnrtua itv to )nil. I I.Lirm;m i Lirg. You 10 d❑ .$0, tJo uL to 9mic %IISILIt 11JL' 3tCS, ahLI wa IL :Ir' 11.11 Id - petting Lhd.[ Lu d1t a iti11 ahr .31.11aUL OL -3 1TfihLlatul'C hflrw%. p1,1+ &J10 6 n WiLre inn:�e :01' oiher mTJFMM13 LhIl1 Vrru c arin 01 SCe I'rxlm I hc) r1. J. 1 ig Sara I%ix opcwtilul JS TnkK- im ;F5S t to CfIrL I -DMI ltln it) I u111 fill-gwl tit'+1 IL of L"y4ry jilRC G &-we Uv .aLuLJ JlsuIL to irrwhat unlmars ih1: in the From *t]u1t flim Llk% Thi prL!senLx QV�e kIA4! 10111`91� I1L -ft-I LO 11114 VA -11a12 Lff UUc propert�. 11 itr= %. 1.12 nah's FPmkn } Lvpcir 01' Ing1 ncIL! iw fi'L1m ai:jb!14L.�' Ilnrhmi LuLd vNinn smnr nvrtn, r 1I.IMv.15wltivjj� g11rd lilt! 'o � Lw1= L1sVOYCLI Lo dtiur UNTO hZWIZ bccrl kEJ 11 iT �y 00 cin.'! M Jum in the e*.,Llncniv Niwl3 hurmc �-*-nCni hLtd 10 Ikelllkla�' Lsocl M -6f $L. rapid rise. in CL.Cd prLLs Fd tIQ I.4� irid r h4WO kUl. -Wwt'iOj I11a1 4kVi'11 J �ifrlr� u1r�1L Iidk tm hirlJ she-* imid FiLivetla !44 tam RL+bpe ty to a dcYdL3per_ .1 f lnnl sh4x11LI IIPNXfl tl11-,.u$nA would 1be bjA and pfAdh1v TfIPILirLd EF} r4 h x,14 de!vg IL>lMMA to htJp bring Mcwt ULF LI U0411£ iii rrS1I11515_ II71% k'i11a11! 1if n Ite 1% Le u5 I,] 3 &L' I Ir1e 111 Ilur prvpfily Y-IuC• 'tiA1511Y t'armuw%; an M111111hv A:+,Ls11I1• Ilam w1Y10d AL1 1tiLSu1-- pari ul: Ihvir bLf11I 1'1 it %vi illn 111H j)I !L -1I U5%v r . LI bLLvins a cr1 r ikmLeF LA �Kavcll Gob1c* wrlI cridb1} IlWPI! 1.1 L-tnv in bLLsinn-i and hr. a %alar% noL-hlmr Fk�r yL;LlN lip koyne, I Lwi :ill Ibr LdIcrwLno D Cc11 ji:vwcrtia hrl•l�r {I Lk11 tI1Jt pTI iprT Y. F1I In ii It I H8 PL -ft;! LIf land 31511 11 Li PUM Ih k' Ihut 3 1 U %6W' I bi� a15Ye- 1P 4ft- diz ia+rerr Well. I Lsm vurc %ve ul I rl'mumb& The outnpe yvc f.1r u 11�j) Ve-4Rrt .,mTmundins' erne of our SlriiMmde nsi. lblxw' ti -r1 upwiv 1hrowed h is i ininess:l y :11 Lrmpl I u E t1i tetilrict hnw 15c ouUW IMC his ri np, gr - M nw thni;1he tabIn art 11 lrnred_ I-+eulel "C1aLIF-IKL' I.I : IkP tt15Lf!Mhvr tlU11 mid out alit m pL to prrvca Scwfo-('m1b1rtSfrotr$ lrxing 1.11ib prate in a WHv that *uuld a1Ig%%,.LIiLTp 1Q rQlik;l1h ItiwyhSly. We I ivod i11 Calif&nm fur uLU]I S �A„1Sk A' rlp#TL! ffA mafr rmtrictilms +,►err- put tri Ihw use u Y LaardL 1YL.A1'1Y s1n81r 0111 Linesmis Ilii ail nr a>}iIlly tLr.WW14, SLUd %W-W=I1L-d IlhS1XWr f-ICILlw 01a14�t k 11411-Ijole Dopar3 1.01' Itt A1.--0 ltTt11% A -OL-4 17Lkf 5 In kat VtME311 In di is I I' X011 phitac 4:SLm1g1r11L,% GLla I)Lit jiuedi Lu �f Lp17d it% pvwn ile Lheir ari+1r inL• 4LINrL1iTivr x' !.c 45 Ilii O.L. i11td11'1Lm;d Mpkit} I& voice_ irxtLna and C1I wrVic 11huy tiwUUM IFo1 he spisndinn HSIM1frC5 tG'TULId Ihesc•111Y5lum_ YUaI may recti; % 1 iu- I v -%% r7!:V 14 icb . NA WL11 TIO ILi ust rlstr I I }'x+11 ary Lr j. jr L d LII Ill i, 1L14wL7, Ln rer17ait1 l75'_' LCall-Y wArL 'WCf51_ }i'1F 511Ln1 Id cww L roar cul I pl%uni;. ,L7I vice 1 expzrt iha! nsaal Jarnd In 1n flur subdivr6ion IIAU 11ILI ItElAv rel l [111110{`S dldi See used 16r 14 xi ing and rltcdle:-.s trnnml lninL11511i. TLII ILPW 1L1;31L rc r cxiicr =n.c iv_�_ VL'e I ti NL dUs relE W�►�r aa,! s►r khaz atec siui er tr]:i,i4 IIW YJ C -A%Qt E. YtM ECS b-iQ 7 %r.1IkI.ILLIC h oLbnrhaf%.l &i,;tL hI RLiS wundr r7u I npLm-ipr-r hLm%c fnmr. AU It, Nuck sainia1wig YLILI W;111'G CYM mXjW in fls m nliths, NWW' Cklgiptorad L-Adim Uv brmn Rabv n MacDonald From: Nancy 4:"r [n.cumff@corfums.l mil 1FAIn; Sundah , Januriry tfl. 2:01a 6:26 FIVI To; 'flas vll Scot; 'Lee. Vicki Thames' 'L stat Tony Dr,3-W; 'Rob,Jod i Lux(Gn', 'Zr-a, Qawld Pk ; Y4�h%-Mlke9,L]ee Bejaia , ' nria3d.YZLerAa Murray'; rPairir-o Stimmel'.-Uncki,ifBtelfd Kahvazakleh', Torn,S!-Lainon W&srlbun';-aavld.Linda H.5II' V,ncen1,r41argaret liam-=;' 'Bill,yurrdk-� Jam"i)n', 'C]rrhla LiandrunY. 'ais-rihawn �- her,[I re , 'Jack Nleh-sk Mclivain' '-Shawn, Carolir�G- Sif moriv, 'Jeff, MlchelLa�arSrmgl~','Rear` 5coh': Damelle Elakert' .cp-; pipplN@a#t rLvL rhrrs Lagerplor,m Raby in h9eKpQnaloli 13urt Hewitt: Sit' Lusk Kw. -2r; thurilli�fI JAL% hnarBMP--, Joe Longoria Joe Lockwood. 'Eddie* Ike gm,, -W. ��t11�ilYa r�a� CZ01 Cell Trntirer • iri supW iR li wu; LI 4durj-. th-9 Ls _- wkc I -on P.Mwxd iJle Jc-vx mW CO3V lW13C-12-9 of uvgrVtlay lifo. uvnrduakhm liba puke it a brad r.) T%i 11 Ir rlwici. TlmiLn is a px9posul i,D pui a L:eLI phogL; In our cope n?it}•. r luny pmoe w5111 v iew 11kim ua an. L^f�nrc ;nd x;Muir 11k %YPF-k ttF W97 il.N MIMmCkp_ ! A'I AJ likC i r lu Lu s1irp back Md mk: u t-uok aL 11je ' gn pktuv. Somn Qablrs um as*0 to ulrr-uu nmQral}- Tbir ft-- clr-4 ILmAr,i9 I{armm. 11 U my undmumd at tbn 4 i,l% bom bT bcf'ury UuLq ,if Ui.c ripbdlvisiol,6 tis erc tmI I It in this rnra I nrrp -"I rr tl+ui hr dr;l ike(l hivvinyf the counlry+ wI 1sw+74Wn- chrul Emil by Mhig 11v1Mild-Al {Ll -itbdivisioruL arvuud ILSs pfaKrLy. I t-owu cr. li-V hog been very kind Lu in Lind til] of i+la b+ - %wck mr1nr- cvar�tw da �uilgv 1U 90%,&l4 1lahlrs iimii L:ni4w his llioriWriq- IF3'IILi h vc wit takviii the 1ipjl grL:nJL;' Ip YiayL JjL7rinM I urn'L7 ycm 14 j -%j w. 11V wLLIGL1r'rlo'J 06 1111 �allti LISLj& Llse eit et,, and walk LQoUnif - peltiine lhlu EhMtr- vsH dic LdpaCh arkf min bdttt hur50L plus. L1het'e IS A wldO Rrlfl:gd 01' 011Wr Ullthlluig Ihus YOU raaant :ieI: fimim kbit, rmd He IMnd Ilii operlu111n It rnl I}• ;In asset Iv oul virrimtm It') I mn r1l IWd V: i11L jf?y 615VCY lima I -driwp-#�y U:11.d JUUIL LU tee k1b.2 arjbaah ule M lJI C frraJ pLIMMI: JWJ alr�'. 11111 PftUeuk;o Of SCwoh i}llltlo 9=1Y ilia%k-;9 1114 a�alud ULA cmlI vyo"7 11 uvpis HaapKes Mon sneuee SIL LncurnC is Jura etabl in° Jior�c l; Owl fp11hm somr °tq. I Lomr awnm s:=d 1llc heEtwRNI:4 inn l'ym ill LIL jI' 43re hump berg Fuad Jiff hj- Ilic tmvik tura In 11rc t!;rrnpmy. Many lirmrse o*nrz-. hrxi 1u sv1p hom.m b&Hiaw O'l1w rmplkl rL,x ul f4L-Li pr34tD. F,kI&d LCL' mild I J L we bLcreu 4L uriied tltut Svvai [;aL1tcs iMEEISI IalI ois bar{ INtL'i and IL7ve 10 !C I I LIYC pri]pl`Ai to a kI%,V 'IepYT• I IF 111;1 •iWd h�pvn rf� ilgscl %veru Id he Inst and pI%iI-hl N. :rpUccd h- .1 hi --h LICIAi4y 4JC" T135 I Lo IML' Ip lli-ln�- nimi: Lux Irl�tmtt ti- MOwn; 14W WULII;t+kflslital} IL:L d tL, .t dL:,ILIW m LVU pgLLp4-Lv YLLLIL,LA. ? I any I.,hmum ars ii 1,11. 1110 CLluI�rI IMM1*L! iiurmii to h-,44 1t 1AA X71' Iliolf JI.I ld fiat W ll Id;gjj114 LU CrIl h)WL?S. ]f •1W3'inL u C LII WitCr Lit 4a1 en l •+n hlex wi� l I cn:lhlt` I IbL- ll ro Maq ilk bi.,;ivim am:d h- ;I yaauj,,d ij�lpb +r f�3r YL-wz rn wLnne- I rLn Al Jbr AlhlmiiiNg a tell wwor Ln tit pjaL:e.d -1n III.d prl1p'Ilt'• Hili Iw Lt f}lk� pl�gL'Le iL IN 1hIk! tlsVq FOW'WWN-M L+� ;IL110 Ltr %ee die tomo well. I Lull sw-C VL L7 uIJ rejrlrnitacj HW -OW mE4 tirc Cc'Ir WhVfl prxapl �pm�llnclltrS -PI3C 41 MIT -Stl 1�-?ILi� lltii FjL+r,r'ti I1mElcrrr dsllc:,rerLul� 11k6LI�3nI tri atl�InpLin� to r� �IcL how Illy L� MId IMM !I i% jmiNrt�'. Nam -114a lho ta'I3616;ft WIJL't A LILIld kll7L'4Me Un .Q (-- Zu I L7ge1n1Xf dirtl tCs}L7n am jWL LkHeulpl LU pVVv4L ISLLYvn Ombla fF im Ir5itlg 01is Muir,} ' In p "-.T:4ai: wpak4 M" dioin [i} rini iin hwikhy. WQ Ii'YgLl Irl t,"RllfMIkU f0f FMIWL�' Wagrk A-� lkjaTcmW inckm resLTkLiQpa VLVr4+PU an.>�e use Lrm -Dr tand, mall} plI bux.niesscs Imi: Iflcir Ilei 11L� 1L1 • 14 ti h.1g, y I � d µ-C �I'P�II' L flay w %ld!j �hwIgc ioLu i jpuic ]]epau. 1,4 tis nIW louk a our own livolvrawm Jn Jwx i I tell ptKw r:kvnpm1m did nut nee -i tkr impowl. tck psuti-rdr their eine carLonwr bqR ~with rlw 4Ldditiwlml ci pu ky Icer wice. im Ing_', and 61 skrn-it N, 111CY would W)t he .rr.cnd ing T: c%nrrccm W build I f v;L: t1myci-s-J I1hYou 111py Tecojw: }�ood aive;l mne t) yr bul wi Il iiLri :L'J UNC rhes IL }-va are uppo44d 1v thd.5 t wui- Irk remmin logicAy con -,con -,I's, IRI!- %-LAi 7utdd .4;gw l �cw1T "Ll phronc wyr i�x J'mpLm Itial iyw l hiisihct in our �ubrj.ivik cm *Lve miduple "11 phwhn thgLars tL5ZLI ror textIng -nod 11 � lC xy Cs1g17r1tul�iestic�tx, rnthm!rtim for mnoiumcles We k%il I K -I11' t*. oju�gh5iiqL. 1:I11.WJ1 ILI14VV 911L) W&,: I Iulr 3'4'+ urlllJiisWr Ladcillg 41? QlaLC rFlmv. V%W risk- Idift LN x-01liii'We TKigbIwE�wd• l• Tn thio w mderful opull hri c• -e 1lur w I ikw I, �Ll to blo*- %Lw.mh ine, ykmI ti4�I't R k+u1 Iti}ti"- il5 sirs rn(imill'. - Npiie� CL=ff nhd JEd&r laae J3imnlp Robyn MDonald k0m, ,lana GhL�tef j @Pay neuvstems. camp Segt Surnday, aaftinry ID. 2D10 12.3$ PM Tcl: Robyn A+FaaeOcnaild Subject LlO�t WJ 5 Ff eWall Road I -Mob k- tmYr=r I rITn IL ree,ide eft. in t lme I i-ey atony+ L' mum ii ai ly a rLd jim in oppertaitien to t he pr-DpnRwd �s pp li-cat i« a Eo r_rect a (m11 tinv F3 r i3 t 14 ft)5 11rjpc-%v cl l lic t-ul . The p Incement of the i rmrcr will cmmw ail unsiglat iv vim axfthe towor frcim my hi me .is w i ll cit= for' ,urrrjundint* a1 1g11brj rA. Z think IL 19 rua44 i1ubly foe I i.L14 pp Icr 14 p hi, c imnu m'`od rabble Lt thl- � ! I.'1.� of 11 M'0X imiiy u p ,11 u1i j v phe ati w w rij on hORIth. the it Iit'���� rty V� iIU41Hr mid th# noaLhL uo, 41f m houii,'ti Thc-u� ;art, many fawn+ri fdReady exiia. R 1 ng t hixpu#hout hl iltan on€1 I ca nr ijl fsce the nc.,L-d &r julothur-1 wmild like t o c riytLrt, that t he p tip agatiun study iii diay iimi xinx�d by a thin ci rfrnrty to dotcrmi170 Lhn� nn antitonrtii munnot hL, m-lmated as an E a_—ting:ex,$J tower, would hulwt; rhsE r.UL tity [If NfAurt is jmlfj4!iI ir r5 -Am. d bobind Emir 6ii4su__q W11j Ntv[, edg,IihLI yjPH. tt nd a x;?:It?E LLL i n 11 VOWPL'ti g rjur 5111.1. tlL tin 1 ].] v1 ,_ Unvjat�L 'Plvink yo u, Jikniii ChOVILlif"r Rgby n MacDonald From: Miohalle Ver Sr h [rr emteeghgwmcaunet� $ont- lurday, J&nwiryr N. 2101a 8:06 PM To- Rasreti Scott 0-hris LagerhLaDm, Robyn r0acOarrald; Burt Hewitt; 8111 Luak Karfm Thurman ,tulle ZahrWaailiy+. JM I-dnq�ia; .loiR Lock d Cc: plppiO at1.ne1: Lee.VJC�3 Thames Kry5tai, Tony Drakv,.Rot;L,Jodi Liaggn, ZnraPPYid PN�mvic�h, Mike flea R3-rrxarr: 11UnaM.VJ0leris Mme; Palrzia Slln;mbl; Linda Hamid Kahvazadeh, Tom.S19.ancm W shburn_ Peggy+ E3,1m elt: Davi d.Unda Hail: VanCmRrq,Margar,3t Wil4mB; Biit.Y4+rruk{, Jama$on: Vatxa LandFum:'Fod-a dee Brown. N.Ornyr Cutter, 3rlgilp_Shawn C hr=eshLru, Jack, Mche11.6.1krcllwaili. Silawl, Car -Nine Simm�ms: Ryrap ScM. Danlelle Bake[ 8uboc ; Call Trwer in $6A n ambles Farm P1pa su La7c1 u:dt our• ri mvs in &uppo rFZ of the pet itim against the T -Mobile ii�eU tWer to bo pj a.L.i:!,J A 14495 Hopcwt? 1 Road. We are very st rmgly Qp mW. T ank5 f sa r cur Lim. 51ncmrv1yr Ki rhe1 j r= A ] e -F f Ver Staeoh 7.R-5 5trFiL FuvdL• Or`lire Nf 1tom, CGA 30DM 7 7e -EAD • 131113L� RoW MacOiandtri FTQM; F?asihell S-=li [rasheAlsr.D l m .Vwn1 Sia nt. Saturday, January W. 2-010 x:08 PM To; thus Lagarblwm; Flip 1.+IUDunald; Burt Himitt; Bill Lusk: Karem Tl Lwrrman; Julie ZehrierBaileyr: Joe tangohria; JCLa LO&ODod CV; pkpp@:�@atl.hot, LLb-e,Vickk thama�ir KfyrS �, Carly Drake; Rob. Jodi L"km- tva,Ravlr) P)5kovich: Mike,De:e BeAme; aorLald:Vaa ena Murray: Patrice SlimmeL tin�la.Mamid Kahn nzadeh, Tom,Shzinun VOiNth[Furn, Peiggy i 1Lnjwelt; Davict,Llnda Halt, Vinceint, Margaret WrIllams. Bill,Yumlkca Jameson: Dnhia Landrum, Edda Lee Brmvn, fdaiicy Cume; on!4ie,shawn C,h nm: Jar -k. Mb:1wlle Wlvain: Sh 71_ Comifne Simmms: deft Mic Llle V&Steogh, Ryan Scott Danrstle Sak4rt Subject: T -mobil monpPole in Seven Gables Farm Qk2ar Mayor LbCkWoDd mid Council r#mb�?r1. L' m A - i t i ng this. ems 1 t o express My wt rang r. ancer'n and objection to T- mobile's applicati-011 to place a monopole& cell tawLir in Seven Gables Farm across the street from my rrei gbho res ncl 5 t r a t fordo Estates Drw mp"eLl Rd-, neat -cw ly t11 i s is. an arts i ghtly *hstrucd 0n. In rru r be aiti f i rl imimitirLf ty , blit tber u� 1s no nfae d for It a s Our celluiYar rmeea�;e is juvt tine in aur rme,unity. Please consider -d"ging r- Mobile -amess to aur camounity Feir such 3truetures.. thank you aarV wich. Pashell Trott 7q$ Stratfarde Or. Mi ltpna - -aA � G 4p4-307-14.8 Robyn Mac Donald Frl)m; Norvall GP'PRCIa(1 Sent: Satu i cayr, dariLoN 09, 201 Cr IM PM To: Rod n Macoodald; Chris L29"Ji�-bm ! vbju": Fw: Patilior) — Original Message — F rom:Snair m 7o= jpicp iL8Qg t.ae3 Sant: SaT"ay, Jipulary.04, 7910 Z-1 P M dab t: PigUon We v4whi Nke LrL IM un the Ve i Lis,n au -pi nil (hlc w I I U i 4k Lu' [t. t,[lid �'.1rq,4ttivk� C'anoEr [ 4 (4 0 I'I nibcr f iml ?�1 ilii}i3 ga 34 H 04 wic I 15835 ThanIp ni 0 N-IiIwi, gn JOWP 861 cmtu nmr tpw Robyn MacDonald Frorn: Nolvau 1p �LnWj Te: Robyn WcDoninld 5ubleCt: F #fid InaDrn'tff�on ri�gardirrq y0Lir gall sarwicz� — Gri mal Message From, 1 -awls &inkle�i To: Wxmli gent: GaLuraa�. January -09.2070 1�:22_ AM S ablacL: Fie Na@d I rtion-nation regarding yorir od sflrylc� +Cay,l haai�r T49abile 3,errlce art -d my rtxxoan 1� fine Thin kiF fUr an yaw efto t.. Low Brirlkleyf oriqlrQa uassaga — From: Naiwall To, Ter�pa�Lcket , R labwe and Qwn PA Is , his n come t.a� l ; � e a� +�d � �11k� er��_N�p, l : IldJifaa. and J dhan f+arri _ Micneile and George McMgstaf , iVlleleedawr�ck , MIaBI sillrolwr, McA : Ahlhael and $re!id Lia Stradlar, , Lrsa ; Lew end Li nda Br ink!ty., J ud and SLlaarrne Marvin ; Joe -and C Andy G2 !or` ; Jane Me OLPIe Larher and Scvt Sepoiatni , C*este Jackson ; Camun Pam . kac-a i . &ur,e.NbcYell ulnc marl _ Brendff and My Flli!�_r ARTHU R R WORLEY Ang ie 1� haslnpre ; 8l;el_1y ; tvr _n € eack ho Robert 5ke ohii n Sent: Frift, January 06. 2101-D t0 47 AM Sub)ea Need 1n Qmzbon regarding yrqur call seance Grm icl wfprnRr k ni, ighhcrrn 1 It W kKj utifEL1 u utsidc- h ut rs1 c k i hih Lho roil ds _ BID' o"re full_ Z ii A d J3 V it 01-111RIA VO In V-4! t i it #: 1 rj H I. rti ght w 1 th 1.1io T10A I nv gidLerit rff Grr�vgwrl*_ Bob My hm worked 1 rt pit). p ltrn ning liar ma n%- V(,LL rra A rtc C h5fl' �l 13Itu k k"U rid in w.rliltng city �Iwiiag 4iw.F- His q nn d ni Ji Mout w innmz this right iign1iwt thL, v.(-, l I I owL v ium ulifttion rin H opin-ao ll t{c Ld 1s t hn t we swod I ti 11 roviL thn ( there i:,; tu)t n gpLp .iii -qervic L- in our rams, npplicari€In i:t sites tlti2- ix t Heir yo: son 1 or p Lac] ng the tower is Qur :7ze rt. PH}f1 :i LtLUjlLrjj Lh(. [)j4 j_i1;a F4��� ��� � teat; TdLIV ren Jil rl ; i whL�rc, lhe maril � tht cit} :i w :1 ra o I' iht+ p <<<<d W Numi_uL, OW }Err,p.t� trtii P11 AuLl • i -t nij Elc�tod by T-Mutile by u tui iiia d third parry. - Thi; i L4 r.ht riLudv that r..sltrlws .1 iwil .l lhi. it I ow 0xr to J G -9 jjtar:ifJL:- rico u. City COUnIU-1M EI1 t Bill Litsk was iuti :7 t re ndan�o Lit this rueeti li1>; rwd "id Lhat M Utoiti crLtld pay fur this to lx� done- If it Can be pru incl tht -ra Es. no -?a p in sere iciL_ the tow!r can hc- dezi-Ic tl 1i v the city 15 W i he L-1 ty will not d.LLnv it iwon if nond eniano t be agLab.1i--q13-a d if thprrl i€I no t eaoul;h oT3poaiti ❑n t -D it. WO V&n airs) ar-gint In t.1116 h �WIIQ r rn�,r In%r MnT ]rrn Iti each Of Gesr Ru Fedi v i€ tons repirdilI rr VLL]j' , Vf. roti 1~e_ I ku13w pt'rs&tt:-LUVL 11) o Verizon a rtd ha %v na frrti b]E rn.,; with dvipped calls, 11F.! tfPwL, r' ri t Pjirtuiltgh. I rn CTtar_ r1 Mi ttLL. r--, -j Vv rizon Ti)w4 Fv I to W 0110 S thL, t.L5W(! r an 'Tid+ o-11 ruxrl, T VIi while I_'lluld pmEq-bly fiilAW01LP aFli rini, iS L�iim- to uCti to i310rPdno_� thLUr cAr4'L'lIn-p - Tht_kre aria :nkUntIVNIiw 15dw r WWLm in w r f k vf- r. T H{ arC h Eld 1 Fnlink, moil 11,L;vovk.- ry 0 the rF,. a rki r t fml ormw; rli d l-Qw urs in �1 -1 milt- rudi%11` of (i Lie homr;sl a Wu. rL'•:11LV nv, efI ;jinn I hr,r onrrrx My httz&nnil hni T- lii)d hw, gooLl selYWL- u1t the h.klI--A,-. 0juld at1ch of you- errs ail incl 14 hotl3ei' OF. ntlt y-cp11 have 90(d.zen ir-e rj ild whtE vote aro wit h. I w ill U01111 }ilo t I}f��, em ads m wilco to Cktc- 1�t.K!tin� A 1 Ca31g with thn Ntit 11 Pk'a.w' IAN 11'% ff �rnU n e) g hh{ i C31ood e. Ft ndkir unA 11 thaw frionk6 WJtitr �i re itn the a tr to ask 1 r C h -e -y will lea yr kni p :�tfr- in, pthering Lhtt+ i ii rurro ki �ion. A] --;x; irYnt, hUVL. ural 1111-U MlyL F01121 %vri1 v lour eDitri ,lI ineMbo.N. mayor. a nd RiAyn Kat DoTml Id PI)nm rtinig PITr t<ujkpo l Tku r I1t• � owe r. IST* 1)(I hl�vt� tip, L r. r.hl ;0 :� Lower t►p PhL'9ti«]3 z Will M -t t IIL' p e dm ce- c Lilco ruing fUtUT I ;)pV jjCatto.ns. L_I n jbrf iui ately. wD uzxu the--guinen p Ega liv w hidiL fiituw ZJD= g 1U 6. W1 Edi bo tiwr7 a I{.)rx, T h u kkk firs ti' 1) 0 r �,uj71)r ft, Kay. 'N MtrVA Robyn MacDonald K r m -. jara_u� Pace. jYi-pv0u2Qwt1, neq Sent: f ridgy, Jarwry 08, 20110 6:44 P M 7o' Robyn MarnCkurlald Subject: Fw; GeU TcwDr Lawn • Mopewen Roan • &every Gables Farr: SubjeCt: CZ11 TQwu7 Wuation - Fropewell ROW • Ewen roi +ks Parra WL! Yu L i 4'ed noel fica l I Du 41 F tha plro]1131,�C11 roning, fm tlic vvl I loo r rIi vee G nblc�--s V urm i%w da) -L.- Im.Ccl re C-11ASWl LS. Atid rde L ilri; is Mcmnside ruts mall a ns ufLLuiv nt Li Me llsr tha: eiffmn►ir11 tV tO :ull[rl!sc: this i I.NLILL (."N I u I -Pk0C W dnil MgIAMI i OF] Of dWSe I(rkk M'4Tc n mdi; d Ire wr-vr and benclil our cn 6m ci rmmun i:iy, Mcirc, phmnTng i:� ne-eJed And %vc, capiiot �ppnri this #t)%Nvr now. C ;.uxFlYrr .end .lin L T 2LX v.�?� I �:atjtl It�pr�g�-T}�1re 71ow 0-6.173 Robyn MacDonald F rere. Nomfll [PIPPOEk att mij Sc -fit: Friday. January 1)9 201 3:6Z RM To. Robyn Ma---Npiald Sttb)E�CL F4%r Neud Info metiDn re!�ardm4 �rt�-irr aN1 8Ervrce = Ordinal — FfCL,rF- 1211P -;-S To: orv;211 Sent: Frr'Jaw, Janwiaq 6$, 2010 1.57 PM Subject', Re [Vend Irrfic�nnaLlort riggarding your ct�11 svrvmca I I r.k S. fa'T the %vork You girt do rng RNP Our Mpllllun;t� 1 O' y (rte.4n;ZEr1 and t FI)13gh ClfQ tt! WE have t cam] III )MIL: -•:r% 3t: :irAdu mt mied-addit tim l scr.�icv. Go girl - thi ng,; LITS Ithl-h ng gtxxi. -'hip is th-1ypc &) C 11,-rl nay.-dW Lc i Lala emm X11•taut' e6mmiuliky- r`arolvki Pace - 71 -fF67-627 Fmtn: Nor~r l plpj l9fra�t.r f' Tar Teresa Stkkels -c"W +@rahou=m }; Rubye and I)uWh MIRG er4l"11164ryr�lu�� psktmn m sin � ut+r1 r avid Paulin dav; aol_C rr� ; # ik2 and Nasrin Lodi Mike and 1I01an Harris cjandinharrisitealwuth.net>; r%licheNe and George McMaster Mir-11clu Sedgwick <michPI65edgwrrrk@jaa1.crm ; Mir=h.�tA and f-1rap mr`Alph - t mr-SWczbttorn>, Mmlael and Br&-nda EIV r Q,i�h�a�al �Jlwultnet -'; ti'�a T radcir Lisa c Ilsa_dawn�i-ptorlr5t, net -; Levi and Linda arinkJey <Iab1?2@belisouth,net>; Jud -and Shczarine Mama lue anO '�Imdv 6�!;L m ,cgivmi:@teJisouttr,ret>; Jane htandula cjianeK�geri-tmn.,mm>; He4lh& arm $CCU 1�e Whys -heathLn"gln Cimrast,net ; a4p-sC, Jacksm -e:belesw@ a"Whera*szbm>-, i`anakyn Pace <ylpyou2ri�-att rvx atl cool &uce.NGrvell4� gunx,c3m; Etrerldaarld David Filer <V1Ier'@m;ic Com>� ARTKR R ORLE Y <-ark.•m"- r-pmax.rWL>; Atlgle L-11E!1;hI AJlsorh f{etfyr Ali nk b lls.xlkl7 -rr t y -nn RauokhOFq <UMF 19itii;hcq 3b3d. net>; Robert SD! 1f do c fstep3-] @abelJsoukh. nek� sent: Fri, January 8, 2010 10;47:12. AM Subj m HeW lrlt min regarding yaur mIl smite I 1 r iris.J u I 1i'rtJ t I ll L sial, • l OU r slit -h 4 111 alar roti€lA_ BL' Cat re fry]' I 11rkil .1 Yl?i' - tl.Yf{lrffllLLivc ioi`�ting IfLff.1 night with the IIO L Pe�o-t+ denI 151' (1rir3�tiri,ra�!� 1#�fl, � ,h-M!1L1711. ���• �pir wirrkpfl !T] �'tt.}' Idiin imiI; for iininnv }L-Ftl'ti and h;%L at hm-kt.mninrl In W r3t111;; 121t r Yk1Iii ILo-14�'�. �l F U4 rTLI, J ktgt(}15 ;117 OF W innkl1 u, thjr; fight ue t lm;t thu uLrll tower M- L4 t all ati-sn (in Hopew:oll P Fal a is I ltkr l we nL L vl rt, 17 v - - i b ?t t thi r r,y i:P .n«t !I --al) in SU r V t in L)uv tiro+im_ T• 2Vob-1 Ic7'R ;application s t-Litm t hip i!� their rea 11 kw.14110ir our {, l-n- Bn b rx ttcndt d i hk-_ ,,agn 1 vk.L;v mmting on •1r] ]i ; }.whm Citi* maslo tho t;ity nwo rcL al' the no.Qd to r-x:amlily thr PrOp Kpl titin xt udv m mple t ed by 'T- lc1 ki Ira I Fy rM i i b mibu d third P 1 Lrt}•_ Th w t�- Ow st ivly t [m t hof 4, mx-d fir r; towr-r 1 n a gpmAir nren (' i Ly U nitnv'ilm n n Bi l l Ll iA WN t� in fsLIrInr1mau., let th+�- M71E•F-111tir, tJ1111 �ili1l t11,1t M-k11.Dn WriLllft 1); Ey rOr tai_; tt) hr� IICmi, Ci' it cm Im. prnveri thr1re iq no gap in Lit- ry Im. I. lig 11 v r PkID Ili flr., 1.1k, rl 11.%' tht- e41 I U1 �hO -UkV W-111 LL(11. dL'jaV it ek•i-n if nvuri cimnot licr v si rk hlj shir d if t lig, rr, i i� >ir i r 4 9mi h r I 1111 Oµltli �ti 91) it. W -e- rm 11 kbhw) n 2mis t in this in �uthermg infornm t -.on in i7 Ach of o wr -�; ubd iv rugn vd t rip, -L-Wl etrvern-o. 1 kilow pex&or liv. I haVAY VeTitr)n tin€111:1Vl� [W JYn 11Yy4UU� z Wi1l1 elVI1i11115 l 1'101�-'PILO tIAv{�t• 0t NrMIll �kIILITD CVD!ti u" is V VeTlzon Tower Us wt -11 aft LNE9.Lbws*r on Tidwo l ruil. T-Mobilt• Wtllcl cru j44f C0 -10C R Le On 0ite- OE thk�t tow -ars -to intx� their owe rage _ Ther? a m, waynerous EithOr tClWi�rXS j4j E�t1~.xlrQEI, ],eftM hed Qalm' a mid (1�gxw-rcrl thero UA; 77 :.1TIV110M; rrkld UMOTti Z l rk -1 m j1 rfla k)j� I PC Q tl r hOmftti' J�t).w i3 vpaEy wmtl r)jioLhi)r arc? My hugbAm d h ct .�; T- Mol Pi k-. Lind haR �ms)d S�._r vioe at the hour ('r.i Q i11 J.Ek.Ulj i ti f V1 JU tLMJ w 1 I f] hQ W h+ativ:r 4 w nc rr fail hove gfjgW :-rvi%!E. N nd w ho yn w z1 ru ti% E r 11 1 ti 1I I VtIMt11lE, Chi.-Hv ESM -,IIih rrl 1414 io tim.xrvet1rag nlong with the 1poLLfasPik . Pluhof* entIvxI- kf141r 11r.i Wlkt KOH :*ridisar LUMM i I th6L_qe filen rk w h6 aim In tho arctia h o a A i f t hi!!r ivi I L tram 11:13 5;1 1 i kl glr l hurin �: t hiq iu_for naut ion AUu- if yf m hitve not u.l.rttazdv. plm-m Writq L, UV t Ouncil members, Ln ayov, and Robyn Maul)ona ld cuncernin g yo R,t.i' *rappo rL v ppo- ing Lha_ k uiver _ NVe beh t-Va thn# thew 3 tower allp limit ionN Wlfl set the pretudowe vcaic(!ruiiti,, future applic"1110no_ lLfnfart►inatE4, we art~ L4.a guinea Pius 1�y %xturL, rorxing MWK ter'sth by Writ�.FLn_ 'I lulkik fL).r Your Fupport, lig i • or-VESll R Robyn.MacDonald Prrumt Norven IRiPpiQU'&kt net] Sent; Frid2V, Jantwe y 5 4� PM To. RoWn MaQDvnald Subjem Fw; jBu Ikj R E: geed I nfom Duan re$2r0 ing yirip cmll sarwr ,.... Original Mes$age From: Cele�fthyULCIberaMes mrw To:� Sent: rF-Qayr, Ja nLquy q$• 2002-. 54 PM $ ubject; 16ulkI RE' NEwe f I aforr Vbarr negarding you r yell servica Kay, hays rind T-'rieibl IL serwiu yirr* mgvir.� to Al la F1ta :n 1;1 0. I L h in k ie was tailed w nVtFhing Ow whm we r1rsE mov&d 11Ere Anywa%-. I lui-op, had excellan# WrVK-a in WI lim-F-4 ¢f AOanWp AlpFrarr:tta; %I ton. (Wmrnin, T P"Ilr qtr= MY "r'VI[k P5 51piDfitY w pm -q,, o I the fiot.15e, but I k hirrk kr has morn to riv with the lay [1f #hW- la rid rn v ho usv i!s ¢n_ I rej:riri f ]yr s Itthed to A.&T ir1 NOYLI.iiifit;r. opLcarise I Ymnted to Iawt limy 41�eL 115hiinir TnN wrvlrw• cmvPf-?kkj i6 curppuab6+n ahs hliltonAlp` aniti n aai a as we I] a rrrV hmi se. I do r10 I Lau i i k yv L ni?ud snGLhur I t)Wer For T-mulak seitieJtt C&mra�� I r1 Lhii sex. rii,ano hila A -�LT and h:a5 ggaij suvf r a r. �•r �l_ !3hanc Beni fl I.-1 k i:r 1 a R r?byrn Fa7-L n ire ht 1 w IN krV and sand of st riTiv. F • to k11e 4'-rn�ll 3dt rn5Ef VEW 1IKLP.rI. in A prrhrbus t rrla I-1. - Ila n I s ego In far a IL of wow ha rd -work to fight this I Ce1fi�iL l,f��ibl* °5 Saddle 4Pr I n!�i Dr. Hilton, CA 5[OW-. rnrr>: Norwell trna6lto_P�ppJC�Sfatt,net] Sent: Friday, Jjinwry W, 2DID 11;47 AM To: Tams SU601s; Rmjbye and Dutch Mills; Pauline t)avh): Mike and Wasrin Lch, Mike apd Jiklian Harris; Kchek and George McMmrt-Pr Mkf ehp 5,adgwkik.; V.irhael and far*n McA1rjin; Mict%ael ar1d F�mrd4 Li5a Strpcer, Imo; Lew and Linda Ori nkrq, Jud,3nt655=nr,e marvin.; ]rye ai id Ci:idy�3ston; Jame rarbdula; Heathv-rand �IAL:SuXA11isr CelLnte E Jadoon ()H -ATL;, Carolyn Pace, Du3cemlr Bfwe.Norvell;bprni:.c rls; &:enda and Ljavid Filer; ARTHUR R 1NORt,E . Angle Afir;w iKolly, , I-Vmn Rawcklwnrsty Robeit Sitphark Subject: Nead 11;fDmiaIJcwi regarding your cell erv+ae Clood Ill I �Yil I r L1; nc4glhbrjr-1;1 It Nr borA utiful ouu iao but aim on the rmd;o, Be ctkm6l'. I 11 :D rl ji 4. i L.V ilsfcirm Ltt1VL- nie(Aing 1 nst night .kith the 1 -JOA pl rt - s ido n t L7f Givvittono- Bob B u:5cenii_ He,, lkn�; Wgrkksd In my 1ll:Ill n1n4 for a-LriitV VL-aTr: Mid h.j ; k tr, Lckgm arl d in w-ritJ ng city- 7.Dniniz law _ Ria erm clwgion -t bo uE wiuru v g t h is fight ri-gi t h o col C roewky ira .-iilition f)D HL)j5k1%-VP1! R1)n4 Ls th it C wo nC•Lcl to prove ibut r.hu vu I d rLE11• as Baja Ul d!! rVice. i n u ki r aim In. T-. lub ikL's a 1 pj)l 14,211 1(n) Sir t th3.�-: i,: rlit-ir rE-t3riPa for plaeing the tower ui r,ur nr�ti_ R(c J) aL l I I LTIJ [L.41 L hi, Dt%kgi► R -0,r icW MUC LLIW Gu J11n ; � Wlrir jV &L mud-- Hwr ujty a warti L3f Lhe nt l�- d Ltr 14X1 min F-- r h4+ Jr I'r11,tL40 t W It N1,ucly e.l jlupke ti'll by T -M. h t1i - 1-y kt unh Li mA Ovi rd ri 1 C rty. . Thi -L; i thi- tit•Ta kly k 11 rl I huW w dl 1'Ji H! (i fr.liK :� C retiYf't' Ii a h [W-V.I - FLre[!.. C' C '' I'tlltli;tlljtFL n 1 611 1, ul;k W. -I �: ].11 11 t1Ori 111 L Ua:i • ;11 r.b ifL Qj(%-.tin g a Md Raid thIlk Al11 I.1) U W4rUILI pts w ffJr r.11 i�l 11) iIV [ f it t'., i u bc. P 1-ovo d LhV 1'[' B 11 E i;ikp IR Br_`rVICC'_ thr+ t owt}r m n Ix, LI o nw d by t.hiY r a y Inir t ho .1 !lt y w tl.l not dt-ny I T. o vii ja if no ed cLinnut be es tab listwd if t.htr-- is not o noxigh opposition to it. We r-: to k1 kri :i,, rKLO in i h i kx Esq ga thr+ring inA Frrnation i n c.Lich (if i ki Ir yiibdivi�uion, re garding LLAT L'la1fie'i'rd l', I kMnw per--ul7'LL I LX', Ih.Ivi•''tI _0n �U-jEl ha�•C. niP prjPh]eui!+ W.jth f[rffi715['fi �.`i►ll�. 'I'lS, iI�+�er 4t . in Illiri h f�fli i'ixicl + is u VL' n' 71Fn T+3wei, a- w(iil 11,- the tower rin Tidwell ro t1 d. T- M ul ahr Cots IAC L�}-l+etktkL ran L no of the-,-w tower to iacrea-L� thtLu' tmw-rt1ge- Tire re, [trt' aum Lira, ktL;- -oI her 9.vxc• r-b in a ur -arefi. i 2�P-ar-chcil on Iinr- and dis�ov�, red thero are 77 . im? naaF, Maid t mvk-. rS in 1i 4 mils_ r.i rliut� of 4 n r horneg! Leo we iL-a 11v -need rinotho r { me" J1h- h Lu;bUnd hrs ; 'l•'-NI-A ilcs) ml has good --wrvlt`kk at the hrjuso, COWL[ ULCh Of V gat oma,mz what fier or ilot yrr� h����c� ;mod ��Y�� i � t � ; i 73f! �• hr, }�ri 61 al rx' x�' i C h. I v�' i LLa J 0 Pi1LF OW Kra � mnihE to talo, in thLS Illi{`f i Ito � 1#5il.� Wjrii thi F tai - r t I 1 � 7 n. I }li k so c;:i nv:16 you r vii, 1 mh Ntk-h,,r,a Lti : Lildil I r fAmuil thc7�w frik� n kl kl % hrti ii rrr 1 n r.h4� tG NEL I I t - k 1 f they- w ill P:i 1'tiriptEt a in , �h�,rin.r rh,� itp1t�rrrt,ikiota, Alyf,, 11'yi)%1 lirk:��� dr71. �tIrt'�id�•. plrs;k�� �v�'Itl� ik4lP �'nurlcsl ma^ml�crrs, mai ,kir, uwl il5yn N1.1wDrzalel t'41nu-Qvain p fmr tiuppufl. r,lrjsra iriK thI` t-,wr-r_ W4j beli+1 ti-r• t Ii ; k r r hemo :3 1 d �WF�%r Lipli 110 kt low, will k t tho premLdeikce -uonrerntng Future app Uc:i t Wi3n _ UnfortahLi v ly_ wtj av � I lie �rwnun 1) i" k}}- V4 hich fui tu-6 .taiklag lavv: with be w ritten. Tha nk r for ynur !3mj) 7nrr K iiv Nory Ll I Rob4n MacDonald MEMP Fromi -•. �s�i L i3lkinerapis hG Sent_ F r -;1a}, Jarl wary %a, �!G1 D 3 04 RM To; Arlie ZahIit !BailEy, Chrib Lsg&Snom, puri HuWiCL gill Ludk, kidi�, T wrrrian; JoLh L6CKWC Ad Cc= Robyn M& -.Donald Subject- P11 bposed real tame at 8imm Gah-es Fara, Fear howrable Maymj nil i-: It crtizd C otiwil Mcm hcrs_ I am writing to leit you kriaw that my hue band and J are. agairrsl the placement of a cell Ph one tower at 7 Gables Farre, We are re6dent!3 of the adjoining neighbarhoaki at Sunnybmork Farms at 2285 Sadd Iespri ng$ DT Whi le we are not against cell lowers in any part of our city, we believe they sh D uld be placed carefully In cornmercial areas and rpt in residential areas -such as this where they are sure to bQ eyewfies and bring down adjoining property values. We appreblat your public service and t�Wol attenVon Eo this issue. Best regards, Shane -.and Gale ste JaQ�son 2285 Said d Iesprwg% Dr. L%on. GA 3DD04 Rol) r7 M-a-cOur ald From: shan!aba,rhtentYns.wm StFLI; ThurrdDry, ,January 07, 2DJ0 11.4 t PM To: Robyn MwDonald Subject: PrCkpo!5ed Ceti Ta ver at 7 agues ra" Rotwn — 1 Am wr,Nnp in Iit you knew mat mfr mfe and I 2f argair?st 1hEL placan-*ntiat a Goll pho-na kyuvr at 7 Gablts Farm VV$-ana re��leMs of kh,� �d�iirlie5� na��bp�h�c� at Su nnyrl�rt�lc Farrr� a� ���� ��eldl�spr�r,gs �r +le ,rr$ ars not. �g�Gns1 �� fwera inany pat#Ol our elty, we flim they should be pIaukd t:w9ifuhly Irl -: Iw 17erciigl ilr35 anct not Lri nTidenfral jriMrt 5urh as this Wherz lheyr ars sure Ln t]2 e:�etofes and biin!� ¢Ic'wn ad�nLniN proper#y Values Wfl aPPM-cia1Z your public soivica and careful atlaritian to INs iE�Iue- Bess regards, nre Eind Cele=1e Jac lc5.0rti Robyn Marporta Ld From: Norwell jp1pp9O8@a1f r3Bfl sora: Tlsursday. January 07, 2D10 R:3G PM TD: Rot�Vn Ma aanald Sub)"%: Fw. PE14 ori Fmn: Lyon Rauzkkw To- NppjWkaRLnet sCtnl. Tnursdsy, Januwy-W. �O10 6.25 PDA sUbj tet: NLii!• n 1 k hib I Nukd mW i just move J'tu Allamw (i mo I hK Cloarbw.Aa snWivisi n E pix -%vec k; err- u-nd ;irk vcn- RTOTLgI , orymI -mrl to hmf L.[; it Le I 11471k)L1r p IaCLOd 50 4`I Cls LSF W116LTC WC 111'C ["Irl 171 111-0 ; U!E' L,rL %%•ti 11116%'6!LI c 11 LL LI I11%, �4UN. m u,% i]miUse IYf :141 1hL I.,pum 111130 JOIJ KL'4uL1!'Ld SJIUUL Ihal LAW vxLwu ulI IIii-. 4LI.ly' W' 4iA%11 H�. AI,iL r1 11LLl':1Ilti %k L; .32t 4;Lf11 1 LI LLIIUU1 %V1 tilt It M - LIM dO Lt1 LFLL1 I'Ll-P%r1}' tiU1IIV YOE CM caul LL L.)11 i N 1'or our 4ujc] ri tM 111V pVt1j c!r1 111 L gqXksr L'-� j Li41, ItF� ;I Jjj ILL LIM q1- I .11 11 X41447 I %WSI1 'I jl}a�; co c�amc by io pr-v.oual f) iign i[ klm� t1ds t3 >Linj�. I Imilk vci I I tiio T11 LiGh E�*r i% 11,YL ou MCL dad jlg .3rkL[ 1M atc Ili n LL; 10 tbi 5 CL5nL'k.'m sdlw L. mly, LY].111 f& ] iL-W ki ormi "p gacoomid From: NoiVelt tp+pFQO tt.!ietj 5IPL-11; Thum -day. Jamiary PT 2010 -3:07 FIWI To; Kok nc-aanald subjAtt Fvr� T-Moblie petRk n — Oilglrral Me --sage. — Frnm: Anise C Ilesh ire T.D= pJl i09 'f nat Be at: Tliui sday, Jallilary 07.26.1 1� $_n AM subject: r-rdlbhila pejdbvn Pltaa6 rnelude. our names IrM a.u? pj r af. thi§ p+ Nein against t1i -T•M II X11 tower w bOD places at 1405 Aopawml Rlamd. Thank yaw fbr yotGr of urtg on I7eKaif Qf aur mrnffxmityr i �3hiawn & Arge Ck im 7$0 Slratroc-de arra Milm, GrA - K004 771 -WG jphone] 7 ��rfi63.7� � F �tarc� ar�p:� he�ir��n�rt ries Robyn MacDonald t=ram, Dutch Muir jhntasQtYrtheAMt,jr%d.rornj Sent= Thursday. January 07, 2.} 10 2:42 PM To; guhkn MacDwald Cr-: pipplM@altnet 15 ubic�t; Purpmesd Call Tiy yDr'on S9van Gables P;mpe %r Attach me nta= al!d U%e jpg Ms. McDonald, We are Holland and Ruhy Mills ands we reside at 2405 Saddlesprirlgs Drive in Sunny 0rook Farms. The placing c f a 154 -foot cell tow$ r in a residential area is counter intuitive to what the Milton area re prey ants. We are adamantly against it. Ru by an d I p U rG h used he re, moor in 9 fro m Sandy Sp ri rugs 20 yea rs ago, to hevo a r -U ra i lifesty le. 5 M in ray Sroo k Fa rms iEx a pictu res quo a xamp to of what a; UIl Ito n equestrian cc rrim ren Ny shoul d be. as i I fustra Led a ri all t Publicatdc ns of th 6 C ity of M rlto r}_ It is -a s ha me that the rnsi dents of Ml IbDn whom h a ire ch on -e n th is sa me tifesWe a re tinct e r siege fc r sheer econom is ga GM. T h e econ om is gai n of S even Gab tes Farm s haul d not he at the expen-se -of itsa urroun di ng nei q hbom. I would $ncou raga the City of N111ton to investigate rr reating ec onom Gc zones of development s pec If cal ly for teleco rrim un5 cation_ T his war, Id e n s rrra not on Iy the seren i ty of our city but keep vital revenues of '{ to x a nd Ian d leases" to en s u re ou r city's Futu re- Wc rec o g n tze tho imp arta rice of eco nornlc de -w elopme rit an d e no ou rage g rowth For th e s a ke of a larger to x Wse, howea er, i t s ho u Id not bo th rust into the middt$ of a maid ua I co m mu n ity where acreorg a ex ist to s uppc rt th e e questrian I Ifestyles- promoted by the C ity of M i1ton. P t e ase lo g o e r op positio n to th, Is pro pasal. Holland and Ruby -lllls 2405 S ate dles pri n gs Drive NtiJton, GA 304114 No Text RobXn MacDonald FrcrFn! NorwellIpippiO] tt.netj sent= ThuF ,r, . snuary 07. �R4 TCI 12'V ANI To; Robyn MwDoneJij 9LAIIEClL Fw, gell tgwu — Orgral M�ssag� — FpomL Lasa To: oiopiMamrYt? sent Tuw_sdayr. Jersuery ON 2010 7 1.2 PIM au bjea; oell tWier I am &malhnq asst femw a�_ iollow% mnoemiFtig the pvDpoaed yell WAw Q 14-d9!5 Hopogwr-A Fid r0* 60pn r! Me R,eNrorr A GAMST 1h* bihittFing of a CeY ltrww a! 144:95 He)pawtPf fEq syrmyn�Un4 XP.SidgnbM usa. rho fql VAaLr�d irof w0y bs a.n9w& imod asth icagy, btri such a W'Fu stur; ,g not irr keeon.9 w0th thfF rzarar, rQ;5hderitrar eine of suM1,UndioIq Peop-niIr[i9, Fta PCM fltir k W a rrapatov0 e,•rwfro HrrIerrret 8rci hPfm07 1mP�hpf of :5rj�h :o"rs haas .Oof be.9n l jWr6lnfr. SII ars?ori hR& iim�L - ttleru zhaulri tie arr environrrwr;tal iMpad 51uidy fdr=d Unth ihi2 r5LM Lit Mi1Lart ar fLllOn COufity as part Gf the apps sawn proces% For T. depaL- ling 4n requi mrie-r7ts - wQlih oi- EcMna into prmr is Lhe rriE tui lig 1,211 Tbui Sdlisg 699 - you M1 a15D fagLhik a &apyr 0 the appliwrrurti as wren -.all pu GVH information - t suomssiully lought Ono al lha sa goilig up adjawnr10-my propel#' ftu5a) in NG many years aqo� Regard, LIsm SvFrkI i i Mrlr><a �;7ndl,� Robyn MacDonald brow: J and M HarriF, Uarmdrnharr Qb� aLwuth rix] Sant: Thursday, Jarwary N..201(1 xt1U.AM To: Robyn MarAonald Subjel I: 'r-mbilft ter nn Hopywell Ms. McDonald. WE are Michael -arid J111 ian Harris and we raside at X410 5 addlespri ngs Drives ire Sunr7 yr Brook Fam rs: The piaong of a 15.4 -foot cell tuwti r i n a res itfr,-ntWl a ries Is- bounter inlUitive to vrW the M i Iton area repres a nis We art. adamantly agatnsi it_ We purchased Dere moving Rom Gunwood y, to have a ru ra I lifestylie to r Ou r chi fdiren a rid fUtu re Sunny Bryk Farms is a picturesque exaMple of awhal a Milton equeWan etimm b n ity should he_ It Is a shame that the rarildent-, of M ilio n whom have chin this -,-amia I ifestyte are under siege for shee r economic gai n The %onorn a in of Seven Gables Farm s h o u Id nol to a t tha expense of its :� usmund,ng naig h boos would -e ncau rage the City of Millon to in gest ate creating economic zen es of deae leprnent specifical Iy [Dr 18le❑ommuniicntp❑ rrs_ This wau Id ensure nut or7Iy the se renily Df aUr City IJu t keep Arita I €evi3nues affair and land I-easea" to ensure onr city's future P lea st! log our oppo:satsun to R his proposal, M Ithael end Alian H wns 2410 Saddlespdncls Drive bRIWA, GA 30004 No Text Robyn MacDonald From: Norvell [pippi08@att.net] Sent: Thursday, January 07, 2010 12:21 AM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Fw: cell tower ----- Original Message ----- From: Lisa To: pippia8@att.net Sent: Tuesday, January 05, 2010 7:92 PM Subject: cell tower I am emailing a statement as follows concerning the proposed cell tower @ 14495 Hopewell Rd - 1 strongly support the petition AGAINST the building of a cell tower at 94495 Hopewell Road as this is not in keeping with surrounding residential use. There would not only be a negative impact asthetically, but such a structure is not in keeping with the rural, residential use of surrounding properties. The potential for a negative environmental and health impact of such towers has not been disproven. (If anyone has time - there should be an environmental impact study filed with the city of Milton or Fulton County as part of the application process for T -Mo bile depending on requirements - worth checking into prior to the meeting on Thursday night - you can also request a copy of the application as well - all public information - 1 successfully fought one of these going up adjacent to my property (house) in NC many years ago) Regards, Lisa Renko We must become the change we want to see. MAialma G; wrlhi Robyn MacDonald From: Ed Richardson [ed@issracksystems.coml Sent: Monday, January 18, 2010 6:41 PM To: Chris Lagerbloom; Robyn MacDonald; Burt Hewitt; Bili Lusk; Karen Thurman; Julie ZahnerBailey; Joe Longoria; Joe Lockwood Subject: Stop The Cell Tower At Seven Gables Farms Importance: High To The City Of Milton Elected Officials: I am a City of Milton taxpayer and I respectfully request that you deny the application by T -Mobile to obtain a use permit for a cell tower at the Seven Gables Farm on Hopewell Road in Milton, GA. This is something that should not be located in a beautiful residential area of our fine city. Instead, T -Mobile should find an appropriate industrial space to install their cell tower so that it will not infringe on the beautiful landscape we have fought so many years to conserve. Please help us to protect our beautiful city from this unnecessary eyesore. Thank You, Ed Richardson 805 Bethany Green Court Milton, GA 30004 Also, recently purchased a new home at the Greystone subdivision right down the road from Seven Gables Farm: 105 Foxhollow Trail Milton, GA 30004 Robyn MacDonald From: WILLIAM SHOULDICH [will iamshouldice[ia bellsouth.net] Sent: Wednesday, January 13, 2510 5:38 FM To: pippi08@att.net Cc: Joe Lockwood; Burt Hewitt; Bill Lusk; Karen Thurman; Julie ZahnerBaiiey; Joe Longoria; Chris Lagerbloom; Robyn MacDonald Subject: petition signature - T -Mobile application for use permit Please accept my support for the petition against the application to build a 150 foot monopole cell tower. This tower placement will have a direct negative effect on property values in an area that is primarily residential and agricultural. The proposed area contains a significant number of residences ranging in value from $500k to $2 million. We have no use for this commercial and industrial fixture within the confines of our community. There are alternative industrial areas within 2 miles of the proposed site which would be much more suitable for all parties. There is also potential risk of health issues that have not been fully researched (see below). 1 trust that Mayor Lockwood, our city council members, city managers and zoning board will act competently to preserve the value and safety of our community. Respectfully submitted William Shouldice 485 North Fields Pass Milton, GA 30004 770-343-9515 What are the Dangers of Living Near Cell Phone Towers? by www.Six'Wise.com Over 190 million cell phones are in use in the United States, with users often scrambling to another room, buildir street to get better reception. As consumers, it is frustrating when your cell phone reception gets dropped or is toy garbled to hear. But beyond "Can you hear me now?" is another considerably more important question: Are the cell towers and antennas popping up all over the country - -the very ones that we depend on for clear reception and a wide coverage area -- safe? This may have been a moot issue in the past when the towers were sparse and limited to obscure cornfields and hilltops. But the number of these cell "sites," as they're called, has increased tenfold since 1994. Among the more than 175,000 cell sites in the United States are antennas on schools, churches, firehouses, cemeteries and national parks. There's even a cell tower near Old Faithful in Yellowstone. "Don't Put That Tower Here" "Our companies are always running into this conundrum, which is, 'We want cell phone service, but don't put that tower here.' When you're dealing with communications through the air, you have to have antennas and towers," said Joe Farren, a spokesman for CTIA -The Wireless Association, the industry's trade group. Aesthetics aside, the primary reason most people don't want cell sites near their homes and communities is because they're afraid of the potential health effects. Already, more than 500 cases have sprung up across the country in which people have tried to stop cell phone sites from being constructed, according to Washington attorney Ed Donohue, who represents several cell phone companies. Most of the time, the cell phone companies win because, as it stands, federal law does not allow rejection of a tower based on health risks. Cell Phone Towers: Risky or Not? If you ask the government, no studies have shown conclusive evidence that radio-frequency emissions, a form of electromagnetic radiation (EMR), from cell towers are harmful. According to the Food and Drug Administration: "RF [Radio frequency] exposure on the ground is much less than exposure very close to the antenna and in the path of the transmitted radio signal. In fact, ground -level exposure from such antennas is typically thousands of times less than the exposure levels recommended as safe by expert organizations. So exposure to nearby residents would be well within safety margins." Cell phone companies also maintain that no risks exist from the towers. "There are no health risks posed by the towers. Independent scientific panels around the world have reached this conclusion," said Russ Stromberg, Beni( manager of development at T -Mobile. But other studies seem to tell a different story, with findings such as: A study by Dr. Bruce Hocking in Australia found that children living near three TV and FM broadcast towers (similar to cell towers) in Sydney had more than twice the rate of leukemia than children living more than seven miles away. Says Dr. Neil Cherry, a biophysicist at Lincoln University in New Zealand: a "Public health surveys of people living in the vicinity of cell site base stations should be being carried out now, and continue progressively over the next two decades. This is because prompt effects such as miscarriage, cardiac disruption, sleep disturbance and chronic fatigue could well be early The government and cell phone indicators of the adverse health effects. Symptoms of reduced companies maintain cell towers immune system competence, cardiac problems, especially of (and phones) are safe. the arrhythmic type, and cancers, especially brain tumor and leukemia, are probable." • Biomedical engineer Mariana Alves -Pereira says exposure to cell phone towers can lead to vibroacoustic disease. "From what I understand, some of the complaints are similar in what is seen in vibroacoustic disc patients, which are people who develop a disease caused by low frequency noise exposure," she said. Symptoms can include mood swings, indigestion, ulcers and joint pain. • Dr. Gerard Hyland, a physicist who was nominated twice for the Nobel Prize in medicine, says, "Existing safety guidelines for cell phone towers are completely inadequate ... Quite justifiably, the public remains skeptical of attempts by governments and industry to reassure them that all is well, particularly given the unethical way in which they often operate symbiotically so as to promote their own vested interests." ■ According to the Mount Shasta Bioregional Ecology Center, "Studies have shown that even at low levels this radiation, there is evidence of damage to cell tissue and DNA, and it has been linked to brain tumors, cancer, suppressed immune function, depression, miscarriage, Alzheimer's disease, and numerous other serious illnesses." • According to Dr. W. Lvscher of the Institute of Pharmacology, Toxicology and Pharmacy of the Veterina School of Hannover in Germany, dairy cows that were kept in close proximity to a TV and cell phone tov for two years had a reduction in milk production along with increased health problems and behavioral abnormalities. In an experiment, one cow with abnormal behavior was taken away from the antenna and t behavior subsided within five days. When the cow was brought back near the antenna, the symptoms returned. Robyn MacDonald From: Moshe Ben Herut [mbh929@hotmail.com1 Sent: Saturday, January 23, 2010 6:01 PM To: vickie_30004@yahoo.com; djtad@bellsouth.net; rjluxton@mindspring.com; mbh929 @hotmail.com; mike2dee@comcast.net; squirt50@bellsouth.net; pstimme2@comcast.net; kahvaz@comcast.net; washburnt@gmail.com; linda.hall@att.net; mhwilli@bellsouth.net; sgi1433@hotmail.com; debra.landrum@hotmail.com; angiecheshire@comcast.net; 4mcilvain@comcast.net; shawn_simmons2002@yahoo.com; mversteegh@comcast.net; rscott@jsmithlanier.com; danielle2bakert@yahoo.com; pippi08@att.net; Chris Lagerbloom; Robyn MacDonald; Burt Hewitt; Bill Lusk; Karen Thurman; Julie ZahnerBailey; Joe Longoria; Joe Lockwood; eddie- lee- brown@oomcast.net: pattisilva+@mac.com; n.cutter@comcast.net-, rashellscott[,]a me.com Subject: FW: Cell Tower - in support PR From: mbh929@hotmail.com To: rashellscott@me.com Subject: RE: Cell Tower - in support Date: Sat, 23 Jan 2010 09:32:40 -0500 PR for poor people? who are Nancy Cutter and Eddie Lee Brown ? coming from California explains everything !!!!!! obviously they seem very sympathetic towards the farm owners and but not sympathetic toward us.Why don't they STICK the antenna on their own property or somewhere ELSE? Moshe Ben-Herut CC: vickie_30004@yahoo.com; djtad@bellsouth.net; rjluxton@mindspring.com; mbh929@hotmail.com; mike2dee@comcast.net; squirt50@bellsouth.net; pstimme2@comcast.net; kahvaz@comcast.net; wash burnt@gmail.com; linda.hall@att.net; mhwilli@bellsouth.net; sg11433@hotmail.com; debra.land rum@hotmai1.com; angiecheshire@comcast.net; 4mcilvain@comcast.net; shawn_simmons2002@yahoo.com; mversteegh@comcast.net; rscott@jsmithlanier.com; danielle2bakert@yahoo.com; pippi08@att.net; Chris. Lagerbloom@cityofmiltonga.us; Robyn. Macdonald@cityofmiltonga. us; burt.hewitt@cityofmiltonga.us; bill. lusk@cityofmiltonga.us; karen.thurman@cityofmiltonga.us; julie.zahnerbailey@cityofmiltonga.us; joe.longoria@cityofmiltonga.us; joe.lockwood@cityofmiltonga.us; eddie. lee. brow n@comcast.not; pattisilva@mac.com From: rasheliscott@me.com To: n.cutter@comcast.net Subject: Re: Cell Tower - in support Date: Sun, 10 Jan 2010 15:50:21 -0800 how would we know that Harmon wanted this to take place on his property, I would assume he didn't, unless we were to hear from him as you have only because it seems like you know him. I of course wouldn't want him to go out of business, is he indeed in danger of this happening? I have seen new construction on the home on this property -I would think if he was in financial struggle that this wouldn't be possible. On Jan 10, 2010, at 3:25 PM, Nancy Cutter wrote: Dear Neighbors, It is human nature that we take for granted the joys and conveniences of everyday life, overlooking the price we need to pay for them. There is a proposal to put a cell phone tower in our community. Many people will view this as an eyesore and vow to work to stop its construction. I would like for us to step back and take a look at the bigger picture. Seven Gables is an asset to our community. The owner's name is Harmon. It is my understanding that he has been here before many of the subdivisions were built in this area. I am sure that he disliked having the country atmosphere changed by the building of subdivisions around his property. However, he has been very kind to us and all of you by welcoming everyone to come to Seven Gables and enjoy his menagerie. If you have not taken the opportunity to visit Harmon, I urge you to do so. He welcomes us to come inside the gates, and walk around - petting the goats, visit the alpaca and miniature horses, plus there is a wide range of other animals that you cannot see from the road. He and his operation is truly an asset to out community. I am filled with joy every time I drive by and look to see what animals are in the front pasture that day. The presence of Seven Gable surely increases the value of our property. It seems Harmon's main source of income is from stabling horses and selling some goats. Horse owners and the businesses involved in their care have been hard hit by the down turn in the economy. Many horse owners had to sell horses because of the rapid rise in feed prices. Eddie Lee and I have been worried that Seven Gables might fall on hard times and have to sell the property to a developer. If that should happen this asset would be last and possibly replaced by a high density development to help bring more tax income to Milton; this would definitely lead to a decline in our property values. Many farmers around the country have turned to leasing part of their land for windmills or cell towers. If having a cell tower at Seven Gables will enable them to stay in business and be a valued neighbor for years to come, I am all for allowing a cell tower to be placed on that property. This is a big piece of land and it is possible that you won't be able to see the tower well. I am sure we all remember the outrage we felt when people surrounding one of our Stratforde neighbor's property threatened his business by attempting to restrict how he could use his property. Now that the tables are turned, 1 would encourage us to remember that lesson and not attempt to prevent Seven Gables from using this property in a way that would allow them to remain healthy. We lived in California for many years. As more and more restrictions were put on the use of land, many small businesses lost their ability to survive, and we watched flower fields change into Home Depots. Let us also look at our own involvement in this. If cell phone companies did not need to expand to provide their growing customer base with the additional capacity for voice, texting, and G3 services, they would not be spending resources to build these towers. You may receive good coverage today, but will not as use rises. If you are opposed to this tower, to remain logically consistent, you should cancel your cell phone service. I expect that most families in our subdivision have multiple cell phones that are used for texting and needless communications, rather than for emergencies. We will not be opposing this cell tower and suggest that you consider taking the same stance. You risk losing a valuable neighborhood asset in this wonderful open space horse farm, all to block something you won't even notice in six months. Nancy Cutter and Eddie Lee Brown Hotmail: Trusted email with Microsoft's powerful SPAM protection. Sign up now. Hotmail: Trusted email with Microsoft's powerful SPAM protection. Sign up now. Robyn MacDonald From: Karen Muller [kkmuller@comcast_net] Sent: Thursday, January 21, 2010 8:40 PM To: Robyn MacDonald; Joe Lockwood; Burt Hewitt; Julie ZahnerBailey Cc: Bill Lusk; Joe Longoria; Alan Tart; Karen Thurman Subject: Cell tower Dear Madame and Sirs, I am writing in regards to, the possible, cell tower being erected at Seven Gables Farm. I moved to this area, from out of state, almost 4 years ago. I loved the "country in the city" feeling. Exiting my sub-divsion, Greystone, and seeing the horses, barns, tractors, goats etc. I made a great investment in this neighborhood. was disheartened to learn of a 150 foot cell tower in line with my two million dollar home. I have asked everyone I know, not one is a T -mobile customer. Are they trying to improve their customer base and make more money? That would be at my cost and the cost of my children. I Auld never purchase a home, especially an expensive one, in clear sight of a cell tower. My home value will go down so, in turn, my $26,040 tax bill should go down. I drive to work each day. I have seen many other, more commercial areas, that would better suit a cell tower. Some towers have dual uses. Can they use an existing tower? I know I speak for all of my neighbors, we are enraged. I strongly hope this cell tower does not pass city council approval. Sincerely, Karen Kelly Muller Robyn Macdonald From: Ed Richardson [ed@issracksystems.com] Sent: Monday, January 18, 2010 6:41 PM To: Chris Lagerbloom; Robyn MacDonald; Burt Hewitt; Bill Lusk; Karen Thurman; Julie ZahnerBailey; Joe Longoria; Joe Lockwood Subject: Stop The Cell Tower At Seven Gables Farms Importance. High To The City Of Milton Elected Officials I aro a City of Milton taxpayer and I respectfully request that you deny the application by T -Mobile to obtain a use permit for a cell tower at the Seven Gables Farm on Hopewell Road in Milton, GA. This is something that should not be located in a beautiful residential area of our fine city. Instead, T -Mobile should find an appropriate industrial space to install their cell tower so that it will not infringe on the beautiful landscape we have fought so many years to conserve. Please help us to protect our beautiful city from this unnecessary eyesore. Thank You, Ed Richardson 805 Bethany Green Court Milton, GA 30004 Also, recently purchased a new home at the Greystone subdivision right down the road from Seven Gables Farm: 105 Foxhollow Trail Milton, GA 30004 Prepared by the Community Development Department for the Mayor and City Council Meeting on April 12, 2010 (First Presentation) 4/5/2010 Page 1 of 18 U09-05 PETITION NUMBER(S): U09-05 PROPERTY INFORMATION ADDRESS 13302 New Providence Road DISTRICT, LAND LOT 2/2, 996, 997 OVERLAY DISTRICT Northwest EXISTING ZONING AG-1 (Agricultural) ACRES 51.59 EXISTING USE Single family residence PROPOSED USE 150 foot Monopole Cell Tower with a 4 ft. lightning rod for a total of 154 feet OWNER Rosemarie J. Schmidt Family Limited Partnership ADDRESS 13302 New Providence Road Milton, GA 30004 PETITIONER/REPRESENTATIVE T-Mobile South, LLC/Shawn Blassingill ADDRESS 4 Concourse Parkway, Suite 300 Sandy Springs, GA 30328 PHONE 678-612-7489 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT RECOMMENDATION U09-05 – DENIAL INTENT To obtain a use permit for a 150 foot tall monopole cell tower with an additional 4 foot lightning rod for a total of 154 feet (Article 19.4.7). Prepared by the Community Development Department for the Mayor and City Council Meeting on April 12, 2010 (First Presentation) 4/5/2010 Page 2 of 18 U09-05 PLANNING COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION – MARCH 23, 2010 U09-05 – DENIAL 7-0 Mr. David R. Gilley of Georgia Tax and Regulatory Solutions, LLC presented his findings regarding U09-05 concluded that “Section 19.2.4” gives the Mayor and Council the authority to impose conditions on the approval of use permits. Accordingly, GTRS recommended the Application be approved with the following the conditions: 1. Applicant will submit a certification from a registered engineer that the structure will meet the applicable design standards for wind loads and construction drawings signed and sealed by a licensed structural engineer with its building permit application. 2. Tower will be built as a stealth design and shall be a maximum height of 100 feet. After hearing public concerns regarding the proposed cell tower discussion included whether it was inconsistent with the design of the neighborhood. The applicant couldn’t fully answer questions regarding the need for the tower. The residents believed it is just a business proposition to expand the sale of co- locaters and inconsistent with community preferences for the neighborhood. The Planning Commission discussion included the following issues: 1. The possibility of lowering the height of the tower but the applicant can’t agree to the lowering of the tower until a radio frequency study is conducted. 2. The height of the adjacent power lines which are approximately 60-70 feet. The applicant stated that the height wouldn’t be high enough for co-location with the power poles within the easement. 3. Discussion of stealth structures and if it is available for this site. The applicant stated that it depends on the needed height and trees surrounding it. 4. Why they submitted a property value study using properties that were sold 6 and 7 years ago. 5. Planning Commission requested documentation of discussions with Georgia Power regarding the potential for co-location on utility poles. Please note the following: No new material has been submitted for U09-05 as of March 30, 2010. An additional Design Review Board (DRB) meeting will be held on April 6, 2010 to meet the zoning ordinance’s required advertising for the DRB. Prepared by the Community Development Department for the Mayor and City Council Meeting on April 12, 2010 (First Presentation) 4/5/2010 Page 3 of 18 U09-05 LOCATION MAP Prepared by the Community Development Department for the Mayor and City Council Meeting on April 12, 2010 (First Presentation) 4/5/2010 Page 4 of 18 U09-05 CURRENT ZONING MAP Prepared by the Community Development Department for the Mayor and City Council Meeting on April 12, 2010 (First Presentation) 4/5/2010 Page 5 of 18 U09-05 FUTURE LAND USE MAP Prepared by the Community Development Department for the Mayor and City Council Meeting on April 12, 2010 (First Presentation) 4/5/2010 Page 6 of 18 U09-05 SITE PLAN SUBMITTED DECEMBER 1, 2009 - Distances from property lines/structures Proposed Leased Area Prepared by the Community Development Department for the Mayor and City Council Meeting on April 12, 2010 (First Presentation) 4/5/2010 Page 7 of 18 U09-05 SUBJECT SITE - Looking west toward house on subject site SUBJECT SITE – Interior of property from driveway Prepared by the Community Development Department for the Mayor and City Council Meeting on April 12, 2010 (First Presentation) 4/5/2010 Page 8 of 18 U09-05 Looking east across New Providence Road Photo simulation of tower from subject site Prepared by the Community Development Department for the Mayor and City Council Meeting on April 12, 2010 (First Presentation) 4/5/2010 Page 9 of 18 U09-05 Photo simulation from New Providence Road looking south SUBJECT SITE: The subject site is a 51.59 acre tract of agriculturally zoned land, located on the southwest side of New Providence Road. The subject site is developed with a single-family residence. It is located within the Residential 1 unit or less per acre Land Use designation on the Focus Fulton 2025 Plan which was still in place at the time of this application’s submittal. Existing uses and zoning of nearby property The subject site is surrounded by lots on average ranging in size from one acre to approximately 30 acres. They are developed with single family residences within the AG-1 (Agricultural) district. Providence Plantation subdivision is located to north on the north side of New Providence Road developed with single family residences zoned AG-1 (Agricultural). Further north is Boxwood Estates subdivision zoned CUP (Community Unit Plan) with minimum one acre lots and minimum 3,500 square foot heated floor area. Southeast down Dorris Road are scattered single family residences on large lots with equestrian facilities. Further to the southeast is Oxford Lakes subdivision zoned AG-1 (Agricultural) with single family residences. Further to the south is Ranchette road developed with smaller Prepared by the Community Development Department for the Mayor and City Council Meeting on April 12, 2010 (First Presentation) 4/5/2010 Page 10 of 18 U09-05 AG-1 (Agricultural) lots ranging in size between three and five acres. West of the subject site are large AG-1 (Agricultural) lots with scattered single family residences. Northwest of the site is Providence Lake subdivision zoned AG-1 (Agricultural). The Mayor and City Council approved a Use Permit (U08-06) on the east side of Arnold Mill Road (SR 140) on November 17, 2008 for a Landscaping Business. In addition, the Mayor and City Council denied a Use Permit (U09-01/VC) on the west side of Arnold Mill Road on October 19, 2009 for a Landscaping Business. A 100-foot wide Oglethorpe power easement bisects the subject site and Is located directly north of the proposed leased area. A. Whether the proposed use is consistent with the Comprehensive Land Use Plan and/or Economic Development Revitalization plans adopted by the Mayor and City Council: Focus Fulton 2025 Plan Map: Residential 1 unit or less per acre The proposed monopole cell tower is inconsistent with the intent and following policies of the Focus Fulton 2025 Comprehensive Plan (this plan was still in place at the time of the applicant filing this request): Encourage development consistent with the surrounding scale, transition of densities and uses, and Comprehensive Plan policies, where appropriate. Protect the existing rural character of Northwest Fulton. B. Compatibility with land uses and zoning districts in the vicinity of the property for which the use permit is proposed; The proposed 150 foot monopole with 4 foot lightning rod is inconsistent with the adjacent land uses of single family residences on large agricultural parcels and associated agricultural uses such as barns and riding rings. The closest residential structure is approximately 479 feet from the proposed monopole cell tower located on east side of New Providence Road. Other residential structures are located 539 feet, 432 feet and 506 feet to the southwest (on the subject site), northwest and north respectively. Although, it meets the use permit standards for setbacks, it is Staff’s opinion that it is incompatible based on the location of the tower to nearby residential structures. Further, the tower appears to be located such that it will be higher than the tree stands and will not be visually screened from the road as depicted in the tower simulation photos above. Prepared by the Community Development Department for the Mayor and City Council Meeting on April 12, 2010 (First Presentation) 4/5/2010 Page 11 of 18 U09-05 C. Whether the proposed use may violate local, state and/or federal statutes, ordinances or regulations governing land development; It is Staff’s opinion that the proposed use does not violate local, state and/or federal ordinances or regulations governing land development. D. The effect of the proposed use on traffic flow, vehicular and pedestrian, along adjoining streets; The proposed monopole cell tower is an unmanned operation that will generate only an occasional trip to the site for maintenance. Staff is of the opinion that the proposed monopole cell tower will not impact traffic flow along adjoining streets. E. The location and number of off-street parking spaces; For occasional maintenance trips to the site, space is available nex t to the gate of the 10,000 square foot leased area. Staff is of the opinion that parking will not impact the surrounding areas due to the size of the large parcel and the location of the leased area away from New Providence Road and located in the middle of the parcel . F. The amount and location of open space; The applicant’s site plan indicates a leased area of 10,000 square feet and an additional access easement. The remainder of the property is developed with a single family residence. The parcel is approximately 51 acres which provides a large area of open space. G. Protective screening; Although the submitted site plan meets the requirements of Article 19.4.7 to provide a 10-foot landscape strip planted to buffer standards exterior to the required fencing not less than 6 feet in height, Staff recommends that the applicant provide a 20-foot landscape strip in lieu of the required 10 foot landscape strip planted to buffer standards to provide additional screening of the tower and associated facilities. This will be reflected in the Recommended Conditions. H. Hours and manner of operation; The proposed monopole cell tower is an unmanned operation that will generate only an occasional trip to the site for maintenance. Staff will condition the site maintenance to be completed between the hours of Prepared by the Community Development Department for the Mayor and City Council Meeting on April 12, 2010 (First Presentation) 4/5/2010 Page 12 of 18 U09-05 8:30 a.m. and 5:30 p.m., Monday through Friday except in cases of emergency or when an after-hours permit is obtained pursuant to the City of Milton Noise Ordinance. I. Streetscape lighting; The applicant has not indicated any streetscape lighting for the site. In addition, no lights will be attached to the monopole tower. Staff notes that any security light utilized in the maintenance area must comply with the Northwest Overlay District and/or Night Sky Ordinance standards for site lighting. J. Ingress and egress to the property. The applicant’s site plan indicates that access to the leased property will be derived from the existing driveway into the site off of New Providence Road. Given the limited use of the subject site for regular maintenance, Staff is of the opinion that the proposed development’s ingress and egress will have limited impact upon the community when conditioned to the limited times listed above. SITE PLAN ANALYSIS Based on the applicant’s site plan submitted to the Community Development Department on December 1, 2009, Staff offers the following considerations: Use Permit Standards – Article 19.4.7 1. Towers must be set back a distance equal to one and one-half (1½) times the height of the tower adjacent to residential and/or AG-1 zoned property. The closest AG-1 zoning property is located 395 feet from the proposed cell tower location. The minimum required is 231 feet which includes the lighting rod. Therefore, it meets the required one and one-half times the height of the 154 foot tower. 2. Height shall not exceed 200 feet from existing grade. The proposed height of the tower is 154 feet and is below the maximum height allowed. 3. Tower and associated facilities shall be enclosed by fencing not less than six feet in height and shall also be equipped with an appropriate anti- climbing device. Prepared by the Community Development Department for the Mayor and City Council Meeting on April 12, 2010 (First Presentation) 4/5/2010 Page 13 of 18 U09-05 The site plan and associated plans indicate a new six foot high chain link fence with 3 strands of barbed wire. Staff notes that all chain link fencing shall be black vinyl clad. Although barbed wire is permitted in this use and zoning district, Staff recommends that the barbed wire not be utilized which will be reflected in the Recommended Conditions. 4. A minimum 10-foot landscape strip planted to buffer standards shall be required surrounding the facility exterior to the required fence unless the City Arborist determines that existing plant materials are adequate. The site plan indicates a 10-foot landscape strip planted with Leyland cypress. Staff recommends that a 20-foot landscape strip in lieu of the 10- foot landscape strip be planted to buffer standards per the specifications of the City Arborist to provide additional screening of the facilities from adjacent single family residences. 5. Antennas or towers shall not have lights unless required by federal or state law. The proposed tower and antenna will not have any lighting, as it will be less than 200 feet per the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) and the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA). Staff notes that any security light utilized in the maintenance area must comply with the Northwest Overlay District and/or Night Sky Ordinance standards for site lighting. 6. Towers shall not be located within one-half mile from any existing telecommunication tower above the district height, excluding alternative structures. Staff has confirmed that no existing towers are located within one-half mile from the proposed tower. 7. The tower shall comply with applicable state and local statutes and ordinances, including, but not limited to, building and safety codes. Towers which have become unsafe or dilapidated shall be repaired or removed pursuant to applicable state and local statutes and ordinances. The applicant has stated that the proposed tower will comply with all state and local ordinances as listed above and will apply for building permit approval prior to any construction. The applicant is aware and agrees to removal requirements for unsafe or dilapidated wireless facilities. Prepared by the Community Development Department for the Mayor and City Council Meeting on April 12, 2010 (First Presentation) 4/5/2010 Page 14 of 18 U09-05 8. Facilities shall not be artificially lighted except to assure human safety or as required by the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA). The applicant has stated that the facilities will not be artificially lighted. Staff notes that on page C3.3 of the construction plans, lighting is indicated. Staff notes that any security light utilized in the maintenance area must comply with the Northwest Overlay District standards and/or the Night Sky Ordinance for site lighting. 9. Communication towers shall be designed and constructed to ensure that the structural failure or collapse of the tower will not create a safety hazard to adjoining properties, according to applicable Federal Standards which may be amended from time to time. The applicant has stated that the proposed tower is designed by certified structural engineers to ensure proper safety according to applicable Federal standards. 10. Telecommunications facilities shall not be used for advertising purposes and shall not contain any signs for the purpose of advertising. The applicant has stated there will not be any advertising on the proposed wireless facility. 11. Any telecommunications facility may co-locate on any existing tower, pole or other structure as long as there is no increase in height to the existing facility. The applicant has stated that the proposed facility may accommodate two additional carriers without increasing the height. 12. A commercial telecommunication facility that ceases operation for a period of 12 consecutive months shall be determined to have terminated and shall be removed within 90 days of termination at the property owner's expense. It shall be the duty of both the property owner and the tower owner to notify the City in writing of any intent to abandon the use of the tower. The applicant has stated that Section 19.4.7(B)(12) will be met. 13. Communication facilities not requiring FAA painting/marking shall have either a galvanized finish or [be] painted a dull blue, gray, or black finish or shall be screened through fencing and landscaping. Prepared by the Community Development Department for the Mayor and City Council Meeting on April 12, 2010 (First Presentation) 4/5/2010 Page 15 of 18 U09-05 The applicant states that the facility will be galvanized steel and screened behind fencing and landscaping. Staff notes that the City Design Review Board shall make the final recommendation for the finish of the structure. 14 An application for a telecommunications facility shall be submitted in accordance with the Department’s Plan Review submittal requirements. The applicant states that the facility will adhere to the above requirements. 15. An application for a telecommunication facility shall include a certification from a registered engineer that the structure will meet the applicable design standards for wind loads. The applicant states that a certified/registered structural report will be provided for the proposed facility. 16. Communications facilities shall not be located in 100-year flood plain or delineated wetlands. The applicant states that the proposed communication facility is not located in a 100-year flood plain or delineated wetlands. Staff has confirmed these findings to be correct. OTHER CONSIDERATIONS Transportation Engineer – No Comments Building Official – No Comments City Arborist – There will be no specimen trees affected by the proposed cell tower. PUBLIC INVOLVEMENT On Thursday, January 13, 2010 the applicant was present at the Community Zoning Information Meeting held at the Milton City Hall. There were approximately 70 to 80 people in attendance from the community of which 4 people indicated interest in U09-05 on the City’s sign in sheet. Public Comments – Staff has received e-mails which are attached expressing both opposition and support of the request. Staff has met with the adjacent property owners. In addition, one resident has called Staff to express their opposition to the proposed cell tower. Prepared by the Community Development Department for the Mayor and City Council Meeting on April 12, 2010 (First Presentation) 4/5/2010 Page 16 of 18 U09-05 City of Milton Design Review Board Meeting – January 5, 2010 Staff notes that another meeting before the Design Review Board is required based on the Zoning Ordinance’s requirement to publish the DRB meeting in the newspapers as well as include it in the adjacent property owners’ notice. This meeting will occur on April 6, 2010. Although this meeting will occur after the Planning Commission, any new comments received at the meeting will also be included as an addendum to the Staff report prior to the Mayor and City Council meeting. The following recommendations were made by the DRB: Board/Applicant comments: o The Board stated that their purpose is to examine the aesthetic aspects of the proposed towers; land use/location is not for them to decide. o The applicant states that the tower will be a standard grey tower, as this is the best option for blending in. The Board states that they preferred this to the fake tree option. o Applicant states that they are willing to meet City standards in terms of fencing. They are willing to remove the 3 rows of barbed wire topping the chain link fencing. o Board inquired as to whether the Applicant would be able to screen the cell tower compound that is adjacent to the power easement (New Providence). The applicant states that the compound is at least 15’ away from the easement, and that the existing trees will remain. o Board informed the applicant that the trees used to screen the compound had to be a mix of evergreens that would provide screening in one year; Leylands are not allowed according to the Ordinance. o Only towers above 200’ are required to be lit. o Stealth products include: light pole, flag pole, mono pine. o The Board reminded the residents that the Board has the responsibility to protect the Code, and therefore the applicant. They ask the public to help by providing as much information as possible. o A balloon test has been flown; applicant has pictures taken from 20 different locations. These pictures would be on display at the CZIM meeting scheduled for Thursday, January 7th at 7:00pm. o There appears to be a Code disconnect. The Code states that a tower “buried far from the ROW is better.” Did not anticipate that homes would be so nearby. Public comments: The cell tower is a commercial use; not appropriate for rural, residential area. Should be on commercial property. The tower would ruin the land value of the surrounding area. The tower would be an eyesore. This is not for the good of the community; not in the spirit of what the City was dreamed of. Prepared by the Community Development Department for the Mayor and City Council Meeting on April 12, 2010 (First Presentation) 4/5/2010 Page 17 of 18 U09-05 The residents would like to explore options for tower camouflage. The applicant should look into other collocate options first. Does the code require a propagation study to access the need for more towers? (This is included in the submitted documents). Resident expressed his frustration and displeasure with the process. Resident stated that his house was 327’ from the proposed Mountain Road tower location; trees less than 100’ tall. Feels that this location was not a good choice for a cell tower. It is important for the Council/Board to visit the sites before they made any decisions. Residents asked if Board considered areas that are highly populated as undesirable for cell towers. (Board reminded her that their purview is limited to aesthetics.) It is incumbent upon Board to understand the unique requirement of the Milton rural community. Resident asked if a fall zone analyses is required. (Towers are designed to collapse within itself.) Resident is concerned about environment impact of tower, especially the poisoning of the spring fed pond if the tower was to fall. Public Participation Plan and Report This petition was administratively deferred to the March 23, 2010 Planning Commission meeting. Staff received an updated Public Participation Report on March 15, 2010 which meets the required submittal date of seven (7) days prior to the Planning Commission meeting. The applicant will be required to submit an updated public participation report 7 days prior to the Mayor and City Council meeting. CONCLUSION It is Staff’s opinion that the proposed cell tower is inconsistent with the adjacent land uses of single family residences on large agricultural parcels and incompatible based on the location of the tower to adjacent residential structures. In addition, the proposed cell tower is inconsistent with the surrounding scale, transition of densities and does not protect the existing rural character of Milton. Therefore, Staff recommends DENIAL of U09-05. Prepared by the Community Development Department for the Mayor and City Council Meeting on April 12, 2010 (First Presentation) 4/5/2010 Page 18 of 18 U09-05 RECOMMENDED CONDITIONS If this petition is approved by the Mayor and City Council , it should be approved USE PERMIT for an Antenna Tower and Associated Structure to Exceed the District Height (Article 19.4.7.) CONDITIONAL subject to the owner’s agreement to the following enumerated conditions. Where these conditions conflict with the stipulations and offerings contained in the Letter of Intent, these con ditions shall supersede unless specifically stipulated by the Mayor and City Council. 1) To the owner’s agreement to restrict the use of the subject property as follows: a) One monopole communications tower and equipment slab(s) and/or building(s). b) The tower shall not exceed 150 feet with a 4 foot lighting rod. 2) To the owner’s agreement to abide by the following: a) To the site plan received by the Milton Community Devel opment Department on December 1, 2009. Said site plan is conceptual only and must meet or exceed the requirements of the Zoning Ordinance and these conditions prior to the approval of a Land Disturbance Permit. Unless otherwise noted herein, compliance with all conditions shall be in place prior to the issuance of the first Certificate of Occupancy or Certificate of Completion. 3) To the owner’s agreement to the following site development considerations: a) To provide a 20 foot landscape strip planted to buffer standards around the leased area. b) All chain link fencing shall be black vinyl clad. c) No barbed wire will be permitted on top of the minimum 6 foot high security fence. d) All site maintenance to be completed between the hours of 8:30 a.m. and 5:30 p.m., Monday through Friday except in cases of emergency or when an after-hours permit is obtained pursuant to the City of Milton Noise Ordinance. Robyn MacDonald From: Norvell [pippi08@att.net] Sent: Monday, January 25, 2010 9:46 AM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Fw: T -Mobile towers ----- Original Message ----- From: Renee Pierce To: i08 att.net Sent: Thursday, January 21, 2010 10:37 AM Subject: T -Mobile towers I am sending this e-mail in support to the petition AGAINST the towers. Renee Pierce 824 Bethany Green Court Hotmail: Free, trusted and rich email service. Get it now. Robyn MacDonald From: Ravi Prakash [rp_bowling@hotmail.corn] Sent: Wednesday, January 20, 2010 1:25 PM To: Robyn Macdonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications ❑ear Sir/Madame: All three sites will improve wireless coverage in Milton, especially in areas where T need it most - at home and in my neighhorhood. T moved to Milton in Dec 2005 and it is almost impossible to talk using our cell phone from home and even in most places around my entire Lake Deerfield community. We are very frustrated and hope that you can assist by giving permit to T -mobile for new towers. Thank you. Sincerely, Ravi Prakash Mailing Address: Ravi. Prakash 12877 Deer Park Ln Milton,GA 30004 Rob n MacDonald From: Rohan Patil [maverickrohan@yahoo.co.in] Sent: Wednesday, January 20, 2010 2:02 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T --Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. All three sites will improve wireless coverage in Milton, especially in areas where I need it most - at home and in my neighborhood. I want to talk, check e-mail or get online with my wireless device from wherever I am, particularly at home. Having poor coverage in a place like Milton is simply unacceptable. In order to have reliable coverage, we need the necessary infrastructure to provide it. I've dropped my landline phone and I rely solely on my wireless phone. It is absolutely imperative that I have reliable wireless coverage to stay connected, particularly in an emergency. Wireless phones have become vital personal and public safety tools in Milton. Please make certain that citizens continue to have the best coverage possible throughout our community. My wireless phone has become a necessity. I use it to check in with my children wherever they are in our community. More importantly, I want my children to always be able to reach me or a 9-1-1 operator in an emergency. I use my wireless phone to stay connected with work, family and friends. Having reliable coverage is important to me. Reliable wireless coverage at home and in my neighborhood is essential for me. Wireless phones are no longer a luxury, they are a necessity. Sincerely, Rohan Patil Mailing Address: Rohan Patil 31003 Deer Trail Milton,GA 30004 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Evilson Rodrigues [wellbonitodemais@hotmail.com] Sent: Wednesday, January 20, 2016 2:46 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Appiications Dear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. I want to talk, check e-mail or get online with my wireless device from wherever I am, particularly at home. Having poor coverage in a place like Milton is simply unacceptable. In order to have reliable coverage, we need the necessary infrastructure to provide it. Sincerely, Evilson Rodrigues Mailing Address: Evilson Rodrigues 1121 northpark In milton,GA 30004 I Robyn MacDonald From: Carolyn Medrano [cmed715@hotmail.com] Sent: Wednesday, January 20, 2010 2:54 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: A new Target Supercenter opened in Milton and there is no service inside the facility for T - Mobile customers. There have been many situation in which family members tried to contact me, with urgent situations and I couldn't be reached while in Target. I also agree the most with the three statements below. All three sites will improve wireless coverage in Milton, especially in areas where I need it most - at home and in my neighborhood. My wireless phone has become a necessity. I use it to check in with my children wherever they are in our community. More importantly, I want my children to always be able to reach me or a 9-1-1 operator in an emergency. Reliable wireless coverage at home and in my neighborhood is essential for me. wireless phones are no longer a luxury, they are a necessity. Sincerely, Carolyn Medrano Mailing Address: Carolyn Medrano 9324 Deer Trail Milton,GA 30004 1 Robyn MacDonald From: loan Turc [icturc[7a gmail.coml Sent: Wednesday, January 20, 2010 3:28 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. All three sites will improve wireless coverage in Milton, especially in areas where I need it most - at home and in my neighborhood. I want to talk, check e-mail or get online with my wireless device from wherever I am, particularly at home. Having poor coverage in a place like Milton is simply unacceptable. In order to have reliable coverage, we need the necessary infrastructure to provide it. I've dropped my landline phone and I rely solely on my wireless phone. It is absolutely imperative that I have reliable wireless coverage to stay connected, particularly in an emergency. Wireless phones have become vital personal and public safety tools in Milton. Please make certain that citizens continue to have the best coverage possible throughout our community. I use my wireless phone to stay connected with work, family and friends. Having reliable coverage is important to me. Reliable wireless coverage at home and in my neighborhood is essential for me. wireless phones are no longer a luxury, they are a necessity. Sincerely, Ioan Turc Mailing Address: Ioan Turc 13561 Weycroft Circle Milton,GA 30004 I Roba`Donald wrr� w � i From: Cindy Carter (ccarte r611@a aol.com] Sent: Wednesday, January 20, 2010 1:18 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: Please approve the cell site locations for T -Mobile which is desperately needed! Thank you! C. Carter Homeowner City of Milton Sincerely, Cindy Carter Mailing Address: Cindy Carter 611 Sandringham Dr Milton,GA 30004 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Joy Uoy.albert@gmail.com] Sent: Thursday, March 11, 2010 4:17 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. All three sites will improve wireless coverage in Milton, especially in areas where I need it most - at home and in my neighborhood. Wireless phones have become vital personal and public safety tools in Milton. Please make certain that citizens continue to have the best coverage possible throughout our community. I've dropped my landline phone and I rely solely on my wireless phone. It is absolutely imperative that I have reliable wireless coverage to stay connected, particularly in an emergency. Reliable wireless coverage at home and in my neighborhood is essential for me. Wireless phones are no longer a luxury, they are a necessity. Sincerely, Joy Mailing Address: ]oy Tang 10090 ]ones Bridge Rd Unit 12 alpharetta,GA 30022 Robyn MacDonald From: Tom Oliff [tomo2006@belIsouth.net] Sent: Thursday, March 11, 2010 5:18 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. All three sites will improve wireless coverage in Milton, especially in areas where I need it most - at home and in my neighborhood. Wireless phones have become vital personal and public safety tools in Milton. Please make certain that citizens continue to have the best coverage possible throughout our community. Sincerely, Tom Oliff Mailing Address: Thomas Oliff 14750 Wood Rd milton,GA 30004 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Alicia Griffin [alicia.griffin a@t-mobile.coml Sent: Thursday, March 11, 2010 5:19 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. I've dropped my landline phone and I rely solely on my wireless phone. It is absolutely imperative that I have reliable wireless coverage to stay connected, particularly in an emergency. Wireless phones have become vital personal and public safety tools in Milton. Please make certain that citizens continue to have the best coverage possible throughout our community. Sincerely, Alicia Griffin Mailing Address: Alicia Griffin 7391 North Point Parkway Alpahretta,GA 30022 I Robyn MacDonald From: Laryn Alfred [lalfred@comcast.net] Sent: Thursday, March 11, 2010 5:47 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications ❑ear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. Wireless phones have become vital personal and public safety tools in Milton. Please make certain that citizens continue to have the best coverage possible throughout our community. My wireless phone has become a necessity. I use it to check in with my children wherever they are in our community. More importantly, I want my children to always be able to reach me or a 9-1-1 operator in an emergency. Sincerely, Laryn Alfred Mailing Address: Laryn Alfred 40 Arabian Ave. Milton,GA 30094 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Don Hogan [me@dhogan.name] Sent: Monday, March 08, 2010 2:32 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. All three sites will improve wireless coverage in Milton, especially in areas where I need it most - at home and in my neighborhood. Reliable wireless coverage at home and in ray neighborhood is essential for me. Wireless phones are no longer a luxury, they are a necessity. Sincerely, Don Hogan Mailing Address: Donald Hogan 3284 Kentworth Lane Milton,GA 30004 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Mary Michels [no3puttca@yahoo.com] Sent: Wednesday, March 10, 2010 510 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. I am tired of having to turn my cell phone off the minute I enter my home. The only reason I still have a landline is because of the lack of current service I have. Wireless phones have become vital personal and public safety tools in Milton. Please make certain that citizens continue to have the best coverage possible throughout our community. Sincerely, Mary Michels Mailing Address: Mary Michels 513 Northumberland Street Milton,GA 30004 1 Robyn MacDonald From: LynnAnn Agnew [Iynnann@gmail.corn] Sent: Wednesday, March 10, 2010 3:48 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: All three sites will improve wireless coverage in Milton, especially in areas where I need it most - at home and in my neighborhood. Sincerely, LynnAnn Agnew Mailing Address: LynnAnn Agnew 330 Marshalls Cove Milton,GA 30004 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Adam Agnew [adam.agnew@capgemini.com] Sent: Wednesday, March 10, 2010 3:47 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: Wireless phones have become vital personal and public safety tools in Milton. Please make certain that citizens continue to have the best coverage possible throughout our community. Sincerely, Adam Agnew Mailing Address: Adam Agnew 330 Marshalls Cove Milton,GA 30004 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Judy Whalen Dudyaw2@gmail.com] Sent: Wednesday, March 10, 2010 1:47 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. All three sites will improve wireless coverage in Milton, especially in areas where I need it most -- at home and in my neighborhood. I use my wireless phone to stay connected with work, family and friends. Having reliable coverage is important to me. Reliable wireless coverage at home and in my neighborhood is essential for me. Wireless phones are no longer a luxury, they are a necessity. Sincerely, 7udy Whalen Mailing Address: Judy Whalen 2495 Hopewell Plantation Dr Alpharetta,GA 30004 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Parul Sharma [ram.sharma77 a@gmail.com] Sent: Wednesday, March 10, 2010 5:35 PM To: Robyn Macdonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: Dear Respected Local Official, I am buying house in City of Milton on Crabapple Road under new subdivision named as Crabapple Crossroads. One of the hindering factor is that I could not make and receive calls in and around this subdivision as this is a newly developed subdivision. This is very close to on of the 3 sites proposed by T -Mobile. These 3 sites will enhance my confidence about my kids going to schools, while I go to Pediatrics when my kids get cold or other, when we go to shopping center (Kroger on Arnold Mill and Crabapple), when I go to play Golf on Atlanta National Golf on New Providence Road. I not only hope but confident that we all have similar concerns for our work and family, irrespective of whatever Carrier/Mobile Operator we use. I want to talk, check e-mail or get online with my wireless device from wherever I am, particularly at home. Having poor coverage in a place like Milton is simply unacceptable. In order to have reliable coverage, we need the necessary infrastructure to provide it. I've dropped my landline phone and I rely solely on my wireless phone. It is absolutely imperative that I have reliable wireless coverage to stay connected, particularly in an emergency. Reliable wireless coverage at home and in my neighborhood is essential for me. Wireless phones are no longer a luxury, they are a necessity. Sincerely, Parul Sharma Bailing Address: Parul Sharma 1728 Hemingwway Lane Alpharetta,GA 30075 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Erica [ericadorris@gmail.com] Sent: Monday, March 08, 2010 2.05 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: My phone doesn't work from Wal-Mart all the over to Zagby's. I have roadside assistant and if something were to ever happen between the 2 locations, i will be medded up. T -Mobile is the cheapest National Provider out there right now. And with these hard times we are facing these days, I need all the help I can get. SO that's why I decided to go with T -Mobile blc of the price. I am an AT&T emplyee and it is cheaper for me to go to T -Mobile even with my companies discounts. That's how important the savings are to me. And now I can't get 1005 of service because of this tower issue. I just want my phone to work. Sincerely, Erica Mailing Address: erica Dorris 5006 Lake Union Hill Road Alpharetta,GA 30004 Robyn MacDonald From: Shirley A. Slaughter [shirleyann012000@yahoo.com] Sent: Monday, March 08, 2010 2:47 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. All three sites will improve wireless coverage in Milton, especially in areas where I need it most - at home and in my neighborhood. I want to talk, check e-mail or get online with my wireless device from wherever I am, particularly at home. Having poor coverage in a place like Milton is simply unacceptable. In order to have reliable coverage, we need the necessary infrastructure to provide it. Wireless phones have become vital personal and public safety tools in Milton. Please make certain that citizens continue to have the best coverage possible throughout our community. I use my wireless phone to stay connected with work, family and friends. Having reliable coverage is important to me. I use my wireless phone to stay connected with work, family and friends. Having reliable coverage is important to me. Reliable wireless coverage at home and in my neighborhood is essential for me. Wireless phones are no longer a luxury, they are a necessity. Sincerely, Shirley A. Slaughter Mailing Address: Shirley Slaughter 1473 Mayfield Road Alpharetta,GA 30009 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Maria -Luisa Beatriz Halbert [emma_bachi@yahoo.comj Sent: Monday, March 08, 2010 5:03 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject. Approve T -Mobile Applications ❑ear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. All three sites will improve wireless coverage in Milton, especially in areas where I need it most - at home and in my neighborhood. I want to talk, check e-mail or get online with my wireless device from wherever I am, particularly at home. Having poor coverage in a place like Milton is simply unacceptable. In order to have reliable coverage, we need the necessary infrastructure to provide it. I've dropped my landline phone and I rely solely on my wireless phone. It is absolutely imperative that I have reliable wireless coverage to stay connected, particularly in an emergency. I use my wireless phone to stay connected with work, family and friends. Having reliable coverage is important to me. Reliable wireless coverage at home and in my neighborhood is essential for me. Wireless phones are no longer a luxury, they are a necessity. I am a pet -sitter and am constantly driving down the back roads of Milton and am constantly losing service or not having service at all which is very frustrating. The new towers are located not only on the road i live on but on the back roads that I work on Wireless phones have become vital personal and public safety tools in Milton. Please make certain that citizens continue to have the best coverage possible throughout our community. Sincerely, Maria -Luisa Beatriz Halbert Mailing Address: Maria -Luisa Halbert 16675 Hopewell RD Alpharetta,GA 30004 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Sent: To: Subject: Dear Sir/Madame: Julie Burns gulieb_1961@yahoo.corn] Wednesday, March 10; 2010 1:00 PM Robyn MacDonald Approve T -Mobile Applications I want to talk, check e-mail or get online with my wireless device from wherever I am, particularly at home. Having poor coverage in a place like Milton is simply unacceptable. In order to have reliable Coverage, we need the necessary infrastructure to provide it. I've dropped my landline phone and I rely solely on my wireless phone. It is absolutely imperative that I have reliable wireless coverage to stay connected, particularly in an emergency. Sincerely, 3ulie Burns Mailing Address: 7ulie Burns 123 North Park Lane Alpharetta,GA 30004 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Jay Call ins UaycI bird@gmai1.corn] Sent: Wednesday, March 10, 2010 1:10 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. All three sites will improve wireless coverage in Milton, especially in areas where I need it most - at home and in my neighborhood. I've dropped my landline phone and I rely solely on my wireless phone. It is absolutely imperative that I have reliable wireless coverage to stay connected, particularly in an emergency. Sincerely, Jay Collins Mailing Address: Jay Collins 16058 Inverness Trail Milton,GA 30004 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Toni Santos [chatwmstoni@gmail.com] Sent: Wednesday, March 10, 2010 1:46 PM To: Robyn Macdonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I am a home owner, tax payer and registered voter in Alpharetta. I am also a TMobile customer. The addiion cellsites provides better service for those of us that live up here. These sites I am sure can be utilitzed in some way to support our state and county services. I don't know the infrastructure of our emergency services but potentially we will need more access to more of these technologies. I'm sure the government has all the legal support to make sure they make the most of this situation. Please support the cell site builds. Reliable wireless coverage at home and in my neighborhood is essential for me. Wireless phones are no longer a luxury, they are a necessity. Sincerely, Toni Santos Mailing Address: Toni Santos 2180 Brookridge Terrace Alpharetta,GA 30004 Robyn MacDonald From: venkataraju thimaiah [shyamusa@aol.com] Sent: Friday, March 19, 2919 1:55 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: please kindly approve the t -moble applications thanks venka thimaiah Sincerely, venkataraju thimaiah Mailing Address: venkataraju thimaiah 455 waterhaven lane alpharetta,GA 30004 Robyn MacDonald From: Edward Chase [kamauski@gmail.com] Sent: Friday, March 19, 2010 1.54 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. I am unable to attend the Planning Commission Hearing on January 25. However, please accept this e-mail as a show of support for these site applications. I've dropped my landline phone and I rely solely on my wireless phone. It is absolutely imperative that I have reliable wireless coverage to stay connected, particularly in an emergency. Sincerely, Edward Chase Mailing Address: Edward Chase 524 Sandringham Drive Milton,GA 30004 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Doug and Tiffany Ray [Tifforay@aol.com] Sent: Friday, March 19, 2010 1:53 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: My wireless phone has become a necessity. Z use it to check in with my children wherever they are in our community. More importantly, I want my children to always be able to reach me or a 9-1-1 operator in an emergency. Sincerely, Doug and Tiffany Ray Mailing Address: Doug Ray 2685 Highland pass Alpharetta ,GA 30004 I Robyn MacDonald From: Dennis Fulton [dennis.fulton@crowncastle.com] Sent: Friday, March 19, 2010 1:43 PM To: Robyn Macdonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. Sincerely, Dennis Fulton Mailing Address: Dennis Fulton 12725 Morris Road extension Alphereta,GA 30004 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Saad Mandi [smimo@hotmail.com] Sent: Friday, March 19, 2010 1:32 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: Wireless phones have become vital personal and public safety tools in Milton. Please make certain that Citizens continue to have the best coverage possible throughout our community. Sincerely, Saad Mandi Mailing Address: Saad Mandi 1409 Treeridge Pkwy Alpharetta,GA 30022 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Linda K_ Elliott [maggiezone@comcast.net] Sent: Friday, March 19, 2010 1:26 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. Wireless phones have become vital personal and public safety tools in Milton. Please make certain that citizens continue to have the best coverage possible throughout our community. I am unable to attend the Planning Commission Hearing on Danuary 26. However, please accept this e-mail as a show of support for these site applications. Sincerely, Linda K. Elliott Mailing Address: Linda Elliott 318 Karen Dr. Alpharetta,GA 30009 1 Robyn acDonald From: joe pfaff Uoepfaff@hotnnail,com] Sent: Friday, March 19, 2010 1:16 PM To: Robyn Macdonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: All three sites will improve wireless coverage in Milton, especially in areas where I need it most - at home and in my neighborhood. Sincerely, joe Pfaff Mailing Address: joe Pfaff 105 quay cir. alpharetta,GA 30009 Robyn MacDonald ■ � - �rr�w-w�rw From: eliane pacheco [epacheco02@grnaiLcom] Sent: Friday, March 19, 2010 1:02 PM To: Robyn Macdonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: All three sites will improve wireless coverage in Milton, especially in areas where I need it most - at home and in my neighborhood I am unable to attend the Planning Commission Hearing on January 26. However, please accept this e-mail as a show of support for these site applications. I am unable to attend the Planning Commission Hearing on January 26. However, please accept this e-mail as a show of support for these site applications.l am unable to attend the Planning Commission Hearing on 7anuary 26. However, please accept this e-mail as a show of support for these site applications_ Sincerely, eliane pacheco Mailing Address: Eliane Pacheco 702 Northpark lane Alpharetta,GA 30004 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Greg [grsears@grnail.com] Sent: Friday, March 19, 2010 1:01 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I greatly support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. T -Mobile is a very Customer friendly Company ( vs The Dinosaurs ) and Happy customers are happy voters : ) Thanks, Greg Sincerely, Greg Mailing Address: Greg Sears 457 Windstone Trail Alpharetta,GA 30004 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Dana Luck [datz rnr.luck a@hotrnai1,conn] Sent: Friday, March 19, 2010 1:01 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I feel it would be a great benefit to those of us in the Milton area with T -Mobile service if you would allow these towers. I, as many of us, use my cell phone when at home and sometimes lose signal when otherwise I have awesome service! I sometimes do have to avoid Bethany Bend due to a couple of dead zones along that route between McGinnis Ferry and Highway 9. I will not be able to attend the meeting because of work and ask you to accept this email as a show of support for this proposal!, All three sites will improve wireless coverage in Milton, especially in areas where I need it most - at home and in my neighborhood. I want to talk, check e-mail or get online with my wireless device from wherever I am, particularly at home. Having poor coverage in a place like Milton is simply unacceptable. In order to have reliable coverage, we need the necessary infrastructure to provide it. Wireless phones have become vital personal and public safety tools in Milton. Please make certain that Citizens continue to have the best coverage possible throughout our community. I use my wireless phone to stay connected with work, family and friends. Having reliable coverage is important to me. Reliable wireless coverage at home and in my neighborhood is essential for me. Wireless phones are no longer a luxury, they are a necessity. Sincerely, Dana Luck Mailing Address: Dana Luck 822 Deerfield Point Milton,GA 30004 1 Robyn Macdonald From: Eran Fainshtad [eranfain c@yahoo.ccrn] Sent: Tuesday, March 16, 2010 10:14 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. All three sites will improve wireless coverage in Milton, especially in areas where I need it most - at home and in my neighborhood. I want to talk, check e-mail or get online with my wireless device from wherever I am, particularly at home. Having poor coverage in a place like Milton is simply unacceptable. In order to have reliable coverage, we need the necessary infrastructure to provide it. My wireless phone has become a necessity. I use it to check in with my children wherever they are in our community. More importantly, I want my children to always be able to reach me or a 9-1-1 operator in an emergency. I use my wireless phone to stay connected with work, family and friends. Having reliable coverage is important to me. Sincerely, Eran Fainshtad Mailing Address: Eran Fainshtad 3124 Commonwealth Milton,GA 30004 1 Robyn MacDonald From: sarah shafor [s_shafor@yahoo.com] Sent: Tuesday, March 16, 2010 10:13 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. All three sites will improve wireless coverage in Milton, especially in areas where I need it most - at home and in my neighborhood. I want to talk, check e-mail or get online with my wireless device from wherever I am, particularly at home. Having poor coverage in a place like Milton is simply unacceptable. In order to have reliable coverage, we need the necessary infrastructure to provide it. I've dropped my landline phone and I rely solely on my wireless phone. It is absolutely imperative that I have reliable wireless coverage to stay connected, particularly in an emergency. Wireless phones have become vital personal and public safety tools in Milton. Please make certain that citizens continue to have the best coverage possible throughout our community. My wireless phone has become a necessity. I use it to check in with my children wherever they are in our community. More importantly, I want my children to always be able to reach me or a 9-1-1 operator in an emergency. I use my wireless phone to stay connected with work, family and friends. Having reliable coverage is important to me. Reliable wireless coverage at home and in my neighborhood is essential for me. Wireless phones are no longer a luxury, they are a necessity. I am unable to attend the Planning Commission Hearing on January 26. However, please accept this e-mail as a show of support for these site applications. Sincerely, sarah shafor Mailing Address: sarah shafor 1465 mayfield rd alpharetta,GA 30009 I Robyn MacDonald From: Steven Spalding [spaIdingsm@yahoo.corn] Sent: Tuesday, March 16, 2010 6155 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I agree with the proposals presented by TMobile. I receive horrible service in this area, especially my house, and feel that we need additional coverage. Sincerely, Steven Spalding Mailing Address: steven spalding 13085 morris road #7002 alpharetta,GA 300e4 Robyn MacDonald From: Daniel Harry [dr_harry@comcast.net] Sent: Tuesday, March 16, 2010 5:52 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. I've dropped my landline phone and I rely solely on my wireless phone. It is absolutely imperative that I have reliable wireless coverage to stay connected, particularly in an emergency. Wireless phones have become vital personal and public safety tools in Milton. Please make certain that citizens continue to have the best coverage possible throughout our community. Thank -you. Sincerely, Daniel Harry Mailing Address: Daniel Harry 112 Laurel Ridge Drive Alpharetta,GA 30004 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Glenda (martstha@yahoo.com) Sent: Tuesday, March 16, 2010 5:47 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. I want to talk, check e-mail or get online with my wireless device from wherever I am, particularly at home. Having poor coverage in a place like Milton is simply unacceptable. In order to have reliable coverage, we need the necessary infrastructure to provide it. Wireless phones have become vital personal and public safety tools in Milton. Please make certain that citizens continue to have the best coverage possible throughout our community. My wireless phone has become a necessity. I use it to check in with my children wherever they are in our community. More importantly, I want my children to always be able -to reach me or a 9-1-1 operator in an emergency. Reliable wireless coverage at home and in my neighborhood is essential for me. Wireless phones are no longer a luxury, they are a necessity. Reliable wireless coverage at home and in my neighborhood is essential for me. Wireless phones are no longer a luxury, they are a necessity. I am unable to attend the Planning Commission Hearing on January 26. However, please accept this e-mail as a show of support for these site applications. Sincerely, Glenda Mailing Address: Glenda M PQ Box 723 Alpharetta,GA 30007 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Rohan Patil [maverickrohan@yahoo.co.in] Sent: Tuesday, March 16, 2014 5:46 PM To: Robyn Macdonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications ❑ear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. All three sites will improve wireless coverage in Milton, especially in areas where I need it most - at home and in my neighborhood. I want to talk, check e-mail or get online with my wireless device from wherever I am, particularly at home. Having poor coverage in a place like Milton is simply unacceptable. In order to have reliable coverage, we need the necessary infrastructure to provide it. I've dropped my landline phone and I rely solely on my wireless phone. It is absolutely imperative that I have reliable wireless coverage to stay connected, particularly in an emergency. Wireless phones have become vital personal and public safety tools in Milton. Please make certain that citizens continue to have the best coverage possible throughout our community. My wireless phone has become a necessity. I Use it to check in with my children wherever they are in our community. More importantly, I want my children to always be able to reach me or a 9-1-1 operator in an emergency. I use my wireless phone to stay connected with work, family and friends. Having reliable coverage is important to me. Reliable wireless coverage at home and in my neighborhood is essential for me. Wireless phones are no longer a luxury, they are a necessity. I am unable to attend the Planning Commission Hearing on January 26. However, please accept this e-mail as a show of support for these site applications. Sincerely, Rohan Patil Mailing Address: Rohan Patil 31003 Deer Trail Milton,GA 30004 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Ravi Prakash [rp_bowling@hotmail.comj Sent: Tuesday, March 16, 2010 5:45 PM To: Robyn Macdonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: Dear Milton City Council, I am a resident of Milton since Dec 2005 and live right across from your office. In all these years we have had T -Mobile and we have almsot no coverage inside our home or in the entire subdivision. Please this is not a luxary these days, it is a bare necessity. I am unable to attend the Planning Commission Hearing on January 26. However, please accept this e-mail as a snow of support for these site applications. Kindly look into this matter and I thank you in advance for your time and consideration. Sincerely, Ravi Prakash Mailing Address: Ravi Prakash 12877 Deer Park Lane Alpharetta,GA 30004 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Laryn Alfred flalfred@comcast.net] Sent: Thursday, March 11, 2010 5:47 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. Wireless phones have become vital personal and public safety tools in Milton. Please make certain that citizens continue to have the best coverage possible throughout our community. My wireless phone has become a necessity. I use it to check in with my children wherever they are in our community. More importantly, I want my children to always be able to reach me or a 9-1-1 operator in an emergency. Sincerely, Laryn Alfred Mailing Address: Laryn Alfred 40 Arabian Ave. Milton,GA 30004 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Alicia Griffin [alicia.grifFin&-mobile.com] Sent: Thursday, March 11, 2010 5:19 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. I've dropped my landline phone and I rely solely on my wireless phone. It is absolutely imperative that I have reliable wireless coverage to stay connected, particularly in an emergency. Wireless phones have become vital personal and public safety tools in Milton. Please make certain that citizens continue to have the best coverage possible throughout our community. Sincerely, Alicia Griffin Mailing Address: Alicia Griffin 7393 North Point Parkway Alpahretta,GA 30022 1 Robyn MacDonald -PI - - IA IPI PIIII From: Tom ❑lift [tomo2006[7a bellsouth.net] Sent: Thursday, March 11, 2016 5:18 PM To: Robyn Macdonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. All three sites will improve wireless coverage in Milton, especially in areas where I need it most - at home and in my neighborhood. Wireless phones have become vital personal and public safety tools in Milton. Please make certain that citizens continue to have the best coverage possible throughout our community. Sincerely, Tom Qliff Mailing Address: Thomas Qliff 14750 Wood Rd milton,GA 30004 ]. Robyn MacDonald From: Joy Uoy.albert@gmail.com] Sent: Thursday, March 11, 2010 4:17 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear SirMadame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. All three sites will improve wireless coverage in Milton, especially in areas where I need it most - at home and in my neighborhood. Wireless phones have become vital personal and public safety tools in Milton. Please make certain that citizens continue to have the best coverage possible throughout our community. I've dropped my landline phone and I rely solely on my wireless phone. It is absolutely imperative that I have reliable wireless coverage to stay connected, particularly in an emergency. Reliable wireless coverage at home and in my neighborhood is essential for me. Wireless phones are no longer a luxury, they are a necessity. Sincerely, aoy Mailing Address: Toy rang 10050 hones Bridge Rd Unit 12 alpharetta,GA 30022 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Parul Sharma [ram.sharma77 a@gmail.com] Sent: Wednesday, March 10, 2010 5:35 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: Dear Respected Local Official, I am buying house in City of Milton on Crabapple Road under new subdivision named as Crabapple Crossroads. One of the hindering factor is that I could not make and receive calls in and around this subdivision as this is a newly developed subdivision. This is very close to on of the 3 sites proposed by T -Mobile. These 3 sites will enhance my confidence about my kids going to schools, while I go to Pediatrics when my kids get cold or other, when we go to shopping center (Kroger on Arnold Mill and Crabapple), when I go to play Golf on Atlanta National Golf on New Providence Road. I not only hope but confident that we all have similar concerns for our work and family, irrespective of whatever Carrier/Mobile Operator we use. I want to talk, check e-mail or get online with my wireless device from wherever I am, particularly at home. Having poor coverage in a place like Milton is simply unacceptable. In order to have reliable coverage, we need the necessary infrastructure to provide it. I've dropped my landline phone and I rely solely on my wireless phone. It is absolutely imperative that I have reliable wireless coverage to stay connected, particularly in an emergency. Reliable wireless coverage at home and in my neighborhood is essential for me. Wireless phones are no longer a luxury, they are a necessity. Sincerely, Parul Sharma Mailing Address: Parul Sharma 1728 Hemingwway Lane Alpharetta,GA 30075 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Mary Michels [no3puttca@yahoo.com] Sent: Wednesday, March 10. 2010 5:10 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. I am tired of having to turn my Cell phone off the minute I enter my home. The only reason I still have a landline is because of the lack of current service I have. Wireless phones have become vital personal and public safety tools in Milton. Please make certain that Citizens continue to have the best coverage possible throughout our community. Sincerely, Mary Michels Mailing Address: Mary Michels 513 Northumberland Street Milton,GA 38884 1 Robyn MacDonald From: LynnAnn Agnew [lynnann@gmail.com] Sent: Wednesday, March 10, 2010 3:48 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: All three sites will improve wireless coverage in Milton, especially in areas where I need it most - at home and in my neighborhood. Sincerely, LynnAnn Agnew Mailing Address: LynnAnn Agnew 330 Marshalls Cove Milton,GA 30004 I Robyn MacDonald From: Adam Agnew [adam.agnew@capgemini.com] Sent: VVednesday, March 10, 2010 3:47 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: Wireless phones have become vital personal and public safety tools in Milton. Please make certain that citizens continue to have the best coverage possible throughout our community. Sincerely, Adam Agnew Mailing Address: Adam Agnew 339 Marshalls Cove Milton,GA 30004 Robyn MacDonald From: Judy Whalen Hudyaw2@gmail.com] Sent: Wednesday, March 10, 2010 1:47 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T --Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. All three sites will improve wireless coverage in Milton, especially in areas where I need it most - at home and in my neighborhood. I use my wireless phone to stay connected with work, family and friends. Having reliable coverage is important to me. Reliable wireless coverage at home and in my neighborhood is essential for me. Wireless phones are no longer a luxury, they are a necessity. Sincerely, ]udy Whalen Mailing Address: Judy Whalen 2495 Hopewell Plantation Dr Alpharetta,GA 30004 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Toni Santos [chatwmstoni(a gmail.com] Sent: Wednesday, March 10, 2010 1:46 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I am a home owner, tax payer and registered voter in Alpharetta. I am also a TMobile customer. The addiion cellsites provides better service for those of us that live up here. These sites I am sure can be utilitzed in some way to support our state and county services. I don't know the infrastructure of our emergency services but potentially we will need more access to more of these technologies. I'm sure the government has all the legal support to make sure they make the most of this situation. Please support the cell site builds. Reliable wireless coverage at home and in my neighborhood is essential for me. Wireless phones are no longer a luxury, they are a necessity. Sincerely, Toni Santos Mailing Address: Toni Santos 2180 erookridge Terrace Alpharetta,GA 30004 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Jay Collins bayc1bird @gmai 1.corn] Sent: Wednesday, March 10, 2010 1:10 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. All three sites will improve wireless coverage in Milton, especially in areas where I need it most - at home and in my neighborhood. I've dropped my landline phone and I rely solely on my wireless phone. It is absolutely imperative that I have reliable wireless coverage to stay connected, particularly in an emergency. Sincerely, Jay Collins Mailing Address: Jay Collins 7.5058 Inverness Trail Milton,GA 30004 I Robyn MacDonald From: Sent: To: Subject: Dear Sir/Madame: Julie Burns Julieb_1961@yahoo.corn] Wednesday, March 10, 2010 1:00 PM Robyn MacDonald Approve T -Mobile Applications I want to talk, check e-mail or get online with my wireless device from wherever I am, particularly at home. Having poor coverage in a place like Milton is simply unacceptable. In order to have reliable Coverage, we need the necessary infrastructure to provide it. I've dropped my landline phone and I rely solely on my wireless phone. It is absolutely imperative that I have reliable wireless coverage to stay connected, particularly in an emergency. Sincerely, 7ulie Burns Mailing Address: Julie Burns 123 North Park Lane Alpharetta,GA 30004 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Maria -Luisa Beatriz Halbert [emma_bachi@yahoo.com] Sent: Monday, March 08, 2010 5:03 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. All three sites will improve wireless coverage in Milton, especially in areas where I need it most - at home and in my neighborhood. I want to talk, check e-mail or get online with my wireless device from wherever I am, particularly at home. Having poor coverage in a place like Milton is simply unacceptable. In order to have reliable coverage, we need the necessary infrastructure to provide it. I've dropped my landline phone and I rely solely on my wireless phone. It is absolutely imperative that I have reliable wireless coverage to stay connected, particularly in an emergency. I use my wireless phone to stay connected with work, family and friends. Having reliable coverage is important to me. Reliable wireless coverage at home and in my neighborhood is essential for me. Wireless phones are no longer a luxury, they are a necessity. I am a pet -sitter and am constantly driving down the back roads of Milton and am constantly losing service or not having service at all which is very frustrating. The new towers are located not only on the road i live on but on the back roads that I work on Wireless phones have become vital personal and public safety tools in Milton. Please make certain that citizens continue to have the best coverage possible throughout our community. Sincerely, Maria -Luisa Beatriz Halbert Mailing Address: Maria -Luisa Halbert 16675 Hopewell RD Alpharetta,GA 30004 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Don Hogan [me@dhogan.name] Sent: Monday, March 08, 2010 2:32 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. All three sites will improve wireless coverage in Milton, especially in areas where I need it most - at home and in my neighborhood. Reliable wireless coverage at home and in my neighborhood is essential for me. Wireless phones are no longer a luxury, they are a necessity. Sincerely, Don Hogan Mailing Address: Donald Hogan 3284 Kentworth Lane Milton,GA 30004 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Shirley A. Slaughter [shirleyann012000@yahoo.com] Sent: Monday, March 08, 2010 2:07 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: I support, and encourage you to approve, T -Mobile's three proposed cell site applications in the City of Milton. All three sites will improve wireless coverage in Milton, especially in areas where I need it most - at home and in my neighborhood. I want to talk, check e-mail or get online with my wireless device from wherever I am, particularly at home. Having poor coverage in a place like Milton is simply unacceptable. In order to have reliable coverage, we need the necessary infrastructure to provide it. Wireless phones have become vital personal and public safety tools in Milton. Please make certain that citizens continue to have the best coverage possible throughout our community. I use my wireless phone to stay connected with work, family and friends. Having reliable coverage is important to me. I use my wireless phone to stay connected with work, family and friends. Having reliable coverage is important to me. Reliable wireless coverage at home and in my neighborhood is essential for me. Wireless phones are no longer a luxury, they are a necessity. Sincerely, Shirley A. Slaughter Mailing Address: Shirley Slaughter 1473 Mayfield Road Alpharetta,GA 30009 1 Robyn MacDonald From: Erica [ericadorris@gmail.com] Sent: Monday, March 08, 2010 2:05 PM To: Robyn MacDonald Subject: Approve T -Mobile Applications Dear Sir/Madame: My phone doesn't work from Wal-Mart all the over to Zagby's. I have roadside assistant and if something were to ever happen between the 2 locations, i will be melded up. T -Mobile is the cheapest National Provider out there right now. And with these hard times we are facing these days, I need all the help I can get. 50 that's why I decided to go with T -Mobile b/c of the price. I am an AT&T emplyee and it is cheaper for me to go to T -Mobile even with my companies discounts. That's how important the savings are to me. And now I can't get 100% of service because of this tower issue. I just want my phone to work. Sincerely, Erica Mailing Address: erica Dorris 5006 Lake Union Hill Road Alpharetta,GA 30004 r RobX 1 UacDonald Fes: Art Fix [aHx@sulwerrnanr-pm Qqrnj Ont; Weijnesday, danua fr 13 2010 9.06 AM TW -'om Wilgan Cc: Robyn MacDonald; dgoir�@dHonwerysszorn, Bill Lusk *bw: FSE Cell 'Criwer Tom - Good morning; aktunoefl ill a puhlic uFformat�urr meet ing la st nlgl i t loc the prDpci sed cL-Ia t.OWd-r at toe- AlPlharetto rrTarai fir, After slgn Ind In, the Pnf :Fxi,tbit thatT M*61e sI wM rire was frauduler•,t'ln the re0+e5eir .Wore. TfiE 5i#e plan shawetr a taawerat toe Ih1g4n pour[ of tho to pWORraWTV of tte ares+, Yet I h -e 5tre:et vi�w& where thev snared rn� !I allonn was floated to a ppmrrriatp tower hL-lWiT .4nrmed the lacation al rhe 4al Ina n a Glivance of in exce s5 of 'I la a:5 feet Of trorn t he Fr-, N -Sed Irrotlp;n -rF the tower -%howri an the plan, 7 N5 diffprvrK+- in what war st 4t win in the -5vpii�t view pijt ahe 150 fmt IiFLIgh t QT #hli� O wirr a t a Point Of the ¢1 '#hit was 511 b50nli til Iw Iigw.�r In a IeVatF¢n tna n where the actVa I t -Ower WO u ILi be ha -5e -d upun thepr pQs+eb in Arlan, The impar -t cif this disc.repa:lCw iS telat the -$treeK WLeW s'hOWS khat #f -pe balloon was be luw the tri Iirw, when In mality, the to we -r wrll I e -pboye the t+� I ine b&sed upan the actlaa I to poEr i pb1 r a nd The IrtoVun �tivn aft IKF tite pla#rw. 1.thaHengett them East nigtil r a»d they lw:E i cEuWrh frim their. repnesentorlions which initially they d1il"10d wee IUtUal. I em rEat stm If a nl ;D ne a Ipe 1La4 natice- the I ncQcisisfencles to the it exfliblJ514 but 1h6 -calls unto} fjtiestaon everw dui umc-n r $Et tbi!,y I iawe n5umbW. I a rrr rrcatatal-pd Irk the prospect pf M;Itp n *slbly appmwerg t h -es. #ower%, pgtQrririliyr h.35c-d kipon tN5 lnacwrat infgrmnion which may set a piece nx for rvur1#I-Ess -[Iter vrsnd-Drs w it-raIt ts)Werf ! h rouj�lhv«r nor cornnau". I am 415c Elmplyt tcosabied by the irtaccuf-ate d�:u;lierltanun p regeflteo Lpy T Tobi le rhea ft 15 tha`ir ne5pnn5lbl Itt� to axua ately reprise nt the facts, -and If approved rased ,apo n th Is anf-a mji�tpon, vwhat we W111 attualh+ have to alua: with withal qur City if approved. F will not be a lase to a tteixo the rneeting toin4ht due -to a fain fly- III neses, but vo6ird ovpteclatr your assk5�Unci In gatr ing rrryr erna il tO -appr a pr is to derision m2kert to let Myr obGerMat,briS and co mems be knowii. Al mi n irimu). T Mobile sh i}uld pecurately re present i lie furs with t1i!lr + vpre-ta!ltaiEoris. rurthar. whlkm M .ori G .3g.a Inst iia! WWW, Vs, If tliv City I Eos no upLion u flier tha i i Ea a p p rove the Ingtallatic n. the 0 ty+ silo uld ret lre t#1dt ihN towe r s ba rmilou rlaEL:�o as o the�r ju risdii tior is flava= stir cessfuIIV requ irtd Art Fax Vlce Presi&nt & C HW Ope'ratjg OITirL4 r SOVefr.na n ConstruL1i Ion Program Management Inc - 1V5 '�onxo lite Road 15ui to 5 AI la m a, GA X0306 -M]3 Dlr-�{t! 4LI4.96E� 43()1 Cef1: 404, 24,7.6296 www ,si tverm,alr corn .coni Robyn MacDa-na I@ Fro4x1: Torn Volsan Serrk ThursdaV- Jatlunryr D7, 21314 322 PM To: Art Fix Cc, R yrn Macconam SUMOCI: R�- CAI Tv - w Pmna s Art fur w0mr rrreswga'. I am pas -5i -ng Ths � rri-L-naga a Ivag tv I�v bVrL Mac!)mia Id, t he Ikla i i i wr whD i, preen#rng alis ease to -the titer LaNnidt-s r thsat 3oki r corn ni eats MI I Liv knOWn to thT rarrrwr it Ffowjk�ye r. i L is alwtys beUtr'to carne t4 The coundl meeting to vQio your concerrrs tF ymp ca R ma ke it. By the way, I r&. you a rr- iwa re t tia t the m"-tft sched Oed fu r tinh%ht titre at t" Hd 11 lim bt±cfl mcsr.Itie-d is Imt #a J1an 13 3t 7 fti. SC.c Imlow. The Community Zoning rnfolnnatton ?sleeting is rescl duked far Wednesday, Jan. 13 at 7 p.m the locator will be in Jhe -CGBrFi Ir Chambers at City Hall, 130DO Dec -4n Id Parkway Su Ite 107. 1'I- ase htlp get ikLIs mamEe n-wtto Thgm yroia knipw aro. mterELrte•r.l 1h rtk� for retiln.S your thogGM5 bLL known. Tom From: Art Fix irnalltD:afiix@5ily marcpm.com] gent: That p, An�iarV D , 2010 1.33 PM To: Torn Mimn Subject. Celt Tm,+er Importance: Rkyh Tara_ I had work -ed With you W114m you were with City of Saindy Springs Mnd as re�iderit 4# PdilMn. need yrpur help. please- I am g2ppmed tQ the. prpposed re II tower be ink r-an5idered as Mpllows=. Patltfon Number L) - C 5 Location ; 13302 New Pr vid encs Road Appllcarot; T-Mab11i� Request: To obta In a use permit for 1513 rwt tal I Monopole call towner with an mddl anal 4 foot I ig htni ng red for a total of 154 feat (Art1de 19.4,7 The proposed tower Ls In the mild la of a reslda ntiai naig h1orhood r and -should riot bV approved fn r Instarlation h&& hl le there may be some ne-L-A there is w (thin the grid Ether morn appropfrate si te.9 where the tower ca n be placed to taia nrgulate Mthil n the g rld to cover weak spots in transmksslon. I have had T rnahW servlet arid ltue in this mi qa, 4nd wh I IL- !ha �lg r,a I war. weak. I alwar had reimptiori. E would apprecLate fur passaqnake opposition to ails matter, F1�t FiMc gxeciitivt vice 15resldan t $. Chlet Opera I I ng Offirr Sily&rnan CorLstfuct.Ior+ program Manageme tit. I rbL 1075 Zonclipte Road [Suite 5 Atianta, GA 3MOS-2-013 Rimm 404.9&, .43131 Call- 404,247,62-4Fj wvyw-541P[f Li EkgcL3 i n &opt City of Milton 13000 Deerfield Parkway, Suite 107, Milton, Georgia 30004 1 To: Honorable Mayor and City Council Members From: Stacey Inglis, Finance Manager Date: April 12, 2010 City Council Meeting Agenda Item: Approval of the Issuance of an Alcohol Beverage License to I Love N.Y. Pizza & Attila’s Grill City Manager’s Office Recommendation: Approve the issuance of an Alcohol Beverage License to I Love N.Y. Pizza & Attila’s Grill for consumption on premises of wine and malt beverage. Background: City of Milton Ordinance Chapter 4 allows for the issuance of Alcohol Beverage Licenses to businesses that properly submit application for and meet all the legal requirements to hold such license. Discussion: Staff has processed the application for the following business and recommends issuance of the applicable license: Business Name: I Love N.Y. Pizza & Attila’s Grill Owner(s) Name: Anar Gafarzada Business Address: 980 Birmingham Rd, Ste 200, Milton, GA 30004 Type of License to be Issued: Consumption on Premises – Wine and Malt Beverage Concurrent Review: Chris Lagerbloom, City Manager Deb Harrell, Chief of Police Lynn Tully, Director of Community Development